Do we need an alternative to local gauge coupling to electromagnetic fields?

F. Minotti, G. Modanese · 2025

Read Do we need an alternative to local gauge coupling to electromagnetic fields? by F. Minotti, G. Modanese (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-09697.txt.

Introduction

F. Minotti and 1 co-author question a basic recipe of electrodynamics in a 2025 paper on how scalar fields couple to light. The standard local gauge recipe works beautifully for Dirac spinors, but for scalar fields it produces a coupling current that does not match the conserved Noether current of the global symmetry. The authors ask what follows if the scalar field is instead coupled exactly through its conserved current, as spinors are.

That choice, they show, forces local gauge symmetry to be given up. The electromagnetic field must then be described by a theory that tolerates the loss, such as the extended electrodynamics linked to Aharonov and Bohm. Fermion systems under strict charge conservation show no difference, so the fork matters mainly beyond the familiar case.

Catalog record

CREATORF. Minotti, G. Modanese
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE45 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-09697

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Do we need an alternative to local gauge coupling to electromagnetic fields? F. Minotti, G. Modanese Abstract The local gauge coupling through the recipe ∂ μ ψ → ∂ μ ψ + i ​ q ​ A μ ​ ψ \partial_{\mu}\psi\to\partial_{\mu}\psi+iqA_{\mu}\psi works perfectly well with Dirac spinors in QED and in the gauge theories of the Standard Model, but for scalar fields it has a peculiarity: it generates in the Lagrangian a coupling term J μ ​ A μ J_{\mu}A^{\mu} in which J μ J_{\mu} does not coincide with the conserved Nöther current associated to the global gauge symmetry. If we want to preserve a coupling through a conserved current, which is true for spinors and has definite physical grounds, one possibility is to renounce to the principle of local gauge symmetry and couple the fields to the extended electrodynamics by Aharonov-Bohm. No differences with the usual theory appear for fermion systems when strict local charge conservation applies. In particular, if we consider the non-relativistic quantum theory as the low-energy limit of the relativistic theory, we would expect no modifications of Schrödinger equation when applied to fermion systems. However, when scalar boson systems are considered, like Cooper pairs quasi-particles in superconductors, in the new formulation the electromagnetic (e.m.) fields include a source, additional to the usual conserved four-current, and, besides, the corresponding Schrödinger equation acquires a new term, proportional to 𝐀 2 \mathbf{A}^{2} , which leads to observable consequences, like a sizable change in the estimate of the magnetic penetration depth in superconductors, compatible with the experimental data. I Introduction Local gauge invariance (LGI) is a powerful principle that, in the case of interaction of the considered system with e.m. fields, is further justified by the LGI of Maxwell equations. It is well known that LGI is intrinsically linked to strict local charge conservation (LCC). However, Aharonov and Bohm aharonov1963further posited that LCC could be invalid at some small enough scale, and consequently built up an electrodynamics compatible with this non-conservation, which reduces to Maxwell’s when LCC holds. Although they favored scales as small as Planck’s for the failure of LCC, there are arguments for the possibility of non-conservation happening even at molecular scales li2008definition ; zhang2011first ; walz2015local ; cabra2018simulation . With these considerations, it could be argued that, at least for e.m. interactions, LGI is rather a consequence of LCC than its cause, and, consequently, it would be of interest to explore alternatives applicable if LCC happens to fail at some significant scale. What could thus be the alternative principle to determine the interaction of a general system with the e.m. field? In the following we argue that a possibility is that the interaction of the system with the e.m. field is quantified by a Lagrangian density term of the general form J^{\mu}A_{\mu} , where A_{\mu} is the four potential of the e.m. field, and J^{\mu} the four current resulting from \bm{global} gauge invariance of the full Lagrangian. It is shown below that LGI and the alternative principle result in the same matter and interaction terms in the action of a Dirac field, whereas for a boson field the resulting actions differ. In the case of the Dirac field the e.m. term could thus be either Maxwell´s or that of Aharonov-Bohm (AB). If Maxwell expression is used LCC and the usual QED equations result, while with the AB e.m. term the resulting equations coincide with those of QED when LCC is imposed. For the case of boson systems the alternative principle is not equivalent to LGI, and thus incompatible with a Maxwell e.m. term, so that the AB term is required. In this way we can say that, as a principle applicable to both, fermion and boson systems, we should consider the J^{\mu}A_{\mu} interaction term discussed above, in conjunction with an AB e.m. term in both cases. In the following sections we develop with some detail these ideas, and explore possible consequences of the application of the alternative principle to superconductors, considered as charged boson systems. II Aharonov-Bohm electrodynamics and gauge invariance In order to introduce the general ideas we consider a system having e.m. interactions with e.m. fields given in terms of the four potential A_{\mu}=\left(\frac{1}{c}\varphi,-\mathbf{A}\right) . Greek indices denote the four coordinates, with x_{0}=ct , while Latin indices indicate the three spatial coordinates. We consider that the system, matter plus e.m. fields, is described by an action of the generic form S=\int_{R}\mathcal{L}\left(\phi,\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)d^{4}x in which \phi represents all the matter and e.m. fields, and R is a space-time region bounded by two space-like hypersurfaces. The equations of motion and conserved magnitudes are determined from this action using Hamilton principle and Noether theorem. Since we will be concerned only with conserved magnitudes arising from internal symmetries, space-time related symmetries will not be considered in the application of Noether theorem. Variation of the fields results in the variation of the action \displaystyle\delta S \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{R}\left[\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\phi}\delta\phi+\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}\delta\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)\right]d^{4}x \displaystyle= \displaystyle\int_{R}\left[\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\phi}-\partial_{\mu}\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}\right]\delta\phi d^{4}x+\int_{\partial R}\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}\delta\phi d\sigma_{\mu}, where \partial R corresponds to the boundary of R . The application of Hamilton principle thus results in the equations of motion for the fields \frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\phi}-\partial_{\mu}\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}=0. (1) The considered version of Noether theorem, on the other hand, results for the case in which a particular variation of the fields, of the general form \delta\phi=\varepsilon\Phi , with \varepsilon an infinitesimal parameter, leaves the action invariant: \delta S=0 . Assuming that the given variation is that of fields that satisfy the equations of motion, the action invariance means that, for a generic \partial R , \int_{\partial R}\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}\Phi d\sigma_{\mu}=0, or, equivalently, \partial_{\mu}J^{\mu}=0 , with J^{\mu}=\frac{\partial\mathcal{L}}{\partial\left(\partial_{\mu}\phi\right)}\Phi. (2) Let us consider as a concrete example the case of QED, in which the matter field is described by the Lagrangian density \mathcal{L}_{M}=\frac{i\hbar}{2}\left(\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\partial_{\mu}\psi-\partial_{\mu}\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi\right)-mc^{2}\overline{\psi}\psi, (3) in terms of Dirac four spinor and matrices, where the overbar indicates the Pauli adjoint. The gauge principle, or minimal coupling principle, tells us that matter of electric charge q interacting with the e.m. field is described by the Lagrangian ( 3 ) in which partial derivatives are replaced by covariant ones: \partial_{\mu}\rightarrow\partial_{\mu}+i\frac{q}{\hbar}A_{\mu}, that is \mathcal{L}_{M\_int}=\frac{i\hbar}{2}\left[\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\left(\partial_{\mu}+i\frac{q}{\hbar}A_{\mu}\right)\psi-\overline{\left(\partial_{\mu}+i\frac{q}{\hbar}A_{\mu}\right)\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi\right]-mc^{2}\overline{\psi}\psi, which can be written as \mathcal{L}_{M\_int}=\mathcal{L}_{M}+\mathcal{L}_{int}, with \mathcal{L}_{int}=-J^{\mu}A_{\mu}, in which J^{\mu}=q\overline{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi. (4) The full Lagrangian density for matter interacting with e.m. fields is thus \mathcal{L}=\mathcal{L}_{M}+\mathcal{L}_{int}+\mathcal{L}_{em} (5) where \mathcal{L}_{em} describes the e.m. part and depends only on e.m. fields. We further note that J^{\mu} given by ( 4 ) is the conserved current, as given by Noether theorem, resulting from the global gauge invariance of the action, corresponding to variations of the fields of the form \displaystyle\delta\psi \displaystyle= \displaystyle-i\frac{q}{\hbar}\Lambda\psi, (6a) \displaystyle\delta\overline{\psi} \displaystyle= \displaystyle i\frac{q}{\hbar}\Lambda\overline{\psi}, (6b) \displaystyle\delta A^{\mu} \displaystyle= \displaystyle\partial^{\mu}\Lambda=0, (6c) with \Lambda an infinitesimal constant. We thus see from this familiar example that in QED there are two possible approaches to determine the interaction of charged matter with the e.m. field. We can use the minimal coupling principle, as done above, or we can alternatively postulate a Lagrangian like ( 5 ), in which \mathcal{L}_{M} is the non-interacting matter field Lagrangian, \mathcal{L}_{em} describes the e.m. part, and the interaction term is \mathcal{L}_{int}=-J^{\mu}A_{\mu} , with J^{\mu} the conserved current resulting from the global gauge invariance of the full action. Note however that both approaches are not equivalent, for instance, for a charged scalar matter field, with Lagrangian \mathcal{L}_{scalar}=\hbar^{2}\partial^{\mu}\phi^{\ast}\partial_{\mu}\phi-\kappa^{2}\phi^{\ast}\phi.

Read the complete text