Incentives for Digital Twins: Task-Based Productivity Enhancements with Generative AI

Catherine Wu, Arun Sundararajan · 2025

Read Incentives for Digital Twins: Task-Based Productivity Enhancements with Generative AI by Catherine Wu, Arun Sundararajan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08732.txt.

Introduction

Catherine Wu and 1 co-author study incentives for training an AI twin in a 2025 paper. An AI twin is a digital copy that can write or work in a person's own style. It may help its creator, but over time it may also replace them.

A principal-agent model, where one side hires and the other side works, frames the trade-off. Tasks differ in how easy AI output is to edit and how well non-experts can judge it. Workers may hold back training to keep wage power. The authors argue firms and policy must reward workers if gains are to last.

Catalog record

CREATORCatherine Wu, Arun Sundararajan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE59 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08732

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Incentives for Digital Twins: Task-Based Productivity Enhancements with Generative AI Catherine Wu, Arun Sundararajan Abstract Generative AI is a technology which depends in part on participation by humans in training and improving the automation potential. We focus on its ability to replicate the process or style of an individual human worker. This kind of “AI twin” could complement its creator’s efforts, enabling them to produce higher-quality output in their individual style more efficiently. However, increasingly intelligent AI twins could also, over time, replace individual humans. We analyze this trade-off using a principal-agent model in which agents have the opportunity to make investments into training an AI twin that lead to a lower cost of agent effort, a higher probability of success, or both. We propose a new framework to situate the model in which the tasks performed vary in the ease to which AI output can be altered or improved by the human (the “editability” of the output) and also vary in the extent to which a non-expert can assess the quality of human or AI output (its “verifiability.”) Our synthesis of recent empirical studies indicates that productivity gains from the use of generative AI are higher overall when task editability is higher, while non-experts enjoy greater relative productivity gains for tasks with higher verifiability. We show that during investment decisions, paradoxically, a strategic agent will trade off improvements in output quality and ease of effort to preserve their wage bargaining power. Tasks with high verifiability and low editability are strategically most aligned with a worker’s incentives to “train their twin,” but for tasks where the stakes are low, this alignment is constrained by the agent holding back to mitigate their risk of displacement. We extend these results in a two-period model and show that settings in which training investments yield the highest productivity gains also put the non-strategic agent at the greatest risk of mistakenly creating an AI twin that will displace them in the long run. Our results suggest that sustained improvements in company-sponsored generative AI will require nuanced design of human incentives, and that public policy which encourages balancing worker returns with generative AI improvements could yield more sustained long-run productivity gains. 1 Introduction In the early days of computer-based factory automation, a human machine operator’s manual actions were recorded, often via punched cards or tapes, and then ”played back” to drive machine tools automatically. These ”teach-and-repeat” methods laid the foundations for the computer numerical control (CNC) systems that powered an early wave of computer-driven automation ( Reintjes 1991 ) . Today, although generative AI is largely viewed as general-purpose source of knowledge and skills, a distinguishing characteristic of the technology is its ability to replicate the process or style of an individual human creator . A human’s body of work can now serve as training data to create AI that emulates their unique approaches, skills, and creative processes. From replicating an author’s writing style to capturing a surgeon’s precise movements, these ”digital twins” ( Sundararajan 2024 ) generate the ability to scale human expertise in unprecedented ways, while simultaneously raising new challenges to an individual’s ownership of their human capital. The potential of a new wave of replication-driven displacement extends beyond creative domains and into highly skilled professional fields, where complex individual human capabilities may be systematically captured and partially reproduced by AI systems, leading to a potential reversal of the skill-biased technological change that has characterized digital progress over the last decades ( Acemoglu 2002 ; Acemoglu 2021 ) . Platforms like Wizly 1 1 1 https://askwizly.ai/ that allow individuals to create “AI twins” and use them to scale their independent work will no doubt proliferate in the coming years. Thus, training an AI system to replicate individual skills may augment human potential, improving labor market outcomes and reducing inequality ( Agrawal et al. 2023 ) . A custom-trained generative AI model could augment its creator’s skill in their own domain, enabling the creator to produce higher-quality output faster and more efficiently. At the same time, workers may view increasingly intelligent tooling as a threat that could replace them or lower their ability to command premium wages. How will the net effect of these opposing forces affect the incentives for a knowledge worker to participate in the creation of their AI twin? This remains an open question, one that depends on factors that include the relative rate of quality improvements an AI twin provides with or without the human in the loop, the impact of individually customized AI systems on a human’s cost of effort, and the benefits that an organization enjoys from outcomes of varying levels of quality and success. While there is a growing body of literature about whether artificial intelligence will substitute for or complement human labor across various sectors ( Noy and Zhang 2023 ; Felten et al. 2023 ; Brynjolfsson et al. 2023 ) , research into the incentives a human worker might have to participate in the creation and improvement of such systems is limited. Moreover, recent projections about the impact of AI on worker productivity are mixed. A study conducted by The Upwork Research Institute reports that “77% [of employees] say [AI] tools have actually decreased their productivity and added to their workload” ( Monahan and Burlacu 2024 ) . In contrast, a study by McKinsey and Company estimate that generative AI “could add the equivalent of $2.6 trillion to $4.4 trillion annually” to the economy ( Chui et al. 2024 ) . Because AI is a general purpose technology ( Eloundou et al. 2023 ) , it is valuable to assess how these shifts of productivity will manifest in the long-run in market structure and governance ( Tucker 2024 ) . In this paper, we model a human worker who can partner with an AI system to accomplish tasks assigned by a manager. The capabilities of the AI system are inferior to those of the human worker, but the worker can choose to invest in training it to be an AI twin in order to either reduce the effort they need to exert, to improve work outcomes when partnering with the AI system, or both. [A more detailed paper with mathematical details and proofs is available on request.] We first consider a short-run problem, investigating how the worker’s level of investment in the creation of their AI twin depends on intrinsic task properties—specifically, (i) how easily a human worker can modify AI output to reach a desired quality level, which we term the editability of the task, and (ii) whether the manager is able to verify the quality of AI output absent the human worker, which we term the task’s verifiability . We define these properties based on their ability to explain recent findings from the empirical literature connecting the use of generative AI to productivity. We situate our problem in a two-outcome limited liability moral hazard model with hidden action. The manager (principal) chooses whether or not to offer the capability to customize an AI system to the worker (agent). If offered, the worker chooses a level of training investment in customizing the AI system. A higher level of training investment may lower the worker’s cost

Read the complete text