The impact of kinetic and global effects on ballooning 2 nd stable pedestals of conventional and high aspect ratio tokamaks

M.S. Anastopoulos Tzanis 1 , M. Yang 1 , A. Kleiner 2 , J.F. Parisi 3 , G.M. Staebler 1 and P.B. Snyder 4 · 2025

Read The impact of kinetic and global effects on ballooning 2 nd stable pedestals of conventional and high aspect ratio tokamaks by M.S. Anastopoulos Tzanis 1 , M. Yang 1 , A. Kleiner 2 , J.F. Parisi 3 , G.M. Staebler 1 and P.B. Snyder 4 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-11484.txt.

Introduction

M. S. Anastopoulos Tzanis and 5 co-authors refine a standard model of tokamak edge stability in this 2025 paper. The edge of a fusion plasma, the pedestal, is limited by ballooning instabilities. The widely used EPED model pairs two such limits, but it usually approximates the kinetic ballooning threshold with a simpler ideal one, an approximation that can drift badly in squat, low-aspect-ratio machines.

The team applies a reduced model built on a gyro-fluid code, which captured the kinetic modes in both a conventional and a spherical tokamak. They also show that global high-turn modes can block access to a prized second stable region. Feeding both improvements into EPED brought its pedestal predictions closer to measured data.

Catalog record

CREATORM.S. Anastopoulos Tzanis 1 , M. Yang 1 , A. Kleiner 2 , J.F. Parisi 3 , G.M. Staebler 1 and P.B. Snyder 4
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-11484

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The impact of kinetic and global effects on ballooning 2 nd stable pedestals of conventional and high aspect ratio tokamaks M.S. Anastopoulos Tzanis 1 , M. Yang 1 , A. Kleiner 2 , J.F. Parisi 3 , G.M. Staebler 1 and P.B. Snyder 4 Abstract The EPED model [P.B. Snyder et al 2011 Nucl. Fusion 51 103016] had success in describing type-I ELM and QH-mode pedestals in conventional tokamaks, by combining kinetic ballooning mode (KBM) and peeling-ballooning (PB) constraints. Within EPED, the KBM constraint is usually approximated by the ideal ballooning mode (IBM) stability threshold. It has been noted that quantitative differences between local ideal MHD and gyro-kinetic (GK) ballooning stability can be larger at low aspect ratio. KBM critical pedestals are consistent with observation in initial studies on conventional and spherical tokamaks. In this work, the application of a reduced model for the calculation of the kinetic ballooning stability boundary is presented based on a novel and newly developed Gyro-Fluid System (GFS) code [G.M. Staebler et al 2023 Phys. Plasmas 30 102501]. GFS is observed to capture KBMs in DIII-D as well as the NSTX(-U) pedestals, opening the route for the integration of this model into EPED. Finally, high- n n global ballooning modes are observed to limit local 2 nd stability access and thus provide a transport mechanism that constrains the width evolution with β p , p ​ e ​ d \beta_{p,ped} . The high- n n global ballooning stability is approximated by its ideal MHD analogue using ELITE. It is shown that nearly local high- n n with k y ​ ρ s ∼ 1 / 2 k_{y}\rho_{s}\sim 1/2 modes can provide a proxy for the critical β p , p ​ e ​ d \beta_{p,ped} when 2 nd stable access exists on DIII-D plasmas. The use of GFS and ELITE scaling in EPED provided improved agreement in comparison to EPED1 with DIII-D pedestal data. 1 Introduction As the efforts for the design and construction of a tokamak Fusion Pilot Plant (FPP) becomes more intense, the need for reliable predictive modeling capabilities becomes imperative as current tokamak devices operate far from a reactor parameter space. This requires deep physics understanding for the creation of robust reduced models that are accurate but also fast enough to be integrated in reactor design and optimization tools. The general goal of such design loops is the creation of FPPs that have good enough core performance in order for fusion reactions to take place. The fusion performance of the tokamak is often measured in terms of the triple product, <p_{DT}>\tau_{E} , where <p_{DT}> is the volume averaged pressure of the Deuterium and Tritium (DT) mixture and \tau_{E} is the energy confinement time. In current tokamak devices, the maximization of the core pressure is often achieved by the formation of an insulating edge region that leads to the formation of a pedestal on which the core pressure sits. Although this operational regime, called the H-mode, is beneficial for performance it is accompanied by the destabilization of edge localized modes (ELMs). In a reactor, just a few large ELMs will lead to excessive sputtering, erosion and melting of the divertor components and therefore it is necessary to understand, predict and eventually avoid the occurrence of such events. For the design of a tokamak FPP, the pedestal conditions are extremely important. The core of the plasma will be most likely close to turbulence critical gradient limits to achieve significant fusion gain and therefore the height of the pedestal is one of the main drivers to maximize performance. In addition, continuous FPP operation highly relies on non-inductive current and the pedestal will contribute significantly to the bootstrap current fraction. As a result, accurate pedestal modeling capabilities are necessary for predicting performance and stability limits in order to develop strategies for small/no ELM and non-inductive operation. The most successful model to date used to predict the pedestal structure and the onset of large type-I ELMs and QH-mode is the EPED model [ 1 ] . EPED is based on two simple ideas that define how the pedestal, which is characterized by the width \Delta_{\psi_{N}} and height \beta_{p,ped} , evolves. That relation is defined as \Delta_{\psi_{N}}=c_{1}\beta_{p,ped}^{c_{2}} . Here \beta_{p,ped}=2\mu_{0}p_{ped}/(\mu_{0}I_{p}/L)^{2} , where p_{ped} is the top of the pedestal pressure, I_{p} is the plasma current and L is the circumference of the plasma boundary. There exists a local “stiff” transport constraint that limits the pressure gradient of the pedestal and a global constraint based on ideal MHD instabilities that limits the maximum width and height of the pedestal. The pedestal width and height (pressure gradient) evolves close to the kinetic ballooning limit, and type-I ELMs or QH-mode occur when eventually the peeling-ballooning modes become unstable. Implicitly the relation between the width and height has profound implications for the destabilization of peeling-ballooning modes. Therefore it is important to be able to capture this relation as accurate as possible. In conventional aspect ratio tokamaks it is experimentally observed that c_{1}\sim 0.06-0.13 and c_{2}\sim 0.5 [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ] [ 6 ] [ 7 ] , which is also theoretically reproduced considering the stability of local ideal or kinetic ballooning modes. The same square root dependance of the width with \beta_{p,ped} is also observed in MAST with somewhat larger c_{1}=0.12-0.15 [ 8 ] . However, in NSTX a different relation is observed experimentally with c_{1}\sim 0.4 and c_{2}\sim 1 [ 9 ] . Considering the ideal ballooning limit of NSTX pedestals, almost a linear relation c_{2}\sim 0.8-1 between the width and the height is reproduced by the ideal ballooning mode (IBM) limit but the c_{1}\sim 0.2-0.3 , which implies a much larger \beta_{p,ped} for a certain \Delta_{\psi_{N}} than what is measured. This discrepancy has been recently attributed to the difference between kinetic and ideal ballooning mode threshold [ 10 ] which seems to be enhanced in low aspect ratio tokamaks. The impact of kinetic effects on the critical \beta_{p,ped} results in a more strict stability limit (lower critical \beta_{p,ped} ) and therefore a larger c_{2} coefficient. Moreover, one of the features of local ideal or kinetic ballooning stability is the existence of a 2 nd stable region at high enough \beta^{\prime}=2\mu_{0}/B^{2}dp/dr_{N} , where r_{N}=r/a and a the plasma minor radius. In cases of low magnetic shear \hat{s}=d\ln{q}/d\ln{r} and shaped magnetic geometry no stability boundary exists with increasing \beta^{\prime} . This feature makes the determination of the width and height constraint impossible based on local ballooning physics alone. It remains an open question whether local analysis is appropriate in the pedestal region where the width of the pedestal is often smaller than the k_{y}\rho_{s} of the most unstable kinetic ballooning mode (KBM). It has been shown through global gyro-kinetic simulations that kinetic effects in fact close the access to a 2 nd region at low magnetic shear [ 11 ] . However, the gyro-kinetic ordering is intrinsically local, excluding global equilibrium variations. The impact of finite- n effects on 2 nd stability access was also examined considering ideal MHD physics based on the interplay between local high- n kink/peeling and ballooning modes [ 12 ] [ 13 ] introducing global equilibrium variations. In this

Read the complete text