Suppression of pair beam instabilities in a laboratory analogue of blazar pair cascades
Charles D. Arrowsmith, Francesco Miniati, Pablo J. Bilbao, Pascal Simon, Archie F. A. Bott, Stephane Burger, Hui Chen, Filipe D. Cruz, Tristan Davenne, Anthony Dyson, Ilias Efthymiopoulos, Dustin H. Froula, Alice Goillot, Jon T. Gudmundsson, Dan Haberberger, Jack W. D. Halliday, Tom Hodge, Brian T. · 2025
Read Suppression of pair beam instabilities in a laboratory analogue of blazar pair cascades by Charles D. Arrowsmith, Francesco Miniati, Pablo J. Bilbao, Pascal Simon, Archie F. A. Bott, Stephane Burger, Hui Chen, Filipe D. Cruz, Tristan Davenne, Anthony Dyson, Ilias Efthymiopoulos, Dustin H. Froula, Alice Goillot, Jon T. Gudmundsson, Dan Haberberger, Jack W. D. Halliday, Tom Hodge, Brian T. (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-09040.txt.
Introduction
Charles D. Arrowsmith and 30 co-authors test pair beam stability in a lab analogue of blazar cascades in a 2025 paper. Blazars are bright active galaxies whose gamma rays can spawn electron positron pairs in deep space. Lab beams of such pairs can test if those cascades break up.
Protons from CERN's synchrotron make a dense pair beam, sent through a metre of plasma. Beam instabilities were thought to shred cascades and explain missing low energy glow from blazars. The beam stays stable if it is not in a perfect beam shape or at one exact energy. That keeps past lower bounds on the space magnetic field firm.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Charles D. Arrowsmith, Francesco Miniati, Pablo J. Bilbao, Pascal Simon, Archie F. A. Bott, Stephane Burger, Hui Chen, Filipe D. Cruz, Tristan Davenne, Anthony Dyson, Ilias Efthymiopoulos, Dustin H. Froula, Alice Goillot, Jon T. Gudmundsson, Dan Haberberger, Jack W. D. Halliday, Tom Hodge, Brian T. |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 72 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-09040
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Suppression of pair beam instabilities in a laboratory analogue of blazar pair cascades Charles D. Arrowsmith, Francesco Miniati, Pablo J. Bilbao, Pascal Simon, Archie F. A. Bott, Stephane Burger, Hui Chen, Filipe D. Cruz, Tristan Davenne, Anthony Dyson, Ilias Efthymiopoulos, Dustin H. Froula, Alice Goillot, Jon T. Gudmundsson, Dan Haberberger, Jack W. D. Halliday, Tom Hodge, Brian T. Huffman, Sam Iaquinta, G. Marshall, Brian Reville, Subir Sarkar, Alexander A. Schekochihin, Luis O. Silva, Raspberry Simpson, Vasiliki Stergiou, Raoul M. G. M. Trines, Thibault Vieu, Nikolaos Charitonidis, Robert Bingham, Gianluca Gregori Abstract Dated: August 10, 2026 Abstract The generation of dense electron-positron pair beams in the laboratory can enable direct tests of theoretical models of \gamma -ray bursts and active galactic nuclei. We have successfully achieved this using ultra-relativistic protons accelerated by the Super Proton Synchrotron at CERN. In the first application of this experimental platform, the stability of the pair beam is studied as it propagates through a metre-length plasma, analogous to TeV \gamma -ray induced pair cascades in the intergalactic medium. It has been argued that pair beam instabilities disrupt the cascade, thus accounting for the observed lack of reprocessed GeV emission from TeV blazars. If true this would remove the need for a moderate strength intergalactic magnetic field to explain the observations. We find that the pair beam instability is suppressed if the beam is not perfectly collimated or monochromatic, hence the lower limit to the intergalactic magnetic field inferred from \gamma -ray observations of blazars is robust. Significance statement In this work, a dense beam of electron-positron pairs is produced using protons accelerated by the Super Proton Synchrotron at CERN. The beam is propagated through an ambient plasma, analogous to pair cascades produced as blazar jets propagate through the intergalactic medium (IGM). It has been proposed that plasma instabilities disrupt these pair cascades, explaining the lack of secondary \gamma -rays observed from blazars. However, we find that under non-ideal conditions likely to be relevant in the blazar context, pair beam instabilities are strongly suppressed and it is unlikely they play a significant role. This experimental study supports the hypothesis that the IGM contains a magnetic field of unknown origin that may well be a relic of the early Universe. Main TeV-blazars are a class of active galactic nuclei (AGN) with relativistic jets pointing towards Earth that emit \gamma -rays with a hard spectrum extending to TeV energies 2013ApJ…764..119S . As the \gamma -rays propagate through the intergalactic medium (IGM), often through cosmic voids where matter exists as a tenuous, collisionless plasma, they are expected to scatter with extragalactic background light and trigger electromagnetic cascades of electron-positron (e ± ) pairs. Subsequently, inverse-Compton scattering of the pairs with cosmic microwave background (CMB) photons is expected to produce a reprocessed spectrum of GeV energy \gamma -rays, but this is at odds with astronomical observations accumulated over more than a decade which have set stringent limits on the expected GeV \gamma -rays aharonian2006low . The leading hypothesis is that e ± pairs are deflected by intergalactic magnetic fields (IGMF) neronov2010evidence , spreading the GeV emission into diffuse halos that are not resolved by \gamma -ray telescopes archambault2017search ; ackermann2018search (but may be detectable by the Cherenkov Telescope Array 2021JCAP…02..048A ). However, the required strength and coherence length of the IGMF is sufficiently large that an astrophysical origin is unlikely; it may well be a relic of the early Universe 2018PhRvL.121b1301M ; 2021RPPh…84g4901V ; hosking2023cosmic . An alternative suggestion is that a substantial fraction of the pairs’ energy is dissipated via electromagnetic beam-plasma instabilities weibel1959spontaneously ; fried1959mechanism ; fainberg1970nonlinear ; 1971JETP…32.1134R before the pairs inverse-Compton scatter with CMB photons broderick2012cosmological ; schlickeiser2012plasma . Such instabilities lead to exponential amplification of electromagnetic fields via the unstable separation of electrons and positrons into current filaments. In extreme scenarios, they can lead to significant dissipation of the bulk kinetic energy and the onset of collisionless shocks. Whether these indeed play a role in the blazar-induced pair cascade, and similar situations involving streaming e ± pairs such as \gamma -ray bursts, depends on the initial linear stage of the instability (characterized by a linear growth rate), and the subsequent quasi-linear evolution which determines the transition to the saturation stage. When non-idealized conditions are considered, for example finite divergence and energy spread, plasma kinetic theory suggests that beam-plasma instabilities may be strongly suppressed. For relativistic pair beams with a low density compared with the ambient plasma, the fastest-growing modes of electromagnetic beam instability are oriented obliquely to the beam direction shaisultanov2011stream , with a characteristic scale comparable to the plasma skin depth, \lambda_{\mathrm{s}}=c/\omega_{\mathrm{p}} , where \omega_{\rm p}=(4\pi n_{\rm p}e^{2}/m_{\rm e})^{1/2} is the plasma frequency, n_{\rm p} is the ambient plasma electron density, e is the elementary charge and m_{\mathrm{e}} is the electron rest mass. The theoretical growth rate for a pair beam with a small angular spread \Delta\theta=\Delta p_{\perp}/p_{\parallel} is given by fainberg1970nonlinear : \Gamma=\frac{\sqrt{3}}{2^{4/3}}\,\omega_{\rm p}\bigg(\frac{n_{\pm}}{n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\pm}}\bigg)^{1/3}\left[\frac{k_{\perp}^{2/3}}{k^{2/3}}-\frac{3k_{\perp}^{2}(\Delta\theta)^{2}}{8k_{\parallel}^{2}}\bigg(\frac{2n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\pm}}{n_{\pm}}\bigg)^{2/3}\right], (1) where k_{\parallel} and k_{\perp} are the parallel and perpendicular components of the wavevector relative to the beam’s propagation axis, n_{\pm} is the pair number density and \gamma_{\pm} is the relativistic Lorentz factor. The factor in square brackets accounts for transverse thermal motion of the beam, and tends to unity for a sufficiently collimated beam given \Delta\theta\ll(n_{\pm}/n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\pm})^{1/3} , with the fastest-growing modes oriented transversely to beam propagation. However, if the transverse momentum spread is large enough, i.e. \Delta\theta\gtrsim(n_{\pm}/n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\pm})^{1/3} , particle trajectories traverse the characteristic scale of unstable modes before current fluctuations can be amplified. The effect is to stabilize small-scale transverse modes, reduce the fastest growth rate, and tilt the direction of the fastest-growing mode towards the longitudinal direction. This is important in astrophysical contexts, where relativistic pair beams may be neither perfectly collimated nor monoenergetic. The purely transverse filamentation instability growth rate (scaling as \Gamma\sim\omega_{\rm p}\sqrt{n_{\rm\pm}/n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\rm\pm}} fried1959mechanism ) only applies under very strict conditions, namely when the beam and return current are perfectly symmetric with the same density, temperature, and drift energies bret2010multidimensional . If the angular spread is sufficiently large ( \Delta\theta>\Gamma\lambda_{\rm s}/c ) then the purely transverse filamentation modes are completely stabilized silva2003interpenetrating , whereas oblique unstable modes that lead to beam filamentation and magnetic field growth at an angle with respect to the beam distribution can still exist with a suppressed growth rate. In the kinetic regime, with very large transverse spreads the growth rate scales as \Gamma\sim\omega_{\rm p}(n_{\rm\pm}/n_{\rm p}\gamma_{\rm\pm})/(\Delta\theta)^{2} breizman1971quasilinear ; bret2010exact , even more severely suppressed than predicted by Eq. 1 . In order for pair beam instabilities to provide a plausible explanation for the observed lack of secondary GeV \gamma -rays from TeV blazars, the instability must lead to the generation of sufficiently large electromagnetic fields for a substantial fraction of the pairs’ energy to be dissipated, or for pairs to be sufficiently deflected by self-generated fields that the secondary GeV emission is dispersed. This scenario has recently been discussed when considering whether the 400 GeV photon detected by Fermi from the “BOAT” GRB 221009A axelsson2025grb may be generated from a TeV electromagnetic cascade in the IGM, a possibility consistent with the observation by LHAASO of \gamma -rays with energy up to 13 TeV from the direction of