Deep-Field Analytical Calibration 2026 Deep-Field Analytical Calibration – References
Andy Park, Xiangchong Li, Rachel Mandelbaum, Matthew Becker · 2025
Read Deep-Field Analytical Calibration 2026 Deep-Field Analytical Calibration – References by Andy Park, Xiangchong Li, Rachel Mandelbaum, Matthew Becker (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05152.txt.
Introduction
Weak gravitational lensing surveys will measure galaxy shapes for billions of objects, and shape errors must stay below one percent. Andy Park, lead author with three co-authors, extend an analytical calibration method in a 2025 astronomy paper. The original framework reaches the needed accuracy but adds noise to images, wasting their depth.
Their deep-field version computes shear responses from much deeper images, preserving the statistical power of wide fields. Tests on simulated isolated and blended galaxies with survey-like seeing and noise meet the strict bias requirement. The method raises the effective galaxy density substantially for simulated ten-year survey data, improving cosmological reach.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Andy Park, Xiangchong Li, Rachel Mandelbaum, Matthew Becker |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05152
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Deep-Field Analytical Calibration 2026 Deep-Field Analytical Calibration – References Andy Park, Xiangchong Li, Rachel Mandelbaum, Matthew Becker Abstract The next generation of imaging surveys, including the Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time (LSST), Euclid, and the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope, will provide unprecedented constraints on cosmology using weak gravitational lensing. To fully exploit the statistical power of these surveys, shear measurement methods must achieve sub-percent accuracy while mitigating a range of systematic biases, including those arising from noise, the point-spread function (PSF), blending, and shear-dependent detection effects. The latest version of the analytical calibration framework ( AnaCal ) has been demonstrated to achieve such accuracy, but requires the addition of noise to the images, reducing their effective depth. In this work, we introduce Deep-Field Analytical Calibration ( deep-field AnaCal ), an extension of AnaCal that exploits deep-field images to compute shear responses while preserving the statistical power of wide-field images. We validate deep-field AnaCal on both isolated and blended galaxy image simulations with LSST-like seeing and noise levels, showing that it meets the stringent requirement of a multiplicative bias | m | < 3 × 10 − 3 |m|<3\times 10^{-3} at the 99.7 percent confidence level. Compared to standard AnaCal applied on wide-field images, deep-field AnaCal improves the effective galaxy number density from 17 17 to 30 30 galaxies per arcmin 2 for simulated 10-year LSST images. If the deep field has 10 × 10\times the exposure time of the wide field, we find the pixel noise variance in the shear estimation is reduced by 30 % 30\% and the uncertainty in shear estimation is reduced by approximately 25 % 25\% . Finally, we assess the impact of sample variance on deep-field AnaCal , following the LSST Deep Drilling Fields observing strategy, and find that its equivalent calibration uncertainty is ≲ 0.3 % \lesssim 0.3\% . Our results show that deep-field AnaCal is a promising approach for shear calibration in upcoming weak lensing surveys. 1 Introduction The next generation of imaging surveys, such as the Vera C. Rubin Observatory Legacy Survey of Space and Time ( Ivezić et al. 2019 , LSST;) , Euclid ( Laureijs et al. 2011 ) , and Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope High Latitude Imaging Survey ( Akeson et al. 2019 ) , will provide unprecedented constraints on the growth of large scale structure and the fundamental properties of the Universe. A key observable in these surveys is weak gravitational lensing, or cosmic shear, which probes the distribution of matter by measuring the coherent distortions in the shapes of distant galaxies induced by intervening large-scale structure (see Kilbinger 2015 ; Mandelbaum 2018 for a review of cosmic shear). To fully exploit the statistical power of these surveys, shear measurement techniques must achieve sub-percent accuracy while mitigating a range of systematic biases, including those arising from the point-spread function (PSF), noise biases, model biases, selection effects, blending effects, and detection biases (see Mandelbaum 2018 for a review of systematics in weak lensing and references). Several advanced shear estimation methods have been developed to reduce the reliance on external simulations in calibration. These methods include BFD ( Bernstein et al. 2016 ) , metacalibration ( Sheldon & Huff 2017 ; Huff & Mandelbaum 2017 ) , and FPFS ( Li et al. 2018 ; Li et al. 2022 ) . These methods have demonstrated the ability to reach the required sub-percent accuracy for isolated galaxies. Sheldon et al. 2023 extended metacalibration and introduced the state-of-the-art technique metadetection and Li & Mandelbaum 2023 ; Li et al. 2024b further extended FPFS to include an analytical calibration technique and introduced AnaCal . Both of these newly developed shear estimators are able to reach the sub-percent accuracy in the presence of blending. Because it is an analytical approach, AnaCal is more than a hundred times faster than the metadetection algorithm. The previous version of FPFS ( Li & Mandelbaum 2023 ) corrected the noise bias by computing the second-order derivative (Hessian matrix) of the ellipticity. However, this approach required estimating noisy second- and higher-order derivatives, introducing additional complications from higher-order noise terms. The current implementation of metadetection and AnaCal achieves the required accuracy in shear measurement by introducing an additional layer of noise, matched to the statistical properties of the original image, to cancel out noise bias. This process effectively doubles the variance of pixel noise in survey images ( \sqrt{2} in the noise standard deviation) or equivalently reduces the signal-to-noise ratio of every source by approximately 30\% . Modern imaging surveys typically allocate the majority of their observing time, over 90 percent, to wide-field imaging, while dedicating a smaller fraction to deep-field imaging, which covers a limited area, but receives a significantly higher number of visits per observing night. This strategy was used in the Dark Energy Survey deep-fields ( Hartley et al. 2022 ) and is planned for the LSST Deep Drilling Fields ( Gris et al. 2024 , DDFs;) and Euclid Deep Fields ( Euclid Collaboration et al. 2024 ) . Wide-field surveys provide the statistical constraining power necessary for cosmic shear studies but are limited by the higher level of noise in the images. In contrast, deep-field observations capture fainter galaxies, improve photometric redshifts, and enable more precise shape measurements due to lower noise. Both the metadetection and AnaCal ensemble shear estimation methods consist of two key components: the uncalibrated shape measurement, \langle\bm{e}\rangle , and the mean shear response matrix, \langle\bm{R}\rangle . The mean shear estimate is then obtained as ( Huff & Mandelbaum 2017 ; Sheldon & Huff 2017 ; Li & Mandelbaum 2023 ) \hat{\gamma}\equiv\frac{\langle\bm{e}\rangle}{\langle\bm{R}\rangle}. (1) Traditional analyses derive both components using wide-field survey data, where the dominant source of uncertainty in shear estimation arises from the shape measurement noise. Zhang et al. 2023 introduced deep-field metacalibration , a novel technique in which the mean response matrix \langle\bm{R}\rangle is computed using deep-field survey data instead of the wide-field survey data. This approach effectively confines the doubling in the pixel noise variance to the deep-field survey, avoiding additional noise contributions in the higher-noise wide-field data. They demonstrated that deep-field metacalibration yields an unbiased shear estimate while reducing the pixel noise variance in images by \sim 30%, increasing the signal-to-noise of lensing sources and reducing pixel noise contributions to the uncertainty in shear estimation. However, the technique was only demonstrated on isolated galaxies. Building upon this approach, we introduce deep-field AnaCal , an extension of AnaCal , that calibrates the shape measurement using the shear responses derived from the deep-field survey data. Furthermore, we generalize this technique to account for the effects of blending and incorporate corrections for shear-dependent detection bias. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2 we give a brief overview of the FPFS shear estimator within the AnaCal framework and introduce the formalism for deep-field AnaCal . In Section 3 we present galaxy image simulations that we used to test our method. In Section 4 , we cover the main results of our work and tests of shear calibration for isolated galaxies (Sec. 4.1 ) and blended galaxies (Sec. 4.2 ). In Section 4.3 , we address the issue of sample variance in the deep-field images.