Probing the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation via Non-Parametric Reconstruction for High Redshifts

Felipe Avila, Fernanda Oliveira, Camila Franco, Maria Lopes, Rodrigo Holanda, Rafael C. Nunes, Armando Bernui · 2025

Read Probing the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation via Non-Parametric Reconstruction for High Redshifts by Felipe Avila, Fernanda Oliveira, Camila Franco, Maria Lopes, Rodrigo Holanda, Rafael C. Nunes, Armando Bernui (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07848.txt.

Introduction

Felipe Avila and 6 co-authors test a basic rule of cosmology in a 2025 paper. The cosmic distance duality relation links two ways of measuring distance to faraway objects. If the rule fails, something in standard assumptions about light and space must be wrong. The team checks it at high redshift, meaning very large distances.

Angular distances come from baryon acoustic oscillations and galaxy clusters. Light-based distances come from exploding stars in the Pantheon+ sample and from quasars, with noisy quasar data cleaned by selection and binning. Gaussian processes rebuild the relation without assuming a fixed cosmic model. A clean test like this helps confirm that distance measures used across astronomy agree with each other.

Catalog record

CREATORFelipe Avila, Fernanda Oliveira, Camila Franco, Maria Lopes, Rodrigo Holanda, Rafael C. Nunes, Armando Bernui
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07848

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probing the Cosmic Distance Duality Relation via Non-Parametric Reconstruction for High Redshifts Felipe Avila, Fernanda Oliveira, Camila Franco, Maria Lopes, Rodrigo Holanda, Rafael C. Nunes, Armando Bernui Abstract We test the validity of the cosmic distance duality relation (CDDR) by combining angular diameter distance and luminosity distance measurements from recent cosmological observations. For the angular diameter distance, we use data from transverse baryon acoustic oscillations and galaxy clusters. On the other hand, the luminosity distance is obtained from Type Ia supernovae in the Pantheon+ sample and from quasar catalogs. To reduce the large dispersion in quasar luminosity distances, we apply a selection criterion based on their deviation from the Λ \Lambda CDM model and implement a binning procedure to suppress statistical noise. We reconstruct the CDDR using Gaussian Processes, a non-parametric supervised machine learning method. Our results show no significant deviation from the CDDR within the 2 ​ σ 2\sigma confidence level across the redshift range explored, supporting its validity even at high redshifts. I Introduction One of the most pivotal achievements in modern cosmology is the precise determination of distances to remote astronomical sources. By comparing a source’s redshift with its measured distance—obtained either from standard candles (luminosity distance, D_{L} ) or standard rulers (angular diameter distance, D_{A} )—we can place stringent constraints on cosmological models. For example, the existence of dark energy and dark matter has been confirmed with remarkable precision through observations of Type Ia supernovae, which serve as standard candles, and baryon acoustic oscillations, which act as standard rulers (see, e.g., Di Valentino et al. 2025 ; Caldwell and Kamionkowski 2009 ; Weinberg et al. 2013 ). These discoveries highlight the crucial role of distance measurements from diverse cosmic probes in advancing our understanding of the universe, as they provide insights into the nature of roughly 95% of its matter-energy content. Despite the success of the standard flat- \Lambda CDM model in accounting for a wide array of observations, the increasing precision of modern datasets has brought to light several persistent tensions—such as discrepancies in the Hubble constant and the amplitude of structure growth—that challenge the model’s completeness and may point toward new physics beyond the current framework Di Valentino et al. 2025 ; Perivolaropoulos and Skara 2022 ; Vagnozzi 2023 . The luminosity distance function, D_{L}(z) , and the angular diameter distance function, D_{A}(z) , are related by the so-called cosmic distance duality relation (CDDR), given by D_{L}(z)=D_{A}(z)(1+z)^{2} ( Etherington 1933 ; Ellis 2007 ) . This relation holds in all cosmological models based on Riemannian geometry and does not rely on Einstein’s field equations or on the specific properties of the universe’s matter-energy content. For the CDDR to remain valid, three fundamental conditions must be satisfied ( Qin et al. 2021 ; Bassett and Kunz 2004 ) : (i) spacetime must be described by a metric theory of gravity; (ii) photons must travel along null geodesics; and (iii) the number of photons must be conserved. This consistency condition underpins the interpretation of key cosmological probes, including the cosmic microwave background, galaxy clusters, and gravitational lensing. Consequently, any observed deviations from the CDDR could signal the presence of new physics beyond the standard model or point to unaccounted-for systematic effects in the data 1 1 1 For discussions on violations of the CDDR in modified gravity scenarios, see, e.g., Hees et al. 2014 ; Azevedo and Avelino 2021 ; Levi Said et al. 2020 ; Holanda and Barros 2016 ; Holanda et al. 2017 . . In fact, in the context of Type Ia supernova observations, some possible systematics such as the attenuation of photons due to cosmic opacity may arise from dust Kumar et al. 2022 ; Holanda et al. 2018 ; Combes 2004 ; Shafieloo et al. 2013 ; Jesus et al. 2017 ; Li et al. 2013 ; Liao et al. 2013 . On the other hand, several theoretical and observational efforts have been made to investigate possible violations of the CDDR Rasanen et al. 2016 ; Renzi et al. 2022 ; Qi et al. 2025 ; Keil et al. 2025 ; Rana et al. 2016 ; Gahlaut 2025 ; Mukherjee and Mukherjee 2021 ; More et al. 2016 ; Holanda et al. 2010 . These tests are generally categorized into two classes: those that assume a specific cosmological model and those that do not. Model-dependent analyses, often based on the \Lambda CDM framework, can place tighter constraints on deviations of the CDDR, but their conclusions are limited by the assumed cosmological scenario Avgoustidis et al. 2010 ; Bassett and Kunz 2004 ; Holanda et al. 2016 ; Holanda et al. 2011 ; Holanda 2016 . Model-independent methods, by contrast, rely directly on astrophysical measurements without invoking an underlying model, though they tend to yield results with larger statistical uncertainties Holanda et al. 2010 ; Li et al. 2011 ; Holanda et al. 2012a ; Ellis et al. 2013 ; Wu et al. 2015 ; Yang et al. 2019 ; Xu et al. 2020 ; da Silva et al. 2020 . Additionally, most of these analyses are restricted to the redshift interval covered by type Ia supernovae. Although current observations are broadly consistent with the expected relation, expanding these tests to include alternative observables and higher redshifts is crucial. Such efforts can help detect subtle deviations, confirm the robustness of the cosmological framework, or reveal hidden sources of systematic errors. More recently, several non-parametric methods have been employed to test the validity of the CDDR Santos-da-Costa et al. 2015 ; Liu et al. 2021 . In Teixeira et al. 2025 , the authors investigate how potential violations of the distance duality relation could help reconcile the Hubble tension and affect the inferred properties of dark energy from cosmological observations. Similarly, ref. Holanda 2012 examined how violations of the CDDR impact estimates of the Hubble constant, H_{0} . Along the same lines, ref. Afroz and Mukherjee 2025 search for systematics in DESI DR2 and Pantheon+ data by applying a distance duality consistency test to ensure robust inferences about dark energy. These studies highlight the importance of further probing the CDDR, as it offers valuable insights into multiple aspects of observational cosmology. In this work, we use the following observables for the angular diameter distance data: transverse BAO and Galaxy clusters (GC). For the luminosity distance data, we consider standard candles—specifically, type Ia supernovae (SNIa) and quasars (QSO). To incorporate quasar-based D_{L}(z) measurements into the CDDR analysis, we adopt two complementary approaches: (i) we apply a selection criterion based on the dispersion of SNIa D_{L}(z) values relative to the \Lambda CDM model, and (ii) we implement a data binning technique that significantly reduces the intrinsic scatter by compressing a large number of measurements into a smaller set of representative points. As emphasized by Bassett and Kunz 2004 , potential deviations from the CDDR are expected to be more prominent at high redshifts, making the inclusion of QSO in the D_{L}(z) sample particularly crucial. This paper is organized as follows. In Section II , we describe the dataset used to test the CDDR. Section III.1 outlines the binning strategy employed to effectively incorporate QSO measurements. In Section III.2 , we briefly introduce the non-parametric reconstruction

Read the complete text