A quantitative analysis of leading edge vortices in flapping wing aerodynamics

Alejandro Gonzalo, Manuel García-Villalba, Oscar Flores, [2ex] Department of Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States, [1ex] Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Heat TransferTU Wien, Vienna, Austria, [1ex] Aerospace Engineering DepartmentUniversidad Carlos III de Madrid, · 2025

Read A quantitative analysis of leading edge vortices in flapping wing aerodynamics by Alejandro Gonzalo, Manuel García-Villalba, Oscar Flores, [2ex] Department of Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States, [1ex] Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Heat TransferTU Wien, Vienna, Austria, [1ex] Aerospace Engineering DepartmentUniversidad Carlos III de Madrid, (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05040.txt.

Introduction

A leading edge vortex is the swirling structure that boosts lift on flapping wings, yet describing it quantitatively is hard. Alejandro Gonzalo, lead author with two co-authors, propose a method for that description in a 2025 aerodynamics paper. Their approach works in stages on flow data around a flapping wing.

First, a standard criterion identifies vortical structures, with little sensitivity to threshold choice. A thinning algorithm then finds the vortex core, using local vorticity direction to separate it. Finally, flow quantities are averaged along the core. Applied to forward flight data, the method shows the vortex growing smoothly before splitting near mid-downstroke.

Catalog record

CREATORAlejandro Gonzalo, Manuel García-Villalba, Oscar Flores, [2ex] Department of Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States, [1ex] Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Heat TransferTU Wien, Vienna, Austria, [1ex] Aerospace Engineering DepartmentUniversidad Carlos III de Madrid,
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE53 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05040

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A quantitative analysis of leading edge vortices in flapping wing aerodynamics Alejandro Gonzalo, Manuel García-Villalba, Oscar Flores, [2ex] Department of Mechanical EngineeringUniversity of Washington, Seattle, WA, United States, [1ex] Institute of Fluid Mechanics, Heat TransferTU Wien, Vienna, Austria, [1ex] Aerospace Engineering DepartmentUniversidad Carlos III de Madrid, Spain[1ex] Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract The leading edge vortex (LEV) is one of the most important lift augmentation mechanisms in flapping wing aerodynamics. We propose a methodology that aims to provide a quantitative description of the LEV. The first step of the method consists of the identification of the vortical structures surrounding the wing using the Q Q criterion. The impact of the employed threshold is shown to be minor, not influencing the observed trends. In the second step we identify the core of the LEV using a thinning algorithm, discriminating the LEV using the orientation of the locally averaged vorticity vector. Finally, we compute relevant flow quantities along the LEV core, by averaging in planes perpendicular to the local vorticity at the LEV core points. We have applied this methodology to flow data corresponding to a pair of wings performing a flapping motion in forward flight at moderate Reynolds number. We have performed a geometrical characterization of the LEV and we have computed several flow quantities along the LEV core. For the particular configuration under study, we have shown that the LEV, during the first half of the downstroke develops and grows increasing its circulation smoothly. Approximately at mid-downstroke the leading edge vortex starts splitting and its downstream part is advected towards the wake while keeping its circulation rather constant. Finally, we have briefly explored the link between the sectional lift on the wing and the local circulation obtained with the present methodology. Keywords: Flapping wings, leading edge vortex, unsteady aerodynamics 1 Introduction In recent years there is a growing interest in the development of bio-inspired micro air vehicles (MAVs) that mimic the flight of insects and small birds ( Haider et al. 2021 ) . Such development efforts require a deep understanding of the unsteady aerodynamic mechanisms behind their flapping flight, in order to guide the design of MAVs able to exploit these mechanisms for enhanced maneuverability. These unsteady mechanisms were identified rather early ( Ellington 1984 ) and are well known: leading edge vortex (LEV), clap-and-fling, wake capture, etc ( Shyy et al. 2013 ; Liu et al. 2024 ) . Among them, probably the most important one is the LEV ( Eldredge & Jones 2019 ) In spite of this, it has proven difficult to use this knowledge for the systematic design of MAVs. Probably the reason behind is that, at present, the acquired knowledge is mostly of a qualitative nature. For example, it is well known that an attached LEV provides additional lift ( Ellington et al. 1996 ; Dickinson et al. 1999 ) , however, it is difficult to predict exactly how much additional lift is obtained as a function of the large number of parameters involved in flapping flight. Furthermore, for a general flapping motion, the LEV might present a non-trivial 3D structure, whose precise geometry, location and intensity is very difficult to predict a priori. In the literature, several approaches are used to identify the LEV. For instance, Visbal 2011a ; Visbal 2011b used pressure contours to qualitatively identify vortices as regions of low pressure. Visbal et al. 2013 determined some specific features of the LEV (e.g. the motion of the legs of the arch-vortex) by means of the phase-averaged surface pressure. Other authors employ the vorticity field to identify the vortices ( Birch & Dickinson 2003 ; Taira & Colonius 2009 ; Jones & Babinsky 2011 ; Jardin & David 2014 ; Calderon et al. 2014 ) . Thus, regions with high vorticity values are considered vortices, although it is important to note that this magnitude is also high in shear layers. There are other local approaches based on the velocity gradient tensor that do not present this limitation. Among others, the Q ( Hunt et al. 1988 ) and the \lambda_{2} ( Jeong & Hussain 1995 ) criteria are extensively used in the unsteady aerodynamics field to identify vortical structures ( Taira & Colonius 2009 ; Kweon & Choi 2010 ; Visbal 2011a ; Jardin et al. 2012 ; Harbig et al. 2013 ; Jantzen et al. 2014 ; Harbig et al. 2014 ; Kolomenskiy et al. 2014 ; Zhang et al. 2020 ; Lee et al. 2022 ; Son et al. 2022 ; Wei et al. 2023 ; Chen et al. 2023 ) . All these approaches have been used to explain qualitatively the flow features observed around the wing, such as the LEV, the tip vortices (TiVs) and the trailing edge vortex (TEV). In order to characterize the effect of the LEV on the aerodynamic forces generated by flapping wings, it is important to provide quantitative information in addition to qualitative one. This includes for example the precise determination of the relative position of the LEV with respect to the wing and the quantification of the LEV intensity. Several authors have attempted to tackle this issue. Birch et al. 2004 performed experiments on revolving wings at constant angular velocity, observing a stable LEV on the wing. They integrated the vorticity over wing cross-sections to estimate the local circulation around the wing. Jones & Babinsky 2011 performed a similar experiment at a somewhat higher Reynolds number than Birch et al. 2004 . They identified the vortices using the vortex identification method of Graftieaux et al. 2001 . They studied the geometry and location of the LEV as a function of time by analyzing several wing cross-sections. The growth of the LEV at a given cross-section was quantified by computing the local circulation as a function of time. Jardin & David 2014 performed direct numerical simulations of flow over a wing undergoing different maneuvers. They characterized the LEV by analyzing the midspan plane and computing the local circulation as a function of the distance traveled by the wing. Jantzen et al. 2014 performed direct numerical simulations and experiments of flat-plate rectangular wings undergoing pitching maneuvers about the leading edge. They tracked the LEV along the midspan plane employing the same vortex identification method ( Graftieaux et al. 2001 ) as Jones & Babinsky 2011 . They also evaluated the vortex strength by integrating the spanwise vorticity inside the vortex core boundary. These results were limited to a 2D plane, but the flow visualizations showed that the LEV was a complex 3D structure, so that different results might have been obtained at other cross-sections. Lastly, Chen et al. 2022 investigated how Reynolds number affects the dynamics and stability of LEV formation in revolving rectangular plates. Building on prior knowledge of LEV dynamics in revolving wings, they employed cylindrical slices along the spanwise direction to locate the LEV region and estimate its vorticity and circulation. These curved slices are aligned with the wing’s motion and the shape of the shed LEV, helping to better characterize its intensity. This methodology has also been used to characterize the LEV evolution during the rapid rotation of flapping wings ( Chen & Wu 2024 ) . In this article, we

Read the complete text