Locality, Micro- vs. Macro-, Particle Interpretations and All That: a Lagrangian Approach to the Measurement Problem

W. David Wick · 2025

Read Locality, Micro- vs. Macro-, Particle Interpretations and All That: a Lagrangian Approach to the Measurement Problem by W. David Wick (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07206.txt.

Introduction

Quantum mechanics predicts outcomes well, yet the measurement problem asks why single definite results appear at all. W. David Wick tackles that puzzle alone in a 2025 research paper. In 2017 he proposed adding terms to Schrödinger's equation, making it nonlinear, as a possible fix. That fix used a trick from Steven Weinberg that resists a local, particle-based reading.

Wick asks which nonlinear theories can come from a Lagrangian field theory, the standard recipe for building physical theories, once some fields are removed. He examines what a local interaction really means. He also asks whether fields split into micro and macro kinds. His conclusion is negative: the 2017 theory cannot be read in particle terms. It also cannot be derived from such a field split. The result narrows where a solution can hide.

Catalog record

CREATORW. David Wick
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07206

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Locality, Micro- vs. Macro-, Particle Interpretations and All That: a Lagrangian Approach to the Measurement Problem W. David Wick Abstract Abstract In 2017, this author proposed, as a resolution of the Measurement Problem, that terms be added to Schrödinger’s wavefunction equation, rendering it nonlinear. Said equation derived from a trick employed by S. Weinberg in 1989 which may be unfamiliar to most physicists, as well as uninterpretable in terms of local (“particle”) interactions. Motivated by A. O. Barut’s work on electrodynamics, here I analyze which kinds of nonlinear theories can be derived from Lagrangian field-theory by integrating out some fields. The issues of “What is a local interaction?” and “Might there be Micro- and Macro-fields?” arise. In the end, I will argue that my 2017 theory cannot be given a “particle” interpretation, nor be derived from a splitting into the two categories of fields. 1 Introduction For my 2017 proposal, [ 1 ] , I adopted an elegant trick (utilized by S. Weinberg in his 1989 study of “Nonlinear Quantum Mechanics”, [ 2 ] ) for deriving an evolution equation from a functional of the wavefunction representing the system energy. 1 1 1 “Expected energy” for Copenhagenists; just “energy” for Schrödingerists. But this approach may be unfamiliar to most physicists, who are used to field theories being derived from an action principle and a Lagrangian. The present work was motivated partially by that concern and also from a comparison I made, see [ 3 ] , of my theory to the work of A. O. Barut and associates in the 1980s and 1990s on the self-consistent, Dirac-Maxwell electrodynamics. Of course, the two programs are very different; Barut was interested in an alternative to the Quantum Electrodynamics of Feynman, Schwinger, Dyson et al . as an explanation of phenomena on the atomic level. By contrast, my 2017 attempted to revise Schrödinger’s 1926 theory at the macro level (of apparatus), without perturbing it by much on the micro level. Nevertheless, I noted that, by “integrating out” some fields, Barut obtained a Lagrangian superficially similar to that in my theory if given a similar construction. So I aimed to find a Lagrangian formulation, and then determine whether it might arise from another—perhaps “local”?—theory with additional fields. Along the way, I encountered some interesting questions. First, what is a “local interaction” in a field theory? Suppose that \psi(x) and \phi(x) are two fields, say complex functions of x\in R^{3} . Suppose they are made to interact. Then by “local interaction” it would seem we mean a term appearing in the Lagrangian containing the product: F(\psi)(x).G(\phi)(x), (1) with both of the functions appearing here “local”, meaning that F(\psi)(x) can be computed from knowledge of \psi in a neighborhood of x , and ditto for G(\phi)(x) and \phi . So, e.g., we might have: F(\psi)(x)=f(\psi(x),\partial\psi/\partial x_{1}(x),...,\partial^{2}\,\psi/\partial x_{1}^{2},..). (2) where f is some multivariable function. Then a term in the Lagrangian of form: \int\,dt\,\int\,dx\,F(\psi)(x).G(\phi)(x), (3) can be intrepreted as a sum of terms in which the two fields interact locally. By contrast, something of form: \int\,dt\,\int\,dx\,\int\,dy\,F(\psi)(x)\,K(x-y)\,G(\phi)(y), (4) would presumably be intrepreted as representing nonlocal interactions between the two fields. However, a term involving only one field of this form: \int\,dt\,\int\,dx\,\int\,dy\,h(\psi)(x)\,K(x-y)\,h(\psi)(y), (5) can arise by “integrating out” another field as we shall see, and so need not imply any nonlocality! Second, what is a ‘‘particle interpretation” of a field theory? The answer would seem to depend on the preferred theory and ideology. Immediately, in 1926, Max Born provided such an interpretation of Schrödinger’s wavefunction: its modulous squared is the probability density for ‘‘finding the particle there”. 2 2 2 Schrödinger never agreed with this interpretation of his wavefunction. After the so-called “second-quantization revolution” in the ’40s, the wavefunction had supposedly been relegated to history, but at the same time so was particle localization, according to Steven Weinberg, [ 4 ] . In Quantum Field Theory (QFT), in which complex (“c-valued”) fields are replaced by Hilbert space operators, a “particle interpretation” seems to require a long-time appearance of free fields that can be interpreted as, say, “The particle is headed North with such-and-such a momentum” superposed with the same, but North replaced by South. But there is also the belief, incorporated by Arthur Wightman in his axioms for QFT, [ 5 ] , in local interactions. 3 3 3 I believe the local interactions are buried in his choice of generating operators of form \Lambda(f) , where \Lambda() can be a generalized function such as Dirac’s delta (or it’s derivative!) and ‘ f ’ denotes a test function. Presumably Wightman believed the Hamiltonians or Lagrangians would be constructed from products of these fields with localized test functions. Perhaps a residual belief that fields, whether complex-valued, multicomponent (as in Dirac’s theory) or operator-valued, are really some peculiar description of particles interacting with each other locally (and thus evading any atavistic appearance of Newton’s action-at-a-distance at a microscopic level) is why assumption ( 1 ) seems a necessity of thought. In this work I will also consider the possibility that some fields might not be sensitive to microscopic variables, but only to macroscopic ones, e.g., to the Center-of-Mass (CoM) of a (large) configuration. Thus we might entertain a multivariable Schrödinger wavefunction: \psi(x_{1},x_{2},...,x_{N}) , together with a field depending only on the CoM, i.e., of form: \phi(X);{\phantom{...}}\hbox{where}{\phantom{...}}X\phantom{..}=\phantom{..}(1/N)\,\sum_{k=1}^{N}\,x_{k}. (6) Call the former a “Micro-field” and the latter a “Macro-field”. (I relegate discussing whether the latter concept means a total abandonment of the ideal of local interactions, violates Bell’s proscriptions, and so on, to the last section.) The main thrust of the analysis in this paper is determining whether, by incorporating but then integrating out, Macro-fields my 2017 theory might be reproduced. Then it should become clear whether that theory is “nonlocal”, whether it could be given a particle interpretation, and so forth. In the following sections I recast my 2017 model to be similar to Barut’s; demonstate how to derive Schrödinger’s equation (and my 2017) from a Lagrangian; introduce Micro- and Macro-fields and solve a one-dimensional model (but not the author’s 2017); put forth a general scheme and ask whether it can generate my 2017; prove a so-called “No-Go” theorem; and draw conclusions in a final Discussion. 2 The 2017 proposal, rewritten and compared to Barut’s “Nonlinear, Nonlocal” electrodynamics The author’s new terms took the following form. Suppose some macroscopic object is describable by coördinates: x_{1},x_{2},...,x_{N} , with each x_{k}\in R^{d} . In this section I will set d=1 to make the exposition simpler to read, and examine the options with d=3 later. Let X be the CoM as defined in the last section. Then the new terms, which might be dubbed “WaveFunction Energy” (WFE), are given by: \hbox{WFE}\phantom{..}=\phantom{..}w\,N^{2}\,S_{N}, (7) where ‘ w ’ is a (presently unknown) positive parameter and S_{N} , the squared dispersion of X , is given by: S_{N}\phantom{..}=\phantom{..}<\psi\,|\,X^{2}\,|\,\psi>-\left[\,<\psi\,|\,X\,|\,\psi>\,\right]^{2}. (8) Note the factor of N^{2} in ( 7 ) which will imply that, in the presence of a “cat”, the WFE is enormous, even if the prefactor is very small (see [ 1 ] , [ 3 ] for more about “cats” and why blocking them resolves the Measurement Problem). There is another way to write down the same

Read the complete text