A flat-mode perspective on the boson peak in amorphous solids
Shivam Mahajan 1, Long-Zhou Huang 2,3, Cunyuan Jiang 4,5, Yun-Jiang Wang 2,3, Massimo Pica Ciamarra 1 , 6 {}^{1},^{6}, Jie Zhang 4,7, Matteo Baggioli 4,5 · 2025
Read A flat-mode perspective on the boson peak in amorphous solids by Shivam Mahajan 1, Long-Zhou Huang 2,3, Cunyuan Jiang 4,5, Yun-Jiang Wang 2,3, Massimo Pica Ciamarra 1 , 6 {}^{1},^{6}, Jie Zhang 4,7, Matteo Baggioli 4,5 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06340.txt.
Introduction
The boson peak, extra low-energy vibrations in every glass, may be a flat band in disguise, argue Shivam Mahajan and six co-authors in a 2025 paper. Amorphous solids show more low-frequency modes and heat capacity than Debye theory predicts, and the anomaly's origin has been debated for decades. The authors propose its defining feature is spectral weight piled into a narrow frequency window, barely dispersing with wavevector.
Re-reading published experiments and simulations through that lens, and adding their own two- and three-dimensional simulations, they find converging support. The peak then reflects a flat or weakly dispersive band rather than a propagating wave. The interpretation sharply narrows which theories of the boson peak can still be right.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shivam Mahajan 1, Long-Zhou Huang 2,3, Cunyuan Jiang 4,5, Yun-Jiang Wang 2,3, Massimo Pica Ciamarra 1 , 6 {}^{1},^{6}, Jie Zhang 4,7, Matteo Baggioli 4,5 |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 35 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06340
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A flat-mode perspective on the boson peak in amorphous solids Shivam Mahajan 1, Long-Zhou Huang 2,3, Cunyuan Jiang 4,5, Yun-Jiang Wang 2,3, Massimo Pica Ciamarra 1 , 6 {}^{1},^{6}, Jie Zhang 4,7, Matteo Baggioli 4,5 Abstract The boson peak is a characteristic anomaly of amorphous solids broadly defined as a low-energy excess in the density of states and heat capacity compared to the textbook predictions of Debye theory. The origin of this anomaly has long been the subject of ongoing debate and remains a topic of active controversy. While remaining agnostic about the microscopic origin of the phenomenon, we propose that the boson peak (BP) may universally originate from a dispersionless, optic-like excitation, which we refer to as the ‘ flat mode ’. We revisit both experimental and simulation data from the literature through this lens and conduct further simulations in 2D and 3D amorphous systems. These analyses collectively provide supporting evidence for this interpretation. Notably, if this is indeed the case, a striking analogy emerges with similar anomalies observed in crystalline materials, where the nonphononic flat mode is effectively replaced by anomalously low-energy optical phonons. INTRODUCTION Our understanding of the vibrational density of states (VDOS) and heat capacity of ideal crystalline materials is rooted in a century-old theory: the Debye model Debye . This well-established paradigm is based on the premise that the only relevant low-energy excitations in crystals are propagating collective plane waves, also named acoustic phonons. Neglecting dissipation, which would otherwise lead to attenuation, and ignoring different polarizations and possible anisotropies, these sound waves follow a linear dispersion relation \omega=vq (see blue solid line in Fig. 1 ), where \omega , q , and v denote the frequency, wavevector, and propagation speed, respectively. The properties of these acoustic phonons can be derived either through a microscopic normal mode analysis Moon 2023 , or more abstractly, from the spontaneous breaking of translational symmetry Leutwyler 1997 , that is, the formation of a periodic, ordered lattice. Leaveraging on these concepts, the vibrational density of states of ideal crystals takes the well-known form: g(\omega)\propto\omega^{D-1}, (1) where D is the number of spatial dimensions and numerical prefactors are omitted for simplicity. Equation ( 1 ), referred to hereafter as the Debye law, holds in the low-frequency regime where the phonon dispersion remains linear. In the Debye approximation, this linearity is assumed to extend up to a maximum cutoff frequency, the Debye frequency \omega_{D} , beyond which g(\omega) vanishes. Figure 1: Dispersion relation \omega(q) of an acoustic phonon (blue), a low-lying optical mode (red) and a dispersionless flat mode (black). By further recognizing that phonons are quantum mechanical in nature, specifically, bosonic excitations, Debye also derived an expression for the heat capacity of crystals, which in the low-temperature limit takes the universal form: C(T)\propto T^{D}. (2) Both of Debye’s predictions have been experimentally confirmed in crystalline materials and stand as one of the most successful paradigms in solid-state physics Kittel and McEuen 2018 . However, in 1971, Zeller and Pohl Zeller and Pohl 1971 reported that noncrystalline solids present characteristic anomalies in their heat capacity that evade the Debye paradigm. More precisely, they observed an anomalous peak in the normalized heat capacity C(T)/T^{3} around \approx 10 K. This feature is now known as the “ boson peak ” (BP). Moreover, they speculate that this departure from the Debye specific heat may be characteristic of the glassy state, or of amorphous solids in general. Later, in the mid-1980s, Buchenau and colleagues Buchenau et al. 1984 ; Buchenau et al. 1986 convincingly demonstrated that this anomaly was not related to the Bose-Einstein distribution, from where it takes its name, but rather stemmed from an excess of vibrational modes visible in the density of states, exceeding the prediction of the Debye law. This finding was subsequently confirmed by inelastic neutron scattering and various other experimental techniques (e.g., Hehlen et al. 2000 ; Sette et al. 1998 ; Chumakov et al. 2004 ; Kabeya et al. 2016 ), and it is now widely accepted as an established fact. Despite more than half a century of experimental investigations and theoretical modeling, the origin of the boson peak in amorphous solids remains highly controversial and often the subject of debate and disagreement. We refer to the excellent book by Ramos Ramos 2022 for an extensive review of the status quo . In this work, we combine a re-analysis of existing data with new measurements to revisit the nature of the boson peak in amorphous solids. Except for a brief discussion at the end, we intentionally refrain from speculating about its microscopic origin, and corresponding theoretical models to rationalize it. Our starting point is the recent observation in simulated glassy systems Hu and Tanaka 2022 that the boson peak corresponds to a flat, dispersionless mode, clearly visible in both the dynamical structure factor S(q,\omega) and the vibrational spectrum. More precisely, we refer to an optic-like collective excitation with a dispersion of the form \omega\approx\omega_{0} , independent of the wavevector q . This mode is depicted in black in Fig. 1 . The key finding in Hu and Tanaka 2022 ; Hu and Tanaka 2023 is that the characteristic energy \omega_{0} matches the boson peak frequency \omega_{\text{BP}} in both 2D and 3D systems. This dispersionless mode naturally produces a pronounced peak in the vibrational density of states at \omega=\omega_{0}\approx\omega_{\text{BP}} , potentially broadened by disorder or thermal effects. Intuitively, this arises because the density of states g(\omega) is inversely proportional to the slope of the dispersion relation \omega(q) , namely g(\omega)\propto(d\omega/dq)^{-1} . Any flat region in \omega(q) inevitably yields a peak in g(\omega) , irrespective of its microscopic origin. This is precisely the same mechanism underlying van Hove singularities in crystals. Hence, if the observation of a flat nonphononic band at the BP frequency were confirmed across all amorphous solids, the central question would then shift to understanding the microscopic origin of such a dispersionless mode. It is, therefore, essential to determine whether this phenomenon is universal and, indeed, has already been observed or considered in other systems, including experimental results. Interestingly, as noted in the Introduction of Ramos 2022 , as early as 1959, prior to the seminal work of Zeller and Pohl, Flubacher et al. Flubacher et al. 1959 suggested that the excess heat capacity in vitreous silica was due to low-frequency optical modes detected via Raman scattering. This idea was later revisited in depth by Nakayama; see Nakayama 2002 for a comprehensive review. In this work, we investigate the possibility that the boson peak is universally associated with the emergence of an optic-like, dispersionless mode. We support this scenario with substantial evidence, combining new numerical analyses with a re-examination of existing experimental data and prior results on the dynamical structure factor. Specifically, (i) we show that this phenomenon was present, but previously overlooked, in experimental data on a two-dimensional (2D) jammed packing of photoelastic disks, (ii) we show that this feature was already evident in the experimental dynamical structure factor of several disordered systems ranging from granular packings and silicate glasses, to metallic glasses and polymers, and (iii) we provide additional simulation evidence for this scenario in systems of polydisperse particles interacting via a Lennard-Jones-like potential in both