Mitigating the rank reversal probability in the entropy-weight TODIM method through an expanded evaluation matrix: A case study on energy storage technology selection

Lisheng Jiang, Tianyu Zhang, Shiyu Yan, Ran Fang · 2025

Read Mitigating the rank reversal probability in the entropy-weight TODIM method through an expanded evaluation matrix: A case study on energy storage technology selection by Lisheng Jiang, Tianyu Zhang, Shiyu Yan, Ran Fang (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08236.txt.

Introduction

Ranking methods that reshuffle winners when a new option appears are a known embarrassment, and Lisheng Jiang with 3 co-authors reduce that risk in a 2025 decision science paper. Their target is a hybrid method that combines entropy weighting with TODIM, a multicriteria ranking technique. Rank reversal, where adding an alternative flips the order of existing ones, undermines trust in the result.

An expanded evaluation matrix, padded with virtual alternatives, lowers the probability of reversal. The method is then applied to selecting energy storage technology, a choice balancing cost, performance, and risk criteria. Decision tools used for real investments must not change their verdict because an irrelevant extra option wandered into the spreadsheet.

Catalog record

CREATORLisheng Jiang, Tianyu Zhang, Shiyu Yan, Ran Fang
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE39 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08236

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Mitigating the rank reversal probability in the entropy-weight TODIM method through an expanded evaluation matrix: A case study on energy storage technology selection Lisheng Jiang, Tianyu Zhang, Shiyu Yan, Ran Fang Abstract The TODIM method (an acronym in Portuguese for interactive and multiple criteria decision-making) with entropy weights is influenced by rank reversal, a phenomenon where the order of two alternatives changes following the addition of another alternative. Research on rank reversal has predominantly focused on single decision-making methods. To the best of our knowledge, the reduction of rank reversal probability in hybrid methods, such as the entropy-weight TODIM method, remains an unresolved challenge. To address this, this paper introduces the expanded evaluation matrix, which incorporates virtual alternatives, to reduce the probability of rank reversal in the entropy-weight TODIM method. A simulation study is conducted to assess the effectiveness of the expanded evaluation matrix in mitigating rank reversal. The results demonstrate that the expanded evaluation matrix significantly reduces the rank reversal probability. A case study on selecting energy storage technology showcases the potential real-world applications of the expanded evaluation matrix. The reliability of the expanded evaluation matrix is further validated through sensitivity and comparative analyses. Given the simplicity and ease of implementation of the expanded evaluation matrix, it can be readily adapted to other decision-making methods and holds substantial potential for broad application. Keywords: Multiple criteria decision making; entropy-weight TODIM; rank reversal; expanded evaluation matrix; energy storage 1 Introduction Multi-criteria decision-making methods assist decision-makers in ranking a set of alternatives based on evaluations across multiple criteria. The TODIM method (an acronym in Portuguese for interactive and multiple criteria decision-making) ( Gomes and Lima, 1991 ) , which generates a linear order of alternatives with ties, ranks alternatives based on the dominance degree of one alternative over another, which is quantified using a dominance function. In the TODIM method, the weights of the criteria are required. The entropy weight method, which derives objective weights from the information entropy of evaluations ( Shannon, 1948 ) , is commonly used in conjunction with the TODIM method ( Huang et al., 2024b ) . This paper focuses on the entropy-weight TODIM method. Given that TODIM accounts for psychological biases of decision-makers, such as loss aversion and risk aversion, it has been widely applied in various fields, including waste-to-energy decision-making ( Mousavi et al., 2022 ; Wu et al., 2023 ; Narayanamoorthy et al., 2022 ) , renewable energy investment decision-making ( Wu et al., 2019 ; Hashemizadeh et al., 2021 ) , renewable energy site selection ( Zhao et al., 2024a ; Wang et al., 2021 ) , renewable energy risk assessment ( He et al., 2022 ; Yin and Liu, 2022 ; Liu et al., 2024c ) , and performance evaluation of renewable energy ( Zhang et al., 2022 ) . It has been observed that multi-criteria decision-making methods are susceptible to rank reversal, a phenomenon where the order of two alternatives is altered after the addition or removal of another alternative. This phenomenon was first identified in the analytic hierarchy process ( Belton and Gear, 1983 ) and later examined in the TODIM method ( Jiang et al., 2024 ) . Research on rank reversal has primarily focused on single decision-making methods, such as the preference ranking organization method of enrichment evaluations ( Liu and Liu, 2024 ) , the elimination and choice expressing reality ( Liu and Ma, 2021 ) , and the technique for order preference by similarity to ideal solution ( Yang et al., 2022a ) . As far as we know, few studies have addressed how to reduce the rank reversal probability of hybrid methods, such as the entropy-weight TODIM method . To address the aforementioned issue, this paper proposes an expanded evaluation matrix to reduce the probability of rank reversal in the entropy-weight TODIM method. To achieve this, virtual alternatives are introduced to construct the expanded evaluation matrix. Subsequently, simulation experiments are conducted to evaluate the performance of the expanded evaluation matrix in mitigating rank reversal. The contributions and innovations of this paper are summarized as follows. (1) The expanded evaluation matrix is introduced for the entropy-weight TODIM method to reduce the rank reversal probability. First, equally spaced virtual evaluations are defined, from which virtual alternatives are generated. Next, the expanded evaluation matrix is constructed using these virtual alternatives. When applying the entropy-weight TODIM method, replacing the original evaluation matrix with the expanded evaluation matrix helps reduce the probability of rank reversal. To the best of our knowledge, the proposed expanded evaluation matrix is the first method to reduce the probability of rank reversal for hybrid multi-criteria decision-making methods . (2) Simulations are conducted to demonstrate the effectiveness of the expanded evaluation matrix in mitigating rank reversal. This paper examines four simulation factors: the number of alternatives, the number of criteria, the level parameter, and the number of added alternatives. Based on the simulation results, several findings and recommendations are provided for the application of the expanded evaluation matrix. (3) A case study on energy storage technology selection is presented to explore the potential of the proposed expanded evaluation matrix in real-world applications. Sensitivity and comparative analyses are conducted to demonstrate the reliability of the proposed method. The structure of this paper is organized as follows: Section 2 reviews the research on rank reversal of the TODIM method. Section 3 introduces the extended evaluation matrix, followed by an example of using the extended evaluation matrix. Section 4 establishes the simulation experiments. Section 5 presents the case study on the selection of energy storage technologies. Section 6 provides some suggestions, and the paper closes with conclusions in Section 7 . 2 Literature review By using the prospect theory ( Kahneman and Tversky, 1979 ; Tversky and Kahneman, 1992 ) to deal with risk aversion and the loss aversion of decision-makers, Gomes and Lima, 1991 proposed a multi-criteria decision-making method named TODIM. To apply the TODIM method, the evaluations under each criterion are standardized through standardization techniques. Then, based on the standardized evaluations, a preference function is applied to calculate the dominance degree of each pair of alternatives on every criterion. After that, the total dominance degree of every pair of alternatives is calculated by taking a weighted sum of the dominance degrees on all criteria. Based on the total dominance degrees, the scores of alternatives are calculated, which are used to rank alternatives in descending order. The procedure of the TODIM method is given in Appendix . Since the TODIM method was introduced, it has been widely applied in many fields like scheduling ( Huang et al., 2024a ) , emergency management ( Chen et al., 2024 ; Liu et al., 2024b ) , energy management ( Liu et al., 2024a ; Zhao et al., 2024b ) , and global climate management ( Zhou et al., 2024 ) . To perform the weighted sum in the TODIM method, the weights of criteria are required. In addition to allowing decision-makers to directly give weights, the entropy weight method is another way to generate weights ( Huang et al., 2024b ) . The basis of entropy weight is information entropy ( Shannon, 1948 ) . For a criterion, the greater

Read the complete text