Criterion for the Existence of the G ( 3900 ) G(3900) Resonance
Yin Huang 1,2, Xurong Chen 2,3,4,5 · 2025
Read Criterion for the Existence of the G ( 3900 ) G(3900) Resonance by Yin Huang 1,2, Xurong Chen 2,3,4,5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06353.txt.
Introduction
A disputed bump in particle data is a real resonance, argue Yin Huang and Xurong Chen in a 2025 paper on the G(3900). Evidence for this charmed structure near thirty-nine hundred megaelectronvolts appeared eighteen years ago in electron-positron collisions making D meson pairs, but interference effects and a nearby threshold could fake it. A larger BESIII sample in 2024 confirmed the structure without settling its nature.
The authors show that plotting the cross section against the D meson's transverse momentum reveals a prominent Jacobian peak. Interference alone cannot manufacture that feature, so it directly evidences a genuine state, and the peak's position pins the mass precisely. The criterion extends to other hadronic systems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yin Huang 1,2, Xurong Chen 2,3,4,5 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 24 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06353
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Criterion for the Existence of the G ( 3900 ) G(3900) Resonance Yin Huang 1,2, Xurong Chen 2,3,4,5 Abstract About 18 years ago, the BABAR and the Belle Collaborations reported evidence for a new c c ¯ c\bar{c} structure near 3900 MeV 3900~\mathrm{MeV} in e + e − → D D ¯ e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} , triggering debate over whether it represents a genuine hadronic state or arises from interference effects and the opening of the D ∗ D ¯ D^{*}\bar{D} threshold. The issue remained unsettled until 2024, when BESIII, with an enlarged e + e − → D D ¯ e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} sample, confirmed the presence of the G ( 3900 ) G(3900) structure, reviving discussion of its nature. Although it has been proposed as a P P -wave D D ¯ ∗ D\bar{D}^{*} molecular state, no consensus has emerged, and interference effects remain a plausible explanation. In this Letter, we show that analyzing the e + e − → D D ¯ e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} cross section as a function of the transverse momentum of the final-state D D meson reveals a prominent Jacobian peak. This feature cannot be generated by interference effects alone and thus provides direct evidence for the existence of G ( 3900 ) G(3900) . Moreover, the peak position is highly sensitive to the actual mass of G ( 3900 ) G(3900) , offering a precise determination method. Our results further disfavor the interpretation of G ( 3900 ) G(3900) as a D D ¯ ∗ D\bar{D}^{*} molecular state, pointing instead to alternative internal structures. The criterion illustrated by G ( 3900 ) G(3900) can be extended to other hadronic systems, offering a powerful tool to identify genuine resonances. Introduction –With the advancement of experimental techniques, an increasing number of new hadronic states have been observed ParticleDataGroup:2024cfk . Recently, the BESIII Collaboration reported the observation of a novel hadronic structure, G(3900) , through the analysis of the process e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} BESIII:2024ths . The measured parameters of this resonance are M_{G(3900)}=3872.5\pm 14.2\pm 3.0\ \mathrm{MeV} and \Gamma_{G(3900)}=179.7\pm 14.1\pm 7.0\ \mathrm{MeV} , placing it remarkably close in mass to the well-known X(3872) resonance, first discovered by the Belle Collaboration in 2003 Belle:2003nnu ; Brambilla:2019esw ; Chen:2022asf ; Meng:2022ozq . This discovery has attracted considerable attention and sparked further theoretical investigations. Due to its mass (central experimental value) being very close to the D\bar{D}^{*}/\bar{D}D^{*} threshold, some studies interpret it as a newly observed D\bar{D}^{*}/\bar{D}D^{*} molecular state. For instance, the analysis presented in Ref. Lin:2024qcq interprets the structure as a prospective P -wave \bar{D}D^{*}/D\bar{D}^{*} molecule, based on solutions to complex-scaled Schrödinger equations incorporating one-boson exchange potentials. Additional theoretical support comes from Ref. Ye:2025ywy , where the authors construct an effective P -wave contact interaction between the (D,D^{*}) doublet and its antiparticle under the heavy quark symmetry framework. By solving the Lippmann–Schwinger equation, they demonstrate the emergence of a dynamically generated pole near the observed G(3900) position, independent of whether two or three charmonium-like states are introduced into the coupled-channel formalism. Interestingly, early enhancements in the same mass region were reported by both the BABAR BaBar:2006qlj and the Belle Belle:2007qxm collaborations. At the time, these features were generally attributed not to new hadronic states but to threshold effects associated with the opening of the D\bar{D}^{*}+D^{*}\bar{D} channels, as well as the nodal structure of the \psi(3S) radial wave function Eichten:1979ms . Subsequent analyses of existing data BaBar:2006qlj ; Belle:2007qxm by Refs. Uglov:2016orr ; Nakamura:2023obk ; Du:2016qcr demonstrated that the observed line shape in e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} cannot be satisfactorily described without explicitly including the contribution from G(3900) , lending support to its interpretation as a distinct hadronic structure. Nevertheless, some studies contend that these data alone are insufficient to conclusively establish G(3900) as a genuine resonance Zhang:2009gy . Even with the incorporation of the latest experimental results BESIII:2024ths , recent analyses Salnikov:2024wah ; Husken:2024hmi conclude that identifying G(3900) as a bona fide resonance remains uncertain, suggesting instead that the observed enhancement may arise from rescattering effects, coupled-channel interference, or other non-resonant phenomena. These divergent interpretations raise two pivotal questions: • Is G(3900) a genuine hadronic state? • If so, can it be classified as a P -wave \bar{D}D^{*}/D\bar{D}^{*} molecular resonance? In this Letter, we propose to study the cross section of the process e^{+}e^{-}\to D^{+}D^{-} as a function of the transverse momentum distribution of the final-state D meson. The presence of G(3900) would manifest as a pronounced Jacobian peak, distinctly different from that caused by interference effects, thereby providing direct evidence for its existence. At the same time, we also conclude that it is difficult to interpret G(3900) as a D\bar{D}^{*} molecular state. In the following, we detail the theoretical framework. Our Strategies –The differential cross section d\sigma/d\cos\theta for the reaction e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} can be measured with high precision, where \theta is the angle between the final-state D meson and the beam axis, defined along the z -direction. From this measurement, one can extract the cross section projected onto the transverse momentum of the D meson Smith:1983aa : \displaystyle\sigma^{-1}\frac{d\sigma}{d\mu}=\mu(1-\mu^{2})^{-1/2}\,\sigma^{-1}\frac{d\sigma}{d\cos\theta}, (1) where \mu^{2}=P_{\perp}^{2}/P^{2}=\sin^{2}\theta , with P and P_{\perp} denoting the three-momentum and its transverse component of the final-state D meson, respectively. Here, division by the total cross section \sigma serves to normalize the distribution. Equation ( 1 ) gives rise to a characteristic Jacobian peak at \mu=1 , corresponding to the maximal transverse momentum of the D meson Matchev:2019bon , \displaystyle P_{\perp}^{\max}=\sqrt{\lambda(M^{2},m_{D}^{2},m_{\bar{D}}^{2})}/(2M), (2) where \lambda(x,y,z)=x^{2}+y^{2}+z^{2}-2xy-2xz-2yz is the Källén function, and M denotes the invariant mass of the intermediate state, including the G(3900) resonance under study. If G(3900) exists as a genuine resonance, the associated Jacobian peak is expected at P_{\perp}^{\max}=520.995\,\mathrm{MeV} and 504.018\,\mathrm{MeV} for the final states D^{0}\bar{D}^{0} and D^{+}D^{-} , respectively. In contrast, if the observed enhancement arises solely from interference between intermediate states or other nonresonant effects, no such Jacobian peak should appear in this range. Using the currently measured cross section for e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} , we compute the normalized differential cross section \sigma^{-1}d\sigma/d\mu both including and excluding the G(3900) contribution to assess the feasibility of experimentally distinguishing these scenarios. Figure 1: The reaction e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} proceeds via intermediate resonances including R=\psi(3686),\psi(3770),\psi(4040),\psi(4160) , and G(3900) (a), as well as through the opening of the D\bar{D}^{*} channel (b). Here, V denotes the exchanged vector meson. We now evaluate \mathrm{d}\sigma/\mathrm{d}\cos\theta in Eq. ( 1 ), treating G(3900) as a genuine resonance and including the contributions from \psi(3686) , \psi(3770) , \psi(4040) , \psi(4160) , as well as the opening of the \bar{D}^{*}D threshold. Results without G(3900) are obtained by simply removing its contribution. The analysis focuses on the mass region M_{G(3900)}=3872.5\pm 14.2\pm 3.0 MeV, where these effects are most pronounced (Fig. 1 ). Note that, although \psi(3686) lies about 200 MeV below G(3900) , its contribution is included because it can naturally account for the e^{+}e^{-}\to D\bar{D} cross sections in the 3.7 – 3.8 GeV region Li:2009pw ; otherwise, additional mechanisms would need to be invoked Yang:2006nh . Here we interpret the \psi(4040) contribution as a manifestation of the nodal structure of the \psi(3S) radial wave function, as this effect is expected to correspond to a genuine c\bar{c} state