A Web-Based Environment for the Specification and Generation of Smart Legal Contracts

Regan Meloche, Durga Sivakumar, Amal A. Anda, Sofana Alfuhaid, Daniel Amyot, Luigi Logrippo, John Mylopoulos · 2025

Read A Web-Based Environment for the Specification and Generation of Smart Legal Contracts by Regan Meloche, Durga Sivakumar, Amal A. Anda, Sofana Alfuhaid, Daniel Amyot, Luigi Logrippo, John Mylopoulos (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-11258.txt.

Introduction

Regan Meloche and 6 co-authors built a web tool that turns legal contract templates into monitoring smart contracts in this 2025 paper. Checking that parties keep their promises matters most when violations are caught as they happen. Smart contracts can automate that watch, but lawyers write in natural language and programmers write code, and the gap between them is wide.

Their environment guides users through refining a formal specification, written in the Symboleo language, from a contract template. It then generates the monitoring contract for the Hyperledger Fabric platform automatically. A sample contract from the energy trading field walks through the whole flow. The authors argue the tool can speed compliance work where contracts must be watched continuously.

Catalog record

CREATORRegan Meloche, Durga Sivakumar, Amal A. Anda, Sofana Alfuhaid, Daniel Amyot, Luigi Logrippo, John Mylopoulos
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE26 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-11258

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Web-Based Environment for the Specification and Generation of Smart Legal Contracts Thanks: Partially funded by NSERC’s Strategic Partnership Grant Middleware Framework and Programming Infrastructure for IoT Services , by SSHRC’s Partnership Grant Autonomy Through Cyberjustice Technologies , and by the ORF-RE project CyPreSS: Software Techniques for the Engineering of Cyber-Physical Systems . Regan Meloche, Durga Sivakumar, Amal A. Anda, Sofana Alfuhaid, Daniel Amyot, Luigi Logrippo, John Mylopoulos Abstract Monitoring the compliance of contract performance against legal obligations is important in order to detect violations, ideally, as soon as they occur. Such monitoring can nowadays be achieved through the use of smart contracts, which provide protection against tampering as well as some level of automation in handling violations. However, there exists a large gap between natural language contracts and smart contract implementations. This paper introduces a Web-based environment that partly fills that gap by supporting the user-assisted refinement of Symboleo specifications corresponding to legal contract templates, followed by the automated generation of monitoring smart contracts deployable on the Hyperledger Fabric platform. This environment, illustrated using a sample contract from the transactive energy domain, shows much potential in accelerating the development of smart contracts in a legal compliance context. 1 Introduction Legal contracts describe obligations and powers that apply to business transactions between parties playing roles such buyers and sellers, or service providers and consumers. Most often, they are redacted in Natural Language (NL). Violations of obligations may enable defined powers such as premature contract termination or penalties. They can also lead to costly conflict resolution mechanisms, including litigation in courts. Monitoring contract performance is important to detect such violations as early as possible, in order to favor potential alternative courses of actions and avoid litigation. Nowadays, legal contracts can benefit from various automation strategies and technologies. For example, smart contracts are programs intended to partially automate legal contracts and monitor them for compliance with relevant terms and conditions. However, this paper uses a generic definition of smart contracts based on Szabo’s [ 17 ] , which is independent of the blockchain-based technologies commonly referenced in the past 15 years. Contract templates capture standard clauses that enable their reuse (e.g., by selecting clauses), customization (e.g., through parameters), and refinement (e.g., by modifying clauses) for particular contexts. Such templates are particularly useful in situations where the type of business transaction targeted is well understood. One issue here is that refinement of a template may lead to an invalid contract (e.g., due to newly introduced inconsistencies) or to the unexpected dissatisfaction of desirable properties that the original template satisfied. Another issue is that the monitoring mechanisms supporting the original template may need to be updated to reflect such refinements. One solution avenue for both problems is the use of an intermediate formalization of legal templates that supports both property verification and the generation of smart contracts that monitor legal contract executions [ 15 ] . For example, the Symboleo language [ 14 ] can be used to specify contract templates in terms of parameterized obligations and powers, while enabling formal verification of properties [ 11 ] and the automated generation of monitoring smart contracts [ 13 ] . Although Symboleo is supported by an Eclipse-based editor and automated code generators [ 14 ] , the creation of formal specifications for contract templates and their refinements are currently done manually . Also, the Eclipse Integrated Development Environment (IDE) [ 4 ] is a desktop environment that requires many components to be installed locally, which is a major barrier to entry for many potential Symboleo users. In an effort to simplify and partially automate the generation and modification of Symboleo specifications, this paper provides two main contributions: • A Web-based tool ( SymboleoNLP , https://bit.ly/SymboleoNLP ) that handles part of the formalization of NL templates to Symboleo specifications, with a focus on temporal and conditional refinements. • A Web-based IDE ( SymboleoWeb , https://bit.ly/Symboleo_Web ) that takes the generated Symboleo , enables intelligent editing and validation, and converts it to executable smart contracts in JavaScript for the Hyperledger Fabric distributed ledger platform ( https://www.hyperledger.org/projects/fabric ). SymboleoWeb simplifies the access to Symboleo tools. This composite Web-based environment is illustrated here using a transactive energy (TE) contract template example. TE markets already use smart contracts and are eager to support small-scale but automated contracts for trading energy between prosumers (i.e., consumers who also produce and sell energy). The rest of this paper is as follows. Section 2 first presents related work in that area. Section 3 describes how SymboleoNLP helps generate Symboleo specifications from refined NL templates, while Section 4 illustrates how SymboleoWeb supports editing and code generation. An analysis of different refinements to a TE contract template in terms of their impact on the size of the Symboleo specifications and JavaScript code generated is provided in Section 5 . Finally, Sections 6 and 7 present a discussion and our conclusions, respectively. 2 Related Work There exist several formal specification languages for legal contracts [ 15 ] and for smart contracts [ 19 ] . Some support a certain degree of code generation from abstract specifications, while some support the formal verification of properties [ 7 , 19 ] . Symboleo is unique since it enables both i) formal verification of desirable properties expressed in Linear Temporal Logic or in Computation Tree Logic [ 11 ] , as well as ii) the automated generation of smart contracts (using the Symboleo2SC [ 13 ] tool) deployable on the Hyperledger Fabric platform. Symboleo exploits a legal contract ontology with concepts such as obligation, power, party, role, asset, and event [ 14 ] . The language enables modelers to specify contracts by defining a domain model that extends this ontology, and then the legal obligations and powers that express legal clauses and terms. Symboleo has been used to specify different types of supply chain contracts that can benefit from automated monitoring of performance. This includes the transactive energy domain [ 10 ] , where energy is the asset being sold from prosumers to buyers. TE contracts have also been coded manually by others as smart contracts running over different blockchain platforms [ 5 , 6 ] . One key issue is the generation of formal specifications from NL contracts. For the Symboleo ontology, some preliminary work was done by Soavi et al. [ 16 ] , but with limited automation. Meloche et al. [ 8 , 9 ] recently provided a higher level of automation in the generation of Symboleo specifications, but only for certain categories of legal contracts templates . An unrefined template ( T ) is converted manually to Symboleo (specification S(T) ), and then manual refinements ( C ) of the original template, expressed using a controlled natural language (CNL) supported by a dynamic grammar, are automatically transformed into valid refinements of the specification ( S(C) ). We extend this work with a more complete translation and a web-based interface implemented in the SymboleoNLP tool. Tateishi et al. [ 18 ] proposed a technique and a toolset for automatically generating a smart contract from a contract written in a CNL using a template-based approach. For a given contract domain, a contract template is manually created, which contains

Read the complete text