Leading-renormalon-free Trace-anomaly-subtracted σ \sigma -mass for Heavy Quarks up to Five Loops in QCD

Long Chen, Cong Zhao · 2025

Read Leading-renormalon-free Trace-anomaly-subtracted σ \sigma -mass for Heavy Quarks up to Five Loops in QCD by Long Chen, Cong Zhao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-10786.txt.

Introduction

Long Chen and Cong Zhao redefine the mass of a heavy quark in this 2025 paper. The textbook pole mass carries a hidden flaw. An infrared renormalon ambiguity limits its precision, no matter how many loops are computed. Their candidate, the sigma-mass, is built by subtracting the trace anomaly contribution. They argue it is free of that leading ambiguity, and stays scheme- and scale-independent.

The authors show the offending divergence lives entirely in the trace anomaly part of the energy-momentum tensor. They derive a formula linking the sigma-mass to the pole mass. It uses only the beta function, the mass anomalous dimension, and a rewritten conversion factor. They push the relation to five loops. They also chart how lattice QCD could extract the sigma-mass directly, analyzing the matching through four loops. The case is for a cleaner shared standard.

Catalog record

CREATORLong Chen, Cong Zhao
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-10786

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Leading-renormalon-free Trace-anomaly-subtracted σ \sigma -mass for Heavy Quarks up to Five Loops in QCD Long Chen, Cong Zhao Abstract We demonstrate that the leading IR-renormalon divergence in the perturbative pole mass of a massive quark resides entirely in the contribution from the trace anomaly of the energy-momentum tensor in QCD. Consequently, the recently proposed trace-anomaly-subtracted σ \sigma -mass definition for heavy quarks is not only scheme- and scale-invariant, but also free from the leading IR-renormalon ambiguity. We further derive a formula connecting this σ \sigma -mass to the perturbative pole mass, solely in terms of the QCD β \beta -function, quark-mass anomalous dimension γ m \gamma_{m} and a proper rewritten form of the pole-to- MS ¯ \overline{\mathrm{MS}} mass conversion factor. Utilizing this formula along with the ingredients available in the literature, we present the explicit five-loop result for the perturbative relationship between the σ \sigma -mass and the perturbative pole mass in QCD under the approximation of keeping only a single quark massive. Given the theoretical merits of this mass definition and the availability of high-precision conversion relations, we encourage its application to high-energy processes with heavy quarks, e.g. H → b ​ b ¯ + X QCD H\rightarrow b\bar{b}+X_{\mathrm{QCD}} , and to current-current correlators used in determining heavy-quark masses and decay widths. In this short communication we are concerned with the leading infrared (IR) renormalon [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] in the contribution from the trace anomaly of the energy-momentum tensor (EMT) [ 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] to the perturbative pole mass of a massive quark (which is itself defined to any but finite orders in perturbative QCD [ 12 , 13 ] ). And we aim to demonstrate that this contribution fully captures the leading IR-renormalon singularity observed in the perturbative pole mass definition [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] . Regarding the trace-anomaly contribution to the perturbative pole mass in QCD under the approximation of keeping only a single quark massive, one of us has derived the following relation [ 18 ] to any loop orders, \langle p,s\big|\,2\epsilon\big[-\frac{1}{4}F^{a}_{\mu\nu}\,F^{a\,\mu\nu}\big]_{B}\,\big|p,s\rangle\big|_{\mathrm{ampu.}}=\bar{u}(p,s)\Big(\hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big)\,u(p,s)\,, (1) an identity between the dimensionally-regularized bare (unsubtracted) amputated matrix element of the EMT trace-anomaly operator 2\epsilon\big[-\frac{1}{4}F^{a}_{\mu\nu}\,F^{a\,\mu\nu}\big]_{B} over the on-shell massive quark state described by the Dirac spinor u(p,s) with an on-shell momentum \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} 1 1 1 With some abuse of notation, the shorthand equality \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} shall always be understood as implicitly applying to on-shell Dirac-spinors satisfying the on-shell equation of motion. (and helicity s ), and the bare self-energy function \Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu}) in the Landau gauge. \Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu}) is defined according to the usual parameterization of the full inverse propagating function \not{p}-m_{B}-\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu}) of the massive quark, of which we refer to ref. [ 18 ] for more technical details. Although omitted from the notation used, \Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu}) also depends on the bare QCD coupling \alpha_{s}^{B} and will be computed perturbatively as a power series in this parameter. Having in mind the use of the \overline{\mathrm{MS}} renormalization of \alpha_{s}^{B} in Dimensional Regularization (DR) with spacetime D=4-2\epsilon , we adopt the usual convention 2 2 2 Here it is unnecessary to pull out the conventional e^{\epsilon\gamma_{E}}\big(4\pi\big)^{-\epsilon} factor related to the particular choice of normalization convention for loop integration measures, which is irrelevant for the present discussion. \alpha_{s}^{B}\equiv\hat{\mu}^{2\epsilon}\,\hat{\alpha}_{s}^{B} for introducing a reduced mass-dimensionless bare coupling \hat{\alpha}_{s}^{B} at the expense of introducing the auxiliary mass-dimensionful variable \hat{\mu} in DR (which can be set conveniently, albeit not necessarily, the same as the actual renormalization or subtraction scale \mu ). It is very important to note that the logarithmic partial derivative \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} in the r.h.s. of eq. ( 1 ) shall be understood as taken before approaching the on-shell kinematic limit \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} . To be more specific, a slightly generalized form of eq. ( 1 ) can be stated in terms of the amputated Green correlation function with the insertion of the local operator \mathcal{O}_{F}[\xi]\equiv\big[-\frac{1}{4}F^{a}_{\mu\nu}\,F^{a\,\mu\nu}-\frac{1}{2\xi}\big(\partial_{\mu}A^{\mu}_{a}\big)^{2}\big]_{B} at zero momentum as following: \int\mathrm{d}^{D}x\,\mathrm{d}^{D}y\,e^{+ip\cdot(x-y)}\,\langle 0\big|\,2\epsilon\,\hat{\mathrm{T}}\{\mathcal{O}_{F}[\xi]\,\psi_{B}(x)\,\bar{\psi}_{B}(y)\}\,\big|0\rangle_{\mathrm{ampu.}}=\hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\,, (2) which holds for an off-shell momentum p in a generic covariant gauge-fixing condition parameterized by \xi . At the on-shell limit \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} , eq. ( 2 ) reduces to eq. ( 1 ) in the Landau gauge corresponding to \xi=0 . The partial derivative w.r.t. \hat{\mu} in the r.h.s. of eq. ( 2 ) shall be performed before \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} . We shall take eq. ( 1 ) and/or eq. ( 2 ) as the starting point of the following discussion on the leading IR-renormalon terms in the quantum trace-anomaly contribution \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B}\,,\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}} so-defined at the on-shell limit. 1 Leading IR-renormalon terms in the trace-anomaly contribution If we boldly assume that one can exchange the operation ordering of taking the partial derivative in \hat{\mu} and approaching the on-shell momentum configuration \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} , we then obtain \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}=\hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\big(m_{\mathrm{os}}-m_{B}\big)}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}=\hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\,, (3) where we have employed the on-shell renormalization condition leading to \Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})\big|_{\not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}}}=m_{\mathrm{os}}-m_{B}\,, and \frac{\partial\,m_{B}}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}=0 holding by definition. The meaning of this partial derivative \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,m_{\mathrm{os}}}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} shall be interpreted with care, as indicated by the last equality in ( 3 ) with the arguments specified explicitly in brackets, especially in view of the well-known renormalization-scale independence of the perturbative pole mass [ 19 , 12 , 17 , 13 ] , i.e. \mathrm{d}\,m_{\mathrm{os}}/\mathrm{d}\,\mu=0 . The non-vanishing \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} is itself among the possible reasons why taking the partial derivative in \frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} may not, in general, naively commute with approaching the on-shell limit \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} . We now justify the heuristic result in Eq. ( 3 ) with a more rigorous derivation. To this end, let us start from the original unambiguous defining form for the on-shell renormalized operator matrix element in question, namely \bar{u}(p,s)\,\mathrm{TA}_{m}\,u(p,s)\equiv\bar{u}(p,s)\,Z_{\psi}\,\Big(\hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big)\big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\,u(p,s)\, (4) where the partial derivative \frac{\partial\,}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} is defined as taken before approaching the on-shell limit \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} . It is convenient at this moment to recall the on-shell renormalization condition in terms of the subtracted self-energy correction \Sigma_{R} defined according to Z_{\psi}\,\big(\not{p}-m_{B}-\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})\big)=\not{p}-m_{\mathrm{os}}-\Sigma_{R} , which reads \Sigma_{R}\,\Big|_{\not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}}}=0\,;\quad\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{R}\,}{\partial\,\not{p}}\Big|_{\not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}}}=0\,. (5) We can now proceed with the derivation in the following sequence: \displaystyle\bar{u}(p,s)\,\mathrm{TA}_{m}\,u(p,s) \displaystyle=\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,Z_{\psi}\Big(\hat{\mu}\,\frac{\partial\,\Big(\Sigma_{B}(\not{p},m_{B},\hat{\mu})+m_{B}-\not{p}\Big)}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\Big)\,u(p,s) \displaystyle=\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,Z_{\psi}\Big(\hat{\mu}\,\frac{\partial\,\Big(Z^{-1}_{\psi}\,\big(m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})-\not{p}+\Sigma_{R}\,\big)\Big)}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\Big)\,u(p,s) \displaystyle=\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,Z_{\psi}\Big(\hat{\mu}\,Z^{-1}_{\psi}\,\frac{\partial\,\Big(m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})-\not{p}+\Sigma_{R}\,\Big)}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\Big)\,u(p,s) \displaystyle\,+\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,Z_{\psi}\Big(\hat{\mu}\,\Big(\frac{\partial\,Z^{-1}_{\psi}\,}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big)\,\Big(m_{\mathrm{os}}-\not{p}+\Sigma_{R}\,\Big)\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\Big)\,u(p,s) \displaystyle=\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,\Big(\hat{\mu}\,\frac{\partial\,\Big(m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})-\not{p}\Big)}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\,+\,\hat{\mu}\,\frac{\partial\,\Sigma_{R}\,}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\Big|_{\not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}}}\Big)\,u(p,s) \displaystyle=\,\bar{u}(p,s)\,\hat{\mu}\,\frac{\partial\,m_{\mathrm{os}}(m_{B},\hat{\mu})}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}}\,u(p,s)\,, (6) where the partial derivative w.r.t. \hat{\mu} is always taken before approaching \not{p}\rightarrow m_{\mathrm{os}} . The vanishing of the second part in the third last equality of eq. ( 1 ) at \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} is due to the on-shell renormalization condition ( 5 ), i.e. the vanishing of the inverse renormalized propagator m_{\mathrm{os}}-\not{p}+\Sigma_{R} at \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} , and the existence of \partial\,Z^{-1}_{\psi}/\partial\,\hat{\mu} . The vanishing of the second part in the second last equality of eq. ( 1 ) is due to the implication of ( 5 ): \Sigma_{R} has an asymptotic series expansion around the pole mass \not{p}=m_{\mathrm{os}} that begins with the quadratic power-suppression factor \mathcal{O}\big((\not{p}-m_{\mathrm{os}})^{2}\big) . We thus manage to demonstrate in a rigorous manner that the heuristic result ( 3 ) happens to be the correct result. The task now is to properly interpret the meaning of this partial derivative \hat{\mu}\frac{\partial\,m_{\mathrm{os}}}{\partial\,\hat{\mu}} in eq. ( 3 ) and ( 1 ). For the sake of investigating the IR-renormalon behavior [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 ] related to the pole-mass definition, we shall take a parameterization form where this property is fully manifested.

Read the complete text