Market-Driven Equilibria for Distributed Solar Panel Investment

Mehdi Davoudi, Junjie Qin, Xiaojun Lin · 2025

Read Market-Driven Equilibria for Distributed Solar Panel Investment by Mehdi Davoudi, Junjie Qin, Xiaojun Lin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07203.txt.

Introduction

Mehdi Davoudi's 2025 paper, with 2 co-authors, studies long-term investment in rooftop solar panels through the lens of electricity markets. Homeowners and firms invest based on expected revenue over a panel's life. That revenue depends on short-term market prices and allocations, which in turn depend on how much total panel capacity gets installed.

The authors model investors as a non-atomic game, meaning many small players who each barely move the market. They compare three market designs: a plain real-time energy market, one that treats solar and grid power as distinct products, and a contract market that trades rights to future output. The product-based market reaches the social best outcome in their baseline case. The plain market underinvests, while the contract market can overinvest under some user conditions. The framework links daily market rules to long-term building choices.

Catalog record

CREATORMehdi Davoudi, Junjie Qin, Xiaojun Lin
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE95 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07203

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Market-Driven Equilibria for Distributed Solar Panel Investment Mehdi Davoudi, Junjie Qin, Xiaojun Lin Abstract This study investigates market-driven long-term investment decisions in distributed solar panels by individual investors. We consider a setting where investment decisions are driven by expected revenue from participating in short-term electricity markets over the panel’s lifespan. These revenues depend on short-term markets equilibria, i.e., prices and allocations, which are influenced by aggregate invested panel capacity participating in the markets. We model the interactions among investors by a non-atomic game and develop a framework that links short-term markets equilibria to the resulting long-term investment equilibrium. Then, within this framework, we analyze three market mechanisms: (a) a single-product real-time energy market, (b) a product-differentiated real-time energy market that treats solar energy and grid energy as different products , and (c) a contract-based panel market that trades claims/rights to the production of certain panel capacity ex-ante, rather than the realized solar production ex-post . For each, we derive expressions for short-term equilibria and the associated expected revenues, and analytically characterize the corresponding long-term Nash equilibrium aggregate capacity. We compare the solutions of these characterizing equations under different conditions and theoretically establish that the product-differentiated market always supports socially optimal investment, while the single-product market consistently results in under-investment. We also establish that the contract-based market leads to over-investment when the extra valuations of users for solar energy are small. Finally, we validate our theoretical findings through numerical experiments. I Introduction The increasing adoption of renewable energy, particularly solar photovoltaic systems, plays an important role in modern power systems. While utility-scale solar projects contribute significantly to overall capacity, distributed rooftop installations are playing an increasingly prominent role in reshaping the electricity landscape. Notably, as of 2022, approximately 140 GW of solar capacity had been installed in the U.S., with more than 35% of it coming from installations by households and commercial entities [ 1 ] . Unlike centralized projects planned and operated by utilities, distributed solar investments are driven by decisions of individual households and businesses. Several factors influence these decisions. A key factor is the financial return from the investment, driven by the expected revenue earned in short-term distribution-level markets over the panels’ lifespan, where that revenue is determined by the markets’ equilibria. Meanwhile, these short-term equilibria depend on the aggregate invested panel capacity available in the markets, which is shaped by the long-term investment equilibrium that emerges from interactions among individual investors. Therefore, there is a feedback loop between short-term markets equilibria and long-term investment equilibrium, as each influences the other. A precise characterization of this relationship is crucial for understanding the emergence of investment equilibria. This insight is not only important for utilities and independent system operators, who should account for distributed capacity growth in their planning studies, but also for policymakers and market designers aiming to understand the long-term impact of diverse market designs on the solar panel adoption. This motivates us to study the following critical open question: How do short-term market equilibria, arising from diverse solar market mechanisms, shape the corresponding long-term distributed investment equilibrium? I-A Organization and Contributions To address this problem, we consider a large population of individual investors and aim to characterize the long-term investment equilibrium that emerges from the previously described feedback loop. We first develop an investment model, formulated as a non-atomic game, that links long-term investment decisions to expected revenues under a given market design (Section II ). To characterize these revenues, we introduce a unified modeling framework for short-term markets (Section III ). This framework allows us to formally define and compare different market designs by capturing key features such as product differentiation and ex-ante/ex-post trading. We then apply it to three representative mechanisms that differ in these key features (Section IV ): (a) a single-product real-time market, (b) a product-differentiated real-time market, and (c) a contract-based panel market. For each, we first derive analytical characterizations of the short-term market equilibria and then use the investment model to derive the associated long-term equilibrium aggregate capacities (Section V ). Our analysis, initially assuming homogeneous operation periods, is extended to handle heterogeneous operation periods (Section VI ), followed by numerical experiments (Section VII ). We contribute to the literature in the following key ways: (a) The non-atomic game-based investment model encapsulates how individual investors impact each other through their aggregate investment decisions, offering an analytically tractable way to link short-term market equilibria to long-term aggregate investment equilibrium. (b) The proposed unified modeling structure provides closed-form characterizations of short-term market equilibria across diverse mechanism designs, accommodating both ex-ante and ex-post trading as well as heterogeneous consumer preferences. (c) These analytical characterizations enable us to theoretically establish that the single-product real-time market, where solar energy is pooled with conventional grid energy and traded ex-post , leads to under-investment. In contrast, the product-differentiated market, where solar energy is traded ex-post and may be sold at a premium due to heterogeneous user preferences, yields the socially optimal capacity. Finally, the contract-based market, where ex-ante panel capacity is traded instead of realized generation, can result in over-investment when users’ extra valuations for solar are low. I-B Related Literature This work is related to the intersection of two broad lines of literature: distribution-level electricity market mechanisms and long-term investment in solar panels. Most existing studies on the investment side of the literature adopt a centralized perspective, focusing on the optimal strategy of a single decision-maker such as a utility planner or an individual investor (see, e.g., [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] ). However, this line of work neglects the interdependencies of investment decisions in distributed settings, where the actions of one investor can influence the returns of others through shared market mechanisms. On the market side, a variety of distribution-level electricity market designs have been proposed. Understanding how these structures differ is essential for our analysis, as their design features shape the expected revenue of investors. In this context, prior research has proposed a range of market designs, with particular emphasis on real-time pricing and service contract-based approaches. In a broad sense, real-time pricing mechanisms involve the determination of time-varying electricity prices based on the ex-post realized values of supply and demand. In contrast, service contract-based mechanisms typically offer less volatile prices in exchange for a fixed level of electricity service, relying on ex-ante statistics such as those related to random solar generation. Extensive research has explored the relative merits of these retail market designs, examining factors such as economic efficiency [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 ] , price and bill volatility [ 11 , 12 , 13 ] , and environmental impacts [ 14 ] . In addition, some studies have examined another facet of market design: whether electricity from solar and conventional sources should be treated as differentiated products in electricity markets, given their distinct operational characteristics and emissions [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 ] . Despite the contributions of all these reviewed studies, they all focus primarily on short-term performance criteria and overlook the long-term impacts of their designed markets on investment decisions. The most closely related paper to ours is [ 20 ] , which analyzes the

Read the complete text