Primordial Black Holes Evaporating before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Preprint: August 10, 2026
Quan-feng Wu, and Xun-Jie Xu · 2025
Read Primordial Black Holes Evaporating before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Preprint: August 10, 2026 by Quan-feng Wu, and Xun-Jie Xu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05618.txt.
Introduction
Black holes born in the infant universe and evaporating before the first elements formed are constrained by Quan-feng Wu and Xun-Jie Xu in a 2025 cosmology paper. Their Hawking radiation would have disturbed big bang nucleosynthesis, the process that set the amounts of light elements, leaving measurable traces.
Working through the intermediate steps analytically, the authors find an effect needs a mass above a stated threshold, higher than some earlier studies reported. Sensitivity rises steeply just above that threshold, peaks, then falls, and current element measurements cap the initial share of such black holes across the studied mass range. Their code is public for use with updated nuclear and cosmological inputs.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Quan-feng Wu, and Xun-Jie Xu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05618
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Primordial Black Holes Evaporating before Big Bang Nucleosynthesis Preprint: August 10, 2026 Quan-feng Wu, and Xun-Jie Xu Abstract Primordial black holes (PBHs) formed from the collapse of density fluctuations provide a unique window into the physics of the early Universe. Their evaporation through Hawking radiation around the epoch of Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) can leave measurable imprints on the primordial light-element abundances. In this work, we analyze in detail the effects of PBHs evaporating before BBN, with various intermediate steps understood analytically, and obtain the BBN constraint on PBHs within a transparent and reproducible framework. We find that, to produce observable effects on BBN, the PBH mass must exceed 10 9 10^{9} g, a threshold higher than that reported in some earlier studies. Slightly above 10 9 10^{9} g, the BBN sensitivity rapidly increases with the mass and then decreases, with the turning point occurring at 2 × 10 9 2\times 10^{9} g. For PBHs in the mass range [ 10 9 , 10 10 ] [10^{9},\ 10^{10}] g, current measurements of BBN observables set an upper bound on the initial mass fraction parameter β \beta ranging from 10 − 17 10^{-17} to 10 − 19 10^{-19} . To facilitate future improvements, we make our code publicly available, enabling straightforward incorporation of updated nuclear reaction rates, particle-physics inputs, and cosmological data . 1 Introduction Primordial black holes (PBHs) provide a unique window into the physics of the early Universe. Unlike astrophysical black holes, which form from the gravitational collapse of massive stars, PBHs could have originated from the collapse of density fluctuations in the very early Universe, well before the onset of structure formation Escriva:2022duf . Their possible existence has been considered for decades Hawking:1971ei ; Carr:1974nx ; Carr:1975qj , and in recent years they have attracted renewed interest due to the rich phenomenology associated with them, including possible connections to dark matter Carr:2020xqk ; Green:2020jor ; Baldes:2020nuv ; Gondolo:2020uqv ; Bernal:2020kse ; Bernal:2020bjf ; Bernal:2020ili ; Auffinger:2020afu ; Cheek:2021odj ; Masina:2021zpu ; Cheek:2021cfe ; Bernal:2021yyb ; Bernal:2021bbv ; Calabrese:2021src ; Sandick:2021gew ; Bernal:2022oha ; Gehrman:2023esa ; Arcadi:2024tib , baryogenesis Hooper:2020otu ; Datta:2020bht ; JyotiDas:2021shi ; Bernal:2022pue ; Coleppa:2022pnf ; Gehrman:2022imk ; Calabrese:2023key ; Schmitz:2023pfy , gravitational waves Nakama:2016gzw ; Garcia-Bellido:2016dkw ; Raidal:2017mfl ; Papanikolaou:2020qtd , and high-energy cosmic neutrinos Chianese:2024rsn ; Wu:2024uxa ; Klipfel:2025jql ; Boccia:2025hpm ; Choi:2025hqt ; Anchordoqui:2025xug . A key property of black holes is their instability under quantum effects. As first demonstrated by Hawking Hawking:1974rv , black holes radiate thermally and lose mass over time, a process that eventually leads to complete evaporation on sufficiently long timescales. The lifetime of a black hole scales as the cube of its mass, so PBHs with masses below about 10^{15}\,\mathrm{g} would have fully evaporated by the present epoch. In particular, PBHs lighter than about 10^{9}\,\mathrm{g} would have completely evaporated before the onset of Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN), at cosmic times t\lesssim 1\,\mathrm{s} . BBN is among the most important probes of the early Universe, providing precise predictions for the primordial abundances of light elements such as deuterium, helium, and lithium. These predictions, derived within the standard cosmological framework, are in remarkable agreement with astronomical observations, leaving little room for significant deviations in the thermal and particle history of the Universe around the BBN epoch. As a result, any nonstandard physics that could inject energy, alter particle abundances, or modify the expansion history around this epoch is subject to stringent constraints—see, e.g., Refs. Kawasaki:2017bqm ; Hufnagel:2017dgo ; Hufnagel:2018bjp ; Huang:2017egl ; Depta:2019lbe ; Sabti:2020yrt ; Boyarsky:2020dzc ; Chen:2024cla ; Dev:2025pru . PBH evaporation prior to BBN is an especially interesting case in this context. Although such PBHs would not survive long enough to directly influence later cosmological processes, the particles and entropy they release could still affect the conditions under which nucleosynthesis begins. Consequently, PBHs evaporating before BBN have the potential to leave measurable imprints on the abundances of light elements, thereby allowing BBN to serve as a sensitive probe of their existence and abundance. In this work, we investigate in detail how PBHs evaporating before BBN could alter BBN predictions and derive the corresponding constraints on such PBHs. Previous studies have presented several BBN constraints on PBHs Carr:2020gox ; Carr:2009jm ; Keith:2020jww ; Kohri:1999ex , but the results in the literature exhibit significant discrepancies, which necessitate a careful examination in a transparent framework. Therefore, our work presents an anatomy of the calculation. We scrutinize various steps that could affect the BBN sensitivity to PBHs, including the background effect evaluation, the hadronization of Hawking radiation, meson-driven neutron–proton conversion processes, and the evolution of the neutron-to-proton ratio. At each step, we provide the output of our code and carefully cross-check it against analytical estimates and qualitative expectations. This allows us to disentangle the physical effects responsible for modifying the light-element abundances and to assess the robustness of the resulting BBN constraints. Finally, we make our code publicly available, so that it can be readily improved and extended to incorporate future updates in nuclear reaction rates, particle physics inputs, and cosmological observations. The structure of this paper is as follows. In Sec. 2 , we introduce the basic formulations, including the standard BBN framework and the properties of PBHs. In Sec. 3 , we discuss the influence of PBHs on the background evolution. Sec. 4 is devoted to the hadronization of Hawking radiation and meson-driven neutron–proton conversion. In Sec. 5 , we present numerical solutions and results. Finally, we conclude in Sec. 6 and relegate some details to the appendices. 2 Basic formulations We begin with a brief review of the relevant physics and formulae involved in BBN and PBHs. 2.1 BBN When the temperature of the Universe, T , is above a few MeV, neutrons and protons maintain chemical equilibrium with each other via weak interaction processes: \displaystyle n+\nu_{e} \displaystyle\leftrightarrows p+e^{-}\thinspace, \displaystyle n+e^{+} \displaystyle\leftrightarrows p+\overline{\nu_{e}}\thinspace, \displaystyle n \displaystyle\leftrightarrows p+e^{-}+\overline{\nu_{e}}\thinspace. In the standard scenario, the chemical potentials of neutrinos ( \nu_{e} , \overline{\nu_{e}} ) and electrons ( e^{\pm} ) are negligible. Hence, the chemical equilibrium implies that the neutron and proton chemical potentials, denoted by \mu_{n} and \mu_{p} , are equal. Since neutrons and protons are highly non-relativistic and sparse at this temperature, they approximately obey the Maxwell-Boltzmann statistics, with number densities given by n_{N}=e^{\mu_{N}/T}\frac{g_{N}m_{N}^{2}T}{2\pi^{2}}K_{2}\left(\frac{m_{N}}{T}\right), (2.1) where N\in\{n,\ p\} , g_{N}=2 accounts for the spin multiplicity, m_{N} denotes the mass of the nucleon N , and K_{2} is the modified Bessel function of the second kind. Equation ( 2.1 ) implies the following in-equilibrium ratio of the neutron and proton number densities: \frac{n_{n}}{n_{p}}\approx e^{-Q/T} (2.2) with Q\equiv m_{n}-m_{p}\approx 1.3 MeV. At T\ll Q , the in-equilibrium ratio is exponentially suppressed. However, the weak interaction processes can no longer maintain the equilibrium when T drops below about 1 MeV, and the neutrons begin to freeze out. The freeze-out process is quantitatively governed by the Boltzmann equation: \frac{dX_{n}}{dt}=-\Gamma_{n\to p}X_{n}+\Gamma_{p\to n}\left(1-X_{n}\right), (2.3) with X_{n}\equiv\frac{n_{n}}{n_{n}+n_{p}}\thinspace, (2.4) where \Gamma_{n\to p} and \Gamma_{p\to n} denote the conversion rates of a neutron to a proton and a proton to a neutron, respectively. In the SM, \Gamma_{n\to p} and \Gamma_{p\to n} receive contributions (denoted by \Gamma_{n\to p}^{({\rm SM})} and \Gamma_{p\to n}^{({\rm SM})} ) from the aforementioned three weak processes.