A graphical diagnostic of topological order using ZX calculus

Sergi Mas-Mendoza, Richard D. P. East, Michele Filippone, Adolfo G. Grushin · 2025

Read A graphical diagnostic of topological order using ZX calculus by Sergi Mas-Mendoza, Richard D. P. East, Michele Filippone, Adolfo G. Grushin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-12355.txt.

Introduction

Topological order is a deep pattern of long-range entanglement, yet the usual test, entropy scaling, can be fooled by junk contributions. Sergi Mas-Mendoza and three co-authors propose a graphical test in 2025 built on the ZX calculus, a diagram language for quantum processes.

Feed the method a split of a state into two regions, and it returns a contour diagram that shows long-range links only when the state is truly long-range entangled. The toric code and color code pass with different counts of nonlocal nodes, which separates their orders, while trivial states show none. The count survives changes of boundary and ground state mixture.

Catalog record

CREATORSergi Mas-Mendoza, Richard D. P. East, Michele Filippone, Adolfo G. Grushin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE359 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-12355

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A graphical diagnostic of topological order using ZX calculus Sergi Mas-Mendoza, Richard D. P. East, Michele Filippone, Adolfo G. Grushin Abstract Establishing a universal diagnostic of topological order remains an open theoretical challenge. In particular, diagnosing long-range entanglement through the entropic area law suffers from spurious contributions, failing to unambiguously identify topological order. Here we devise a protocol based on the ZX calculus, a graphical tensor network, to determine the topological order of a state circumventing entropy calculations. The protocol takes as input real-space bipartitions of a state and returns a ZX contour diagram , 𝒟 ∂ A \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} , displaying long-range graph connectivity only for long-range entangled states. We validate the protocol by showing that the contour diagrams of the toric and color codes are equivalent except for the number of non-local nodes, which differentiates their topological order. The number of these nodes is robust to the choice of the boundary and ground-state superposition, and they are absent for trivial states, even those with spurious entropy contributions. Our results single out ZX calculus as a tool to detect topological long-range entanglement by leveraging the advantages of diagrammatic reasoning against entropic diagnostics. Introduction – Classifying quantum many-body phases of matter beyond symmetry-breaking requires discerning different types of topological order Wen 2004 . Diagnosing topological order is often achieved by calculating the entanglement entropy between subsystems, S Hamma et al. 2005a ; Levin and Wen 2006 ; Kitaev and Preskill 2006 ; Chen et al. 2010 . Topologically-ordered gapped systems have long-range entanglement. Thus, they satisfy the area law S=\alpha L-\gamma , with L the length of the boundary between partitions, and \alpha,\gamma>0 real constants. Finding \gamma\neq 0 points to long-range entanglement because it is independent of L . Unfortunately, a non-zero \gamma is not sufficient to declare that a phase is topologically ordered. Typically, \gamma=\gamma_{\mathrm{top}}=\ln(D) , a topological entanglement entropy set by the total quantum dimension D of the anyons Hamma et al. 2005a ; Levin and Wen 2006 ; Kitaev and Preskill 2006 . This observation served to diagnose topological order, both numerically Jiang et al. 2012 ; Cincio and Vidal 2013a ; Zaletel et al. 2013 ; Grushin et al. 2015 ; Laflorencie 2016 and experimentally Satzinger et al. 2021 . However, a growing body of examples showcases that \gamma suffers from spurious, non-topological contributions \gamma_{\mathrm{spur}} Cano et al. 2015 ; Bravyi ; Zou and Haah 2016 ; Fliss et al. 2017 ; Santos et al. 2018 ; Williamson et al. 2019 ; Kato and Brandão 2020 ; Stephen et al. 2019 . Applying finite depth unitary circuits can change \gamma=\gamma_{\mathrm{top}} to \gamma=\gamma_{\mathrm{top}}+\gamma_{\mathrm{spur}} , and even topologically trivial states can display \gamma=\gamma_{\mathrm{spur}}\neq 0 Cano et al. 2015 ; Bravyi ; Zou and Haah 2016 ; Fliss et al. 2017 ; Santos et al. 2018 ; Williamson et al. 2019 ; Kato and Brandão 2020 ; Stephen et al. 2019 . The spurious contribution \gamma_{\mathrm{spur}} depends on the computation method used, emerging typically, but not exclusively Kato and Brandão 2020 , from sub-system symmetries. A full understanding of when \gamma_{\mathrm{spur}}\neq 0 is to our knowledge lacking, even though it was shown that \gamma\geq\gamma_{\mathrm{top}} for certain computation schemes Kim et al. 2023 ; Levin 2024 . The non-universality of \gamma calls for alternative and robust diagnostics of topological order. Figure 1: Protocol to find the contour diagram \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} for the toric code on the square lattice. (a) ZX diagram representing the toric-code ground state ( 1 ). The qubits are marked by red spiders with outputs ( ) and sit on the edges of a square lattice shown in gray. The black lines denote ZX connections issued from the Pauli projectors ( 3 ). (b) ZX diagram representing \mathrm{Tr}(\rho) . It implements the trace of all qubits in (a) with their conjugate copies. Using the inverse fuse rule, we double ( pin ) qubits with ZX connections to both regions A and B , highlighted in blue and gray respectively. The orange squares highlight \Sigma_{AB}=12 green Z spiders corresponding to Pauli projectors acting on the plaquettes connecting A and B . (c) Contour diagram \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} obtained from simplifying the diagram (b), but without simplifying the pinned red X spiders at the boundary. It features a single non-local spider ( N_{\mathrm{nl}}=1 ) connected to the boundary plaquettes, whose number \Sigma_{AB} scales with the boundary length. (d) The contour diagram \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} in panel (c) is simplified further to obtain a Pauli tree. It features an extension of the Pauli projector ( 3 ), delimited by the dotted box, acting on the \Sigma_{AB} green Z spiders of each copy marked in orange in panel (b). In this work, we show the possibility to graphically identify topological long-range entanglement, bypassing the calculation of entanglement entropies S . We propose a graphical diagnostic of topological order based on diagrammatic ZX calculus Coecke and Duncan 2008 ; Coecke and Duncan 2011 ; Coecke and Kissinger 2017 ; van de Wetering 2020 . ZX diagrams are a type of tensor network that excels at visualizing entanglement. By expressing quantum circuits as ZX diagrams, one can use graphical simplification rules, the ZX calculus, to find more compact, equivalent circuits with fewer gates. In these simplified diagrams only entangled qubits are graphically connected. ZX-calculus reasoning has far-reaching applications in quantum information and circuit optimization Duncan et al. 2020 ; Kissinger and van de Wetering 2020a ; de Beaudrap et al. 2020a ; Cowtan et al. 2020 , measurement-based quantum computation Duncan and Perdrix 2010 ; Kissinger and van de Wetering 2019 ; Backens et al. 2021 and error correction de Beaudrap and Horsman 2020 ; Gidney and Fowler 2019 ; de Beaudrap et al. 2020b ; Hanks et al. 2020 ; Rodatz et al. 2024 ; Khesin and Li 2024 ; Bombin et al. 2023 ; Khesin et al. 2025 ; Bombin et al. 2024 . It is used to study symmetry-protected topological phases East et al. 2022a , loop quantum gravity East et al. 2022b ; East 2022 , entanglement propagation Sommers et al. 2024 and deep-reinforcement learning Nägele and Marquardt 2024 . Here, we devise a ZX-based protocol that unambiguously diagnoses topological long-range entanglement of gapped states and is insensitive to spurious contributions. Our protocol performs a graphical trace over all degrees of freedom, delivering a number whose ZX diagrammatic form, the contour diagram \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} , informs us about the entanglement between a chosen bipartition. We then conjecture that \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} displays long-range graph connectivity if there is long-range entanglement. We test this conjecture by computing \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} for the toric code on square and hexagonal lattices Kitaev 2003 and for the color code Bombin and Martin-Delgado 2006 ; Lacroix et al. 2024 . In all these cases, \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} displays a total number of non-local nodes that equals \gamma_{\mathrm{top}} , and can be cast into a Pauli-tree form defined by the presence of Pauli projectors Kissinger and van de Wetering 2024 . Crucially, \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} shows only local connectivity for trivial cluster states, even those with \gamma_{\mathrm{spur}}>0 . We show that the contour diagram \mathcal{D}_{\partial A} is robust to the choice of ground-state superposition, boundary deformation, bipartition and to applying finite-depth

Read the complete text