Affleck-Dine Leptoflavorgenesis
Kensuke Akita, Koichi Hamaguchi, Maksym Ovchynnikov · 2025
Read Affleck-Dine Leptoflavorgenesis by Kensuke Akita, Koichi Hamaguchi, Maksym Ovchynnikov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-08175.txt.
Introduction
Kensuke Akita and 2 co-authors propose a way for the early universe to hide big flavour gaps inside a zero total, in a 2025 cosmology paper. Their route uses the Affleck-Dine mechanism. In that scheme, a scalar field moves in the young universe and makes more matter than antimatter. Here the field also breaks into lumps called Q-balls.
The gaps are in lepton flavour: electrons, muons, and taus. One flavour can hold a surplus while another holds a matching deficit. The total stays zero on its own, with no fine tuning. Neutrino mixing later spreads the gaps around. That spread dodges the tight limits from the first minutes of the universe and from the microwave sky.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Kensuke Akita, Koichi Hamaguchi, Maksym Ovchynnikov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 53 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-08175
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Affleck-Dine Leptoflavorgenesis Kensuke Akita, Koichi Hamaguchi, Maksym Ovchynnikov Abstract We propose a scenario to produce large primordial lepton flavor asymmetries with vanishing total lepton asymmetry, based on the Affleck-Dine mechanism with Q-ball formation. This scenario can produce large lepton flavor asymmetries while automatically maintaining the vanishing total lepton number without fine-tuning, evading the current BBN and the CMB constraints by neutrino oscillations at MeV temperature. The asymmetries can be produced at cosmic temperatures of T ≳ 1 GeV T\gtrsim 1\ {\rm GeV} , early enough to have broad impacts from the early Universe to the present cosmology. This scenario could affect various aspects of early Universe cosmology simultaneously or separately: (i) explaining the observed baryon asymmetry by the same origin as the lepton flavor asymmetries, (ii) affecting the nature of the QCD transition, (iii) opening up a new parameter space of sterile neutrino dark matter by enhancing their production, and (iv) altering the abundance of the light elements, in particular, resolving the recently reported helium-4 anomaly. I Introduction We observe that the Universe consists almost entirely of matter and a little antimatter. This is commonly parameterized as the number density of baryons minus antibaryons normalized to the entropy density, given by Y_{B}\equiv\Delta n_{B}/s=(n_{B}-n_{\bar{B}})/s=(8.75\pm 0.23)\times 10^{-11} Planck:2018vyg . On the other hand, we have less clues about primordial lepton asymmetries, Y_{L_{\alpha}}\equiv\Delta n_{L_{\alpha}}/s=(n_{L_{\alpha}}-n_{\bar{L}_{\alpha}})/s , where n_{L_{\alpha}} ( n_{\bar{L}_{\alpha}} ) is the number densities of the (anti)lepton with flavor \alpha (\alpha=e,\ \mu,\ \tau) . Naively, baryon and lepton asymmetries would have similar magnitudes, Y_{B}\sim Y_{L_{\alpha}} , due to the electroweak sphaleron transition in the early Universe Kuzmin:1985mm . However, the sphaleron processes are ineffective at the temperature of the Universe of T\lesssim T_{\rm sph}\simeq 130\ {\rm GeV} DOnofrio:2014rug , and large lepton asymmetry can be produced below this temperature, consistent with the observed small baryon asymmetry. Indeed, scenarios to produce large primordial lepton asymmetry have been proposed in refs. Dolgov:1989us ; Casas:1997gx ; March-Russell:1999hpw ; Kawasaki:2002hq ; Yamaguchi:2002vw ; Pilaftsis:2003gt ; Shaposhnikov:2008pf ; Shu:2006mm ; Gu:2010dg ; Kawasaki:2022hvx ; Borah:2022uos ; Kasai:2024diy ; Borah:2024xoa . Observationally, the Big Bang Nucleosynthesis (BBN) and the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) are sensitive to lepton asymmetries Sarkar:1995dd ; Iocco:2008va ; Pitrou:2018cgg ; Lesgourgues:2006nd ; Serpico:2005bc ; Mangano:2011ip ; Chu:2006ua ; Simha:2008mt ; Li:2024gzf ; Oldengott:2017tzj ; Seto:2021tad ; Kumar:2022vee ; Matsumoto:2022tlr ; Burns:2022hkq ; Escudero:2022okz ; Froustey:2024mgf ; Domcke:2025lzg ; Yanagisawa:2025mgx . The former primarily probes the asymmetry in the electron neutrino flavor through the neutron-proton ratio. In addition, both the BBN and the CMB are sensitive to the total radiation density enhanced by the asymmetries. In particular, there are almost no clues about lepton flavor asymmetries summing up to zero total lepton asymmetry, as recently studied comprehensively in Ref. Domcke:2025lzg . The BBN and CMB observations are sensitive to the asymmetries below the temperature of the Universe of T\simeq 1\ {\rm MeV} . At T\sim 15\ {\rm MeV} before neutrino decoupling, neutrino oscillations start Dolgov:2002ab ; Pastor:2008ti ; Mangano:2010ei ; Castorina:2012md ; Froustey:2021azz ; Froustey:2024mgf ; Domcke:2025lzg . The flavor-changing oscillations can lead to washing out the flavor asymmetries, relaxing the BBN and CMB constraints on them. Large lepton asymmetry can induce rich phenomenology in the Universe. In particular, less constrained lepton flavor asymmetries might affect baryogenesis Casas:1997gx ; Dolgov:1989us ; March-Russell:1999hpw ; Kawasaki:2002hq ; Yamaguchi:2002vw ; Pilaftsis:2003gt ; Shaposhnikov:2008pf ; Shu:2006mm ; Gu:2010dg ; Kawasaki:2022hvx ; Borah:2022uos ; Borah:2024xoa ; Cohen:1987vi ; Cohen:1988kt ; Davidson:1994gn ; Chiba:2003vp ; Takahashi:2003db ; Gao:2023djs ; Gao:2024fhm , the nature of the QCD transition Asakawa:1989bq ; Schwarz:2009ii ; Middeldorf-Wygas:2020glx ; Vovchenko:2020crk ; Gao:2021nwz ; Ferreira:2025zeu ; Formaggio:2025nde , the production of sterile neutrino dark matter Shi:1998km ; Abazajian:2001nj ; Kishimoto:2008ic ; Laine:2008pg ; Ghiglieri:2015jua ; Venumadhav:2015pla ; Kasai:2024diy ; Gorbunov:2025nqs ; Vogel:2025aut ; Akita:2025txo , the detection prospects of the cosmic neutrino background Stodolsky:1974aq ; Duda:2001hd ; Long:2014zva ; Ruchayskiy:2022eog , the presence of cosmic magnetic fields Joyce:1997uy ; Boyarsky:2011uy ; Akamatsu:2013pjd ; Hirono:2015rla ; Rogachevskii:2017uyc ; Domcke:2022uue and the abundance of the light elements Kohri:1996ke ; Casas:1997gx ; March-Russell:1999hpw ; Kawasaki:2002hq ; Matsumoto:2022tlr ; Kawasaki:2022hvx ; Escudero:2022okz ; Froustey:2024mgf ; Domcke:2025lzg ; Burns:2022hkq . Primordial lepton asymmetries may also resolve the recently reported helium-4 anomaly, indicating a smaller helium-4 abundance compared to the standard BBN scenario Matsumoto:2022tlr ; Escudero:2022okz ; Froustey:2024mgf ; Domcke:2025lzg ; Burns:2022hkq ; Yanagisawa:2025mgx . This anomaly favors a large electron-flavor asymmetry at the BBN epoch in a mild 2\sigma tension with the standard scenario Yanagisawa:2025mgx . The sphaleron process preserves the quantity Y_{B}/3-Y_{L_{\alpha}} for each lepton flavor \alpha but can change Y_{B}+Y_{L} , where Y_{L}=\sum_{\alpha}Y_{L_{\alpha}} is the total lepton asymmetry. This implies that the baryon asymmetry vanishes if Y_{B}-Y_{L}=0 . Interestingly, however, the sphaleron conversion from lepton flavor asymmetries with Y_{B}-Y_{L}=0 to baryon asymmetry is not perfectly canceled due to the differences in the Standard Model (SM) lepton Yukawa couplings Khlebnikov:1988sr ; March-Russell:1999hpw ; Laine:1999wv . Large lepton flavor asymmetries then may offer a natural explanation of small baryon asymmetries while providing a rich phenomenology for the history of the Universe. One of the open questions about large lepton flavor asymmetries is their origin: What is the leptoflavorgenesis scenario? Until now, several models for leptoflavorgenesis have been proposed Kuzmin:1987wn ; March-Russell:1999hpw ; Shu:2006mm ; Gu:2010dg ; Mukaida:2021sgv . However, it would be non-trivial how large asymmetries leptoflavorgenesis scenarios can produce under the latest BBN and CMB constraints. In addition, it would also be non-trivial whether the asymmetries are generated early enough to affect the early Universe physics. In this work, we propose a new scenario to produce large lepton flavor asymmetries, based on the Affleck-Dine (AD) mechanism Affleck:1984fy ; Dine:1995kz . We utilize the Q\bar{u}L\bar{e} flat directions, which can break lepton flavor but conserve the total lepton number. To prevent the overproduction of the baryon asymmetry, we consider a scenario of Q-ball formation Kawasaki:2002hq ; Kawasaki:2022hvx ; Kasai:2024diy , where the generated lepton flavor asymmetries are confined within the Q-balls and protected from being converted into baryon asymmetry. The lepton flavor asymmetries are then produced via the late-time decays of the Q-balls. This Affleck-Dine leptoflavorgenesis (ADLFG) scenario can produce large lepton flavor asymmetries while automatically maintaining the vanishing total lepton number without fine-tuning, evading the BBN and CMB constraints. The asymmetries can be produced at the temperature of the Universe of T\gtrsim 1\ {\rm GeV} , which is early enough to affect the nature of the QCD transition and the production of sterile neutrino dark matter. Our main results are summarized in Figure 1 . This ADLFG scenario can generate large lepton flavor asymmetries of |Y_{L_{\alpha}}|\sim 10^{-3}\cdots 10^{-1} . If tau flavor asymmetry of Y_{L_{\tau}}\sim-10^{-2}\cdots-10^{-1} or muon flavor asymmetry of Y_{L_{\mu}}\sim-10^{-1} is produced, the observed baryon asymmetry can be generated by the same origin as the lepton flavor asymmetries in this scenario (cf. Eq. ( 34 )). The generated lepton flavor asymmetries can open up a new parameter space of sterile neutrino DM Akita:2025txo , alter the abundance of the light elements, in particular, resolve the recently reported helium-4 anomaly Domcke:2025lzg , and may affect the nature of the QCD transition Asakawa:1989bq ; Schwarz:2009ii ; Middeldorf-Wygas:2020glx ; Vovchenko:2020crk ; Gao:2021nwz ; Ferreira:2025zeu ; Formaggio:2025nde as discussed in Section IV . The rest of