Social Media Clones: Exploring the Impact of Social Delegation with AI Clones through a Design Workbook Study
Jackie Liu, Mehrnoosh Sadat Shirvani, Hwajung Hong, Ig-Jae Kim, Dongwook Yoon · 2025
Read Social Media Clones: Exploring the Impact of Social Delegation with AI Clones through a Design Workbook Study by Jackie Liu, Mehrnoosh Sadat Shirvani, Hwajung Hong, Ig-Jae Kim, Dongwook Yoon (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07502.txt.
Introduction
Jackie Liu and 4 co-authors ask in 2025 what happens when AI clones post on social media in our place. A social media clone is an AI delegate built from a person's own data that can interact online as them. Clones promise convenience and comfort, but a mismanaged clone could harm its owner's reputation and relationships. The study sets groundwork for responsible design.
Using a design workbook, the team introduced eight speculative clone concepts to 32 social media users in semi-structured interviews. Users liked the convenience yet worried that clones threaten authenticity and breed skepticism in their communities. Notably, users said they would start behaving more like their clones to reduce mismatches and awkward breakdowns. The authors discuss the findings through identity and impression management research and propose design considerations for future clone products.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jackie Liu, Mehrnoosh Sadat Shirvani, Hwajung Hong, Ig-Jae Kim, Dongwook Yoon |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07502
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Social Media Clones: Exploring the Impact of Social Delegation with AI Clones through a Design Workbook Study Jackie Liu, Mehrnoosh Sadat Shirvani, Hwajung Hong, Ig-Jae Kim, Dongwook Yoon Abstract . ABSTRACT Social media clones are AI-powered social delegates of ourselves created using our personal data. As our identities and online personas intertwine, these technologies have the potential to greatly enhance our social media experience. If mismanaged however, these clones may also pose new risks to our social reputation and online relationships. To set the foundation for a productive and responsible integration, we set out to understand how social media clones will impact our online behavior and interactions. We conducted a series of semi-structured interviews introducing eight speculative clone concepts to 32 social media users through a design workbook. Applying existing work in AI-mediated communication in the context of social media, we found that although clones can offer convenience and comfort, they can also threaten the user’s authenticity and increase skepticism within the online community. As a result users tend to behave more like their clones to mitigate discrepancies and interaction breakdowns. These findings are discussed through the lens of past literature in identity and impression management to highlight challenges in the adoption of social media clones by the general public, and propose design considerations for their successful integration into social media platforms. 1. Introduction The idea of leveraging generative AI and personal data to represent one’s self, or AI clones, has become a reality within social media. In May 2023, LinkedIn introduced their new AI-assisted messaging feature ( Srinivasan 2023 ) , enabling recruiters to create personalized reach-out messages to potential candidates with a click of a button. Meta then took it a step further in September that same year by unveiling a series of interactive AIs to their social media platforms ( Meta 2023 ) ; taking on celebrity personas like Tom Brady and Snoop Dogg, these AIs were met with a great deal of curiosity and criticism due to their replication of real life individuals. Meta has decided since then to discontinue this service, instead focusing on AI tools that let users create their own chatbots ( Peters 2024 ) . The early integrations of this technology, though varying in success, underscore the need for a deeper understanding of AI clones and their potential to shape our social media experiences, both positively and negatively. Concerns surrounding clones and the challenges they present to users have been explored by past studies. Lee et al. introduced issues such as doppelgänger-phobia and identity fragmentation ( Lee et al. 2023 ) , demonstrating the clones’ potential to exploit our persona and threaten our self perception. Morris et al. explained how clones can damage the user’s reputation by creating negative perceptions of them, as well as compromise security and privacy through malicious use ( Morris and Brubaker 2024 ) . These studies emphasize the importance of designing responsible clones in order to mitigate their risk to our security, self identity, and personal relationships. The application of AI clones holds particular significance within social media, as the clones by their very nature challenge and reshape our identities—an element at the core of social interactions ( Tajfel 1974 ) . Despite this, social media has seen a surge in both platform- and user-generated clones ( Hawkins 2023 ; Shepherd 2024 ; Tolentino 2023 ; Verma and Oremus 2023 ) , making social media an accessible and direct way for the general public to engage with such technologies. The use of these clones may challenge the delicate balance of user- and AI agency on social media, which requires nuanced negotiation to operate effectively ( Kang and Lou 2022 ) . For many of us, these social platforms have become a valuable source of emotional connection ( Dhar et al. 2023 ; Brandtzæg and Heim 2009 ) , and any issues that arise can significantly impact our social reputations and relationships ( Baccarella et al. 2018 ) . Expanding on previous work to unveil the unique effects clones would have within social media will be crucial for their successful integration. As a result, this study sets out to answer the research question, What are the benefits and risks of AI clones in social media, along with their ramifications on its users? Our exploration of AI clones is framed through the lens of past literature in the following domain: 1) Social Media Practices ( Valkenburg 2017 ) : How will AI clones be adopted into peoples’ online presentations and what are the value and risks they create for user agency, self-identity and impression management? The communication theory of identity describes the multilayered nature of identity ( Hecht and Phillips 2021 ) , and how inter-layer tension can negatively impact communication ( Jung and Hecht 2008 ; Wadsworth et al. 2008 ) . Impression management has also been shown to be a complex process on social media due to the challenges of balancing authenticity with the ideal presentation of oneself ( Marwick and Boyd 2011 ; Zhao et al. 2013 ; Van Dijck 2013 ) . Understanding how users adapt their social media practices to the introduction of clones may provide insight into how we can preserve the agency and identity of social media users. 2) AI-mediated Communication ( Hancock et al. 2020 ) : Within social interactions involving clones, what are factors that determine impression transfer, and their effects on relationship formation and maintenance? Explicit AI-mediated communication has shown both potential for maintaining relationships ( Hohenstein and Jung 2020 ) as well as undermining interpersonal perceptions ( Mieczkowski et al. 2021 ) . The possibility of impression transfer from AI to humans has also been observed ( Li et al. 2023 ) , along with an increase in mistrust, known as the "Replicant Effect," when the use of AI is not disclosed ( Jakesch et al. 2019 ) . These effects may be exacerbated in the case of clones, as personal identity is further manipulated and communication may become entirely with the clone itself. All these factors may have a profound impact on our long term relationship development online, which often values trustfulness and equality ( Emerson 1976 ) . To address the speculative nature of AI clones in the social media context, we developed a design workbook featuring eight distinct concepts of clone use in social media. The design workbook was presented to 32 active social media (i.e., Facebook, X, LinkedIn) users in a series of interviews. Through these interviews, we captured their responses to a range of scenarios involving clones. Results from the study revealed both the value clones can bring to productivity and comfort, the risks they pose to the authenticity of social media, and the consequences of those risks on the Target’s impression and relationships. This study contributes empirical findings on the benefits and risks of clones on our social reputation and relationships, alongside the impact these clones can have on people’s impression management practices and impression transfer mechanisms. Furthermore, it extends relevant theories by empirically demonstrating the nuanced ways impression management, identity negotiation, and relationship dynamics operate when mediated by AI clones in social media. 2. Related Work This work builds on prior