Reinterpretation of chiral anomaly on a lattice

Huan-Wen Wang, Bo Fu, Shun-Qing Shen · 2025

Read Reinterpretation of chiral anomaly on a lattice by Huan-Wen Wang, Bo Fu, Shun-Qing Shen (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08210.txt.

Introduction

Huan-Wen Wang's 2025 paper, written with Bo Fu and Shun-Qing Shen, reinterprets the chiral anomaly on a lattice. The anomaly is a quantum effect for massless Dirac fermions, particles that appear both in particle physics and in modern materials. Models usually capture behaviour near the Dirac point but lose the high-energy states at the edge of the Brillouin zone.

Effective models built from higher-dimensional Chern insulators cover the whole zone, keeping low-energy chirality and boundary states in one description. With electromagnetic fields present, the chiral coefficient generally depends on chemical potential, yet it locks to a quantised value exactly at the Fermi surface. A cleaner lattice picture of the anomaly helps both lattice gauge theorists and condensed matter physicists trust their simulations.

Catalog record

CREATORHuan-Wen Wang, Bo Fu, Shun-Qing Shen
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08210

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Reinterpretation of chiral anomaly on a lattice Huan-Wen Wang, Bo Fu, Shun-Qing Shen Abstract The chiral anomaly is a quantum mechanical effect for massless Dirac fermions in both particle physics and condensed matter physics. Here we present a set of effective models for single massless Dirac fermions in one- and three-dimensions in the whole Brillouin zone from higher-dimensional Chern insulators, which uniquely capture both the chiral fermion behavior near the Dirac point and high-energy states at Brillouin zone boundaries. In the presence of electromagnetic fields, the chiral coefficient C 5 C_{5} is found to be chemical-potential dependent in general, but quantized precisely at the Fermi surface where chiral symmetry is preserved. This result provides an alternative interpretation of chiral anomaly on a lattice: the anomaly is caused by the symmetry-broken states far below the Fermi surface, and protected by the local chiral symmetry. Our analysis here might provide a potential theoretical foundation for applying the concept of chiral anomaly in condensed matter physics. I Introduction Chiral anomaly is a fascinating phenomenon that arises in quantum field theory and has significant implications in various branches of physics, including particle physics and condensed matter physics ( adler 1969 ; bell 1969 ; fujikawa 1979 ; peskin 1995 ; armitage 2018 ; lu 2017 ; Nielsen 1983 ; Azee 2010 ; Stephanov 2012 ) . At its core, chiral anomaly arises from the interplay between chiral fermions and gauge fields. In the presence of external electromagnetic fields, the chiral anomaly leads to an imbalance between the rates at which left-handed and right-handed fermions are generated or annihilated ( Nielsen 1983 ; DTSon 2013 ; Stephanov 2012 ; peskin 1995 ; armitage 2018 ; lu 2017 ; Azee 2010 ) . This intriguing effect has profound consequences in various physical systems. In condensed matter physics, the chiral anomaly has attracted substantial attentions, particularly in topological materials like Weyl semimetals and Dirac semimetals, where it gives rise to unique transport phenomena ( DTSon 2013 ; burkov 2014 ; huang 2017 ; armitage 2018 ; kim 2013 ; xiong 2015 ; zhang 2016 ; li_nc 2016 ; liang 2018 ; li_np 2016 ; lu 2017 ) . Although the relation between chiral anomaly effect and regularization techniques has been widely discussed in quantum field theory ( Wilson 1977 ; jackiw 1969 ; Rothe 1998 ; fujikawa 1980 ; Nilsen 1981 ; Neuberger 1998 ; kaplan 1992 ; Kaplan_1 2024 ; Kaplan_2 2024 ) , it has rarely been explored in condensed matter physics. Over the past several decades, field theorists have developed diverse approaches to understanding the chiral anomaly, each offering unique insights into its origins. In standard perturbation theory, the anomaly arises from the inability to simultaneously satisfy the Ward identities for both vector and axial currents in the one-loop triangle diagram ( adler 1969 ; Azee 2010 ) . Fujikawa’s functional integral approach attributes the anomaly to the non-invariance of the path-integral measure under chiral transformations, where the Jacobian factor introduces an anomalous term ( fujikawa 1979 ; fujikawa 1980 ) . Alternatively, one can define the chiral current operator by placing the two fermion fields at distinct points separated by a distance \epsilon , and the singularity produced by taking the limit as the two fields approach each other ( jackiw 1969 ; peskin 1995 ) . Pauli-Villars regularization, meanwhile, introduces massive fermions to cancel divergences at the cost of explicit chiral symmetry breaking. All the methods mentioned above are based on a low energy effective model, meanwhile, the anomaly was intensively studied on a lattice as well, while it is usually struggling with the fermion doubling problem for a lattice fermion ( Wilson 1977 ; Nilsen 1981 ) . Efforts to circumvent this—such as domain wall or overlap fermions—have linked chiral anomalies to topological systems ( Neuberger 1998 ; Callan 1995 ) . Notably, topological band theory predicts massless boundary fermions in topological materials, analogous to domain wall fermions ( Qi 2008 ; Qi 2011 ; Moore 2010 ; Hasan 2010 ; SQS 2010 ) . In Ref. ( Fu 2022 ) , Fu et al further connected anomaly to condensed matter systems through quantum anomalous semimetals (QAS). In two dimensions, the relation between parity symmetry and parity anomaly has been clarified based on the semi-magnetic topological insulators ( Zou 2022 ; Zou 2022 ; Wang 2024 ; Fu 2025 ; Chen 2024 ; SQS 2024 ; Bai 2024 ; Mogi 2022 ) . However, the connection between chiral symmetry and chiral anomaly in one or three dimensional QAS has not been satisfactorily built ( Wang 2022 ) . In this work, we derived effective models for the quasi-boundary states of 2D and 4D Chern insulators in the whole momentum space, encompassing both continuum and lattice formulations. These states exhibit linearized Dirac-like dispersion within the bulk band gap, aligning with the idealized framework commonly discussed in prior literature. However, as momentum scales increase, the initially localized boundary states transition towards bulk states, acquiring a Dirac mass in the process, consequently breaking chiral symmetry explicitly. We then analyze the chiral anomaly associated with these states. In contrast to the conventional regularization approach in the field theory, the effective model utilized in this study captures the chiral fermion behavior near the Dirac point while simultaneously incorporating symmetry-breaking contributions at high energies. In the presence of electromagnetic field, the calculated chiral coefficient C_{5} in the continuity equation of the chiral current is a function of the chemical potential, and it is quantized in a finite range. Furthermore, the quantization of C_{5} is proved to be protected by the local chiral symmetry near the Fermi surface. This result provides an alternative interpretation of chiral anomaly on a lattice: the anomaly is caused by the symmetry broken states far below the Fermi surface, and protected by the local chiral symmetry. II Boundary States of 2D Chern insulator As demonstrated in Ref. ( Zou 2022 ; Bai 2024 ) , the single Dirac fermion in two dimensions can be realized on the boundary of three-dimensional topological insulator. Following the same procedure, we proved that the single Dirac fermion in odd dimensions exists in the boundary of even dimensional topological systems. In this part, we derived the continuum model of edge states of two dimensional Chern insulators (CIs) analytically. Here we begin with the effective 2\times 2 modified Dirac equation ( SQS 2010 ) , H_{\mathrm{MD}}=v\hbar\left(k_{x}\sigma_{x}+k_{y}\sigma_{y}\right)+m_{0}(\mathbf{k})\sigma_{z}, (1) where m_{0}(\mathbf{k})=m_{0}-b(k_{x}^{2}+k_{y}^{2}) is the momentum-dependent Dirac mass, \mathbf{k}=(k_{x},k_{y}) is the wave vector, m_{0},v,b are the model parameters, without loss of generality, we assume v>0 . The Chern number of this model can be found as \mathcal{C}=-\left[\mathrm{sgn}(m_{0})+\mathrm{sgn}(b)\right]/2 . For CIs, \mathcal{C}=\pm 1 , which requires m_{0}b>0 . To obtain the edge states of CIs, we divide Eq. ( 1 ) into two parts as H_{\mathrm{MD}}=H_{1d}+v\hbar k_{x}\sigma_{x} with H_{\mathrm{1d}}=v\hbar k_{y}\sigma_{y}+m_{0}(\mathbf{k})\sigma_{z} . For a finite length L along the y direction, we make a substitution as k_{y}\to-i\partial_{y} . To solve the eigen equation H_{\mathrm{1d}}\Psi=E\Psi , we set the trial function as \Psi=e^{i\xi y}\Phi . The eigen equation is reduced to \left[v\hbar\xi\sigma_{y}+m_{0}\left(k_{x},\xi\right)\sigma_{z}\right]\Phi=E\Phi with m_{0}(k_{x},\xi)\equiv m_{0}-b(k_{x}^{2}+\xi^{2}) . For a nontrivial solution of \Phi, the secular equation of \xi and E gives four solutions for \xi(E) in Eq.

Read the complete text