Centered Moments of Weighted One-Level Densities of G ​ L ​ ( 2 ) GL(2) L L -Functions

Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti · 2025

Read Centered Moments of Weighted One-Level Densities of G ​ L ​ ( 2 ) GL(2) L L -Functions by Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05810.txt.

Introduction

The zeros of L-functions, deep objects that encode prime number patterns, are the subject of a 2025 paper led by Lawrence Dillon with eight co-authors. A famous conjecture by Katz and Sarnak says zeros near the center of a family mimic eigenvalues of a classical symmetry group. Which group appears can depend on how family members are weighted.

Knightly and Reno had shown that weight dependence for one-level densities; this team extends it to centered moments, averages that capture how the density spreads. Handling products of many primes forced them to widen a weighted trace formula from primes to all positive integers. A combinatorial rewrite then separates main terms from errors, letting the authors match both orthogonal and symplectic symmetry against random matrix predictions.

Catalog record

CREATORLawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE70 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05810

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Centered Moments of Weighted One-Level Densities of G ​ L ​ ( 2 ) GL(2) L L -Functions Thanks: This study took place at the SMALL REU at Williams College and was supported by Williams College and the National Science Foundation (Grant DMS2241623). The authors are also grateful for the support of Columbia University, Princeton University, University of Michigan, University of Washington, University of Wisconsin, Williams College, and Yale University. The authors are also grateful to Andrew Knightly for suggesting improvements to the paper. Lawrence Dillon, Xiaoyao Huang, Say-Yeon Kwon, Meiling Laurence, Steven J. Miller, Vishal Muthuvel, Luke Rowen, Pramana Saldin, Steven Zanetti Abstract . Katz and Sarnak conjectured that the behavior of zeros near the central point of any family of L L -functions is well-modeled by the behavior of eigenvalues near 1 1 of some classical compact group (either the symplectic, unitary, or even, odd, or full orthogonal group). In 2018, Knightly and Reno proved that the symmetry group can vary depending on how the L L -functions in the family are weighted. They observed both orthogonal and symplectic symmetry in the one-level densities of families of cuspidal newform L L -functions for different choices of weights. We observe the same dependence of symmetry on weights in the n n th centered moments of these one-level densities, for smooth test functions whose Fourier transforms are supported in ( − 1 2 ​ n , 1 2 ​ n ) \left(-\frac{1}{2n},\frac{1}{2n}\right) . To treat the new terms that emerge in our n n -level calculations when n > 1 n>1 , i.e., the cross terms that emerge from n n -fold products of primes rather than individual primes, we generalize Knightly and Reno’s weighted trace formula from primes to arbitrary positive integers. We then perform a delicate analysis of these cross terms to distinguish their contributions to the main and error terms of the n n th centered moments. The final novelty here is an elementary combinatorial trick that we use to rewrite the main number theoretic terms arising from our analysis, facilitating comparisons with random matrix theory. 1. Introduction Many studies have been undertaken over the last few decades to make precise the connection between number theory and random matrix theory. Before situating our work in this chronology, we recount the most relevant results and how they prompted the refinement of this connection. In 1972, Montgomery [ Mon73 ] initiated the connection between number theory and random matrix theory, proving that, for suitable test functions, the pair correlation of the zeros of the Riemann zeta function \zeta(s) agrees with the pair correlation of the eigenvalues of the Gaussian Unitary Ensemble (GUE). In his seminal work, he furthermore conjectured a correspondence between any local statistic of the zeros of \zeta(s) and the eigenvalues of the GUE. In 1987, Odlyzko [ Odl87 , Odl01 ] provided numerical evidence for this conjecture, verifying the correspondence for particular local statistics: the pair correlation and the nearest neighbor spacing distribution. Subsequent works by Hejhal [ Hej94 ] on the triple correlation of \zeta(s) and Rudnick and Sarnak [ RS96 ] on the n -level correlation of any automorphic cuspidal L -function, all for suitably restricted test functions, provided strong evidence for Montgomery’s conjecture in generality. These studies suggested a remarkable universality in number theory: the statistical profile of any L -function matches that of one and only one of the numerous random matrix ensembles, the GUE. At the time, however, there were a few reasons to believe that this conjecture did not capture the connection in full. For one, certain local statistics, such as the n -level correlation, are insensitive to the behavior of any finite set of zeros. As there are many important problems in number theory concerning only finite sets of zeros (e.g., the Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer conjecture [ BS63 , BS65 ] is concerned only with the low-lying zeros of elliptic curve L -functions), this marked a considerable shortcoming of the conjecture on the number theory side. Katz and Sarnak [ KS99a , KS99 ] confirmed that indeed more attention is needed in this regard. They showed that the n -level correlation of eigenvalues is the same coming from the GUE and all five classical compact groups (unitary, symplectic, and orthogonal, split and unsplit by sign). They addressed this possibility of confounding by defining a new statistic called the one-level density, which is not only distinguishable across the classical compact groups but also sensitive to changes in low-lying zeros (near the central point). For any L -function L(s,f) , denoting its non-trivial zeros by \rho_{f}=1/2+i\gamma_{f} 1 1 1 If the Grand Riemann Hypothesis (GRH) is true, then \gamma would be real, and the non-trivial zeros \rho could be ordered accordingly. There are interesting interpretations of this ordering in the context of random matrix theory and nuclear physics, actuating connections to the eigenvalues of classical compact groups and the energy levels of heavy nuclei. With this being said, we do not assume the truth of the GRH in what follows, performing our study in generality. , they defined its one-level density by (1.1) D(f,\phi)\ :=\ \sum_{\rho_{f}}\phi\left(\frac{\gamma_{f}\log Q_{f}}{2\pi}\right), where \phi is an even Schwartz (test) function, and Q_{f} is the analytic conductor of f . The low-lying zeros of L(s,f) have imaginary part approximately 1/\log Q_{f} and the average spacing between zeros with imaginary part T is known to be approximately 1/\log T . Hence, the scaled zeros, \frac{\gamma_{f}\log Q_{f}}{2\pi} , have average spacing 1 , meaning there are only finitely many up to any given constant. As it is not instructive to statistically survey the finitely many low-lying zeros of a single L -function, Katz and Sarnak passed to the study of collections of naturally related (similarly behaved) L -functions, “families” so to speak. In doing so, they were able to execute averages and take limits, as is customary in analytic number theory, to identify the common behavior underlying the L -functions in the family. To facilitate our discussion, we establish a standard notation for averages, writing the average of a map Q over a finite collection \mathcal{C} with weight w as (1.2) \mathcal{A}^{w}_{\mathcal{C}}(Q)\ :=\ \frac{\sum_{c\in\mathcal{C}}w(c)Q(c)}{\sum_{c\in\mathcal{C}}w(c)}. For unweighted averages, i.e., when w is identically 1 on \mathcal{C} , we omit the superscript in the notation ( 1.2 ). In refining Montgomery’s conjecture based on their seminal study, Katz and Sarnak formulated the now celebrated density conjecture, stating that the behavior of zeros near 1/2 in any family of L -functions matches the behavior of eigenvalues near 1 in one of the five classical compact groups. More precisely, consider a family \mathcal{F}=\bigcup_{n}\mathcal{F}_{n} of L -functions, where each sub-family \mathcal{F}_{n} is finite. Let the average one-level density of each sub-family be given by (1.3) \mathcal{A}_{\mathcal{F}_{n}}(D(\cdot,\phi))\ :=\ \frac{\sum_{L(s,f)\in\mathcal{F}_{n}}D(f,\phi)}{|\mathcal{F}_{n}|}. Then, there exists a symmetry group G among the classical compact groups O, SO(even), SO(odd), Sp, and U such that for any test function \phi with compactly supported Fourier transform \widehat{\phi} , (1.4) \lim_{n\to\infty}\mathcal{A}_{\mathcal{F}_{n}}(D(\cdot,\phi))\ =\ \int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\phi(x)W_{G}(x)dx. Here, W_{G}(x) is the limiting distribution of the one-level density of the eigenvalues coming from the random matrices in G as rank tends to \infty . These distributions are given by (1.5) \displaystyle W_{\text{U}}(x)\ \displaystyle=\ 1, (1.6) \displaystyle W_{\text{Sp}}(x)\ \displaystyle=\

Read the complete text