NLO observables for QCD-like theories and application to pion dark matter

Helena Kolešová, Daniil Krichevskiy, and Suchita Kulkarni · 2025

Read NLO observables for QCD-like theories and application to pion dark matter by Helena Kolešová, Daniil Krichevskiy, and Suchita Kulkarni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07102.txt.

Introduction

Helena Kolešová and 2 co-authors address theories that copy quantum chromodynamics, the force law for quarks, but with different content in a 2025 paper. Such QCD-like theories matter for ideas about composite Higgs particles and for dark matter made of pions. At low energies, scientists describe them with an effective field theory, a simpler model that keeps only the key features.

The authors work out next-to-leading order formulas, meaning the first level of corrections past the simplest case, for masses, decay constants, and scattering. They fit the formulas to lattice computer data for one gauge theory and extract its low-energy constants. The refined formulas then sharpen the case for pion dark matter that interacts strongly with itself. Getting the corrections right changes which versions of that idea can still work.

Catalog record

CREATORHelena Kolešová, Daniil Krichevskiy, and Suchita Kulkarni
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE92 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07102

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

NLO observables for QCD-like theories and application to pion dark matter Helena Kolešová, Daniil Krichevskiy, and Suchita Kulkarni Abstract QCD-like theories are of interest in various areas of beyond-Standard-Model phenomenology, including composite Higgs models or pionic dark matter. The effective field theories provide a framework for describing the dynamics of such strongly coupled gauge theories at low energies. In this work, we present next-to-leading order (NLO) expressions for masses, condensates, decay constants, and scattering amplitudes in the chiral expansion of QCD-like theories with N F = 2 N_{F}=2 fermions with non-degenerate masses in both real and pseudoreal representations of the gauge group. We further apply the NLO formulas to fit existing lattice spectroscopic and scattering data for S ​ p ​ ( N c = 4 ) Sp(N_{c}=4) gauge theory with N F = 2 N_{F}=2 fermions in fundamental representation, extracting the NLO low-energy constants of the theory. Using these fits, we refine the NLO formulas describing the 2 → 2 2\to 2 pion self-interactions and confirm that the NLO contributions play a crucial role in determining the viable parameter space of pion dark matter scenarios like the strongly interacting massive particles (SIMP). 1 Introduction Although the Standard Model (SM) of particle physics is an extremely successful framework, it leaves several fundamental questions unanswered. Among these are the nature of dark matter in our Universe Bertone:2004pz or the so-called hierarchy problem Gildener:1976ai that raises the question of why the Higgs boson mass is much smaller than the Planck scale, despite quantum corrections that tend to drive it higher. One compelling approach to address the latter issue is to postulate that the Higgs is not an elementary particle, but rather a composite state arising from a new strongly interacting sector (see Weinberg:1975gm ; Susskind:1978ms ; Kaplan:1983fs ; Kaplan:1983sm for early works or Cacciapaglia:2020kgq for a recent review). Furthermore, different beyond-Standard-Model (BSM) strongly coupled frameworks may give rise to dark matter candidates 1 1 1 Let us add as a curiosity that a strongly coupled dark matter candidate, the sexaquark, was considered even within SM Farrar:2017eqq , however, its viability region seems to be strongly narrowed down Moore:2024mot . (see Kribs:2016cew ; Cline:2021itd for reviews) or might be even related to cosmological inflation (see, e.g., examples in Aoki:2021skm ; Cacciapaglia:2023kat ). In general, the theoretical description of strongly coupled theories is challenging, often the only possible first-principle treatment is enabled by numerical lattice calculations. An important exception to this rule is the case of low-energy interactions of the (pseudo-)Goldstone bosons appearing in the theory spectrum due to spontaneous breaking of a global symmetry. In SM Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), such particles correspond to pions that arise from the breaking of the approximate SU(2)_{L}\times SU(2)_{R} flavor symmetry transforming independently the two flavors of the left-handed and right-handed light quarks to its vector subgroup SU(2)_{V} by the QCD vacuum. The pattern of the spontaneous symmetry breaking then uniquely determines the shape of the low-energy effective field theory (EFT) describing the pion interactions Callan:1969sn ; Coleman:1969sm ; Scherer:2012xha ; Kogut:2000ek which enables analytic calculations. Also in the context of BSM theories, low-energy interactions of dark pions are often relevant for the phenomenology studies. For example, when treating the pion dark matter freeze out, EFT description is typically sufficient Kribs:2016cew ; Cline:2021itd . While SM QCD is based on the SU(N_{c}=3) gauge group (with N_{c} denoting the number of colors) and quarks in the fundamental representation, BSM strongly coupled theories might be based on other gauge groups or fermion representations. In particular, if dark quarks are in real or pseudoreal representations of the gauge group, the flavor symmetry among N_{F} dark Dirac fermions is enlarged from SU(N_{F})_{L}\times SU(N_{F})_{R} to SU(2N_{F}) . At low energies, this symmetry is spontaneously broken by the emergence of the quark condensate to SO(2N_{F}) or Sp(2N_{F}) in the real or pseudoreal case, respectively. Consequently, the low-energy EFT has to be modified compared to the QCD case where quarks are in a complex representation Kogut:2000ek . Dark quarks in (pseudo)real representations are relevant, e.g., for the minimal setup of the pion-dark-matter candidate usually dubbed “strongly interacting massive particle” (SIMP) Hochberg:2014kqa or for many composite Higgs models Ferretti:2013kya ; Witzel:2019jbe ; Bellazzini:2014yua ; Cacciapaglia:2020kgq . Finally, let us remark that the original motivation to build an EFT for QCD-like theories Kogut:2000ek was related to the fact that for theories with quarks in (pseudo)real representations, the so-called “sign problem” Nagata:2021ugx is absent. Consequently, lattice simulations can be performed also at finite chemical potential (see, e.g., Cotter:2012mb for one of many examples), which is problematic for the case of real-world QCD. In this work, we focus on the low-energy EFT for the case of (pseudo)real quarks mentioned above and we give the expressions for the quark condensates and pion masses, decay constants, and scattering amplitudes including the next-to-leading order (NLO) corrections. Since the EFT expansion parameter is proportional to dark-pion mass, higher-order corrections are important for the BSM scenarios with relatively large pion masses. Indeed, NLO corrections were shown to be crucial, e.g., for the phenomenology of SIMP dark matter Hansen:2015yaa . Moreover, higher-order corrections are necessary for interpolation between the limit of massless quarks that is most relevant for the composite Higgs models and the finite-mass regime where lattice simulations can be performed. Existing literature Bijnens:2009qm ; Bijnens:2011fm covers the EFT for (pseudo)real quarks at NLO and even next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO); we extend the NLO results by assuming non-degenerate quark masses. This is motivated, e.g., for the SIMP-dark-matter scenarios where the viable parameter space might be substantially enlarged if different pion species have different masses Hochberg:2014kqa . Let us note that NLO corrections play an important role for the description of the pion mass splitting, as in some cases leading-order (LO) EFT predicts the pion masses to be degenerate even for split quark masses and the pion mass splitting is captured only by NLO corrections. While we argue that the NLO corrections might be important for a reliable description of the BSM theories, the disadvantage is that new low-energy constants (LECs) need to be introduced at this order of EFT expansion. These constants differ for different gauge groups and fermion representations and their ignorance introduces additional uncertainty in the phenomenology results (see, e.g., the example of the NLO SIMP study Hansen:2015yaa ). In the QCD case, the LEC can be determined from experiments Colangelo:2001df , however, for the BSM theories the determination of these constants relies only on lattice calculations. Since these are computationally expensive, the results for BSM theories started appearing only recently, e.g., part of the LECs for the case of SU(N_{c}=2)\cong Sp(N_{c}=2) gauge theory with N_{F}=2 of quarks in fundamental representation were determined in Ref. Arthur:2016dir . In our work, we make use of the new lattice data presented in Refs. Kulkarni:2022bvh ; Dengler:2024maq and we perform a fit of LEC for another example of a theory with pseudoreal quarks, namely, the Sp(N_{c}=4) gauge theory with N_{F}=2 quarks in fundamental representation. 2 2 2 For our NLO results, we restrict ourselves to the minimal case of N_{F}=2 Dirac flavors that is most relevant, e.g., for dark matter phenomenology Hochberg:2014kqa and where the lattice data for the mass-split case are available Kulkarni:2022bvh . Lattice

Read the complete text