Error signals for overcoming the laser power limits of gravitational-wave detectors Publication type: Paper
Liu Tao 1 \orcid 0000-0003-4382-5507, Pooyan Goodarzi 1 \orcid 0009-0008-1093-6706 and Jonathan W. Richardson 1,∗ \orcid 0000-0002-1472-4806 · 2025
Read Error signals for overcoming the laser power limits of gravitational-wave detectors Publication type: Paper by Liu Tao 1 \orcid 0000-0003-4382-5507, Pooyan Goodarzi 1 \orcid 0009-0008-1093-6706 and Jonathan W. Richardson 1,∗ \orcid 0000-0002-1472-4806 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06840.txt.
Introduction
Heat damage to mirrors limits gravitational-wave detectors, and Liu Tao and two co-authors propose watching the mirrors' temperature to fix it in a 2025 instrumentation paper. At megawatt laser power, thermal distortions blur the test masses. New edge-heating correction techniques could cut the quantum noise floor tenfold in future detectors, but each actuator needs a precise error signal, which LIGO lacks today.
Thermal imaging of each mirror's surface supplies the missing signal. Temperature profiles map uniquely onto a finite-element model of the mirror, letting operators reconstruct the full thermal state and the wavefront error across the whole aperture in real time. The authors estimate a sizable sensitivity improvement for LIGO A+, extending the reach for neutron star mergers. The technique is also planned as integral to the forty-kilometer Cosmic Explorer observatory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Liu Tao 1 \orcid 0000-0003-4382-5507, Pooyan Goodarzi 1 \orcid 0009-0008-1093-6706 and Jonathan W. Richardson 1,∗ \orcid 0000-0002-1472-4806 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 28 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06840
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Error signals for overcoming the laser power limits of gravitational-wave detectors Publication type: Paper Liu Tao 1 \orcid 0000-0003-4382-5507, Pooyan Goodarzi 1 \orcid 0009-0008-1093-6706 and Jonathan W. Richardson 1,∗ \orcid 0000-0002-1472-4806 Abstract A major barrier to improving the quantum-limited sensitivity of gravitational-wave observatories is the thermal distortions of the test masses which arise at megawatt laser power. Recent advances in a new form of higher-order wavefront correction, in which corrective heating profiles are applied to the test mass surfaces near their edges, together with other planned instrumental upgrades, have the potential to enable a tenfold reduction of the quantum noise floor of future detectors. However, realizing high levels of quantum noise reduction in practice hinges on identifying measurable error signals to finely control each wavefront actuator, in order to suppress wavefront errors to a few-nanometer precision across the full mirror apertures. No direct source of such an error signal exists in LIGO today. We demonstrate that thermally imaging the surface of each test mass can provide these critical error signals. We show that the surface temperature profiles obtained from thermal imaging can be uniquely mapped to a finite element model of the mirror whose complete thermal state is identified, enabling full-aperture wavefront reconstruction and direct error signals for real-time precision wavefront control. This new sensing capability can enable up to a 34% strain sensitivity improvement in LIGO A+ at 95% confidence, increasing the sky-averaged detection range for binary neutron star mergers by 11 Mpc, and will be integral to a next-generation 40-km gravitational-wave observatory in the U.S., Cosmic Explorer. keywords gravitational-wave detection, thermal compensation, adaptive optics 1 Introduction Since the first detection of gravitational waves from two coalescing black holes in 2015 [ 1 ] , the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO) and the European Virgo observatory have opened a new means of observing the Universe, launching an era of multi-messenger astronomy. A wide variety of merger events involving black holes and neutron stars have now been observed [ 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 ] . The path to opening a much broader range of observational science, from precision cosmology [ 6 , 7 ] to direct tests of strong-field general relativity [ 8 , 9 , 10 ] and dense nuclear matter [ 11 ] , now lies in reducing the instrumental noise floor of gravitational-wave detectors. LIGO plans to incorporate technical improvements in two major upgrades of the 4-km detectors, LIGO A+ [ 12 ] followed by LIGO \rm A^{\#} [ 13 , 14 ] . The A+ upgrades are aimed primarily at reducing thermal noise through improved optical coatings. The \rm A^{\#} upgrades will include larger 100-kg test masses, new improved suspensions, and significantly higher levels of circulating laser power and quantum squeezing [ 15 , 16 ] . Together, these upgrades will demonstrate the key technology for a next-generation 40-km gravitational-wave observatory in the U.S., Cosmic Explorer [ 17 ] . With 320-kg test masses and a tenfold longer arm length, Cosmic Explorer will push the gravitational-wave detection horizon to near the edge of the observable Universe, detecting hundreds of thousands to millions of compact binary merger events per year. Quantum noise, arising from the quantum nature of the laser field [ 18 , 19 ] , is the limiting source of instrumental noise across most of the frequency band accessible to ground-based gravitational-wave detectors. Amplitude-quadrature fluctuations of the laser field displace the test masses through radiation pressure, introducing significant noise at low frequencies (below 20 Hz). Phase-quadrature fluctuations of the laser field also manifest as shot noise in the detector’s phase-sensitive readout signal. Photon shot noise limits LIGO’s strain sensitivity at all frequencies above 200 Hz. In order to reach their strain sensitivity targets, the LIGO \rm A^{\#} and Cosmic Explorer detectors must achieve significantly greater levels of quantum noise reduction, requiring an unprecedented 1.5 MW of circulating laser power in their arm cavities and 10 dB of frequency-dependent squeezing [ 13 , 17 ] . The achievable arm power and squeezing are limited, in practice, by thermal distortions of the test masses [ 20 ] . In recent work [ 21 ] , we reported the potential of a new class wavefront actuator, known as the FROnt Surface Type Irradiator (FROSTI), to enable next-generation quantum noise targets when used to augment LIGO’s existing thermal compensation capabilities [ 22 ] . However, realizing the potential sensitivity improvements of Ref. [ 21 ] relies on there also existing error signals to precisely identify the optimal power settings of the wavefront actuators, so as to minimize root mean square (RMS) wavefront errors across the full aperture of the mirrors. No direct error signals containing full-aperture wavefront information exist in LIGO today. LIGO’s existing Hartmann wavefront sensors [ 22 ] , for example, are fundamentally limited in their field of view by the size of the probe beam. For optical systems with large optics, such as gravitational-wave detectors, this restriction constrains the field of view to only the central region of the optics. Similarly, Virgo employs phase cameras as wavefront sensors to measure the spatial structure of the laser fields, but these systems also suffer from a limited field of view due to the limited beam size [ 23 ] . In this paper, we present a novel sensing technique that can provide these critical error signals using thermal imaging cameras for optics in a thermal steady state. This condition will be ensured in future LIGO operation, as the LIGO A+ upgrades include an offline 10.6- \mu\rm m laser heating system for each input test mass (ITM), known as the Central HEater for Transient Attenuation (CHETA) [ 24 ] , designed to maintain the thermal steady state of the optic when the main laser beam is not present due to lock loss. Furthermore, our sensing technique can be used to match the size and location of the CHETA beam to the interferometer’s main laser beam, as the algorithm runs on millisecond timescales, which is much faster than the typical thermal transient timescale of minutes to hours. We describe this sensing technique in § 2 and demonstrate its feasibility in § 3 , assuming realistic sensor resolution limits. We then show in § 4 that the improved capability provided by this technique to infer, and thus to more finely correct, thermally-driven wavefront errors in gravitational-wave detectors will significantly improve their quantum-limited strain sensitivity, which we find can be improved up to 34% in LIGO A+. Finally, we discuss the enabling impact of this work on future gravitational-wave detectors, beyond A+, in § 5 . 2 Thermal State Inference We aim to uniquely and accurately infer the full thermal state of each test mass directly from the temperature profile of its front (reflective-coated) surface. This surface temperature map is measured in situ using a thermal imaging camera, located outside the vacuum system, and matched to a finite element analysis (FEA) thermal model of the test mass. The calibrated FEA model of the test mass can then be used to produce mirror phase maps representing the thermally induced wavefront errors arising from both thermoelastic surface deformation and thermorefractive substrate lensing, as uniquely determined by its thermal state. As illustrated