Depth and Associated Primes in Group Cohomology
James A. Schafer · 2025
Read Depth and Associated Primes in Group Cohomology by James A. Schafer (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06895.txt.
Introduction
A conjecture about the depth of a group's cohomology ring is shown to be equivalent to a simpler statement by James A. Schafer in a solo 2025 algebra paper. The Connor Conjecture equates the depth of the cohomology ring with the smallest dimension among its associated primes, a measure of the ring's structure. Schafer proves this equivalence. The conjecture holds exactly when some elementary abelian subgroup has a centralizer whose cohomology has the same depth. That trades a global quantity for a check on a smaller subgroup.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | James A. Schafer |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 22 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06895
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Depth and Associated Primes in Group Cohomology James A. Schafer Abstract Introduction If R is a Noetherian local ring and M is a finitely generated R -module then the depth of M is defined to be the length of a maximal M -sequence in the maximal ideal, \mathfrak{m} , of R . Serre demonstrated that \text{depth}\,M\leq\omega_{M}=\text{ the minimum dimension of an associated prime of }M, that is the minimum dimension of a prime ideal equal to the annihilator of an element of M . This result was easily translated to * -local k -algebras A , i.e., graded k -algebras with a unique homogeneous maximal ideal. There are easy examples of strict inequality. After many calculations of the cohomology rings of finite groups, Carlson [ 4 ] , asked whether the above inequality was true if A=H^{*}(G,k) where G was a finite group and k was a field whose charateristic divided the order of G . Carlson showed it was true if \dim H^{*}(G,k)=2 . Duflot [ 5 ] had shown \text{depth}\,H^{*}(G,k)\geq p -rank of the center of a Sylow p -subgroup of G . A result for p -groups by Green [ 7 ] and later extended by Kuhn [ 9 ] to all finite groups showed that if the Duflot lower bound was an equality the conjecture was true. In [ 12 ] it is shown that if \dim H^{*}(G,k)-\text{depth}\,H^{*}(G,k)\leq 1 the conjecture is true. To my knowledge nothing else is known. It is a fact, [ 10 ] , that \text{depth}\,H^{*}(C_{G}E,k)\geq\text{depth}\,H^{*}(G,k) always. The aim of this paper to show that the Conner Conjecture is equivalent to the following: There exists an elementary abelian p -subgroup of G of rank equal to \omega_{G}=\omega_{H^{*}(G,k)} with \text{depth}\,H^{*}(C_{G}E,k)=\text{depth}\,H^{*}(G,k) . It is also true, ( [ 2 ] , [ 14 ] , [ 15 ] ), that if P is an associated prime of H^{*}(G,k) , then P=\mathfrak{p}_{E}=\ker\{\text{res}:H^{*}(G,k)\to H^{*}(E,k)/\text{rad}\} for some elementary abelian p -subgroup of G . We also show that if \mathfrak{p}_{E}=\text{ann}\,y and \dim\mathfrak{p}_{E}=\omega_{G} then \mathfrak{P}_{E}=\ker\{\text{res}:H^{*}(C_{G}E,k)\to H^{*}(E,k)/\text{rad}\} is an associated prime of H^{*}(C_{G}E,k) of dimension \omega_{G}=\omega_{C_{G}E} and in fact \mathfrak{P}_{E}=\text{rad}(\text{ann}\,(\text{res}\,y)) . Notation and a useful result All rings will be commutative, Nöetherian with identity. If M is a finitely generated R -module, denote the associated primes of M by \text{Ass}\,\,M . \mathcal{A}G will denote the elementary abelian p -subgroups of G and \mathcal{A}G^{s} those of rank s . Unless otherwise stated \text{res}^{G}_{H}:H^{*}(G)\to H^{*}(H) for H\subseteq G will be denoted by \text{res}_{H} . The following useful result is easily extracted from Atiyah-MacDonald, [ 1 ] . Theorem 0.1 . Let f:R\to S be a monomorphism of rings and P\in\text{Ass}\,\,R , then there exists Q\in\text{Ass}\,\,S with f^{-1}Q=P . Proof. Let (0)=\bigcap Q_{i} be a minimal primary decomposition of (0)\subseteq S with primes P_{i}=\text{rad}\,Q_{i} . Then \text{Ass}\,\,S=\{P_{i}\} . Since the contraction of a prmary ideal is primary and the contraction of the radical of an ideal is the radical of the contraction, (0)=f^{-1}(0)=\bigcap f^{-1}Q_{i} is a primary decompositon of (0)\subseteq R with primes \{f^{-1}P_{i}\} . Since any primary decompostion of an ideal can be refined to a minimal primary decomposition, \text{Ass}\,\,R\subseteq\{f^{-1}P_{i}\} . ∎ Remark 1 . This does not mean that if P\in\text{Ass}\,\,S then f^{-1}P\in\text{Ass}\,\,R and in fact is false. Special facts for H^{*}(G,k) From this point on G will be a finite group, k a field with trivial G -action and p=\text{char}\,k dividing the order of G . Denote H^{*}(G,k) by H^{*}(G) . The following result may be found in [ 6 ] , corollaries 7.4.6 and 7.4.7. Theorem 0.2 . (1) H^{*}(G) is a finitely generated k -algebra, which is the same as saying H^{*}(G) is Nöetherian. (2) If H\subseteq G is a subgroup then H^{*}(H) is finitely generated as a module over H^{*}(G) via the restriction map \text{res}:H^{*}(G)\to H^{*}(H) What properties does H^{*}(G) have concerning depth and associated primes have that an arbitrary finitely generated graded k -algebra may not. Theorem 0.3 . Let N\subseteq G with [G:N] relatively prime to p . If \{x_{i}\}\subseteq H^{*}(G) is a finite set of homogeneous elements and \{\text{res}_{N}\,x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(N) then \{x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(G) . Proof. In [ 8 ] it is shown that for a non-negatively graded finitely generated k -algebra R , \{x_{i}\}\subseteq R^{+} is a regular sequence if and only k[x_{1},\dots,x_{n}] is a polynomial subring of R and R is free over k[x_{1},\dots,x_{n}] . If \{\text{res}_{N}\,x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(N) , then k[\text{res}_{N}\,x_{1},\dots,\text{res}_{N}x_{n}] is a polynomial algebra and H^{*}(N) is free over k[\text{res}_{N}x_{1},\dots,\text{res}_{N}x_{n}] . Hence H^{*}(N) is free over k[x_{1},\dots,x_{n}]\subseteq H^{*}(G) . H^{*}(G)\subseteq H^{*}(N) is a H^{*}(G) -summand of H^{*}(N) therefore projective hence a free k[x_{1},\dots,x_{n}] -module and \{x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(G) .∎ Theorem 0.4 . (Duflot, [ 5 ] ) Let C\subseteq G be a central subgroup. If \{x_{i}\}\subseteq H^{*}(G) is a finite set of homogeneous elements and \{\text{res}_{C}\,x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(C) then \{x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(G) . Corollary 0.5 . Let C\subseteq Z(P)\subseteq P\subseteq G where P is a Sylow p -subgroup of G . If \{x_{i}\}\subseteq H^{*}(G) is a finite set of homogeneous elements and \{\text{res}_{C}\,x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(C) then \{x_{i}\} is a regular sequence in H^{*}(G) . Corollary 0.6 . \text{depth}\,H^{*}(G)\geq p -rank of the center of a Sylow p -subgroup. Definition 0.7 . If H\subseteq G and E\in\mathcal{A}H , let \mathfrak{p}_{E}^{H}=\ker\{\pi\,\text{res}:H^{*}(H)\to H^{*}(E)\to H^{*}(E)/\text{Rad}\}. If H=G denote \mathfrak{p}_{E}^{G} by \mathfrak{p}_{E} Theorem 0.8 . (Serre, [ 14 ] ,Wilkerson, [ 15 ] ) If P is an associated prime of H^{*}(G) then P=\mathfrak{p}_{E} for some E\in\mathcal{A}G . Theorem 0.9 . (Quillen, [ 11 ] ) \mathfrak{p}_{E}\subseteq\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} iff E^{\prime} is conjugate to a subgroup of E . Hence since minimal primes are associated primes, minimal primes in H^{*}(G) correspond to conjugacy classes of maximal p -elementary abelian subgroups of G . Corollary 0.10 . Let E be elementary p -abelian. Then there exists \tau_{E}\in\mathfrak{p}_{E} such that \tau_{E}\notin\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} for any elemenary abelian E^{\prime} not conjugate to a subgroup of E . Proof. Let W=\{E^{\prime}\in\mathcal{A}(G)\,|\,E^{\prime}\,\text{not conjugate to a subgroup of}\,E\} . Then \mathfrak{p}_{E}\not\subseteq\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} for any E^{\prime}\in W . By Prime Avoidence \mathfrak{p}_{E}\not\subseteq\bigcup_{W}\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} . Therefore there exists \tau_{E}\in\mathfrak{p}_{E} such that \tau_{E}\notin\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} for any E^{\prime}\in W . ∎ Proposition 0.11 . Let E_{0} be the maximal p -elementary abelian subgroup of the center of P where P is a Sylow p -subgroup of G . Then if \mathfrak{p}_{E}\in\text{Ass}\,H^{*}(G) , E_{0}\subseteq E . Proof. Since \text{res}:H^{*}(G)\to H^{*}(P) is a H^{*}(G) monomorphism, by 0.1 , \mathcal{A}ssH^{*}(G)\subseteq\{\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E}\cap H^{*}(G)\,|\,\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E}\in\text{Ass}\,H^{*}(P)\}. Hence if \mathfrak{p}_{E}\in\text{Ass}\,(G) there exists E^{\prime}\in\mathcal{A}(P) with \mathfrak{p}_{E}=\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E^{\prime}}\cap H^{*}(G)=\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}},\text{ and }\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E^{\prime}}\subseteq\text{Ass}\,\,H^{*}(P). Since \mathfrak{p}_{E}=\mathfrak{p}_{E^{\prime}} they are conjugate by Quillen, 0.9 . That is we may always assume that up to conjugation if \mathfrak{p}_{E}\subseteq\text{Ass}\,\,H^{*}(G) , \mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E}\in\text{Ass}\,H^{*}(P) . Let x\in Z(P) be an central element of order p of P and suppose x\notin E . Then E^{\prime}=(x) is not conjugate in P to a subgroup of E and so there exists \tau\in\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E}\subseteq H^{*}(P) with \tau\notin\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E^{\prime}} . Since \mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E^{\prime}}=\ker\{H^{*}(P)\to H^{*}(E^{\prime})/\text{Rad}\} , \text{res}^{P}_{E^{\prime}}(\tau)\in H^{*}(E^{\prime}) is not nilpotent and therefore a non-zero divisor since H^{*}(E^{\prime})=P[\beta\,\mathbb{u}]\otimes\Lambda[\mathbb{u}] . By Duflot’s Theorem, 0.4 , \tau\in H^{*}(P) is a non zero-divisor. But \tau\in\mathfrak{p}^{P}_{E}=\text{ann}_{H^{*}(P)}(y) for some 0\neq y\in H^{*}(P) . Thus \tau\,y=0 and this is