Magnitude of Short-Wavelength Electric Field Fluctuations in Simulations of Collisionless Plasma Shocks VPIC ( Bowers et al. 2008 ; Bowers & VPIC developers 2023 )

Vadim Roytershteyn, Lynn B. Wilson III, Li-Jen Chen, Michael Gedalin, Nikolai Pogorelov · 2025

Read Magnitude of Short-Wavelength Electric Field Fluctuations in Simulations of Collisionless Plasma Shocks VPIC ( Bowers et al. 2008 ; Bowers & VPIC developers 2023 ) by Vadim Roytershteyn, Lynn B. Wilson III, Li-Jen Chen, Michael Gedalin, Nikolai Pogorelov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-11286.txt.

Introduction

Spacecraft flying through collisionless shocks measure very strong electric field fluctuations. Simulations produce much weaker ones. Vadim Roytershteyn and four co-authors chase the mismatch in this 2025 plasma physics paper. Without matching amplitudes, models cannot explain shock energy conversion.

The team ran one-dimensional particle-in-cell simulations. They used the true proton-to-electron mass ratio. One case had upstream electrons hotter than the ions. There, fluctuation size grew with a key frequency ratio. It reached realistic strengths once that ratio passed a few dozen. The big fluctuations came from electrostatic solitary structures. Ion phase-space holes were among them. With the temperature order reversed, fluctuations stayed small.

Catalog record

CREATORVadim Roytershteyn, Lynn B. Wilson III, Li-Jen Chen, Michael Gedalin, Nikolai Pogorelov
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-11286

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Magnitude of Short-Wavelength Electric Field Fluctuations in Simulations of Collisionless Plasma Shocks VPIC ( Bowers et al. 2008 ; Bowers & VPIC developers 2023 ) Vadim Roytershteyn, Lynn B. Wilson III, Li-Jen Chen, Michael Gedalin, Nikolai Pogorelov Abstract Large-amplitude electrostatic fluctuations are routinely observed by spacecraft upon traversal of collisionless shocks in the heliosphere. Kinetic simulations of shocks have struggled to reproduce the amplitude of such fluctuations, complicating efforts to understand their influence on energy dissipation and shock structure. In this paper, 1D particle-in-cell simulations with realistic proton-to-electron mass ratio are used to show that in cases with upstream electron temperature T e T_{e} exceeding the ion temperature T i T_{i} , the magnitude of the fluctuations increases with the electron plasma-to-cyclotron frequency ratio ω p ​ e / Ω c ​ e \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce} , reaching realistic values at ω p ​ e / Ω c ​ e ≳ 30 \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce}\gtrsim 30 . The large-amplitude fluctuations in the simulations are shown to be associated with electrostatic solitary structures, such as ion phase-space holes. In the cases where upstream temperature ratio is reversed, the magnitude of the fluctuations remains small. I Introduction Shocks are ubiquitous in collisionless plasmas and are of great interest due to their role as some of the most efficient energy converters in the universe. Unlike their counterparts in collision-dominated gasses, shocks in collisionless plasmas may dissipate the energy of the upstream flow by a variety of mechanisms as reviewed e.g., by Sagdeev 1966 ; Biskamp 1973 ; Papadopoulos 1985 ; Balogh & Treumann 2013 ; Wilson et al. 2014a . Identification of the specific mechanisms operating under given conditions has been the subject of intense debate and many basic questions remain unresolved. One of such questions is the role of micro-instabilities and large-amplitude fluctuations of the electric field. Spacecraft observations demonstrate that, in contrast to simple theoretical constructs, the shock transition is characterized by the presence of intense fluctuations with magnitude comparable or even significantly exceeding corresponding mean values. Specifically, the focus of the present paper is on intense, short-wavelength fluctuations of the electric field. To a large degree, the present study is motivated by the survey of observational data presented by Wilson et al. 2007 ; Wilson et al. 2014a ; Wilson et al. 2014b , which indicated that such fluctuations are ubiquitously present, with only weak dependence on the shock parameters. Moreover, estimates of the effective dissipation due to the electric field fluctuations yielded values comparable with the global dissipation rate. Such observations reinvigorated the debate on the role of the fluctuations. The difficulties of assessing the contribution of fluctuations to the global dissipation using only limited information obtained along a spacecraft trajectory are self-evident. While the simulations do not suffer from similar limitations, they are hampered by the challenges in resolving the full range of relevant spatio-temporal scales and the sensitivity of the physics of interest to such parameters as the assumed proton-to-electron mass ratio or the separation of scales between the Debye scale and other internal plasma scales, such as ion and electron inertial length and gyroradii. In fact, majority of the self-consistent simulations performed to date have struggled to reproduce observed magnitude of the electric field fluctuations ( Riquelme & Spitkovsky 2011 ; Umeda et al. 2012a , e.g.,) , see also a review of the problem by Wilson et al. 2021 and references therein. Furthermore, parametric studies found strong dependence of the relevant instabilities on numerical parameters of the simulations, such as proton-to-electron mass ratio ( Umeda et al. 2012b , e.g.,) . In order to make progress, many prior simulation studies have focused on analysis of beam-driven instabilities in local configurations modeling shock foot ( Shimada & Hoshino 2004 ; Matsukiyo & Scholer 2006 ; Muschietti & Lembège 2013 ; Muschietti & Lembège 2017 , e.g.,) . While much has been learned from such studies, they lack self-consistent feedback between macroscopic shock structure and the microscopic fluctuations. In this paper, we present results of a scaling study that systematically investigates the dependence of the magnitude of electric field fluctuations in particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations of collisionless shocks on the ratio between plasma frequency \omega_{pe} and the electron cyclotron frequency \Omega_{ce} . The simulations are one-dimensional (1D), which suppresses instabilities with a finite component of wavevectors perpendicular to the shock normal. Nevertheless, several key observations could be made: 1) formation of electrostatic solitary structures, associated with ion phase-space holes, plays a major role in simulations with the upstream electron temperature T_{e} exceeding ion T_{i} , such that T_{e}/T_{i}\approx 3 . The magnitude of the electric field fluctuations in such cases is comparable to the observations when normalized to upstream convective electric field, provided the ratio \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce} is sufficiently high; 2) the normalized magnitude of the fluctuations is shown to increase with the value of \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce} ; 3) the amplitude of the electric field fluctuations in the case of T_{i}/T_{e}\approx 3 is significantly smaller than in the case T_{i}/T_{e}\approx 1/3 . II Numerical method We consider 1D simulations of a quasi-perpendicular collisionless shock characterized by upstream Alfvén Mach number M_{A}=V_{0}/V_{A}\approx 10.5 and the angle between shock normal and the magnetic field \theta_{Bn}=65^{\circ} . Here V_{0} is the upstream plasma speed and V_{A}=B_{0}/\sqrt{4\pi n_{0}m_{i}} is the Alfvén speed defined with the upstream magnetic field B_{0} , density n_{0} , and ion mass is m_{i} . The upstream plasma consists of two populations (ions and electrons) with isotropic Maxwellian distributions characterized by density n_{0} and temperatures T_{i} and T_{e} . Unless otherwise specified, the temperatures are chosen such that \beta_{e}=1 and \beta_{i}=0.3 , where \beta_{s}=8\pi n_{0}T_{s}/B_{0}^{2} and s=e,i denotes particle species. This is consistent with statistical studies of the solar wind at the Earth’s heliospheric distances ( Wilson et al. 2023 ) . The simulations differ in the value of the ratio between electron plasma and cyclotron frequencies, which is chosen to be \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce}=\{8,16,32\} . All other physical parameters are identical. The simulations are performed in a domain of size L_{x}=30\,d_{p} , resolved by a uniform Cartesian grid with the cells size approximately 0.5\lambda_{e} , where \lambda_{e} is the upstream Debye length and d_{p} is the upstream ion (proton) inertial length. Here d_{s}=c/\omega_{ps} , where \omega_{ps}^{2}=4\pi n_{0}q_{s}^{2}/m_{s} , c is the speed of light, and q_{s} is the charge. The thermal speed is defined as v_{ts}=\sqrt{2T_{s}/m_{s}} and particle gyroradius as \rho_{s}=v_{ts}/\Omega_{cs} . The parameters of the simulations are summarized in Table 1 . The upstream plasma is injected with the speed V_{in}=7.5V_{A} from the boundary at x=L_{x} and the shock is created by interaction of the incoming plasma with the plasma reflected from x=0 boundary, which uses a reflecting, perfectly conducting boundary condition. The shock speed V_{sh} in the simulation frame is approximately 3V_{A} . The ion-to-electron mass ratio is realistic m_{i}/m_{e}=1836 . The number of particles per cell N_{\mathrm{ppc}} corresponding to the upstream density is N_{\mathrm{ppc}}=1000 for each species. No particle splitting/merging algorithms are used in the simulations, so that all of the particles have equal and fixed statistical weight (i.e., charge and mass). Additional simulations with N_{\mathrm{ppc}}=4000 were performed for the case with \omega_{pe}/\Omega_{ce}=32 . The simulations were performed using the VPIC code ( Bowers et al. 2008 ) . Table 1: Simulation

Read the complete text