Unitary equivalence in Generalized Uncertainty Principle theories Journal: Nuclear Physics B
Sebastiano Segreto, Matteo Bruno · 2025
Read Unitary equivalence in Generalized Uncertainty Principle theories Journal: Nuclear Physics B by Sebastiano Segreto, Matteo Bruno (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05477.txt.
Introduction
Different mathematical pictures of the same deformed quantum rules may describe the same physics, Sebastiano Segreto and Matteo Bruno examine in a 2025 theoretical physics paper. Generalised uncertainty principle theories modify the basic commutation rules, suggesting a smallest measurable length, but each algebra admits several realisations.
The authors first define what counts as a quantum theory of this type, then give conditions for two realisations to be unitarily equivalent, meaning linked by a map that preserves all predictions. They construct that map explicitly for two widely used realisations and check matching results on a harmonic oscillator and a falling particle. One case where equivalence fails hints that a classic uniqueness theorem may not extend.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Sebastiano Segreto, Matteo Bruno |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05477
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Unitary equivalence in Generalized Uncertainty Principle theories Journal: Nuclear Physics B Sebastiano Segreto, Matteo Bruno Abstract We analyze the fundamental issue of unitary equivalence within the framework of Generalized Uncertainty Principle (GUP) theories in the one-dimensional case. Given a deformed Heisenberg algebra, its representation in terms of the Hilbert space and quantum conjugate operators is not uniquely determined. This raises the question of whether two different realizations of the same algebra are equivalent and thus whether they describe the same physics. Having agreed on the formal definition of a quantum GUP theory, we establish the conditions that must be satisfied to discuss unitary equivalence. We use this framework to rigorously prove that two of the main representations used in the literature are actually unitarily equivalent and we specify the conditions that must be met for this equivalence to hold. We explicitly demonstrate unitary equivalence by providing the unitary map and then discuss two relevant physical examples—the quantum harmonic oscillator and the quantum particle in free fall—showing, for each of them, how both GUP formulations yield the same physical results. Finally, we discuss the relationship between these standard GUP representations and the polymer-like representation, inspired by Polymer Quantum Mechanics (PQM) and related to Loop Quantum Cosmology (LQC). We show that, whenever a GUP theory leads to the emergence of a minimal length, these formulations are not unitarily equivalent and therefore describe different quantum physics. This is particularly relevant, as it may indicate that a generalization of the Stone-von Neumann theorem, which holds in ordinary Quantum Mechanics, may not be possible in the GUP framework, at least within our definition of unitary equivalence. 1 Introduction Generalized uncertainty principle (GUP) theories are widely recognized for providing an effective framework, rooted originally in String theory considerations [ 1 , 2 , 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 ] , that describes an alternative structure of space, consistent with what a quantum theory of gravity is expected to yield. These theories are quantum, non-relativistic models based on a deformation of the usual Heisenberg algebra between conjugate quantum operators [ 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 ] . The new quantum picture that emerges from this fundamental modification is drastically different from the ordinary one. Specifically, the changes introduced in the algebra can manifest in two main features: on the one hand, the emergence of a non-zero minimal uncertainty in position, which can be interpreted as the appearance of a fundamental minimal length or, more generally, a minimal structure in configuration space; on the other hand, in higher-dimensional scenarios, a non-commutativity between position or coordinate operators arises, which can be viewed as the onset of a non-commutative geometry in the configuration space of the theory. As we anticipated, these novel characteristics, directly embedded in the quantum formalism, result in a structure of space that closely resembles what one might expect, on general grounds, from a fundamentally quantum nature of spacetime. In particular, the usual notions of position and localization are profoundly altered, necessitating new concepts and tools to properly describe a system’s behavior in configuration space and, more broadly, its dynamics [ 14 ] . The GUP framework boasts a very wide range of applications in various physical contexts, each of which may require a different conceptual frame to its formulation [ 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 , 22 ] . Indeed, while the GUP can serve as an effective means of introducing corrections to the dynamics of a system at scales where quantum gravity effects become significant, i.e. the Planck scale, it can also be interpreted, when used as a quantization scheme for gravitational systems, as a more faithful method of quantizing gravitational degrees of freedom. Regardless of the conceptual standpoint, the literature offers numerous applications with compelling results, demonstrating both the versatility of the framework and its potential to profoundly affect a system’s dynamics. Nevertheless, the reliability of these results, at least from a formal perspective, fundamentally depends on the correct construction of the mathematical structures defining the theories. Modifying the algebra of fundamental quantum operators must be approached with care to coherently construct the new quantum theory, even in its more formal aspects—areas that are often overlooked in recent discussions of the subject. In this paper, we address a very general issue concerning the construction of a GUP theory: the unitary equivalence among different formulations of the same GUP theory arising from a given modified algebra. This topic is, of course, of broad importance in physics. In standard quantum theory, it is well established that different, yet unitarily equivalent, representations of the Heisenberg algebra are possible, as guaranteed by the celebrated Stone–von Neumann theorem [ 23 , 24 , 25 , 26 , 27 , 28 ] . Unitary equivalence places all such formulations on equal footing, as they necessarily describe the same physics. In light of this, it is entirely natural to pose the same question in the broader context of the GUP framework. This issue is not only relevant at a formal level, but also aids in a deeper understanding of the deformed canonical structure of these models. This could be particularly relevant in constructing deformed quantum canonical transformations, which could reveal themselves to be valuable in solving the dynamics of a given system—a task often complicated by the more intricate GUP representations of the operators involved. We will limit our analysis and considerations to the one-dimensional scenario. In general, given a modified algebra, different Hilbert spaces can be chosen for its representation, that is, for the action of the fundamental operators. A priori, it is not obvious that two different formulations derived from the same algebra are physically equivalent. To determine under what conditions equivalence holds, we must first agree on the definition of a GUP theory, identify the main objects of interest, and establish some minimal properties that the conjugate operators and the deformation operator-valued function f , along with their domains, must satisfy. This procedure allows us to identify a GUP formulation with the Hilbert space \mathcal{H} chosen for its representation and the quantum conjugate operators q,p , along with their specific representation, defined on some proper domains where they result in being self-adjoint. These objects define a triple (\mathcal{H},q,p) by which a GUP theory can be uniquely labeled. Given two such triples, if a unitary transformation exists between the two Hilbert spaces—subject to certain precise requirements—then they represent the same one-dimensional GUP theory and thus describe the same physics. Clearly, if such a transformation does not exist, we must conclude that we are dealing with two distinct physical theories, each with different physical implications. Our analysis mainly focuses on demonstrating the unitary equivalence between two major GUP representations found in the literature. On one side, there is the GUP representation introduced by Kempf, Mangano and Mann in [ 8 ] , where the Hilbert space employs a modified Lebesgue measure to ensure the symmetry of the position operator, thereby determining its momentum representation; on the other, there is a commonly used representation where the Hilbert space is the standard one and the usual operators Q and P , satisfying