Characterization of low-nitrogen quantum diamond for pulsed magnetometry applications

Jiashen Tang, Connor A. Roncaioli, Andrew M. Edmonds, Atli Davidsson, Connor A. Hart, Matthew L. Markham, Ronald L. Walsworth · 2025

Read Characterization of low-nitrogen quantum diamond for pulsed magnetometry applications by Jiashen Tang, Connor A. Roncaioli, Andrew M. Edmonds, Atli Davidsson, Connor A. Hart, Matthew L. Markham, Ronald L. Walsworth (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06884.txt.

Introduction

Diamond sensors with very little nitrogen are described for delicate magnetic measurements by Jiashen Tang and six co-authors in a 2025 quantum sensing paper. Nitrogen-vacancy centers in diamond are flexible sensors, and the amount of plain nitrogen nearby sets their coherence and sensitivity. Low-nitrogen stock should suit pulsed magnetometry, which gains from longer coherence.

The team grew diamond by chemical vapor deposition with low strain, purified its carbon isotopes, and used controlled irradiation and annealing to make the sensing centers. The new stock, under one part per million of the relevant nitrogen, showed even strain and dephasing limited by the spin bath. Across a wide range of light levels, its shot-noise-limited sensitivity beat a previously studied higher-nitrogen diamond at moderate and low excitation. Hands-on guidance for choosing sensor stock follows.

Catalog record

CREATORJiashen Tang, Connor A. Roncaioli, Andrew M. Edmonds, Atli Davidsson, Connor A. Hart, Matthew L. Markham, Ronald L. Walsworth
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE47 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06884

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Characterization of low-nitrogen quantum diamond for pulsed magnetometry applications Jiashen Tang, Connor A. Roncaioli, Andrew M. Edmonds, Atli Davidsson, Connor A. Hart, Matthew L. Markham, Ronald L. Walsworth Abstract Ensembles of nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond are versatile quantum sensors with broad applications in the physical and life sciences. The concentration of neutral substitutional nitrogen ([N 0 s {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ]) strongly influences coherence times, sensitivity, and optimal sensing strategies. Diamonds with [N 0 s {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] ∼ \sim 1-10 ppm are a focus of recent material engineering efforts, with higher concentrations being favorable for continuous-wave optically detected magnetic resonance (CW-ODMR) and lower concentrations expected to benefit pulsed magnetometry techniques through extended NV electronic spin coherence times and improved sensing duty cycles. In this work, we synthesize and characterize low-[N 0 s {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] ( ∼ \sim 0.8 ppm), NV-enriched diamond material, engineered through low-strain chemical vapor deposition (CVD) growth on high-quality substrates, 12 C isotopic purification, and controlled electron irradiation and annealing. Our results demonstrate good strain homogeneity in diamonds grown on CVD substrates and spin-bath-limited NV dephasing times. By measuring NV spin and charge properties across a wide range of optical NV excitation intensity, we provide direct comparisons of photon-shot-noise-limited magnetic sensitivity between the current low-[ N s 0 \text{N}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] and previously studied higher-[ N s 0 \text{N}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] ( ∼ \sim 14 ppm) NV-diamond sensors. We show that low-[N 0 s {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] diamond can outperform higher-[N 0 s {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] diamond at moderate and low optical NV excitation intensity. Our results provide practical benchmarks and guidance for selecting NV-diamond sensors tailored to specific experimental constraints and sensing requirements. 1 Introduction Nitrogen-vacancy (NV) centers in diamond are a leading quantum sensing platform due to favorable optical and electronic spin properties ( Barry et al. 2020 ) , with wide-ranging applications, including in condensed matter physics ( Ku et al. 2020 ; Zhang et al. 2021 ; Rovny et al. 2024 ) , electronics systems ( Turner et al. 2020 ; Garsi et al. 2024 ) , geoscience ( Glenn et al. 2017 ; Fu et al. 2023 ) , and life science ( Barry et al. 2016 ; Aslam et al. 2023 ; Schirhagl et al. 2014 ) . Extensive research has focused on magnetic sensing and imaging using ensembles of NV centers. However, experimentally realized sensitivities remain several orders of magnitude below the fundamental spin-projection limit ( Hart et al. 2021 ; Barry et al. 2024 ) . A recent review ( Barry et al. 2020 ) highlights strategies for further improving sensitivity, including extending spin coherence times through advanced pulse sequences and targeted material engineering. A key material engineering parameter affecting NV ensemble magnetic sensing performance is the concentration of neutral substitutional nitrogen ([N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ]), which strongly influences NV formation, charge stability, and spin coherence properties. Diamonds with higher [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] provide increased NV center density and improved NV - charge stability due to electron-donating nitrogen. However, higher [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] also creates a dense paramagnetic spin bath, significantly limiting NV spin coherence times. Conversely, lower [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] materials offer improved coherence at the expense of NV density and charge stability. Previous studies identified an optimal [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] range around 1–10 ppm for balancing these competing factors ( Bauch et al. 2018 ; Edmonds et al. 2021 ) . In prior work ( Edmonds et al. 2021 ) , we synthesized chemical vapor deposition (CVD) diamonds with relatively high [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] (nominally 14 ppm), demonstrating a favorable balance between NV density and Ramsey dephasing time T_{2}^{*} for broadband DC magnetic sensing. Shorter T_{2}^{*} also reduces the demand on bias magnetic field homogeneity. However, sensitivity assessments using simplified metrics like \tilde{\eta}=(\text{[N}_{\text{s}}^{0}\text{]}\times T_{2}^{*})^{-1/2} inadequately capture experimental overheads from NV spin initialization and readout. Such overheads particularly impact pulsed magnetometry protocols, which are advantageous for high-sensitivity measurements due to their separation of microwave and optical broadening effects inherent in continuous-wave optically detected magnetic resonance (CW-ODMR) methods ( Barry et al. 2020 ) . Accounting for these overheads shifts the sensitivity optimum toward lower [N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] diamonds (Fig. 1 ), where longer coherence improves sensing duty cycles. Realizing these sensing advantages with low-nitrogen diamond materials necessitates careful control of other material parameters. These include 12 C isotopic purification to minimize 13 C nuclear spin noise, optimization of growth conditions to reduce strain and other unwanted defect densities, and controlled irradiation and annealing processes to achieve high N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} -to-NV conversion while preserving the NV - charge fraction despite lower donor concentrations. In this work, we report the synthesis and characterization of low-[N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] ( \sim 0.8 ppm) diamond material for pulsed NV ensemble magnetometry. Focusing on Ramsey-based DC magnetic field sensing, we show that combining low-strain CVD growth, 12 C isotopic purification, and controlled electron irradiation and annealing yields NV-enriched diamond materials with spin-bath-limited dephasing times. We directly compare photon-shot-noise-limited sensitivity between an example low-[N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] sample and a previously studied high-[N {}_{\text{s}}^{0} ] diamond Edmonds et al. 2021 , by characterizing NV spin and charge properties across a range of laser intensities used for optical NV excitation (i.e., NV spin initialization and readout). The low-nitrogen sample demonstrates improved sensitivity, particularly at moderate and low optical powers. This study provides practical benchmarks and guidance for selecting NV diamond sensors across diverse magnetometry applications, considering experimental constraints and sensing requirements, and also informs future diamond material engineering efforts. Figure 1: (a) NV ensemble DC magnetic field sensitivity estimated using the simplified metric \smash{1/\tilde{\eta}=\sqrt{[\mathrm{N}_{\mathrm{s}}^{0}]\times T_{2}^{*}}} , assuming spin-bath-limited T_{2}^{*} and 99.995% isotopic enrichment of {}^{12}\mathrm{C} . Corrections accounting for experimental overhead time ( t_{O} ) are included by multiplying with \smash{1/\sqrt{(T_{2}^{*}+t_{O})/T_{2}^{*}}} (cf. Eq. 1 ). With zero overhead (blue line), sensitivity plateaus for \smash{[\mathrm{N}_{\mathrm{s}}^{0}]\gtrsim 1\,\text{ppm}} . However, incorporating an overhead of 10\mu\,\text{s} , typical in pulsed Ramsey protocols, shifts the optimal \smash{[\mathrm{N}_{\mathrm{s}}^{0}]} towards lower values (red line). A preliminary comparison between the current low- \smash{[\mathrm{N}_{\mathrm{s}}^{0}]} samples ( \sim 0.8\,\text{ppm} ) and a previously characterized high- \smash{[\mathrm{N}_{\mathrm{s}}^{0}]} sample ( \sim 14\,\text{ppm}\smash{} suggests a nearly threefold sensitivity improvement. (b) Estimated optimal nitrogen concentration, and sensitivity improvement between 0.8\,\text{ppm}\smash{} and 14\,\text{ppm}\smash{} samples as functions of overhead time ( t_{O} ). (c) Schematics comparing NV magnetometry protocols based on continuous-wave optically detected magnetic resonance (CW-ODMR) and pulsed Ramsey. CW-ODMR has nominally zero overhead but suffers from intrinsic competition between simultaneous microwave (MW) and optical NV excitation. Pulsed Ramsey avoids these competing effects but incurs non-negligible overhead from NV initialization and readout. 2 Material and Experimental Methods 2.1 Parameters Relevant to Sensitivity The photon shot-noise-limited magnetic sensitivity of an NV ensemble Ramsey-based DC magnetometry protocol is given by: \eta_{Ramsey}^{photon-shot}=\frac{1}{\Delta m_{s}\gamma_{e}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{N\tau}}\frac{1}{e^{-(\tau/T_{2}^{*})^{p}}}\sqrt{1+\frac{1}{C^{2}n_{nvg}}}\sqrt{\frac{\tau+t_{O}}{\tau}}, (1) where \Delta m_{s} denotes the spin-state transition (1 for single-quantum and 2 for double-quantum transitions ( Mamin et al. 2014 ) ), \gamma_{e} is the electron gyromagnetic ratio, N is the total number of NV - contributing to the measurement, \tau is the spin free-precession time during sensing, T_{2}^{*} and p characterize the NV spin dephasing time and Ramsey decay envelope shape, C is the NV spin-state-dependent photoluminescence (PL) measurement contrast, n_{avg} is the average PL photon number detected per NV - per measurement, and t_{O} is

Read the complete text