Hidden correlations in quantum jumps: A theory of individual trials

Hiroshi Ishikawa · 2025

Read Hidden correlations in quantum jumps: A theory of individual trials by Hiroshi Ishikawa (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-11277.txt.

Introduction

Hiroshi Ishikawa wrote this 2025 paper on the basics of quantum theory, with no co-authors. The topic is a clash of two pictures. In one, a watched system jumps between energy states. In the other, its change is smooth. Ishikawa seeks an account that holds both at once, trial by trial.

He recasts each jump sequence as a set of claims. Each claim says which energy states are filled. Chain operators give each claim its odds. A selection rule then filters the claims. It keeps only those with well-defined joint odds for a given state. Claims that clash, the kind behind known paradoxes, are thrown out. The usual demand that operators commute is not imposed. The scheme captures firm links between jumps in one trial. One link says a state is filled by one thing only, much like Boolean logic. Standard odds still come out right.

Catalog record

CREATORHiroshi Ishikawa
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE157 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-11277

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Hidden correlations in quantum jumps: A theory of individual trials Hiroshi Ishikawa Abstract Quantum trajectory theories have not fully reconciled discrete quantum jumps with continuous unitary evolution. We address this challenge by developing a hidden variable formulation that reveals hidden correlations in individual trials. We represent jump sequences as logical propositions on energy eigenstate occupations, where logical variables describe their truth values and chain operators describe their probabilities. To circumvent established no-go theorems, we introduce a proposition selection rule that requires well-defined joint probabilities for a given density operator. This rule unifies compatibility criteria for quantum and hidden variable theories, eliminating incompatible propositions that lead to value assignment paradoxes. Unlike conventional criteria mandating operator commutativity, it permits propositions that become deterministic for specific initial conditions. This framework systematically captures deterministic relations in individual trials, including the exclusivity of state occupation implied by the observed jumps. This exclusivity, distinct from the Pauli exclusion principle, enables the formalization of a quantum version of Boolean logic as laws for quantum propositions. These assumptions circumvent Bell-type inequalities by prohibiting arithmetic operations between incompatible logical variables, while enabling classical descriptions within the complementarity. The resulting theory reconciles discrete jumps with continuous evolution, providing a direct description of individual trials while preserving standard probability predictions. I Introduction Quantum jumps have been observed in diverse systems, including photon counters Hamamatsu1 ; Bachor , trapped ions QuantumJump2 ; QuantumJump1 , and radiation fields in high-Q cavities Haroche1 ; Haroche3 . These discrete transitions have provoked considerable theoretical debate Gisin1992 ; Zeh1993 because they apparently contradict continuous unitary evolution. This contradiction is particularly evident in photon counting experiments, where individual measurements yield discrete integers n(t)\,{=}\,0,1,\ldots , while quantum theory predicts continuous expectation values \langle n(t)\rangle\,{\in}\,\mathbb{R} . Such integer functions are non-differentiable at jump points and thus cannot be derived from any standard differential equations. This observation reveals an intrinsic duality of quantum theory: individual outcomes do not emerge as solutions to its equations of motion Einstein1905 . Consequently, integer functions are found experimentally, even though they themselves cannot be derived from any differential laws. When quantum jumps were first observed for single quantum systems, this fundamental conflict between experiments and theories prompted two distinct interpretations. The early interpretation Cook1985 ; QuantumJump2 treated jumps as transitions between energy eigenstates, following Bohr’s atomic model Bohr1913 and Einstein’s rate equations Einstein1917 . This view, suggesting that binary logical variables can represent state occupation, directly conflicts with established no-go theorems for hidden variable (HV) theories Peres . In contrast, modern theoretical frameworks Haroche ; Daley2014 avoid this conflict by reinterpreting jumps as stochastic interruptions of state evolution. These approaches, however, face inherent limitations in their definitions of quantum trajectories and do not resolve the coexistence of multiple physical mechanisms for the discontinuities. Specifically, the open systems and quantum jump approaches Carmichael ; Plenio1998 define quantum trajectories using quantum master equations, numerically demonstrating state collapse due to environmental decoherence Haroche . These approaches, however, fail to predict the collapse of coherent states and cannot describe the absorption of coherent light. While discrete photodetector responses are conventionally attributed to photons, both the photon concept Antiphoton ; Muthukrishnan and the mechanism of “true” light absorption Hopfield1958 remain controversial in quantum optics. The consistent histories approach Griffiths2001 ; Omnes1992 takes a different approach, defining quantum trajectories through time-ordered products of unitary projectors and focusing on a consistent statistical description. Yet, this approach also faces challenges in restoring classical responses of apparatus within unitary dynamics. These limitations now warrant reconsideration of the early view: observed jumps may indicate true discontinuities, despite theoretical prohibitions. Indeed, detector counts n(t) in photon counting experiments behave as binary logical variables when \langle n(t)\rangle\,{\ll}\,1 . This suggests that logical variables emerge in experimental contexts and may require theoretical analyses. In particular, these logical variables should describe the photoelectric effect at each detection site—single-shot events that initiate counting sequences. Current experimental techniques for manipulating single quantum systems should enable more quantitative verification of such logical variables. Meaningful tests, however, require a theoretical framework that at least admits their existence. We therefore reexamine the premises of major no-go theorems and develop a HV formulation that describes quantum jumps using logical variables. This paper is organized as follows. Section II identifies three fundamental challenges for introducing HVs to quantum trajectory theories. Section III describes our strategy: restricting to energy eigenstates, introducing a proposition selection rule, and incorporating Boolean logic. Section IV formalizes these concepts within non-relativistic quantum electrodynamics (QED), presenting our eightfold assumptions. Section V demonstrates how our framework describes individual trials. We derive deterministic relations in entangled systems and provide three illustrative examples: the EPR correlations, classical trajectories, and the light quantum hypothesis. We also present a numerical simulation of the double-slit experiment using coherent light. Section VI presents overall conclusions. Mathematical derivations are provided in Supplemental Material Supplemental , and applications to contemporary problems are discussed in a separate paper. II Challenges We must address three interrelated challenges simultaneously. First, any self-consistent theory must circumvent established no-go theorems against HV theories. These theorems concern: (i) value assignments to operators (Kochen-Specker Kochen1967 , CHSH CHSH , GHZ GHZ ); (ii) continuity of density operators (Gleason Gleason1957 ; Peres ); and (iii) Bell’s model of local HVs Bell . Value assignment constitutes the primary obstacle, while other paradoxes present unique challenges that require careful treatment. Second, we must identify a proper classical limit to reconcile the discontinuity of logical variables with the continuity of wavefunctions. While this issue arises in both classical motion EPR ; EPR-Bohr and macroscopic two-level systems Leggett , we focus on classical motion, since we do not assume non-invasive measurements. Third, we must harmonize Boolean logic with quantum theory. This challenge, partially addressed in the consistent histories approach, is connected to the first through incompatibility problems specific to the theories of state occupations. III Methods We address these challenges through three interdependent modifications to the consistent histories approach: (A) restricting projectors to energy eigenstates, (B) revising compatibility criteria, and (C) establishing Boolean logic as laws for individual trials. These modifications work together to provide a self-consistent framework. III.1 Restricting projectors to energy eigenstates The first modification restricts projectors to those specified by the spectral decomposition of a single observable. This restriction eliminates the need to assign values to all commuting observables. The same principle Held2022 previously justified Bohm’s HV theory Bohm1952 , which employs position operators to establish an alternative interpretation. We instead use the energy operator to describe the observed jumps between energy eigenstates QuantumJump2 ; QuantumJump1 . Specifically, these states are defined as the orthonormal eigenstates of the non-interacting Hamiltonian in non-relativistic QED Messiah . Our formulation thus concerns the occupation of Bohr’s stationary states, where these stationary states are now generalized to represent both atomic systems and radiation fields. For non-degenerate systems with unique stationary states, assigning 1 to the occupied state and 0 to others yields stochastic logical variables that describe individual trials. Quantum theory can calculate the occupation probability of any such state. For degenerate systems, however, paradoxes persist due to the non-uniqueness of stationary states. For example, a spin-1 system in zero magnetic field has three degenerate stationary states |a;{\mathrm{x}}\rangle , where the parameter {\mathrm{x}} represents

Read the complete text