Effects of the Strict-Tolerant Approach on Intuitionistic and Minimal Logic
Victor Barroso-Nascimento, German Mejia · 2025
Read Effects of the Strict-Tolerant Approach on Intuitionistic and Minimal Logic by Victor Barroso-Nascimento, German Mejia (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-10322.txt.
Introduction
Victor Barroso-Nascimento and German Mejia extend the strict-tolerant approach to logic in this 2025 philosophy paper. That approach redefines valid inference: the truth of the premises must guarantee not the truth but the non-falsity of the conclusion. The same idea can be stacked into metainferences, and one level higher still, and the levels may or may not drift apart.
Applying the recipe to intuitionistic logic, the authors show its strict-tolerant inferences collapse back into the classical ones, matching an effect seen before. Minimal logic behaves differently: its inferences do not collapse, yet it ends up with no valid inferences at all, a quirk that vanishes at the metainferential level. At that higher level, the classical, intuitionistic, and minimal systems all stand apart from one another.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Victor Barroso-Nascimento, German Mejia |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-10322
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effects of the Strict-Tolerant Approach on Intuitionistic and Minimal Logic Victor Barroso-Nascimento, German Mejia Abstract This paper extends the literature on the strict-tolerant logical approach by applying its methods to intuitionistic and minimal logic. In short, the strict-tolerant approach modifies the usual notion of logical consequence by stipulating that, in order for an inference to be valid, from the truth of the premises must follow the non-falsity of the conclusion. This notion can also be generalized to define strict-tolerant metainferences, metametainferences and so on, which may or may not generate logics distinct from those obtained on the inferential level. It is already known that strict-tolerant definitions can make the notion of inference for non-classical logics collapse into the classical notion, but the strength of this effect is not yet fully known. This paper shows that intuitionistic strict-tolerant inferences also collapse into classical ones, but minimal ones do not. However, minimal strict-tolerant logic has the property that no inferences are valid (which is not carried over to the metainferential level). Additionally, it is shown that the logics obtained from intuitionistic, minimal and classical logic at at the metainferential level are distinct from each other. 2021 keywords Strict-tolerant, Inferentialism, Intuitionistic Logic, Classical Logic 1 Introduction The main goal of this paper is to further the study of non-classical logics by investigating some relations between criterias for inferential validity and constructivism. Specifically, we present technical results concerning a combination of the strict-tolerant approach StrictTolerant with intuitionistic and minimal logic. It is claimed that, aside from making evident some perils of combining strict-tolerant notions of consequence with paraconsistent and constructive base logics, these results provides an answer to the questions raised by Fitting at ( Fitting , pg. 393) of (i) whether there is such a thing as a strict-tolerant version of intuitionistic logic and (ii) what would happen if we were to define a strict-tolerant logic in which inferences are valid whenever from the intuitionistic truth of the premises follows the classical truth of one of the conclusions. Our discussion is structured as follows. In the second section, we briefly comment on the relationship between the study of inferences and constructivism, providing some context for our technical results. In the third section, we offer the basic definitions required for our proofs. In the fourth section, we present this paper’s main technical results. In the fifth and final section, we conclude by providing some brief comments on the results of section four, their perceived inner workings and some possible relations to future research. 2 The inferential justification of constructivism Argumentative practices implicitly rely on the possibility of justifying claims by providing reasons for them. In the context of an argument, the act of drawing a conclusion from something purportedly providing it with a justification is called an inference . Inferences are called valid when they succeed in providing acceptable justifications and invalid when they fail to do so. Since arguments themselves are structured as successive acts of inference, the acceptability of an argument depends on the acceptability of its inferences, so an argument is valid whenever all its inferences are valid and invalid when at least one is not. Although the systematic study of argumentation has integrated logic since the works of Aristotle PrawitzValidityInference , there is still no consensus on what makes inferences, and therefore arguments, valid. In fact, Prawitz singles this as the most fundamental question of General Proof Theory PrawitzFundamental , the branch of logic dedicated to study of argumentative structures. It is also fundamental for philosophical doctrines in which inferences play a prominent role – such as inferentialism , according to which the contents of propositions are exhaustively determined by their possible uses as premises and conclusions of inferences BrandomInferentialism . The study of inferences and inferential validity is of particular interest in the context of constructive logics, for which inferentialism is contemporarily viewed as one of the most robust philosophical justifications. Michael Dummett and Dag Prawitz in particular have ostensively argued that inferences and the role they play in the determination of propositional meaning provides both a justification for the laws of intuitionistic logic and motives for rejecting classical canons of reasoning ( DummettMeta , pgs. 245-279) DUMMETT19755 Placek1999 PrawitzLogicalConsequence PrawitzMeaningProof . Also worthy of note is the remarkable affinity between formal semantics defined using the concept of inference and intuitionistic logic sep-proof-theoretic-semantics Sandqvist10.1093/jigpal/jzv021 Stafford10.1093/analys/anac100 GheorghiuLinear10.1007/978-3-031-43513-3_20 , although under suitable conditions the framework can also yield semantics for classical logic Sandqvist gheorghiu2024prooftheoreticsemanticsfirstorderlogic barrosonascimento2025prooftheoreticapproachsemanticsclassical . When it comes to logical consequence, traditional accounts establish truth-preservation, and sometimes relevance, as the main ingredient of validity StephenREad . In such views, a valid argument must at least be capable of guaranteeing that from the truth of its premises follows the truth of its conclusion. Despite its simplicity, the feasibility of this requirement remains highly contentious MurziValidity . It is also regarded as especially problematic by constructivists, as the very concept of truth – unless given unorthodox epistemic readings instead of the traditional ontological one – is considered inadequate for semantical analysis, either in general or specifically in the context of mathematics Prawitz2012 Martin-Lof1987-MARTOA Dummett1998-DUMTFT . The use of different criteria for validity has been suggested in the literature, often as a direct answer to problems arising from the use of truth preservation. In particular, the literature on strict-tolerant logics suggests that by adopting a weaker criterion which submits premises to a “strict” evaluation standard and conclusions to a “tolerant” one it becomes possible to satisfactorily deal with problems pertaining to semantic paradoxes Cobrero . The approach stipulates that an inference is valid whenever from the truth of the premises follows at least the non-falsity of the conclusion, which is the same as truth-preservation in classical logic but yields a distinct entailment notion in other contexts StrictTolerant Fitting . As shown in BarrCarni and bar , this approach allows one to deal with paradoxes related to vagueness by semantically defining sequent-based logics in which the Cut principle (transitivity of deduction) does not hold in general. Such systems easily allow one to provide interesting calculi for paraconsistent logics such as the Logic of Paradox Paradox , whose affinity with the strict-tolerant approach had already been noted before StrictTolerant . The literature also shows that, by applying the approach in a paraconsistent setting, it becomes possible to propose unorthodox solutions to traditional problems: in Hierarchy , for instance, an hierarchy of paraconsistent logics formulated using the strict-tolerant approach is used to propose an entirely new criterion of identity between logics, although the philosophical significance of this hierarchy is challenged in Hlobil2022-HLOATS . In light of the importance given to inferences in the philosophy of intuitionism, the investigation of how deviant concepts of inferential validity fare in constructive frameworks seems to be warranted. This paper will specifically investigate the inferential and metainferential behavior of strict-tolerant notions of validity in Kripke semantics for minimal and intuitionistic logic, the former being a paraconsistent version of the latter which arose from minor disagreements concerning the possibility of constructively justifying the principle of ex falso sequitur quodlibet ( Heyting , pg. 102) Johansson1937DerME Molen . The inclusion of minimal logic is justified not only by the proximity between both logics