Directionality of the Voynich Script
Christophe Parisel (Labyrinthinesecurity) · 2025
Read Directionality of the Voynich Script by Christophe Parisel (Labyrinthinesecurity) (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-10573.txt.
Introduction
Christophe Parisel, writing alone, asks which way the Voynich script reads in this 2025 paper. The famous undeciphered manuscript was almost surely written left to right on the page. Whether the underlying script or cipher itself runs left-to-right or right-to-left is a separate question, and it has had little measured attention. Parisel introduces a statistical test based on how predictable character sequences are in each direction, using n-gram perplexity asymmetry to detect a directional bias in the text.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christophe Parisel (Labyrinthinesecurity) |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-10573
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Directionality of the Voynich Script Christophe Parisel (Labyrinthinesecurity) Abstract Introduction While the Voynich Manuscript was almost certainly written left-to-right (LTR), the question of whether it should be read LTR or right-to-left (RTL) has received little quantitative attention. We introduce a statistical method that leverages n-gram perplexity asymmetry to determine directional bias in character sequences. This language-agnostic method computes n-gram perplexities for text read both LTR and RTL. The difference \Delta=X_{\text{LTR}}-X_{\text{RTL}} of cross-entropy X indicates directional optimization: • \Delta>0 : RTL-optimized • \Delta<0 : LTR-optimized • \Delta\approx 0 : no directional bias When applied to the Voynich Manuscript, the results reveal consistent RTL optimization patterns, providing quantitative evidence for its directional structure. Data preparation We select five corpora in our study: the RF1b-e EVA transcription of the Manuscript [ 6 , 7 ] , and four reference data sets for directionality control: • LTR control (English and French): Melville’s Moby Dick [ 1 ] , Dumas’ Comte de Monte Cristo [ 2 ] • RTL control (Hebrew and Arabic): The Big Arabic Corpus [ 3 ] , The SVLM Hebrew Wikipedia Corpus [ 4 ] All corpora are preprocessed and tokenized consistently to ensure a fair cross-linguistic comparison. To normalize sources of directional signal, we implement two tokenization modes: • baseline: tokenization preserves the original grapheme order. Sentences are flattened to a sequence of graphemes (no artificial word markers). We use this mode for Voynich, French and English tokenization. • visual: reverse graphemes inside each word and then reverse the order of words. This models the surface visual order of RTL scripts (what a reader sees on a page rendered RTL). We use this mode for Arabic and Hebrew tokenization. Perplexity diagnostics and directional asymmetry To quantify directional structure in the Voynich manuscript, we compute n-gram perplexity for both left-to-right (LTR) and right-to-left (RTL) token sequences. Perplexity is a standard information-theoretic measure of how well a sequence model predicts a token stream; lower perplexity indicates higher predictability. Perplexity computation We use two smoothing methods for perplexity computation: Laplace and Kneser-Ney. Both give very similar outcomes. Laplace smoothing Let a corpus be tokenized into N prediction tokens w_{1},\dots,w_{N} (with no an end-of-sentence marker, since words breaking is clear in all corpora). For each n -gram (w_{i-n+1},\dots,w_{i}) with context c=(w_{i-n+1},\dots,w_{i-1}) , we estimate conditional probabilities with Laplace (add-one) smoothing: \hat{p}(w_{i}\mid c)\;=\;\frac{\mathrm{count}(c,w_{i})+1}{\mathrm{count}(c)+V}, where V is the vocabulary size. The average cross-entropy per token (in nats, using natural logarithms) is then X\;=\;-\frac{1}{N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\ln\hat{p}(w_{i}\mid w_{i-n+1},\dots,w_{i-1}), and the perplexity is defined as \mathrm{P}\;=\;\exp(X). This measure captures the sequential predictability of tokens: lower values indicate that the sequence is more regular or better structured in that reading direction. Kneser-Ney smoothing Please refer to appendix A for computation and detailed results. Measuring directional asymmetry with perplexity We define \Delta=X_{\text{LTR}}-X_{\text{RTL}} • Positive \Delta : the RTL model predicts the corpus better (lower perplexity) than LTR, evidence of RTL optimization. • Negative \Delta : LTR is better, evidence of LTR optimization. • Near-zero \Delta : no directional preference detectable. Paired bootstrap confidence intervals To assess statistical uncertainty, we apply a paired bootstrap procedure over sentences: 1. For each sentence in the corpus, compute its log-probability contribution under both LTR and RTL n -gram models. 2. Compute the mean per-token cross-entropy difference \Delta=X_{\text{LTR}}-X_{\text{RTL}} . 3. Resample sentences with replacement to generate B=1000 bootstrap replicates. For each replicate, recompute \Delta . 4. Construct a (1-\alpha)\times 100\% confidence interval from the \alpha/2 and 1-\alpha/2 percentiles of the bootstrap \Delta distribution. This paired design ensures that each bootstrap replicate preserves the correspondence between LTR and RTL scores for the same sentences, accounting for sentence-level dependencies. Here are the methodological advantages of this approach: • Confidence intervals (CIs) were computed via bootstrapping • Language-agnostic: Works without decipherment • Quantitative: Provides confidence intervals and effect sizes • Objective and reproducible: Minimizes subjective interpretation of letter forms Voynich results Applying Laplace smoothing perplexity to the Voynich manuscript: • n=2 : \Delta\approx 0.0653 (RTL lower perplexity) with 95% CI (0.0631,0.0677) • n=3 : \Delta\approx 0.0167 (RTL lower) with 95% CI (0.0158,0.0176) • n=4 : \Delta\approx 0.0058 (RTL lower) with 95% CI (0.0056,0.0060) These results indicate a consistent, statistically significant RTL optimization across 2-gram and 3-gram lengths. The bootstrap confidence intervals demonstrate that the observed directional preference is robust to sentence-level variability. Comparison to LTR languages For English: • n=2 : \Delta\approx-0.0296 (LTR lower perplexity) with 95% CI (-0.0306,-0.0287) • n=3 : \Delta\approx-0.0132 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0136,-0.0127) • n=4 : \Delta\approx-0.0033 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0034,-0.0032) For French: • n=2 : \Delta\approx-0.1197 (LTR lower perplexity) with 95% CI (-0.1210,-0.1185) • n=3 : \Delta\approx-0.0448 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0454,-0.0444) • n=4 : \Delta\approx-0.0068 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0069,-0.0067) In both languagres, \Delta<0 , confirming LTR optimization. Comparison to RTL languages For Arabic: • n=2 : \Delta\approx-0.0359 (LTR lower perplexity) with 95% CI (-0.0376,-0.0342 • n=3 : \Delta\approx 0.0068 (RTL lower) with 95% CI (0.0063,0.0072) • n=4 : \Delta\approx 0.0003 (RTL lower) with 95% CI (0.0002,0.0003) For Hebrew: • n=2 : \Delta\approx 0.0460 (RTL lower perplexity) with 95% CI (0.0454,0.0466) • n=3 : \Delta\approx-0.0265 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0268,-0.0262) • n=4 : \Delta\approx-0.0020 (LTR lower) with 95% CI (-0.0020,-0.0020) For RTL languages, \Delta shifts from positive to negative depending on n due to morphological structure. While mixed results are obtained here, the shifts demonstrate that our method is sensitive: • Natural languages with complex morphology show irregular patterns • Voynich’s consistent RTL pattern stands out more clearly against semitic languages’ complexity Interpretation Perplexity-based \Delta with Laplace smoothing captures sequential directional dependencies across the token stream, which are insensitive to local manipulations of word-initial or word-final grapheme distributions typically found in natural language directionality studies (see appendix). Conclusion Voynich shows consistent positive \Delta (RTL lower perplexity) at n=2 to n=4 with tight bootstrap CIs. Although we cannot exclude the RTL signal could be a byproduct of a cipher or a scribal artifact rather than a natural language, this indicates local n-gram chains are directionally structured in RTL even while boundary asymmetries are suppressed. The unique combination of low perplexity and high prediction accuracy at 4-grams level demonstrates that the Voynich manuscript has weak but extremely consistent directional bias. Our research: • Supports the hypothesis of RTL reading if Voynich is a natural language, independent of visible ink direction. • Introduces a reproducible, language-agnostic methodology. • Provides testable hypotheses for paleographic and cryptographic research, such as the possibility of scribes writing physically left-to-right while encoding right-to-left sequences. We also demonstrate that conventional Gini and entropy metrics are unsuitable for measuring directionality in texts with Zipfian character distributions like Voynich. Data and code are available on Kaggle [ 9 ] Discussion And Future Work The exceptional directional predictability of the Voynich manuscript raises profound questions about its nature. It supports several theoretical frameworks: Complex Encoding Hypothesis The results are consistent with a sophisticated cipher or encoding scheme that preserves or even amplifies directional structure. Simple substitution ciphers would not maintain the higher-order dependencies observed, suggesting more complex cryptographic methods. Artificial Language Construction Viable language theories may need to account for a natural language whose word boundaries departs from a plateau boundary distribution. This makes theories involving a constructed language (with