What is the maximum radius of cold planets?
David Garfinkle, Alberto G. Rojo · 2025
Read What is the maximum radius of cold planets? by David Garfinkle, Alberto G. Rojo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-07048.txt.
Introduction
Why no planet grows much larger than Jupiter is explained with a simple energy argument by David Garfinkle and one co-author in a 2025 planetary science paper. Adding mass to a planet strengthens gravity, and past a point gravity squeezes the planet so hard that its radius shrinks instead of growing. That competition creates a maximum size near Jupiter's. The authors show the effect quantitatively using a variational principle, the same style of argument used to compute the size of the hydrogen atom.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | David Garfinkle, Alberto G. Rojo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 10 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-07048
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What is the maximum radius of cold planets? David Garfinkle, Alberto G. Rojo Abstract Planets have maximum radii close to that of Jupiter. Qualitatively, the reason for this maximum size is that, as one adds mass, the force of gravity becomes sufficiently strong to cause the radius to decrease. We show that this effect can be understood quantitatively using a simple variational principle very similar to that used to compute the size of the hydrogen atom. I Introduction This paper presents a simplified variational approach to explain the upper size limits of cold planets and stars, where by “cold” we mean those without significant energy sources to counteract gravitational compression. Our approach is based on order-of-magnitude estimates and can be used in undergraduate courses. Imagine building a material from atoms. The material grows larger, going from the size of a dust grain to that of a lentil and then to that of a small rock. If we double the number of atoms, the volume also doubles. But each increase in the number of atoms represents an increase in gravitational force, and there comes a critical point where the gravitational force is so great that, if we keep adding atoms, the size starts to decrease instead of increase. We explore the dependence of this maximum size on fundamental gravitational and electrostatic constants. II Variational treatment We consider a planet composed of hydrogen atoms under the effect of gravity and seek to determine its maximum size. The hydrogen atom has a wave function (up to normalization) of \psi_{0}={e^{-r/{a_{0}}}} , where a_{0} is the Bohr radius. The corresponding energy is {E_{0}}=-{e^{2}}/(8\pi\epsilon_{0}{a_{0}}) , which is the lowest eigenvalue of Schrödinger’s equation \mathcal{H}\psi_{0}(r)=E_{i}\psi_{0}(r) , with \mathcal{H} the hydrogen atom Hamiltonian. Note that we use e to denote both the elementary charge and Euler’s number e\simeq 2.718 . While this might seem ambiguous, it follows standard conventions in physics textbooks. The variational principle states that for any trial wave function \psi_{\text{trial}} , the expectation value of the Hamiltonian \langle\mathcal{H}\rangle={\int dv\,\psi^{*}_{\text{trial}}(r)\mathcal{H}\psi_{\text{trial}}(r)\over{\int dv\,\psi^{*}_{\text{trial}}(r)\psi_{\text{trial}}(r)}} (1) provides an upper bound to the true ground state energy E_{0} , that is, E_{0}\leq\langle\mathcal{H}\rangle . By optimizing \psi_{\text{trial}} to minimize \langle\mathcal{H}\rangle , one can obtain the best approximation for E_{0} from the trial function. The Hamiltonian for the hydrogen atom is \mathcal{H}=-{\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m}}{\nabla^{2}}-\frac{e^{2}}{4\pi\epsilon_{0}r}, (2) where \hbar=h/(2\pi) is the reduced Planck constant and m is the reduced mass of the electron. If our trial wave-function is \psi_{\text{trial}}={e^{-r/a}} where a is some number different from a_{0} , then a standard calculation shows that E\equiv\langle\mathcal{H}\rangle={\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m{a^{2}}}}-{\frac{e^{2}}{4\pi\epsilon_{0}a}}. (3) The Bohr radius can be derived from this expression by asking what value of the variational parameter a minimizes the energy E . The result, after setting {\partial E\over\partial a}=0, (4) is exactly a={4\pi\epsilon_{0}\hbar^{2}}/(m{e^{2}})={a_{0}} . We will find that, once the problem of planet size is set up in an analogous way, the calculation of planet size will be remarkably similar to that of the Bohr radius. Our first step is to develop a toy model for hydrogen under extreme pressure. We assume that with N hydrogen atoms in a volume V , the nuclei are distributed in a regular cubic lattice with spacing 2a , and that the total energy is just N times the energy given in Equation ( 3 ). In other words, we treat the atoms as non-interacting, with the only effect of the compression being to change the scale in the wave function. While there is no reason to expect this model to be a rigorous representation of the wave function of this collection of electrons, it can still provide insight into how the energy scales with pressure. Now, the assumption about the lattice spacing means that a={\frac{1}{2}}{{\left({\frac{V}{N}}\right)}^{1/3}}={\frac{1}{2}}{{\left({\frac{V{m_{H}}}{M}}\right)}^{1/3}}, (5) where M=Nm_{H} is the mass of the planet and m_{H} is the mass of a hydrogen atom. Let R be the radius of the planet. Then since V=(4\pi/3){R^{3}} we have R=a{{\left({\frac{6N}{\pi}}\right)}^{1/3}}. (6) For simplicity, we assume that the planet has a uniform density. Then its gravitational potential energy is {E_{\rm grav}}=-{\frac{3}{5}}{\frac{G{M^{2}}}{R}}. (7) We find it useful to express our result in terms of a dimensionless number N_{*} that expresses the relative weakness of gravity compared to electromagnetism, as follows: N_{*}\equiv\left({e^{2}\over 4\pi\epsilon_{0}Gm_{H}^{2}}\right)^{3/2}=\left(1.23\times 10^{36}\right)^{3/2}=1.37\times 10^{54}. (8) In physical terms, N_{*}^{2/3} is the ratio of electric repulsion to gravitational attraction between two protons. The gravitational energy can therefore be written in terms of N_{*} as {E_{\rm grav}}=-{\frac{3}{5}}{\frac{G{(Nm_{H})^{2}}}{a}\left(\pi\over 6N\right)^{1/3}}=-N{\frac{3}{5}}{e^{2}\over a}{{Gm_{H}^{2}\over e^{2}}\left(\pi N^{2}\over 6\right)^{1/3}}=-N{\frac{3}{5}}{e^{2}\over 4\pi\epsilon_{0}a}\left({\pi N^{2}\over 6N_{*}^{2}}\right)^{1/3}. (9) The total energy then takes the form E=N\left[{\frac{\hbar^{2}}{2m{a^{2}}}}-{\frac{{\tilde{e}}^{2}}{4\pi\epsilon_{0}a}}\right], (10) where the quantity {\tilde{e}}^{2} is given by {{\tilde{e}}^{2}}={e^{2}}\left[1+{\frac{3}{5}}{{\left({\frac{\pi{N^{2}}}{6{N_{*}^{2}}}}\right)}^{1/3}}\right]. (11) We can think of \tilde{e} as an N -dependent “modified charge” that takes into account the effects of both electrostatics and gravity. Notice that the dependence on N becomes relevant for large particle number, N\sim N^{*} . The planet will adjust its radius (which is equivalent to adjusting the lattice spacing) so as to have the smallest total energy, so we differentiate Eq. ( 10 ) with respect to a , set the resulting expression to zero, and solve for a ; this gives a={4\pi\epsilon_{0}\frac{\hbar^{2}}{m{{\tilde{e}}^{2}}}}={\frac{a_{0}}{1+\displaystyle{}{\frac{3}{5}}{{\left({\frac{\pi{N^{2}}}{6{N_{*}^{2}}}}\right)}^{1/3}}}}. (12) Hence, the lattice spacing is given by a “modified Bohr radius,” with a charge enhanced according to Equation ( 11 ). Using Eq. ( 6 ), we obtain the radius as R(N)={\frac{{a_{0}}{{\left(\displaystyle{\frac{6N}{\pi}}\right)}^{1/3}}}{1+\displaystyle{\frac{3}{5}}{{\left({\frac{\pi{N^{2}}}{6{N_{*}^{2}}}}\right)}^{1/3}}}}. (13) When N\ll N_{*} we have R\propto N^{1/3} , and volume scales linearly with the number of particles. On the other hand, when N\gg N_{*} we have R\propto N^{-1/3} and the planet size decreases with particle number. The number of atoms that results in the maximum planet size can be found from Eq. ( 13 ) by finding the value of N that maximizes R(N) . We also use the fact that the total mass M is given by M=N{m_{H}} to find M . The results are \displaystyle{R_{\rm max-size}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\sqrt{\frac{5}{2\pi}}}{N_{*}^{1/3}}{a_{0}}, (14) \displaystyle{M_{\rm max-size}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle{\frac{5}{3}}{\sqrt{\frac{10}{\pi}}}{N_{*}}{m_{H}}. (15) Note that N_{*} is independent of \hbar , which means that the mass at which maximum planet size occurs is independent of \hbar . The maximum planet size, on the other hand, depends on \hbar through the dependence of the Bohr radius on \hbar . When we substitute the numbers into eqns. ( 15 ) and ( 14 ), we find \displaystyle{M_{\rm max-size}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 6.86\times{{10}^{27}}\,{\rm kg}=3.45\times 10^{-3}M_{\odot}=3.6M_{J} (16) \displaystyle{R_{\rm max-size}} \displaystyle= \displaystyle 5.2\times{{10}^{7}}\,{\rm m}=0.076\,R_{\odot}=0.75R_{J} (17) Here M_{J}=1.90\times{{10}^{27}}\,{\rm kg} is the mass of Jupiter and R_{J}=7.14\times{{10}^{7}}\,{\rm m} is the radius of Jupiter. More sophisticated calculations yield a maximum planet size of {R_{\rm max-size}}=1.165{R_{J}} with a mass at maximum size of {M_{\rm max-size}}=3.31{M_{J}} for a planet made of hydrogen atoms Zaplosky ; Fortney , and a maximum radius of about 1.2R_{J} and a mass at maximum size of about 3M_{J} for the correct composition of gas giants. Gas giant planets have a chemical composition of 3/4 hydrogen and 1/4 helium (in mass proportions), which is roughly the composition of Jupiter and the Sun. While forming, these planets grew massive enough to accrete all available material along their orbits. For the purposes of our estimation, one of the crude approximations that we are making is a composition of pure hydrogen. So these numbers are surprisingly good for the size and the mass. Conclusions We have developed a simplified variational approach to estimate the