Transient localization from fractionalization: vanishingly small heat conductivity in gapless quantum magnets
Shi Feng, Penghao Zhu, Johannes Knolle, Michael Knap · 2025
Read Transient localization from fractionalization: vanishingly small heat conductivity in gapless quantum magnets by Shi Feng, Penghao Zhu, Johannes Knolle, Michael Knap (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07062.txt.
Introduction
Shi Feng, Penghao Zhu, Johannes Knolle, and Michael Knap explain a puzzle in quantum magnets in a 2025 paper. Some gapless spin liquid candidates, exotic states of matter, show almost no heat flow, though theory says they should carry heat well. The team show that the block can arise from the state itself, with no flaws or dirt in the material.
They study a ladder-shaped model in a magnetic field. In it, each spin splits into two kinds of new particle: heavy visons and light spinons. At mid-range fields, the heavy visons barely move, so they act like frozen disorder that traps the light spinons for a time. That trap chokes heat flow at most test scales. Flow comes back only at ultra-low scales, too low for most lab gear to reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shi Feng, Penghao Zhu, Johannes Knolle, Michael Knap |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07062
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Transient localization from fractionalization: vanishingly small heat conductivity in gapless quantum magnets Shi Feng, Penghao Zhu, Johannes Knolle, Michael Knap Abstract Several candidate materials for gapless quantum spin liquids exhibit a vanishing thermal conductivity, which is at odds with theoretical predictions. Here, we show that a suppressed response can arise due to transient localization from fractionalization, even in the absence of extrinsic defects or disorder. Concretely, we consider a Kitaev ladder model in a uniform magnetic field, whose spin degrees of freedom fractionalize into visons and spinons. For moderate magnetic fields, visons are heavy and act as quasi-static disorder that induce transient localization of light spinons even in the translation-invariant model and at zero temperature, which strongly suppresses the residual conductivity at finite but low frequencies. At ultralow frequencies the conductivity is restored; however, such scales can be extremely hard to reach in experiments. Our results identify transient localization as a signature of fractionalization and provide a framework for interpreting anomalous transport in gapless spin liquid candidates. Introduction.– The description of phases of matter and their response theory is typically formulated in terms of long-wavelength effective theories and provides a unifying framework for understanding emergent phenomena. For systems with fractionalized excitations, these descriptions are typically obtained from parton constructions and associated gauge theories, where the emergent gauge structure is assumed to be translationally invariant Wen 2007 . Within this framework, transport and thermodynamic properties are governed by the long-wavelength dynamics of emergent quasi-particles and gauge fluctuations. Despite the success of this paradigm in capturing key qualitative aspects of many fractionalized phases Savary and Balents 2016 ; Broholm et al. 2020 ; Knolle and Moessner 2019 , challenges arise when theoretical predictions are compared to several experiments. For example, gapless quantum spin liquids (QSL) with emergent Fermi surfaces are predicted to have thermodynamic signatures identical to a metal: a linear-in-temperature specific heat and thermal conductivity Balents 2010 . Several frustrated Mott insulators exhibit such linear specific heat down to the lowest temperatures Dai et al. 2021 ; Yamashita et al. 2011 ; Li et al. 2024 ; Matsuda et al. 2025 . Yet, various compounds, such as candidates of field-stabilized Kitaev QSL: \alpha -RuCl 3 Yu et al. 2018 and Na 2 Co 2 TeO 6 Hong et al. 2024 ; geometrically frustrated spin liquids on the triangular lattice like YbMgGaO 4 Xu et al. 2016 and NaYbSe 2 Li et al. 2024 ; and the organic spin liquid candidates Bourgeois-Hope et al. 2019 ; Ni et al. 2019 , show a concomitant vanishing thermal conductivity at low temperatures, at variance with the theoretical expectation. Therefore, refinements of the long-wavelength effective theories might be required to understand the experimental implications. The coexistence of linear specific heat and seemingly vanishing residual conductivity challenges the presence of gapless quantum spin liquids, and is frequently ascribed to extrinsic defects and disorder. Here, we show that this paradox can arise intrinsically from fractionalization in the absence of extrinsic defects or disorder, and that the very mechanism which produces a finite spinon density at zero energy also suppresses residual conductivity, rendering it a hallmark of fractionalization. Concretely, we demonstrate the idea in a translation-invariant Kitaev model on a ladder geometry in which a moderate uniform magnetic field drives a gapped spinon band insulator into a gapless fractionalized phase with light spinons and heavy visons that mutually interact Kitaev 2006 . The heavy visons imprint a quasi-static coherent randomness on the spinons, thereby localizing them transiently without quenched or extrinsic disorder Schiulaz and Müller 2014 ; De Roeck and Huveneers 2014 ; Papić et al. 2015 ; Yao et al. 2016 ; Darkwah Oppong et al. 2022 . As a consequence, the heat conductivity will be strongly suppressed as frequency is lowered. Asymptotically at ultralow energy scales, the system will become conducting, requiring, however, experimental probes under extreme conditions and the absence of any extrinsic perturbations. The main mechanism for the observed suppressed heat conductivity is therefore the transient localization (TL) of spinons induced by the heavy visons. Figure 1: Model and numerical results for field-induced gapless spectrum and transient localization (TL) from fractionalization. (a) The Kitaev ladder model with local conservation laws F_{a} and F_{b} . (b) Schematic phase diagram of Hamiltonian ( 1 ): increasing the magnetic field h drives a transition from the gapped spin liquid (blue) at h\approx 0.4 , to a gapless regime with TL (purple), and then to the partially polarized phase (gray) at h\approx 0.9 . The blue-to-purple gradient in (b) denotes the increasing vison filling factor \nu . (c,d) Spin spectral function at h=0.04 (c) and h=0.80 (d). (e,f) Energy-density spreading after a local quench applied to the ground state for h=0.04 (e) and h=0.80 (f). The Kitaev ladder.– We start from a Kitaev ladder model of local spin- \frac{1}{2} moments in the presence of a field: \displaystyle H \displaystyle=H_{\rm ladder}-h\sum_{j,l}(X_{j}^{l}+Y_{j}^{l}+Z_{j}^{l}) (1) \displaystyle H_{\rm ladder} \displaystyle=\sum_{j+l\in\rm even}\left(X_{j}^{l}X_{j+1}^{l}+Y_{j-1}^{l}Y_{j}^{l}+Z_{j}^{l}Z_{j}^{l+1}\right). (2) Here, the subscript j is the horizontal index along the ladder, and the superscript l a binary index labeling the lower ( l=0 ) or upper ( l=1 ) leg, see Fig. 1 (a). Similarly to the Kitaev’s honeycomb model, H_{\rm ladder} has extensive local symmetries given by the square faces F_{a}=X^{0}_{0}Y^{1}_{0}X^{0}_{1}Y^{1}_{1} and F_{b}=Y^{0}_{1}X^{1}_{1}Y^{0}_{2}X^{1}_{2} , with F_{a(b)}=1 in the ground state Kitaev 2006 ; Feng et al. 2007 . For h\rightarrow 0 , elementary excitations of H_{\rm ladder} are free Majorana fermions (referred to as spinons) and static Z_{2} fluxes (visons) given by F_{a(b)}=-1 . In contrast to the honeycomb model, the Majorana band in the ground state sector of H_{\rm ladder} is highly gapped, see supplemental materials sup . A non-zero magnetic field breaks the exact local conservation laws. For a small-to-moderate h , the ground-state expectation of F_{a(b)} decreases from 1.0 to \sim 0 Yogendra et al. 2023 ; Feng et al. 2023 ; Wang et al. 2025 , indicating an increasing density of flipped fluxes \nu\sim-\frac{1}{2}(\expectationvalue{F_{a(b)}}-1) at low energy to near half filling, as illustrated by the blue-to-purple gradient in the cartoon phase diagram Fig. 1 (b). The finite flux density \nu under moderate h allows us to put forward a simple approximate description of the ground state as a superposition of quasi-static vison configurations. Since each typical configuration is disordered the fermions are localized Paredes et al. 2005 up to a cut-off timescale set by the weak tunneling between different vison configurations Schiulaz and Müller 2014 ; De Roeck and Huveneers 2014 ; Papić et al. 2015 ; Yao et al. 2016 ; Darkwah Oppong et al. 2022 . We next present numerical evidence using tensor network approaches to support this effective theory. We demonstrate the presence of transient localization (TL) by suppressed energy transport, and the simultaneous presence of fractionalized gapless excitations. Coexistence of vanishing gap and slow dynamics.– Beyond the weak-field limit, the interplay between Majorana fermions and proliferating visons becomes important, leading to a transition into a gapless region under moderate field. This is reflected in the dynamical spin structure factor shown in Fig. 1 (c,d) obtained by the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) Kühner and White 1999 ; Nocera and Alvarez 2016 : while for small but finite field h=0.04 there is an