Embezzlement as a “Self-Test” for Infinite Copies of Entangled States
Li Liu · 2025
Read Embezzlement as a “Self-Test” for Infinite Copies of Entangled States by Li Liu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05036.txt.
Introduction
Entanglement embezzlement lets a fixed catalyst state generate other entangled states without being used up. Li Liu investigates the internal structure that makes that trick possible in a solo 2025 quantum information paper. The analysis uses operator algebra tools for systems with no finite dimension cap.
Liu shows that if a catalyst can embezzle a target state, it must contain infinitely many commuting, locally structured copies of that target. That requirement works like a self-test, certifying the hidden copies. The results clarify what any embezzling catalyst must look like inside, and offer new tools for state certification in such quantum systems.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Li Liu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 40 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05036
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Embezzlement as a “Self-Test” for Infinite Copies of Entangled States Li Liu Abstract We investigate the operator-algebraic structure underlying entanglement embezzlement, a phenomenon where a fixed entangled state (the catalyst) can be used to generate arbitrary target entangled states without being consumed. We show that the ability to embezzle a target state g g imposes strong internal constraints on the catalyst state f f : specifically, f f must contain infinitely many mutually commuting, locally structured copies of g g . This property is formalized using C*-algebraic tools and is analogous to a form of self-testing, certifying the presence of infinite copies of g g within f f . Our results clarify the structural requirements for embezzlement and provide new conceptual tools for analyzing state certification in infinite-dimensional quantum systems. 1 Introduction Embezzlement of entanglement is a very striking phenomena in quantum information: a special “catalyst” state allows Alice and Bob to locally create entanglement seemingly for free, without consuming the catalyst. Since its discovery by van Dam and Hayden [ 9 ] , embezzlement has played a role in nonlocal games [ 4 , 5 ] , complexity theory [ 6 ] , and the study of entanglement as a resource [ 12 ] . The original construction by van Dam and Hayden was formulated in finite dimensions, but more recent developments in infinite-dimensional and operator-algebraic settings have revealed deeper structural phenomena [ 10 , 11 ] . These are particularly relevant when analyzing the ultimate constraints on quantum correlations. To understand embezzlement better, a natural question is what structural features a state must have in order to function as an embezzler. In recent work [ 10 ] , it was shown that any universal embezzler must generate a Type III 1 von Neumann factor. In this work, we show something more concrete about the structure an embezzler must have, in terms of states it must contain rather than the type of von Neumann algebra it must be. Most of the previous studies, including the original paper by van Dam and Hayden, consider embezzlement in the approximate regime . In this work, we focus instead on exact embezzlement of entanglement , which is more restrictive than the approximate case. All of our results concern exact embezzlement, where the catalyst remains completely unchanged and the target state is obtained exactly as specified using local operations. We start by altering the embezzlement protocol by removing the separable state \ket{00} from the input, and show that this new no-input embezzlement is equivalent to the original embezzlement protocol. By removing the \ket{00} , we perform isomorphisms on the catalyst state instead of unitary operations. It allows us to define isomorphisms that maps the catalyst state to the catalyst tensor infinite copies of the target state without running into issues of orthogonality of Hilbert spaces due to reference vector mismatches if we keep the \ket{00} inputs. We show that the ability to embezzle a given target state g imposes strong internal constraints on the catalyst state f . Specifically, if f can be used to embezzle g , then f must contain infinitely many mutually commuting copies of g , with g ’s locality preserved. This is similar to the idea of self-testing. A self-test certifies the presence of a specific entangled state by analyzing correlations produced by local measurements, without assuming anything about the internal workings of the devices. In our case, we use embezzlement to certify the existence of some infinite-copies of state g within the catalyst f . However, unlike traditional self-testing, this approach does not rely on any specific set of observables or measurement statistics. We ground our certification based on the ability to perform exact embezzlement mathematically, which in itself does not contribute an experiment that can be performed to verify the procedure. In [ 6 ] , a non-local game was proposed to verify the embezzlement of a Bell state. We could potentially use this non-local game as a verification procedure to certify the existence of infinite copies of Bell states within the catalyst. However, it is not clear in general how to certify universal embezzlement protocols through experiments. Furthermore, in recent paper [ 7 ] , an approximate universal embezzlement protocol was proposed using a catalyst state that consists of tensor product of all infinite-copies of entangled states with rational Schmidt coefficients. One criticism about such embezzler is that the state seems unnecessarily large. We show that with the main results from this paper, in order to have an embezzlement protocol that can exactly embezzle a dense set of states with all rational Schmidt coefficients, it is necessary for the catalyst to have the structure proposed in [ 7 ] . However, it is not clear if similar result can be extended to the proposed exact universal embezzler for all states, due to the technical challenges in taking the tensor product of uncountably many states simultaneously. The main contributions are as follows: • We establish the equivalence between standard and ”no-input” models of exact embezzlement in the infinite-dimensional setting, giving a precise operator-algebraic formulation. • We prove that exact embezzlement is equivalent to the presence of infinitely many disjoint copies of the target state within the catalyst, and formalize this using C*-algebraic tools. • We show that in order for a catalyst to embezzle any states with rational Schmidt coefficients exactly, it must contain tensor product of infinite copies of all those states simultaneously. Beyond exact embezzlement, our results raise new questions about robustness: is approximate embezzlement also a “robust self-test” for infinite copies of entanglement? Developing such a theory would connect directly to central themes in nonlocal games and quantum cryptography 2 No-Input Embezzlement We start by showing that to perform embezzlement, the input of separable state \ket{00} is not necessary. Following the proof of equivalences betweenstandard and no-input embezzlement, we describe no-input embezzlement using the C*-algebraic model, and explain why it is more natural than the commuting operator model. As a result, the rest of the paper will adopt the C*-algebraic model instead of the commuting operator model. 2.1 Equivalence between Standard and No-input Embezzlement In entanglement embezzlement [ 9 ] , a fixed bipartite state \ket{\psi_{c}}\in\mathcal{H}_{A}\otimes\mathcal{H}_{B} is used as a catalyst to simulate or extract a target entangled state \ket{\psi}\in\mathbb{C}^{n}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{n} , without consuming \ket{\psi_{c}} . In the standard formulation, this is expressed as: \ket{\psi_{c}}\otimes\ket{00}\longmapsto\ket{\psi_{c}}\otimes\ket{\psi}, where \ket{\psi_{c}} is the catalyst state and \ket{00} is the separable input state. However, in many infinite-dimensional constructions, we consider an alternative formulation known as no-input embezzlement , where the protocol directly maps \ket{\psi_{c}}\longmapsto\ket{\psi_{c}}\otimes\ket{\psi}, without requiring any ancillary input. This variation simplifies many constructions and aligns with operator-algebraic models where explicit tensoring with finite ancillas is avoided. The original van Dam and Hayden construction also uses this no-input version of embezzlement. In [ 10 ] , the authors also showed that the two versions of embezzlements are equivalent to each other. We note that their paper is showing equivalence of embezzlement in the approximate case whereas our result is in the exact case. We begin by showing that these two notions of embezzlement are equivalent. Proposition 1 (Equivalence of Embezzlement Models) . Let \ket{\psi}\in\mathbb{C}^{n}\otimes\mathbb{C}^{n} be an entangled state. The following