Multiplicity distributions in QCD jets and jet topics

Xiang-Pan Duan, Lin Chen, Guo-Liang Ma, Carlos A. Salgado, Bin Wu · 2025

Read Multiplicity distributions in QCD jets and jet topics by Xiang-Pan Duan, Lin Chen, Guo-Liang Ma, Carlos A. Salgado, Bin Wu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-06158.txt.

Introduction

How many particles a jet produces, and with what pattern, is recomputed in a 2025 paper led by Xiang-Pan Duan with four co-authors. The authors revisit Koba-Nielsen-Olesen scaling for quark- and gluon-initiated jets, folding energy conservation into the double logarithmic approximation. The modified theory departs substantially from the standard one and lands closer to recently proposed QCD-inspired formulas.

With its two parameters fixed, the modified approximation describes ATLAS measurements of charged-particle counts in the two leading jets of proton collisions. It does so across a wide energy range, within uncertainties, and matches PYTHIA simulations. Cross-checks against quark and gluon jet samples separated by the jet topics method support the picture, though experimental uncertainties remain sizable.

Catalog record

CREATORXiang-Pan Duan, Lin Chen, Guo-Liang Ma, Carlos A. Salgado, Bin Wu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE64 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-06158

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Multiplicity distributions in QCD jets and jet topics Xiang-Pan Duan, Lin Chen, Guo-Liang Ma, Carlos A. Salgado, Bin Wu Abstract We evaluate the Koba–Nielsen–Olesen (KNO) scaling functions for quark- and gluon-initiated jets by incorporating energy conservation into the Double Logarithmic Approximation (DLA). The resulting modified DLA (MDLA) expressions differ substantially from the DLA predictions and qualitatively align with the recently proposed QCD-inspired expressions, albeit with some quantitative differences. By fixing the two parameters in the MDLA expressions, we show that the inclusive charged-particle multiplicity distributions of the two leading jets in p ​ p pp collisions at s = 13 \sqrt{s}=13 TeV, measured by ATLAS over a wide jet p T p_{T} range of 0.1 0.1 – 2.5 2.5 TeV, are well described within experimental uncertainties and consistent with PYTHIA simulations. This conclusion is further supported by direct comparisons with quark- and gluon-initiated jet distributions extracted via jet topics, though the propagated uncertainties from experimental data remain sizable. 1 Introduction QCD jets are collimated sprays of hadrons with fluctuating particle numbers, and their multiplicity distributions, that is, the probability distribution P(n) for producing n particles, constitute an essential feature. Studying these distributions provides valuable insights into the dynamics of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD), particularly the mechanisms of parton branching and hadronization in the high-virtuality regime. An expected simplification of multiplicity distributions in high-energy QCD jets arises from the concept of Koba–Nielsen–Olesen (KNO) scaling Koba:1972ng . This scaling hypothesis states that at asymptotically high energy, the probability distribution of final-state multiplicities P(n) becomes self-similar when rescaled by the mean multiplicity \bar{n} , such that \bar{n}P(n) depends only on the scaling variable x=n/\bar{n} and approaches a universal function \Psi(x) , that is, \displaystyle\bar{n}P(n)=\Psi\left({n}/{\bar{n}}\right) (1) with \int dx~\Psi(x)=1 . It was originally proposed on general grounds of scale invariance in quantum field theory Polyakov:1970lyy ; Feynman:1969ej , and found a natural interpretation within the framework of QCD as a consequence of the cascade structure of parton showers in QCD jets Konishi:1979cb ; Bassetto:1979nt ; Dokshitzer:1982ia ; Malaza:1984vv ; Bassetto:1987fq ; Dokshitzer:1991wu ; Dokshitzer:1993dc ; Vertesi:2020utz ; Germano:2024ier ; Duan:2025ngi ; Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . Multiplicity distributions are expected to exhibit universality across different high-energy collision systems, including e^{+}e^{-} , Deep Inelastic Scattering (DIS), and pp collisions, when dominated by high-energy jets. In particular, measurements of hadronic final states in e^{+}e^{-} annihilation over a wide energy range, from PETRA to LEP TASSO:1983cre ; TASSO:1989orr ; DELPHI:1990ohs ; DELPHI:1991qnt , showed that charged-particle multiplicity distributions approximately collapse onto a universal KNO curve. Nonetheless, deviations from exact KNO scaling are expected, arising from the superposition of jets with different flavors and topologies ALEPH:1995qic ; Giovannini:1997ce , as well as from the running of the strong coupling Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . Similar approximate KNO behavior is observed in DIS at HERA H1:2020zpd , where both theoretical predictions Liu:2022bru ; Liu:2023eve and experimental data support scaling in the current hemisphere at large momentum transfer. Early low-energy pp collisions, from bubble chamber experiments to ISR data, also reported approximate scaling of multiplicity distributions Slattery:1972ni ; Ames-Bologna-CERN-Dortmund-Heidelberg-Warsaw:1983cqw . In high-energy hadronic collisions, however, LHC data UA5:1985kkp ; UA5:1988gup ; CMS:2010qvf ; Grosse-Oetringhaus:2009eis ; ALICE:2017pcy show that multiplicity distributions broaden with increasing energy and no longer follow KNO scaling. This breakdown is not surprising, since contributions from mixed event topologies of hard processes, such as quark- and gluon-initiated jets Duan:2025ngi ; Dokshitzer:2025owq , as well as soft processes, can lead to scaling violation (for recent discussions, see ref. Martins-Fontes:2025iee and references therein). KNO scaling is suggested to hold within QCD jets in pp collisions Vertesi:2020utz ; Germano:2024ier , while such universality is anticipated to reemerge when focusing specifically on high-energy QCD jets with proper quark–gluon discrimination Duan:2025ngi ; Dokshitzer:2025owq . The KNO scaling functions are different for quark- and gluon-initiated jets, referred to as quark and gluon jets below, and have been calculated in perturbative QCD Dokshitzer:1982ia ; Bassetto:1987fq ; Dokshitzer:1991wu ; Dokshitzer:1993dc ; Duan:2025ngi ; Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . In the double logarithmic approximation (DLA), where the dominant soft and collinear emissions are resummed with strong ordering in both energy and angle, the forms of the scaling functions \Psi(x) for gluon and quark jets can be evaluated explicitly Dokshitzer:1982ia ; Bassetto:1987fq ; Dokshitzer:1991wu . These scaling functions are exact in the asymptotic high-energy (high-virtuality) limit, and KNO scaling within DLA has recently been confirmed to hold to a good approximation by numerically solving the multiplicity distributions in QCD jets for a broad jet p_{T} range relevant to LHC energies Duan:2025ngi . However, the DLA KNO scaling functions do not provide a reliable description of the measured multiplicity distributions Malaza:1984vv ; Dokshitzer:1993dc ; Duan:2025ngi ; Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . To remedy this, the DLA for gluon jets was first improved by enforcing energy conservation in the parton cascade Dokshitzer:1993dc . This modified double logarithmic approximation (MDLA) has recently been generalized to jets initiated by any source, including quarks and antiquarks, achieving notable phenomenological success Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . Meanwhile, the KNO scaling functions have also been extracted using PYTHIA Vertesi:2020utz ; Duan:2025ngi , showing good agreement with LHC measurements within experimental uncertainties ATLAS:2019rqw ; Duan:2025ngi . One of the main goals of this work is to compare quark and gluon KNO scaling functions obtained within MDLA and PYTHIA , and to explore their phenomenological implications. Recent advances in jet physics and jet substructure at the LHC Marzani:2019hun ; Larkoski:2024uoc provide an unprecedented opportunity to investigate multiplicity fluctuations in QCD jets at very high transverse momenta, both theoretically and experimentally. A variety of methods for quark–gluon discrimination have been proposed Gallicchio:2011xq ; Gallicchio:2012ez ; Larkoski:2013eya ; Larkoski:2014pca ; Gras:2017jty ; Metodiev:2017vrx ; Metodiev:2018ftz ; Komiske:2018vkc ; Dreyer:2021hhr and applied in LHC analyses CMS:2013kfa ; ATLAS:2014vax ; ATLAS:2016wzt ; ATLAS:2019rqw . If proven effective for multiplicity distributions, these techniques would enable direct experimental tests of the universality of the KNO scaling functions for quark and gluon jets, as illustrated using energy–correlation functions Larkoski:2013eya in ref. Duan:2025ngi . Another central motivation of this paper is to investigate KNO scaling in QCD jets using jet topics Metodiev:2018ftz ; Komiske:2018vkc , which is well suited to extracting multiplicity distributions and can be implemented without additional theoretical input. The rest of this paper is structured as follows. In section 2 , we start with a review of the generating function method for multiplicity distributions within QCD jets, as well as a summary of the DLA results for parton multiplicity distributions and mean multiplicities. We then calculate the KNO scaling function for both quark and gluon jets within the MDLA, i.e., by incorporating energy conservation into the DLA, following refs. Dokshitzer:1982ia ; Bassetto:1987fq ; Dokshitzer:1993dc , as an alternative to the recent calculations in refs. Dokshitzer:2025owq ; Dokshitzer:2025fky . In section 3 , we present a phenomenological study of inclusive charged-particle multiplicity distributions of two leading jets in pp collisions at \sqrt{s}=13 TeV, combining the MDLA KNO scaling functions with leading-order cross sections and the calculations of mean multiplicities, and compare our theoretical results with ATLAS data from ref. ATLAS:2019rqw . As a consistency check, we also directly compare the MDLA KNO scaling functions for quark and gluon jets with those extracted from ATLAS measurements using topic modeling Metodiev:2018ftz

Read the complete text