Causal evidence of racial and institutional biases in accessing paywalled articles and scientific data

Hazem Ibrahim, Fengyuan Liu, Khalid Mengal, Aaron R. Kaufman, Yasir Zaki, Talal Rahwan · 2025

Read Causal evidence of racial and institutional biases in accessing paywalled articles and scientific data by Hazem Ibrahim, Fengyuan Liu, Khalid Mengal, Aaron R. Kaufman, Yasir Zaki, Talal Rahwan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08299.txt.

Introduction

Who gets scientific papers and data when they ask informally? Hazem Ibrahim and 6 co-authors find causal evidence of bias in a 2025 science-of-science study. Paywalls block much published work, and many datasets are shared only on request. Emailing authors works around both barriers, but whether replies depend on the requester's race or institution was unknown.

Survey data, interviews, large-scale observational analysis, and two randomised audit experiments are combined to isolate the disparities. Audit experiments, which vary only the sender's identity, turn correlation into causal evidence. Unequal informal access compounds quietly: researchers already short on resources fall further behind when the community's side door opens more readily for some names than others.

Catalog record

CREATORHazem Ibrahim, Fengyuan Liu, Khalid Mengal, Aaron R. Kaufman, Yasir Zaki, Talal Rahwan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE82 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08299

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Causal evidence of racial and institutional biases in accessing paywalled articles and scientific data Hazem Ibrahim, Fengyuan Liu, Khalid Mengal, Aaron R. Kaufman, Yasir Zaki, Talal Rahwan Abstract Scientific progress fundamentally depends on researchers’ ability to access and build upon the work of others. Yet, a majority of published work remains behind expensive paywalls, limiting access to universities that can afford subscriptions. Furthermore, even when articles are accessible, the underlying datasets could be restricted, available only through a “reasonable request” to the authors. One way researchers could overcome these barriers is by relying on informal channels, such as emailing authors directly, to obtain paywalled articles or restricted datasets. However, whether these informal channels are hindered by racial and/or institutional biases remains unknown. Here, we combine qualitative semi-structured interviews, large-scale observational analysis, and two randomized audit experiments to examine racial and institutional disparities in access to scientific knowledge. Our analysis of 250 million articles reveals that researchers in the Global South cite paywalled papers and upon-request datasets at significantly lower rates than their Global North counterparts, and that these access gaps are associated with reduced knowledge breadth and scholarly impact. To interrogate the mechanisms underlying this phenomenon, we conduct two randomized email audit studies in which fictional PhD students differing in racial background and institutional affiliation request access to paywalled articles (N = 18,000) and datasets (N = 11,840). We find that racial identity more strongly predicts response rate to paywalled article requests compared to institutional affiliation, whereas institutional affiliation played a larger role in shaping access to datasets. These findings reveal how informal gatekeeping can perpetuate structural inequities in science, highlighting the need for stronger data-sharing mandates and more equitable open access policies. Introduction Scientific progress is fundamentally cumulative, with later advances relying on access to the knowledge that came before. As Newton famously remarked, “If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants.” This steady accumulation of knowledge relies on the ability of scientists to access, scrutinize, and build upon the work of others. Without such access to publications, data, code, and methodologies, the scientific enterprise becomes siloed or even stalls. In many ways, knowledge is a public good: its use by one researcher does not diminish its value to others, and broad access can accelerate collective progress. Championing this principle, the open science movement has emerged to ensure that knowledge is widely and equitably accessible: by removing barriers to published articles, mandating the sharing of datasets, and promoting transparent research practices, open science promises not only faster discovery but also more reproducible and inclusive research [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . In practice, however, many obstacles to this ideal remain. A substantial portion of the scientific literature continues to be published behind paywalls [ 6 , 7 , 8 ] , limiting access to institutions with expensive subscriptions. Even when articles are accessible, the underlying data may not be. Despite journals increasingly mandating the inclusion of Data Availability Statements (DAS) [ 9 ] , as well as the proliferation of research data repositories (e.g., figshare [ 10 ] , dataverse [ 11 ] , huggingface [ 12 ] ), compliance with data sharing policies is inconsistent. Many authors offer data “upon request”, yet studies have shown that such requests often go unanswered [ 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . As scientific discovery enters a data-driven era, datasets are becoming ever more crucial to the advancement of science [ 20 , 21 ] . The accessibility of data is not merely a convenience but a critical component for the replication, validation, and extension of scientific findings [ 13 ] . As such, informal discretionary practices create uncertainty and may introduce new barriers that formal open access policies were designed to eliminate. Whether these barriers affect all researchers equally remains an open question. Much of the infrastructure of global science is concentrated in the Global North, among institutions with greater funding, access to subscription databases, and established research networks. In contrast, scholars at institutions in the Global South often operate with fewer resources and limited formal access [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] . Even as open science policies expand, their benefits may be unequally distributed, potentially reinforcing existing disparities in who can fully participate in scientific discovery. This possibility carries particular importance given the growing relevance of Global South researchers to fields that address global challenges. In disciplines such as global health, development economics, and climate adaptation, local context and sociocultural expertise are critical. When researchers closest to the problem are unable to access the literature or data needed to contribute, it not only limits individual opportunity, it impoverishes science itself [ 25 , 26 ] . Here, we study whether and how key hurdles targeted by open science—paywalled papers and the lack of accessible data—disproportionately burden researchers in the Global South. In Study 1, we conduct qualitative semi-structured interviews with researchers from universities across the Global South, providing direct insight into the lived experience of researchers navigating constraints in access to publications and data. Participants describe the criticality of replication data and code to their research and teaching, the hoops they jump through to access paywalled papers, and the deteriorating funding environments that are worsening their research capacity in recent months and years. Motivated by these researchers’ stories, Studies 2 and 4 assess whether these individual experiences are reflected in aggregate patterns of scholarly citation. Drawing on over 250 million articles from OpenAlex and over 120,000 articles with explicit Data Availability Statements, we examine whether researchers from the Global South cite paywalled articles (Study 2) and papers with “upon request” (Study 4) data at different rates compared to researchers in the Global North. Citation behavior, while not a direct measure of access, serves as a useful proxy: if researchers are systematically less likely to cite materials that require special access, this may reflect broader disparities in who can engage with those materials in the first place. These data reveal stark divides, with Global South researchers 26% less likely to cite those with restricted data, and 8% less likely to cite paywalled articles, than researchers in the Global North. Studies 3 and 5 investigate potential mechanisms behind such disparities by conducting two large-scale randomized audit experiments. Based on the extensive literature examining discrimination in non-academic contexts [ 27 , 28 , 29 , 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 ] , we hypothesize that whether one can successfully gain access to knowledge through informal channels may not only depend on what is being requested, but also on who is making the request: discrimination may play a role in Global South researchers’ access to paywalled articles and restricted data. Building on recent work that distinguishes between statistical and taste-based discrimination [ 34 , 35 ] , we send over 29,000 email requests for articles and data to the corresponding authors of published papers. We randomly vary the race, country of origin, and institutional affiliation of the requesters to test whether these social signals influence recipients’ willingness to share paywalled papers (Study 3) or replication data (Study 5). The

Read the complete text