Cosmic Ray Spatial Distribution and the Galactic/Extragalactic Transition

Paolo Lipari, Silvia Vernetto · 2025

Read Cosmic Ray Spatial Distribution and the Galactic/Extragalactic Transition by Paolo Lipari, Silvia Vernetto (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-09028.txt.

Introduction

Paolo Lipari and 1 co-author study the spatial distribution of cosmic rays and the galactic to extragalactic transition in a 2025 paper. Cosmic rays are high energy particles moving through the Milky Way. Their spread shapes the gamma ray and neutrino glow from interstellar gas.

Most models assume spectral shape is the same everywhere, with only intensity changing. New data from Fermi, Tibet, LHAASO, HAWC, and IceCube test that assumption. Results disfavor harder spectra in the inner galaxy and mildly favor softer inner spectra at very high energy. A growing confinement volume with energy could explain the pattern. An extragalactic share at the highest energies is another possible explanation.

Catalog record

CREATORPaolo Lipari, Silvia Vernetto
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-09028

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Cosmic Ray Spatial Distribution and the Galactic/Extragalactic Transition Paolo Lipari, Silvia Vernetto Abstract Determining the spatial distribution of Galactic cosmic rays (CRs) is fundamental to understand how these particles propagate in interstellar space and to infer their source spectra. The most sensitive method of studying this problem is observing the gamma–ray and neutrino diffuse fluxes produced in the inelastic interactions of CR protons and nuclei with interstellar gas that encode the energy and spatial distributions of the interacting particles. Most theoretical models assume that the spatial and energy dependencies of the spectra of CR protons and nuclei are factorized, so that the CR energy spectra have the same shape at all points of the Milky Way. However, on the base of the Fermi–LAT observations, some authors have tentatively inferred that particles in the inner regions of the Milky Way have significantly harder spectra. Recently the ground–based telescopes Tibet–AS γ \gamma , LHAASO and HAWC have extended the measurements of the diffuse gamma–ray flux to much higher energies, and the IceCube neutrino telescope has obtained evidence for a ν \nu flux from the Galactic disk. These new measurements allow for new tests of the factorization hypothesis, and disfavor models in which the spectral shape of CR protons and nuclei is harder in the inner part of the Galaxy. In fact, the LHAASO data above 30 TeV are in better agreement with the opposite hypothesis, that cosmic rays is the inner Galaxy have softer spectra than those in the outer Galaxy. This result, that has currently only modest significance due to large statistical and systematic uncertainties, could be explained by assuming that the CR confinement volume increases with energy. An alternative explanation is that a significant fraction of cosmic rays in the multi–PeV energy range is of extragalactic origin. I Introduction The spectra of cosmic rays (CR) at the Earth are now known with reasonable precision over a wide range of energies. However, much less is known about these spectra in different points in the Galaxy, and determining their spatial and energy distributions is of great importance for high energy astrophysics. Information about the CR spectra in distant regions can be obtained by observing the fluxes of gamma–rays and neutrinos produced in the interactions of the primary cosmic ray particles with the medium in which they propagate Fermi-LAT:2012edv ; Lipari:2018gzn ; Tibaldo:2021viq . The diffuse fluxes can be calculated as the integral of the emission along the different lines of sight and therefore encode the spatial distributions of the interacting particles and of the targets. It is now well understood Gabici:2019jvz ; Kachelriess:2019oqu that most of the cosmic rays observed at the Earth are of Galactic origin, accelerated in sources distributed in the volume of the Milky Way, and confined in the Galaxy by magnetic fields for a time of order of millions of years, forming a “halo” that is significantly larger than the thin disk that contains most of the stars and interstellar gas. However, the absolute normalization and spectral shape of the cosmic ray populations in different points of the halo are currently poorly understood, especially at high energies. The diffuse gamma–ray flux is produced by the interactions of both hadronic (protons and nuclei) and leptonic (electrons and positrons) particles, while the neutrino fluxes are produced only by hadrons. Below few GeV the gamma–ray emission is generated by both the hadronic and leptonic mechanisms, but at higher energies the leptonic emission becomes negligible because the e^{\mp} spectra are significantly softer than protons and nuclei spectra. In the present work we will limit our discussion to the energy range E\gtrsim 1 TeV where the gamma–ray emission is dominated by the hadronic mechanism, and therefore both \gamma and \nu fluxes only encode information about hadronic cosmic rays. Most models for protons and nuclei Galactic cosmic rays assume that their spectra in different points of the Galaxy have the same shape, equal to what is observed at the Earth, with an absolute normalization that changes gradually, so that the density in the inner part of the Galaxy is larger than the density at large distances from the center. This space dependence can be derived under the following assumptions: (a) the cosmic rays accelerators in different regions of the Galaxy produce (on average) spectra of the same shape; (b) the CR propagation can be modeled as diffusion, with a diffusion coefficient that has the same rigidity dependence in all the relevant Galactic volume; (c) the boundaries of the diffusion volume are energy independent; (d) the stationary solution of the diffusion equation is a good description of the CR spectra, at least near the solar system and in most of the Galaxy. However, it is possible that some (or all) of the assumptions listed above are incorrect, and that the CR spectra have different and more complex spatial and energy dependencies. Most of what we know about the CR spectra in different points of the Galaxy has been obtained by interpreting the observations of the diffuse gamma–ray flux in the 0.1–1000 GeV energy range by the Fermi–LAT space telescope Fermi-LAT:2012edv ; Fermi-LAT:2016zaq . These observations are generally consistent with the idea that the disk of the Galaxy contains populations of cosmic rays with approximately the same spectral shape observed at the Earth and a small density gradient. However, several authors have suggested that CR spectra in the inner part of the Galaxy have harder spectra than those at large distances from the center, and it is important to verify these claims by extending the study to higher energies. Recently new observations of the diffuse Galactic gamma–ray flux in the multi–TeV to PeV energy range have been obtained from the Tibet–AS \gamma TibetASgamma:2021tpz , LHAASO LHAASO:2023gne ; LHAASO:2024lnz , and HAWC HAWC:2023wdq telescopes. In addition, evidence for a flux of Galactic neutrinos in roughly the same energy range has been obtained from the IceCube detector IceCube:2023ame . Indications for the existence of a flux of Galactic neutrinos has also recently been obtained by the Baikal neutrino telescope Baikal-GVD:2024kfx . In the following we will discuss what these new measurements imply for the CR spatial distributions at very high energies. The study of of the diffuse gamma–ray and neutrino fluxes can also be a tool for addressing a problem of central importance for cosmic ray astrophysics: measuring the contribution of extragalactic sources to the observed CR spectra. The CR extragalactic component is expected to be dominant above a transition energy E^{*} , which is not yet known, with different estimates suggesting values as low as few PeV ( 10^{15} eV), just above the “knee” in the all–particle spectrum, and as large as 4\times 10^{18} eV, where spectral hardening known as the “ankle” is observed. At the transition energy one expects to observe changes in the CR spectral shape and composition, but similar changes could be also associated to the combination of CR components of Galactic origin, produced by different classes of Milky Way sources and having different spectral shapes and composition. One possible method to establish the extragalactic nature of a new CR component is to measure the energy dependence of the CR anisotropy, however an alternative method is to infer the spatial distribution of the CR

Read the complete text