Ultrafast Deep Learning-Based Scatter Estimation in Cone-Beam Computed Tomography
Harshit Agrawal, Ari Hietanen, Simo Särkkä · 2025
Read Ultrafast Deep Learning-Based Scatter Estimation in Cone-Beam Computed Tomography by Harshit Agrawal, Ari Hietanen, Simo Särkkä (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08973.txt.
Introduction
Harshit Agrawal and 2 co-authors achieve ultrafast scatter estimation in cone-beam CT in a 2025 paper. Scatter blurs cone-beam scans and lowers image quality. Deep learning can estimate scatter, but large networks use too much memory for mobile or edge devices.
The team studies reconstruction error across six resolutions and four interpolation methods. A leading method is then trained at five resolutions and compared on operations, time, and memory. A much smaller input cuts operations about seventy-eight fold while error actually improves slightly. Inference runs far faster with far less memory. Tests on simulated and real phantom scans confirm robustness.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harshit Agrawal, Ari Hietanen, Simo Särkkä |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 34 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08973
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ultrafast Deep Learning-Based Scatter Estimation in Cone-Beam Computed Tomography Harshit Agrawal, Ari Hietanen, Simo Särkkä Abstract Purpose: Scatter artifacts drastically degrade the image quality of cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans. Although deep learning-based methods show promise in estimating scatter from CBCT measurements, their deployment in mobile CBCT systems or edge devices is still limited due to the large memory footprint of the networks. This study addresses the issue by applying networks at varying resolutions and suggesting an optimal one, based on speed and accuracy. Methods: First, the reconstruction error in down-up sampling of CBCT scatter signal was examined at six resolutions by comparing four interpolation methods. Next, a recent state-of-the-art method was trained across five image resolutions and evaluated for the reductions in floating-point operations (FLOPs), inference times, and GPU memory requirements. Results: Reducing the input size and network parameters achieved a 78-fold reduction in FLOPs compared to the baseline method, while maintaining comparable performance in terms of mean-absolute-percentage-error (MAPE) and mean-square-error (MSE). Specifically, the MAPE decreased to 3.85 % 3.85\% compared to 4.42 % 4.42\% , and the MSE decreased to 1.34 × 10 − 2 1.34\times 10^{-2} compared to 2.01 × 10 − 2 2.01\times 10^{-2} . Inference time and GPU memory usage were reduced by factors of 16 and 12, respectively. Further experiments comparing scatter-corrected reconstructions on a large, simulated dataset and real CBCT scans from water and Sedentex CT phantoms clearly demonstrated the robustness of our method. Conclusion : This study highlights the underappreciated role of downsampling in deep learning-based scatter estimation. The substantial reduction in FLOPs and GPU memory requirements achieved by our method enables scatter correction in resource-constrained environments, such as mobile CBCT and edge devices. keywords Scatter Correction, Low Resources, Mobile CBCT, Clinical Application 1 Introduction Cone-beam computed tomography (CBCT) has emerged as a major imaging modality, offering a cost-effective solution with a relatively lower dose compared to multi-detector CT (MDCT) faccioli2020cost ; jacobs2011dental . A key advantage of CBCT is its portability which can potentially enhance the accessibility of imaging services to a broader population shuaib2010introduction ; faccioli2020cost . However, CBCT faces its own obstacles, notably scatter, primarily caused by radiating a large 2D flat-panel detector using a cone-shaped X-ray beam siewerdsen2001cone . Scatter adversely affects the quality of CBCT images joseph1982effects ; kalender2007flat by reducing contrast, causing shading, and leading to inaccuracies in CT numbers, thereby limiting the diagnostic applications of CBCT. Scatter correction methods can be categorized into hardware-based and software-based approaches. Hardware-based methods include the use of air-gaps, anti-scatter grids, beam-blockers, bow-tie filters, and limiting the field-of-measurement (FOM) sore1985 ; kyriakou2007efficiency ; zhu09 ; bootsma2011effects ; chen2008feasibility . However, these methods are not universally accepted as they present their own limitations ruhrnschopf2011general . The second category of approaches, software-based, include gold-standard Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to simulate the scatter signal and subtract it from the measured projections. Despite their accuracy, MC-based methods are time-intensive, often taking several minutes, and require an initial accurate reconstruction badal2009accelerating ; bertram2008monte . As an alternative to MC simulation-based correction, several deep learning-based U-Net Unet15 architectures have been proposed for scatter estimation from CBCT projections maier2019 ; nomura2019 ; pinto2023deep ; cruz2024task ; agrawal2024 . These methods learn the low-frequency scatter from scatter-corrupted projections with training data pairs generated using MC simulations. For instance, Maier et al. maier2019 introduced DSE-Net for real-time scatter estimation for different tube voltages, anatomies, and noise levels in medical CT. Similarly, Erath et al. erath2021deep applied DSE-Net for cross scatter correction in dual source CT. To address the variations in FOM size observed in CBCT scans, Agrawal et al. agrawal20241 ; agrawal2024 proposed Aux-Net, which incorporates FOM size information within the encoder of a U-Net. While these methods are generally faster than MC simulations for scatter estimation, their time and computational complexity largely depend on the size of the input image and the number of parameters in the network. Mobile CBCT or edge devices may not have sufficient GPU memory to handle such computations for large size of input projections. Therefore, a fast neural network is crucial for the clinical application of these networks in resource-constrained environments. To reduce computational complexity, downsampling the input has been a common approach in scatter correction methods simultaneously leveraging the low-frequency nature of scatter distribution. For example, Maier et al. maier2019 downsampled the input to 384\times 256 , while Agrawal et al. agrawal2024 downsampled all CBCT projections of various sizes to 320\times 256 to train a single model for varying FOM settings. Table 1 summarizes different strategies for resizing inputs in the deep learning-based scatter estimation literature. Variations in input sizes are evident, and the optimal downsampling method for scatter estimation remains unclear. To date, no study has investigated a suitable downsampling size and corresponding method for this task. On the other hand, some studies have shown the benefits of bicubic interpolation in chest X-ray classification and face recognition tasks. For chest X-ray classification, a bicubic interpolation-based downsampling performed best hirahara2021effect among different interpolation algorithms, achieving maximum classification accuracy at an image size of 64\times 64 compared to the original size of 1024\times 1024 pixels. Similarly, for the face recognition from electronic identity cards, a bicubic downsampling method performed better compared to the other interpolation methods hindratno2023impact . Table 1 : Original pixel sizes of the CBCT projections and the resized input dimensions for various methods in the deep learning-based CBCT scatter correction literature. method original size input size Maier et al. maier2019 not-provided 384\times 256 Lee et al. lee2019deep 256\times 128 256\times 128 Nomura et al. nomura2019 372\times 372 372\times 372 Lalonde et al. lalonde2020evaluation 1024\times 1024 512\times 512 Agrawal et al. agrawal2024 various sizes 320\times 256 Bastida et al. cruz2024task 512\times 256 512\times 256 Therefore, we investigated different resizing methods and their effect on the scatter signal reproduction. Further, we adopted the Aux-Net proposed in Agrawal et al. agrawal2024 for scatter estimation in CBCT scanners under varying FOM settings. We trained several different models using different input sizes and compared these models using a large, simulated dataset and real CBCT scans. Our contributions are as follows: • We explore various interpolation methods to assess their accuracy in downsampling and reconstructing the upsampled target scatter signal. • We demonstrate that downsampling the network input to an ultralow resolution enables an ultrafast scatter estimation network without compromising performance. Empirically, we identified an optimal resolution that balances speed and accuracy. • We show that the network parameters can be reduced by a factor of three while achieving comparable results. 2 Methods In this section, we detail the simulated training and testing datasets, the phantom scans utilized for testing, the interpolation methods employed, the network architecture, and the processes for training and evaluation. 2.1 Simulated Dataset We used MC simulations following the methods described in salvat2006penelope ; agrawal2023 for voxelized geometry to simulate X-ray trajectories. Primary and scatter CBCT projections were simulated using reconstructions of CT scans. We utilized the publicly available HNSCC-3DCT-RT dataset bejarano2018head from the TCIA repository clark2013cancer and CT scans of anthropomorphic phantoms. Nine scans were randomly selected for training and four scans for testing from HNSCC-3DCT-RT dataset. Additionally, two CT scans of anthropomorphic phantoms were included in the training set, and