ALMA reveals diverse dust-to-gas mass ratios and quenching modes in old quiescent galaxies

G. Lorenzon, D. Donevski, A. W. S. Man, M. Romano, K. E. Whitaker, S. Belli, D. Liu, M. M. Lee, D. Narayanan, A. Long, I. Shivaei, A. Nanni, K. Lisiecki, P. Sawant, G. Rodighiero, I. Damjanov, Junais, R. Davé, C. Pappalardo, C. Lovell, M. Hamed · 2025

Read ALMA reveals diverse dust-to-gas mass ratios and quenching modes in old quiescent galaxies by G. Lorenzon, D. Donevski, A. W. S. Man, M. Romano, K. E. Whitaker, S. Belli, D. Liu, M. M. Lee, D. Narayanan, A. Long, I. Shivaei, A. Nanni, K. Lisiecki, P. Sawant, G. Rodighiero, I. Damjanov, Junais, R. Davé, C. Pappalardo, C. Lovell, M. Hamed (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-10079.txt.

Introduction

Giuliano Lorenzon and 20 co-authors report telescope observations of old, quiet galaxies in this 2025 paper. Once a galaxy stops forming stars, textbooks say its dust and cold gas should fade fast. New finds of dusty, gassy quiet galaxies at high redshift challenge that view, raising the question of whether dust and gas fade together or on separate clocks.

Using the ALMA array, the team measured dust and carbon monoxide gas in 17 quiet galaxies seen as they were billions of years ago. Their dust-to-gas ratios spread widely, from far below to above the usual value. About half the galaxies lost dust quickly, while the rest kept high ratios for billions of years, so no single fading path fits all.

Catalog record

CREATORG. Lorenzon, D. Donevski, A. W. S. Man, M. Romano, K. E. Whitaker, S. Belli, D. Liu, M. M. Lee, D. Narayanan, A. Long, I. Shivaei, A. Nanni, K. Lisiecki, P. Sawant, G. Rodighiero, I. Damjanov, Junais, R. Davé, C. Pappalardo, C. Lovell, M. Hamed
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE40 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-10079

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

ALMA reveals diverse dust-to-gas mass ratios and quenching modes in old quiescent galaxies G. Lorenzon, D. Donevski, A. W. S. Man, M. Romano, K. E. Whitaker, S. Belli, D. Liu, M. M. Lee, D. Narayanan, A. Long, I. Shivaei, A. Nanni, K. Lisiecki, P. Sawant, G. Rodighiero, I. Damjanov, Junais, R. Davé, C. Pappalardo, C. Lovell, M. Hamed Abstract Recent discoveries of dust and molecular gas in quiescent galaxies (QGs) up to z ∼ 3 z\sim 3 challenge the long-standing view that the interstellar medium depletes rapidly once star formation ceases, raising key questions of whether dust and gas co-evolve in QGs, and how their depletion links to stellar aging. We present deep Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) Band 6 continuum and CO(3–2) observations of 17 QGs at z ∼ 0.4 z\sim 0.4 in the COSMOS field. Using the dust-to-molecular gas mass ratio ( δ DGR \delta_{\rm DGR} ) as a key diagnostic, we trace post-quenching evolution of the cold interstellar medium. Our study triples the number of QGs with direct δ DGR \delta_{\rm DGR} estimates, constraining 12 systems with stellar population ages of ∼ \sim 5–10 Gyr. For the first time, we show that δ DGR \delta_{\rm DGR} in QGs ranges from ∼ 8 × \sim 8\times below to ∼ 2.5 × \sim 2.5\times above the canonical value of δ DGR ∼ 1 / 100 \delta_{\rm DGR}\sim 1/100 . Despite uniformly low molecular gas fractions (median f H 2 = M H 2 / M ⋆ ∼ 4.1 % f_{\rm H_{2}}=M_{\rm H_{2}}/M_{\star}\sim 4.1\% ), QGs follow diverse evolutionary paths: about half exhibit rapid ( ∼ 700 \sim 700 Myr) exponential dust decline with age, while the rest show mild decline over ≳ \gtrsim 2 Gyr, maintaining elevated δ DGR ≳ 1 / 100 \delta_{\rm DGR}\gtrsim 1/100 . Our results support simulations predictions of dust and molecular gas evolving independently post-quenching, without a preferred quenching mode. This challenges the use of dust continuum as a H 2 \rm H_{2} tracer, implying that quenching cannot be robustly linked to interstellar medium conditions when relying solely on dust or gas. I Introduction Quiescent galaxies (QGs) are known to host little to no star formation, as quenching processes transform their interstellar medium (ISM) suppressing stellar activity. While their stellar component has been extensively studied out to z\sim 7 ( Weibel et al. 2025 ), its connection to quenching and late-stage cold ISM evolution remains poorly understood. The long-standing paradigm of QGs being deprived of cold ISM is now challenged by growing evidence of significant molecular gas and dust up to z\sim 3 . These seminal works push the limit of faint ISM detection via stacking ( Man et al. 2016 , Gobat et al. 2018 ; Magdis et al. 2021 ), few individual ALMA detections ( Morishita et al. 2022 ; Lee et al. 2024 ; Spilker et al. 2025 ), or via reddened attenuation profiles observed with the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST; Setton et al. 2024 ; Siegel et al. 2025 ). Interpreting such measurements is challenging because wide range of methods often compensates for the lack of individual detections. Estimates of cold molecular gas masses ( M_{\rm H_{2}} ) make use of CO and [CII] signatures, and are mostly biased to recently quenched or ultra-massive systems ( Belli et al. 2021 ; Williams et al. 2021 ; Bezanson et al. 2022 ; Wu et al. 2023 ; Zanella et al. 2023 ; Suess et al. 2025 ; Umehata et al. 2025 ). For more evolved QGs, such constraints are rare ( Spilker et al. 2018 ) , and typically rely on the use of dust continuum ( Donevski et al. 2023 ) from stacking ( Gobat et al. 2018 ; Magdis et al. 2021 ; Blánquez-Sesé et al. 2023 ; Adscheid et al. 2025 ) , since individual ALMA dust continuum detections are limited to only a handful of QGs at z\!\sim\!1-3 ( Whitaker et al. 2021a ; Morishita et al. 2022 ; Lee et al. 2024 ) . Even when detected, dust traces M_{\rm H_{2}} only via assumed dust-to-gas ratio ( \delta_{\rm DGR}=\rm M_{dust}/M_{gas}\!\sim\!1/100 ), calibrated on star-forming galaxies (SFGs; Magdis et al. 2012 ; Scoville et al. 2016 ) and often treated as redshift independent ( Popping et al. 2023 ) . Using this canonical conversion yields uncertain dust-based \rm H_{2} fractions ( \sim 1\% – 20\% ; Gobat et al. 2022 ). Together with the limitations of stacking, this challenges our understanding of processes acting on the cold ISM in individual QGs. Similar disagreement arises in interpreting the dust fraction ( f_{\rm dust}=M_{\rm dust}/M_{\star} ) for which early dust studies find a strong anti-correlation with stellar paopulation age, suggesting rapid dust removal within \sim 150–250 Myr (e.g., Li et al. 2019 ), mirroring a fast {\rm H_{2}} depletion during quenching ( Whitaker et al. 2021a ). However, this uniform picture has been questioned by works pointing to possible dust reformation in QGs ( Donevski et al. 2023 ) and longer removal timescales ( >1 –2 Gyr; Lee et al. 2024 ; Michałowski et al. 2024 ). Theoretical studies based on SIMBA cosmological simulation ( Davé et al. 2019 ) further suggest a complex interplay of molecular gas and dust, producing a broad range of \delta_{\rm DGR} in QGs ( Whitaker et al. 2021b ; Lorenzon et al. 2025 ). Whether this diversity reflects true physical complexity or stems from methodological biases in probing ISM in QGs remains an open question ( Gobat et al. 2022 ). Disentangling the impact of quenching pathways from ISM evolution in QGs requires direct, independent measurements of both dust and gas masses, i.e., their \delta_{\rm DGR} . Efforts so far have focused on high- z , where SFGs show an increase in ISM content from z\!\sim\!0 to z\!\sim\!2 ( Tacconi et al. 2018 ) , a trend QGs may share ( Magdis et al. 2021 ) . A first systematic study of five QGs at z\!\sim\!1 reported low but diverse values ( \delta_{\rm DGR}<1/300-1/1200 ; Spilker et al. 2025 ). However, the limited sample size and bias towards the most massive and {\rm H_{2}} -rich QGs leave open the key question of whether molecular gas and dust evolve similarly after quenching, and whether this evolution is solely driven by their stellar properties such as age and mass. In this Letter, we present deep ALMA observations of 17 homogeneously selected QGs at z\sim 0.4 , simultaneously probing their cold dust and molecular gas. By jointly measuring dust and \rm H_{2} masses, we aim to provide the first unbiased view of their co-evolution in the late phases of galaxy evolution. Throughout the paper we assume a Planck Collaboration et al. 2020 cosmology. II Observations of molecular gas and dust in QGs II.1 Targets Our ALMA Band 6 observations target 17 QGs in the COSMOS field drawn from a statistical parent sample of \sim 500 QGs combining deep, medium resolution spectroscopy (hCOSMOS; Damjanov et al. 2018 ) with > 15 photometric bands from homogeneously calibrated catalogues (HELP; Shirley et al. 2019 ). We refer to Donevski et al. 2023 (hereafter D23 ) for a detailed description of the sample. The 17 targeted QGs are selected

Read the complete text