Bistability and Noise-Induced Evasion in Tumor-Immune Dynamics with Antigen Accumulation and Immune Escape

Mengfan Tan, Shaoqing Chen, Chunjin Wei, Da Zhou · 2025

Read Bistability and Noise-Induced Evasion in Tumor-Immune Dynamics with Antigen Accumulation and Immune Escape by Mengfan Tan, Shaoqing Chen, Chunjin Wei, Da Zhou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-11048.txt.

Introduction

Mengfan Tan and three co-authors wrote this 2025 mathematical biology paper. It models how a tumor and the immune system push against each other. The model tracks four interacting groups. It includes two effects that are often left out. Antigens pile up over time. Tumor cells also mutate to escape attack.

The system can settle into one of two stable outcomes. One is immune control. The other is immune escape. This helps explain why similar cancers can end so differently. Random noise in nearby tissue can tip the system between outcomes. The authors estimate how strong that noise must be. They also estimate how long tipping takes. Oddly, stronger immune pressure can sometimes help a tumor escape.

Catalog record

CREATORMengfan Tan, Shaoqing Chen, Chunjin Wei, Da Zhou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-11048

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Bistability and Noise-Induced Evasion in Tumor-Immune Dynamics with Antigen Accumulation and Immune Escape Thanks: Submitted to the editors DATE. Mengfan Tan, Shaoqing Chen, Chunjin Wei, Da Zhou Abstract Tumor-immune interactions are shaped by both antigenic heterogeneity and stochastic perturbations in the tumor microenvironment, yet the mathematical mechanisms underlying immune phase transitions remain poorly understood. We propose a four-compartment dynamical model that incorporates antigen accumulation and immune escape mutations. Bifurcation analysis reveals bistability between immune surveillance and immune escape states, providing a mechanistic explanation for heterogeneous immune outcomes during tumor progression. In the multistable regime, the stable manifold of a saddle point partitions the state space into distinct basins of attraction, determining the long-term fate of the system. We further analyze how stochastic fluctuations in the tumor microenvironment perturb these separatrices, potentially triggering irreversible state transitions. By characterizing the critical noise intensity and estimating the tipping time, we establish a mathematical framework for assessing noise-induced transitions. The model further predicts that increasing tumor cell death can improve system resilience to stochastic perturbations, whereas stronger immune pressure may facilitate immune escape—highlighting the nonlinear and non-monotonic nature of tumor-immune dynamics. keywords Tumor immune escape, Heterogeneity, Bifurcation analysis, Bistability, Stochastic perturbations Funding. This work of the fourth author was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 12471475 and 11971405), the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities in China (Grant No. 20720230023 and 20720240151) † † runningheads: Tumor-Immune Bistability and Noise-Induced Escape / M. Tan, S. Chen, C. Wei, and D. Zhou MSC 34F05, 65C20, 92B05 1 Introduction Cancer remains one of the leading causes of mortality worldwide, with an estimated 20 million new cases and 9.7 million deaths in 2022 alone [ 8 ] . Despite significant advances in cancer research, many aspects of tumor progression remain poorly understood. The immune system, as the body’s natural defense, plays a critical role in recognizing and eliminating malignant cells [ 12 ] . A central question in cancer biology is how the immune system dynamically responds to tumor development and how tumors, in turn, evade immune control [ 13 ] . The theory of cancer immunoediting provides a foundational framework for understanding tumor-immune coevolution. This process is typically characterized by three dynamic phases: elimination, equilibrium, and escape [ 14 , 34 ] . During elimination, immune cells detect and destroy antigen-expressing tumor cells [ 16 ] . However, prolonged immune pressure can drive the selection of immune-evasive phenotypes, leading to tumor escape. This escape is facilitated by various mechanisms, including reduced neoantigen visibility due to low tumor mutational burden [ 18 , 29 ] , impaired antigen presentation through HLA-I loss or silencing [ 5 , 4 ] , T cell exhaustion driven by PD-L1 overexpression [ 37 , 19 ] , and the formation of an immunosuppressive microenvironment [ 7 , 41 ] . These adaptations highlight the complexity and plasticity of tumor-immune interactions and underscore the need for mathematical models to explore their dynamical behavior. Immune escape remains one of the central challenges in cancer treatment. Immunotherapies—aimed at enhancing antitumor immune responses—have emerged as a transformative strategy and are now regarded as the fourth pillar of cancer treatment alongside surgery, radiotherapy, and chemotherapy [ 33 , 42 , 44 ] . Despite their clinical success in certain cancers, immunotherapies exhibit highly variable efficacy across patients [ 30 , 2 , 11 , 17 , 31 ] . Intratumor heterogeneity (ITH), driven by genetic instability and selective immune pressure, is a major contributor to this variability [ 36 , 1 , 46 ] . Recent studies have suggested that negative frequency-dependent selection (NFDS) accelerates phenotypic diversification and promotes adaptive resistance to immune checkpoint blockade [ 9 ] . Additionally, the tumor microenvironment can suppress immune activity through non-genetic factors such as inflammation, nutrient deprivation, or local immunosuppression [ 35 ] . While these phenomena are well documented experimentally, their dynamic and mechanistic implications remain poorly understood. In particular, the interplay between antigenic evolution, immune pressure, and stochastic perturbations in the tumor microenvironment has not been systematically quantified. Mathematical modeling provides a powerful framework for exploring tumor immune dynamics, allowing researchers to investigate nonlinear behavior, multistability, and treatment response under perturbations. Classical models often abstract tumor-immune interactions as predator-prey systems and employ Lotka-Volterra-type equations to study oscillatory dynamics or tumor elimination [ 40 , 10 , 25 ] . Other efforts have focused on capturing the multistage nature of cancer immunoediting. For example, Alvarez et al. [ 3 ] incorporated multiple immunogenic phenotypes into a nonlinear ODE model to analyze phase transitions between elimination and escape. Delay differential equations have been used to characterize immune regulation [ 43 ] , and hybrid cellular automata have captured transient dormancy states [ 26 ] . More recent models account for tumor heterogeneity, such as the use of integro-differential equations to model phenotypic distributions [ 20 ] , or agent-based frameworks to study how antigen diversity affects immune control [ 24 ] . While these models have deepened our understanding of tumor-immune interactions, most treat antigenic variation and immune escape as static traits or deterministic inputs. In particular, the coupled dynamics of antigen accumulation and immune escape under stochastic microenvironment have not been fully addressed. A unified model that captures both evolutionary dynamics and stochastic processes is essential for understanding how immune surveillance transitions to immune escape. These observations motivate the following key questions: (1) How does the dynamic accumulation of antigenic mutations influence transitions in the cancer immunoediting process? (2) What are the underlying mechanisms that lead to divergent immune outcomes such as surveillance or escape? (3) How do stochastic perturbations in the tumor microenvironment trigger irreversible shifts toward immune escape? To address these questions, we develop a minimal four-compartment model that captures the coupled dynamics of antigen accumulation and immune escape in a fluctuating microenvironment. This framework allows us to explore multistability, bifurcation structures, and noise-induced transitions. By quantifying the tipping thresholds and escape times, our model provides theoretical insights into the emergence of heterogeneous immune responses and the loss of tumor control. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides a detailed description of deterministic and stochastic models, and their long-term dynamic behaviors are analyzed in section 3. Section 4 performs a bifurcation analysis of key parameters. Additionally, the separatrix dividing the two attraction regions is plotted using the stable manifold of the saddle point. Furthermore, we characterize noise-induced transitions and estimate the critical noise intensity and average escape time. Section 5 concludes the paper with a summary and discussion. 2 Mathematical model In modeling the heterogeneous growth of tumors, we consider antigen mutation, antigen accumulation, and immune escape mutations in tumor cells. Based on these processes, tumor cells are classified into four subpopulations: antigenically neutral cells ( \bar{N} ), antigenic cells ( \bar{A} ), immunogenic cells ( \bar{I} ), and immune-escaped cells ( \bar{E} ). The main transition relationships among these subpopulations are summarized in Fig. 1 . To establish a tractable model, we make the following assumptions: (A1) Factors such as angiogenesis, immune cells, and other cytokines are not considered; the focus is solely on the interplay among these subpopulations. (A2) Antigenic mutation, antigen accumulation,

Read the complete text