Shadow Formation Conditions Beyond the Kerr Black Hole Paradigm
Parth Bambhaniya, Saurabh, Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino · 2025
Read Shadow Formation Conditions Beyond the Kerr Black Hole Paradigm by Parth Bambhaniya, Saurabh, Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06244.txt.
Introduction
A black hole's shadow needs less than the textbook photon sphere, show Parth Bambhaniya and two co-authors in a 2025 paper. The shadow's edge is usually tied to a photon sphere or shell, the peak of the potential guiding light. For Kerr black holes that story holds, but the authors state a more general condition for an apparent boundary to form.
A shadow appears whenever the effective potential for light has a positive finite upper bound and a region where photons are trapped or scattered. The framework covers objects beyond Kerr, including naked singularities. The authors also separate the dark shadow's boundary from the bright ring a distant observer sees, clarifying what telescope images actually show.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Parth Bambhaniya, Saurabh, Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 25 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06244
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Shadow Formation Conditions Beyond the Kerr Black Hole Paradigm Parth Bambhaniya, Saurabh, Elisabete M. de Gouveia Dal Pino Abstract A compact object illuminated by background radiation produces a dark silhouette. The edge of the silhouette, or shadow, or the apparent boundary, or the critical curve is commonly determined by the presence of the photon sphere (or photon shell – in the case of rotating spacetime), corresponding to the maximum of the effective potential for null geodesics. While this statement stands true for Kerr black holes, here we remark that the apparent boundary (as defined by Bardeen Bardeen ), forms under a more general condition. We demonstrate that a shadow forms if the effective potential of null geodesics has a positive finite upper bound and includes a region where photons are trapped or scattered. Our framework extends beyond conventional solutions, including (but not limited to) naked singularities. Furthermore, we clarify the difference between the apparent boundary of a dark shadow, and the bright ring on the distant observer’s screen. These results provide a unified theoretical basis for interpreting observations from the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) and guiding future efforts toward extreme resolution observations of compact objects. 𝑲 𝒆 𝒚 𝒘 𝒐 𝒓 𝒅 𝒔 \boldsymbol{Keywords} : Shadow, Photon sphere, Naked singularities, Black Holes, EHT. I Introduction The Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) collaboration has made remarkable strides in exploring the evidence for the event horizon of a black hole, significantly advancing our understanding and opening new avenues for other possibilities. In contrast, as outlined in recent EHT analyses (see, for example EventHorizonTelescope:2022xqj ), the results and analyses based on metric tests, suggested that observational evidence does not definitively rule out the possibility that Sgr A* could be a naked singularity, a compact object without an event horizon. Thus, the analyses favors an open and careful interpretation of their findings. This ongoing uncertainty not only spurs scientific debate but also attracts the attention of both the scientific community and the general public, highlighting the profound implications of these findings. Ultra-compact objects such as singular black holes, regular black holes, charged black holes, naked singularities, wormholes, boson stars and gravastars are key to understanding the shadows and accretion disk properties within the general relativity and other gravity theories Vagnozzi:2022moj . Theoretical studies of gravitational collapse in general relativity suggest that both black holes and naked singularities can emerge, depending on initial conditions and physical parameters joshi ; goswami ; mosani1 ; mosani2 ; mosani3 ; mosani4 ; Deshingkar:1998ge ; Jhingan:2014gpa ; Joshi:2011zm . One of the most critical aspects of studying such objects is understanding their observational signatures, particularly in light of recent and upcoming Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) observations EventHorizonTelescope:2019dse ; EventHorizonTelescope:2019uob ; EventHorizonTelescope:2022xnr ; EventHorizonTelescope:2024hpu ; EventHorizonTelescope:2024rju ; Ayzenberg:2023hfw . The detection of the brightness depression in the images of M87* and Sgr A* by the EHT has provided a direct way to probe the nature of compact objects and test general relativity in the strong-field regime. Although, different ultra-compact objects can cast distinct shadow structures, depending on their spacetime geometry and photon trajectories ( EventHorizonTelescope:2020qrl , see for e.g.,) . These variations in shadow morphology necessitate a framework that can systematically characterize the shadow formation (under the definition mentioned above) across diverse compact object cases. Deriving generalized shadow formation conditions is essential for distinguishing between black holes, naked singularities, and other exotic compact objects in future high-resolution observations. The shadow characteristics, such as size, shape, and brightness distribution, could provide direct evidence for the existence of horizonless objects, thereby challenging the cosmic censorship conjecture and offering deeper insights into quantum gravity and modified theories of gravity. Future observations with the EHT, combined with theoretical advancements in shadow analysis, could play a crucial role in unveiling the true nature of these ultra-compact objects. Recently Broderick et al. Broderick:2024vjp , demonstrated that a broad class of naked singularities exhibit inner turning points for timelike geodesics in the parameter space when shadow occurs, resulting in the presence of an accretion-powered photosphere inside the shadow region of the naked singularity. This implies that the presence of any accretion shock must appear inside the photon sphere if it is a naked singularity. However, the shadows of Sgr A* and M87* in the EHT observations, indicate that the accretion flow remains well ordered down to the photon sphere. Therefore, a broad class of naked singularities, except JMN-1 and JNW naked singularities (within some parameter space), can be generically excluded Broderick:2024vjp . Since these naked singularities do not have generic turning points for timelike geodesics prior to reaching the singularity, it will be difficult to observe accretion-driven shock or photosphere within the shadows of JMN-1 and JNW naked singularities using this approach. In other words, unlike other naked singularities, JMN-1 and JNW spacetimes lack generic turning points for timelike geodesics before reaching the singularity, meaning accretion-driven shocks or photospheres do not develop outside the singularity. As such, they are not ruled out by current EHT shadow constraints. Prior work demonstrates that the shadow forms due to the presence of a photon sphere in the spacetime geometry of the ultracompact object (See, for example, Saurabh:2023otl ; shaikh1 ). However, it cannot define any fundamental relation between the photon sphere, an event horizon, and the singularity to form a shadow. Notably, the presence of a photon sphere will not confirm the simultaneous existence of an event horizon and a singularity. Here, classical singularity is referred to as the boundary of a spacetime manifold where non-spacelike geodesics (timelike and null) are incomplete and volume element of Jacobi field vanishes infinitesimally. An event horizon is a boundary of a causal past of future null infinity, and a photon shell (in the case of axisymmetric rotating spacetimes) is the region of unstable photon orbits of null geodesics. The key interesting point is that a shadow can form whether the singularity is absent, hidden behind the event horizon, or naked, for example, regular BHs, singular BHs and naked singularities, wormholes Vagnozzi:2022moj . A recent study showed that a shadow can be cast without a photon sphere, in this case the singularity itself casts a shadow, but with smaller and larger diameters Joshi:2020tlq ; Dey:2020bgo . This is justified by the fact that shadow formation fundamentally depends on the causal structure of null geodesics and the presence of regions where photons are either trapped or scattered. The effective potential provides a covariant way to characterize these regions across a wide class of spacetimes. While in Kerr black hole, the photon sphere is associated with a peak in the effective potential. We show that even in geometries without a photon sphere, a finite upper bound of the effective potential is sufficient for a shadow to form. Our formalism accommodates both cases, offering a unified description of shadow formation beyond specific solutions. While some of previous studies Joshi:2020tlq ; Vagnozzi:2022moj , including some by the present authors, have investigated shadow formation for compact objects such as naked singularities and regular black holes. These works have largely focused on specific analytic spacetimes, most commonly spherically symmetric and static geometries. For instance, shadow formation in naked singularities has typically been studied in