A massive primordial atmosphere on early Mars
Sarah Joiret, Alessandro Morbidelli, Rafael de Sousa Ribeiro, Guillaume Avice, Paolo Sossi · 2025
Read A massive primordial atmosphere on early Mars by Sarah Joiret, Alessandro Morbidelli, Rafael de Sousa Ribeiro, Guillaume Avice, Paolo Sossi (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-10060.txt.
Introduction
Sarah Joiret and 4 co-authors argue, in a 2025 paper accepted by a planetary science journal, that early Mars held a massive first atmosphere. Mars finished forming while the gas disc around the young Sun still existed, so it could capture a thick envelope straight from that disc. The puzzle is that today's thin Martian air shows no clear cometary xenon mark, even though comets later struck the planet.
The team worked out how much cometary material Mars could have kept, using impact data from two separate studies inside a solar system model. Even in the most cautious case, diluting that cometary input takes a first atmosphere pressing down with at least a few bars of pressure. Such a heavy envelope fits recent models of how Mars captured gas.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sarah Joiret, Alessandro Morbidelli, Rafael de Sousa Ribeiro, Guillaume Avice, Paolo Sossi |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-10060
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A massive primordial atmosphere on early Mars Sarah Joiret, Alessandro Morbidelli, Rafael de Sousa Ribeiro, Guillaume Avice, Paolo Sossi Abstract Mars finished forming while the solar nebula was still present, and acquired its primordial atmosphere from this reservoir. The absence of a detectable cometary xenon signature in the present-day Martian atmosphere suggests that the capture of solar nebular gas was significant enough to dilute later cometary contributions. By quantifying the mass of cometary material efficiently retained on Mars, we place a lower bound on the mass of the primordial Martian atmosphere. To test the robustness of our conclusions, we use cometary bombardment data from two independent studies conducted within a solar system evolutionary model consistent with its current structure. Our calculations show that, even under the most conservative scenario, the minimal mass of the primordial martian atmospheres would yield a surface pressure of no less than 2.9 bar. Such a massive nebular envelope is consistent with recent models in which atmospheric capture is strongly enhanced by the presence of heavier species on Mars - due to outgassing or redox buffering with a magma ocean. I Introduction Mars formed rapidly within the first 4 million years of the solar system ( Dauphas & Pourmand 2011 ) , while the solar nebula was still present ( Haisch et al. 2001 ; Wang et al. 2017 ; Weiss et al. 2021 ) . Heavy noble gas isotopes, which are key tracers of planetary volatile evolution ( Pepin 1992 ) , indicate that Mars acquired its atmosphere from this nebular reservoir. Both in situ measurements ( Conrad et al. 2016 ) and mass spectrometry analyses of Martian meteorites ( Ott 1988 ; Mathew et al. 1998 ; Avice et al. 2018 ) confirm that atmospheric krypton (Kr) and xenon (Xe) have a solar origin. In contrast, the Kr isotopic composition of the Martian mantle is chondritic ( Péron & Mukhopadhyay 2022 ) , ruling out magma ocean outgassing or interior fractionation as main sources of the solar-like noble gas signature in the atmosphere. Instead, these gases were directly accreted from the solar nebula after Mars’ mantle rapidly formed from chondritic material. Sometime after the dispersal of the nebula, a dynamical instability among the giant planets scattered comets into the inner solar system ( Tsiganis et al. 2005 ; Gomes et al. 2005 ; Nesvorný 2018 ) . This cometary bombardment reshaped the volatile inventories of the terrestrial planets ( Joiret et al. 2023 ) . On Earth, cometary Xe appears in the primordial Xe signature of the atmosphere ( Marty et al. 2017 ) . Mars, however, shows no evidence of such cometary Xe signature ( Conrad et al. 2016 ; Péron & Mukhopadhyay 2022 ) . This difference likely stems from Earth’s last giant impacts occurring after solar nebula dispersal - erasing most of the solar signatures in Earth’s atmosphere - whereas Mars finished forming before nebula dispersal ( Avice et al. 2018 ) . Mars must have accreted solar nebular gas with high efficiency, as its atmospheric Xe retained a predominantly solar signature despite later cometary bombardment. Efficient capture of solar nebular gas could also account for the elevated neon (Ne) abundance inferred in the Martian mantle ( Kurokawa et al. 2021 ) . In this study, we quantify the mass of the cometary bombardment on Mars from dynamical constraints, providing a lower bound on the mass of the solar nebula that early Mars must have accreted to overwhelm any cometary Xe signature. II Minimal mass of the primordial atmosphere on Mars We set the lower bound on the mass of the primordial Martian atmosphere, starting from a robust estimate of the cometary material efficiently accreted during the bombardment episode. This estimate is derived through a multi-step modeling framework that integrates: (1) the velocity distribution and impact probabilities of comets during the cometary bombardment phase; (2) the retention efficiency of cometary material depending on impactor sizes and velocities; (3) the size-frequency distribution and total mass of comets in the primordial trans-Neptunian disk; and (4) a correction for comet disruption effects. The total cometary mass efficiently accreted on Mars is given by: m_{\text{comet}}=\sum_{i}M_{\text{tot}}(D\leq 100\text{ km})\,p_{\text{coll}}\,f(D_{i})\,\frac{\chi_{i}(D_{i})}{\alpha\,\beta_{i}} (1) where each of these factors, including the total mass of comets smaller than 100 km in the primordial disk M_{\text{tot}}(D\leq 100\text{ km}) , the collision probability p_{\text{coll}} , size distribution (fraction of the total mass in each comet size-bin f(D_{i}) ), retention efficiency \chi_{i}(D_{i}) , obliquity correction ( \alpha ), and disruption factor ( \beta_{i} ) is introduced and detailed in the subsequent subsections. The last subsection presents an estimate of the minimal mass of Mars’ primordial (solar-derived) atmosphere necessary to dilute cometary xenon signatures. II.1 Velocity distribution and collision probability during the cometary bombardment We first determined the velocity distribution f(v_{j}) (Figure 1 ) and average collision probability p_{coll} of comets impacting Mars during the cometary bombardment. This was achieved by combining N -body simulations of the early evolution of the solar system with an Öpik/Wetherill approach ( Wetherill 1967 ; Farinella & Davis 1992 ; Bottke et al. 1994 ) - a semi-analytical method for computing collision probabilities and velocities between two bodies, based on their orbital elements and assuming random encounter geometries. Although the existence of a phase of dynamical instability of the giant planets, destabilizing the trans-Neptunian cometary disk, is well accepted, the dynamical character of the instability is not uniquely determined. Thus, to assess the sensitivity of our results to its dynamical properties, we used simulation outputs from two independent studies: Joiret et al. 2024 , featuring a violent instability, and Ribeiro et al. 2025 , featuring a milder instability, hereafter J24 and R25 respectively. All simulations started at the time of gas disk dispersal ( t_{0} ) and spanned 100 Myr. In J24, simulations were performed using GENGA ( Grimm & Stadel 2014 ) . Large bodies, including planetary embryos and planets, were treated with full gravity, while smaller bodies such trans-Neptunian objects were only influenced by massive objects. The primordial reservoir of trans-Neptunian objects was distributed between 21 and 30 AU, with a total mass of 25 M_{\earth} . This configuration follows predictions from models of the early solar system’s dynamical evolution ( Nesvorný 2018 ) , which account for collisional losses within the primordial disk ( Bottke et al. 2023 ) . The outer disk was represented by 10^{4} comets. To account for the effects of an Early Instability scenario ( Clement et al. 2018 ) , giant planets were forced into a dynamical instability \sim 2 Myr after gas disk dispersal. This was achieved using simulation outputs of giant planets evolution from Clement et al. 2021b . In R25, simulations were performed using REBOUND ( Rein & Liu 2012 ) . The reservoir of trans-Neptunian objects initially extended from about 22 to 30 AU, and comprised 10^{6} massless, test particles. For computational efficiency, in the present study, we limited our analysis to 88,000 particles, corresponding to one in ten simulations from the original R25 dataset. Jupiter and Saturn were initially placed in their current orbits, while Uranus and Neptune were initially placed inside their current orbits and then forced to migrate outward ( Nesvorný et al. 2017 )