Seeing Identity in Data: Can Anthropographics Uncover Racial Homophily in Emotional Responses? Volume: 44 Issue: 3
Poorna Talkad Sukumar , Maurizio Porfiri , and Oded Nov Tandon School of Engineering, New York University, USA · 2025
Read Seeing Identity in Data: Can Anthropographics Uncover Racial Homophily in Emotional Responses? Volume: 44 Issue: 3 by Poorna Talkad Sukumar , Maurizio Porfiri , and Oded Nov Tandon School of Engineering, New York University, USA (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-09910.txt.
Introduction
Poorna Talkad Sukumar and 2 co-authors study how people react emotionally to data pictures in this 2025 paper. The question is racial homophily, the pull toward one's own racial group. An earlier study using bar charts found no such effect in responses to mass shooting data. This team redesigned the test with anthropographics, charts built from human figures. They also used a larger sample.
In a crowdsourced study with 720 people, each viewer saw victims from one racial group highlighted, either their own group or another. Across all conditions, viewers whose own group was highlighted showed a modest but real rise in negative feeling. The authors offer this as early evidence that homophily can surface in responses to data displays, at least with human-figure charts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Poorna Talkad Sukumar , Maurizio Porfiri , and Oded Nov Tandon School of Engineering, New York University, USA |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 20 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-09910
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Seeing Identity in Data: Can Anthropographics Uncover Racial Homophily in Emotional Responses? Volume: 44 Issue: 3 Poorna Talkad Sukumar , Maurizio Porfiri , and Oded Nov Tandon School of Engineering, New York University, USA Abstract Racial homophily refers to the tendency of individuals to associate with others of the same racial or ethnic background. A recent study found no evidence of racial homophily in responses to mass shooting data visualizations. To increase the likelihood of detecting an effect, we redesigned the experiment by replacing bar charts with anthropographics and expanding the sample size. In a crowdsourced study (N=720), we showed participants a pictograph of mass shooting victims in the United States, with victims from one of three racial groups (Hispanic, Black, or White) highlighted. Each participant was assigned a visualization highlighting either their own racial group or a different racial group, allowing us to assess the influence of racial concordance on changes in affect (emotion). We found that, across all conditions, racial concordance had a modest but significant effect on changes in affect, with participants experiencing greater negative affect change when viewing visualizations highlighting their own race. This study provides initial evidence that racial homophily can emerge in responses to data visualizations, particularly when using anthropographics. \EuroVisShort ccs Human-centered computing Empirical studies in visualization † † year: 2025 † † year: 2025 † † editors: W. Aigner, N. Andrienko, and B. Wang † † subject: Eurographics Conference on Visualization CGF Vol No † † orcid: 0000-0003-2041-1627 † † orcid: 0000-0002-1480-3539 † † orcid: 0000-0001-6410-2995 † † teaser: One of the three experimental conditions featuring a pictograph of mass shooting victims in the United States from 2013 to 2023, highlighting the number of Hispanic victims. Participants had to scroll to view the entire visualization (overview shown on the right). The other two conditions presented the same pictograph but highlighted the number of White and Black victims, respectively. 1 Introduction Homophily is the tendency for individuals to associate with others who share similar characteristics, such as beliefs, values, or demographic traits [ MSLC01 ] . Racial homophily, in particular, refers to the preference for associating with individuals of the same racial or ethnic background. Understanding homophily in the context of data visualizations can provide insight into how shared social identities shape audience engagement, interpretation, and emotional responses to visualized data. A recent study investigated racial homophily in responses to mass shooting visualizations, testing whether individuals experience stronger emotional reactions and shifts in gun control attitudes when victims belong to their own racial group [ SPN24b ] . However, the study found no significant evidence that racial concordance influenced these responses. To better assess whether racial homophily influences responses to data visualizations, we redesigned the study to maximize the likelihood of detecting an effect, incorporating key methodological and design changes. First, we replaced bar charts with anthropographic visualizations—visualizations designed to foster emotional connection and empathy with the people whose data is represented [ MJAD21 ] . Second, we extended the conceptualization of homophily beyond racial concordance alone by integrating additional psychological constructs: in-group identification (the extent to which individuals see their racial group as central to their identity) as a potential mediator and in-group favoritism (the tendency to prefer one’s racial group over others) as a potential moderator of emotional responses. Third, we expanded the sample size to improve statistical power and ensure robust mediation and moderation analyses. We conducted a pre-registered [ pre25 ] crowdsourced experiment (N=720) in which participants were shown pictographic visualizations of mass shooting victims, with one of three racial groups (White, Black, or Hispanic) highlighted (see Figure ). They were assigned to view either a visualization highlighting their own racial group (in-group) or a different racial group (out-group), allowing us to assess the influence of racial concordance on changes in affect. We found that, across all conditions, racial concordance had a modest but significant effect on affect change, with participants experiencing greater negative affect change when viewing visualizations highlighting victims of their own race. This finding suggests that racial homophily may emerge in responses to data visualizations, particularly when using anthropographics. This study advances our understanding of how visualization design interacts with social identity, showing that, while the effects were modest, anthropographics may be a useful tool for targeted communication, shaping engagement in ways that warrant further exploration. 2 Background 2.1 Anthropographics Anthropographics are visual representations, often used by practitioners, aiming to humanize data by shifting the focus from abstract statistics to individual lives [ BPE∗17 , DHW23 , MJAD21 , MJAD20 ] . These visualizations often feature pictorial representations of people, such as silhouettes or icons, to make data feel more personal and engaging. Despite the goal of anthropographics to promote empathy, compassion, or prosocial behavior, empirical evidence on their effectiveness has been mixed [ MJAD21 ] . In this study, we examine whether anthropographics can capture racial homophily in emotional responses—an effect not previously tested in anthropographics research. Based on the design dimensions presented by Morais et al. [ MJAD21 ] , we designed our experimental conditions (Figure ) to have high granularity , as each victim is represented individually, whereas the earlier bar charts study had low granularity [ SPN24b ] , with aggregated counts. Our design also maintains high coverage (representing a broad sample of victims) and high authenticity (using actual data). However, it has limited specificity , as we only highlight one race, avoiding additional victim details that could introduce confounding factors. 2.2 Social Identity Theory and In-Group Processes Social Identity Theory [ Hog16 ] posits that individuals derive a sense of self from their membership in social groups, leading them to categorize others as in-group (belonging to the same social group) or out-group (belonging to a different group). Research suggests that group identity shapes emotional responses, with individuals reacting more strongly to perceived threats or harm to their in-group [ MSR08 , CN05 ] . Based on this, we used in-group identification as a mediator, as stronger identification has been linked to heightened emotional engagement with in-group suffering. We also incorporated in-group favoritism as a moderator, as Intergroup Bias Theory suggests that individuals with stronger biases favoring their in-group assign greater emotional significance to in-group experiences [ HRW02 , MSR08 ] . By testing for moderation, we aimed to determine whether racial concordance effects are amplified among those with stronger in-group biases. 2.3 Individual Differences in Visualization Interpretation Visualization research has shown that individual differences—such as, cognitive and personality traits [ ZOC∗12 , LCO20 , OCZC15 ] , as well as prior beliefs [ MRK∗23 , KRH17 , SPN24a , PMN∗14 ] —influence how people interpret visualizations and/or perform visualization tasks. In contrast, our study shifts the focus from cognitive- and personality-driven differences to social and demographic factors, specifically investigating how these factors shape resonance with visualized data. Our work extends research on individual differences in visualization to consider the social dimensions of interpretation. 3 Experiment Based on prior work, we tested three hypotheses. First, we hypothesized that participants would exhibit stronger emotional responses (i.e. greater negative affect change) when viewing a visualization highlighting victims from their own racial group compared to those from another racial group ( H1 ). Second, we