Shear viscosity to entropy density ratio: A powerful tool for gravity theories and strongly coupled fluids

Marilù Chiofalo, Dario Grasso, Stefano Liberati, Massimo Mannarelli · 2025

Read Shear viscosity to entropy density ratio: A powerful tool for gravity theories and strongly coupled fluids by Marilù Chiofalo, Dario Grasso, Stefano Liberati, Massimo Mannarelli (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06178.txt.

Introduction

How slippery can a fluid possibly be? Marilù Chiofalo and three co-authors review the ratio of shear viscosity to entropy density in a 2025 perspective. A famous bound by Kovtun, Son, and Starinets sets a floor for that ratio across strongly coupled fluids, a result born in gravity theory through holography.

The review summarizes the bound, then examines proposed violations and what they would teach, including their ties to fundamental causality conditions. Experimental tests in very different systems, from quark-gluon plasma to ultracold atoms, are surveyed, with an eye to upcoming measurements. The authors present the ratio as a shared diagnostic linking gravity, nuclear physics, and condensed matter.

Catalog record

CREATORMarilù Chiofalo, Dario Grasso, Stefano Liberati, Massimo Mannarelli
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06178

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Shear viscosity to entropy density ratio: A powerful tool for gravity theories and strongly coupled fluids Marilù Chiofalo, Dario Grasso, Stefano Liberati, Massimo Mannarelli Abstract In this perspective review, we present a concise yet multifaceted overview of the pivotal role played by the the shear viscosity to entropy density ratio across various physical contexts. After summarizing some of the main aspects of the bound obtained by Kovtun, Son and Starinets, we examine potential sources of its violation, exploring the insights these may offer and their connections to fundamental causality conditions. We also review a range of experimental tests conducted in diverse, yet complementary, physical systems, discussing the prospects opened by upcoming measurements. 67.10.Jn Hydrodynamics in Quantum Fluids 04.20.-q Einstein equation 03.30.+p General Relativity 1 Introduction The microscopic description of strongly correlated systems is extremely challenging. When conventional perturbation theory cannot be employed, the standard approach is to resort to numerical techniques. However, they may be structurally limited, as it occurs e.g. in lattice methods, which are hindered by the sign problem for Fermi systems and not well-suited to explore real-time processes. One alternative approach is provided by the seminal concept of AdS/CFT correspondence [ 1 ] . This relates gravity on a higher dimensional “bulk” manifold to a gauge theory on its boundary. Specifically, a gravitational theory in (D+1)-dimensional Anti-de Sitter (AdS) curved spacetime is equivalent to a conformal field theory (CFT) in D dimensions on its boundary and it is, in this sense, holographic [ 60 , 40 ] . In this holographic duality, new weakly coupled degrees of freedom dynamically emerge from a strongly coupled system. Difficult problems in strongly interacting quantum field theories, such as those relevant to condensed matter [ 30 ] or quantum chromodynamics [ 28 , 38 ] , can be mapped to more tractable problems in classical gravity. The additional spatial dimension in the gravitational theory effectively encodes the energy scale of the quantum field theory, functioning as a geometric representation of the renormalization group flow. Conversely, transport properties of the boundary theory can be computed as the response of conserved charges to perturbations by external fields. Each conserved quantity in the finite-temperature field theory corresponds to a field in the dual gravitational theory: for instance, the stress-energy tensor maps to the graviton, while conserved charge currents correspond to components of a five-dimensional Maxwell field [ 56 ] . The gravitational field configuration relevant to field theories at finite temperature T is an AdS 5 black hole (BH). BHs can be viewed as thermodynamical objects with an entropy proportional to the cross-sectional area of the event horizon divided by the square of the Planck length [ 7 ] and T=T_{H} , i.e. the one set by their Hawking radiation [ 31 ] . The BH fills the AdS spacetime with a bath of gravitational radiation, whose temperature coincides with that of the boundary field theory. The graviton propagation dynamics in the BH background determines the finite-temperature correlations in the stress tensor at the boundary field theory, and therefore the transport coefficients, like the shear viscosity \eta and the bulk viscosity \zeta , according to the Green-Kubo equations [ 56 ] . The BH membrane paradigm [ 20 , 62 ] showed that this behavior also extends to non-equilibrium thermodynamics hence to dynamical horizons which behave as viscous friction fluids with negative bulk viscosity. In the duality, a classical BH in AdS spacetime corresponds to a strongly coupled thermal CFT on the boundary at T=T_{H} . The ’t Hooft coupling \lambda=g_{\text{YM}}^{2}N of the \mathcal{N}=4 gauge theory is related to the ratio of the AdS curvature radius L to the string length l_{s} via \lambda=(L/l_{s})^{4} . As a result, the large-scale dynamics of the BH is dual to the hydrodynamics of the thermal gauge theory [ 53 ] . Clearly, not all strongly correlated systems possess known gravity duals, and most AdS/CFT results pertain to idealized CFTs with a large number of degrees of freedom (colors) N and supersymmetric conditions. Nevertheless, the correspondence provides valuable qualitative insights to build intuition and offer useful diagnostics for the macroscopic behavior of strongly correlated fluids at large distances and long timescales [ 1 ] . This is particularly significant when scaling symmetries and universality play a central role in the underlying physics, as in quantum criticality during phase transitions, the behavior of non-Fermi liquids or strange metals, and universal transport phenomena. Indeed, the holographic duality is particularly useful in the computation of transport coefficients such as viscosity, conductivity, and diffusion constants. In this context, a prominent role is played by the Kovtun, Son, and Starinets (KSS) [ 39 ] bound limiting the shear viscosity to entropy ratio. In the limit of infinite coupling, any gauge theory with an Einstein gravity dual has a ratio of shear-viscosity coefficient to entropy- density \frac{\eta}{s}=\frac{\hbar}{4\pi k_{B}}\,, (1) hence {\eta}/s=1/4\pi in natural units, which we will use in the following. The KSS bound is the conjecture that the above \eta/s value is the lower one achievable for any physical system, and that it is universal and independent of the fine details of the underlying microscopic description, see Fig. 1 . A number of specific-to-general conditions have been explored under which violations of the KSS bound have been found. Nonetheless, investigating such violations — or the existence of a universal lower bound different from the KSS value — is particularly valuable, as it can shed light on our understanding of transport in strongly coupled fluids and, on the gravity side, offer gauge-theoretic interpretations of higher-derivative couplings or new perspectives on causality constraints in gravitational theories. As quantum technologies 2.0 increasingly enable the engineering of transport properties in strongly coupled fluids under highly controlled conditions, these high-level connections between table-top condensed matter analogues, fundamental interactions, and cosmological concepts become both timely and promising for advancing our understanding in these domains. In this perspective review, we thus first recollect the main derivations of the KSS bound, to form an intuition on its importance. We then identify the possible sources of violation or, vice versa, the extent to which a universal bound may exist. We then review the outcomes of experimental tests of universality designed so far. Finally, we draw the perspective of forthcoming research in this field. Figure 1: Transport properties of strongly correlated fluids. Shear viscosity \eta to entropy density s ratio vs. (T-T_{c})/T_{c} , with T_{c} some transition temperature, like e.g. to superfluidity in ultracold Fermi gases, deconfinement in quantum-chromodynamics and for liquid-gas transition in water and helium. Dashed curves: theoretical predictions scaled by overall factors to match the data near T_{c} . Holographic bounds: KSS 1/4\pi and Gauss–Bonnet (16/25)(1/4\pi) bounds ( \hbar/k_{B} units). Notice that these systems span 19 orders of magnitude in T and 44 in pressure. From [ 1 ] with included references. (Permission to use this content granted by CC Licence https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/). 2 Discussion of the KSS bound Shear viscosity is a measure of a fluid’s resistance to shear stress. A good fluid is by definition one with low viscosity, as indeed it can easily flow. However, a fluid with zero viscosity becomes dry [ 24 ] , so in some sense ceases to be a fluid. Entropy is instead

Read the complete text