Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null 2025 Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null – A

P. J. Cargill, A. W. Hood, D. Johnson · 2025

Read Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null 2025 Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null – A by P. J. Cargill, A. W. Hood, D. Johnson (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-05032.txt.

Introduction

At a magnetic null in the solar corona, heat conduction cools plasma in a pattern set by the earlier heated state. P. J. Cargill, lead author with two co-authors, examine that cooling in a 2025 solar physics paper. They set up an equilibrium balancing thermal conduction against uniform heating, then switch the heating off.

An equation for cooling follows from separation of variables. Remarkably, the cooling equations match the equilibrium equations after a simple change of variables, so the equilibrium determines the cooling phase. For a two-dimensional null, the cooling timescale grows by a modest factor set by flux element areas.

Catalog record

CREATORP. J. Cargill, A. W. Hood, D. Johnson
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE42 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-05032

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null 2025 Heating and cooling at a coronal magnetic null – A P. J. Cargill, A. W. Hood, D. Johnson Abstract Conductive cooling of the solar corona at a magnetic null is examined. An initial equilibrium is set up, balancing thermal conduction and a constant, spatially uniform coronal heating. The heating is then turned off and the subsequent conductive cooling calculated. An equation for the cooling is obtained using the method of separation of variables and it is shown that the equations for the equilibrium between conduction and heating, and the time-dependent cooling are mathematically identical with a simple change of variables. Thus the properties of the cooling phase are automatically determined by the equilibrium state. For a two-dimensional null, the characteristic cooling timescale increases over that in a straight field by a factor of between 2 and 5, with a scaling determined by the ratio of the average and base areas of a flux element. There is no explicit dependence on the very large areas that can arise near the null. 1 Introduction In the solar corona, magnetic nulls are locations where the magnetic field vanishes. They can arise in two- or three-dimensional geometries ( Priest & Forbes 2000 , e.g.) and form an important part of the coronal magnetic field structure. Magnetic fields at the photosphere appear as discrete sources arising as positive and negative polarity pairs. Four sources of similar flux will have at least one null point. In addition, such null points are coronal regions where heating is likely to occur. Indeed, recent work by Cheng et al. 2023 identified a local ‘hot’ spot at a coronal null point with sustained emission around 10 MK seen from the AIA 131 Å channel. In general terms, the plasma properties of a coronal null are determined by the energy balance between localised plasma heating, and cooling by thermal conduction and optically thin radiation. A first approach was due to Johnson et al. 2024 , who derived analytic solutions for the equilibrium temperature in the vicinity of a two-dimensional null by balancing conductive losses and two different coronal heating functions (both constant in time but one spatially uniform and one with magnitude proportional to B^{2} ). The temperature profiles arising from each heating function differ considerably, and include singular solutions in the former case that are removed by perpendicular thermal conductivity. This paper develops the work of Johnson et al. 2024 and considers the conductive cooling of plasma around a two-dimensional null. The null magnetic field profile makes conductive cooling there especially interesting because the field strength varies rapidly. In turn, this implies that the cross-sectional area of an elemental flux tube associated with a given field line also varies. It is well known that conductive cooling of a hot plasma can be strongly dependent on this cross-sectional area, with an increase in area in the region of hot plasma inhibiting conductive cooling (e.g. Antiochos & Sturrock 1976 ; Cargill et al. 2022 ). In turn this raises the possibility of the lifetime of hot plasma near a null being extended from that associated with a straight field as in, for example, a braiding model of coronal heating, and may be of importance in accounting for the faint active region emission from hot plasma in excess of 5 MK ( Reale et al. 2009 ; Testa et al. 2011 ; Schmelz & Pathak 2012 , e.g.) . Accounting for this emission in a braided field has some difficulties due to the very effective field-aligned conduction in a roughly uniform magnetic field (see discussion in Barnes et al. 2016 ). Hence, alternative field geometries might provide a longer-lived hot plasma. Conductive cooling around a null is investigated by taking the two equilibria of Johnson et al. 2024 and studying the cooling after the heating is turned off. As before, optically thin radiation is neglected. We use a conductive cooling model originally proposed by Antiochos & Sturrock 1976 hereafter AS76. However, for the case of spatially uniform heating, there is an interesting (and quite general) ‘short cut’ for solving conductive cooling that does not require a full solution of the cooling equation. Section 2 outlines the magnetic field and cooling models used, including the addition of a ‘guide field’ to the work of Johnson et al. 2024 . Section 3 presents the results for all cases, and shows that simple scalings can account for some, though not all, of the results. Section 4 discusses the distribution of hot plasma around the null during the cooling phase and Section 5 summarises some limitations of the model. 2 Two-dimensional null equilibria Johnson et al. 2024 obtained static plasma equilibria between a heating term and conductive cooling in a magnetic field with a null point. In this paper, we will be interested in plasma with temperature of order 10 MK, density of 10^{9}\rm cm^{-3} and characteristic length scales of 25 Mm. For these parameters, optically thin radiation can be neglected ( Cargill 1993 , e.g.) . Indeed in a plasma heated to a high enough temperature, the radiative cooling phase will always follow the conductive cooling phase ( Cargill et al. 1995 ) . The equilibria are then given by: {\bf B}\cdot\nabla\left(\frac{\kappa_{0}T^{5/2}}{B^{2}}{\bf B}\cdot\nabla T\right)=-H_{0}f(B)\;, (1) where T is the temperature, {\bf B} and B the field vector and its magnitude respectively, \kappa_{0}=8\times 10^{-7} in cgs units ( Bradshaw & Cargill 2013 , e.g.) and H_{0}f(B) is the heating per unit volume with f(B) permitting a dependence on B . Normalising the spatial dimensions to a length L , which is taken as the half-width of the model box (see Figure 1 ), and simplifying the equations by defining the quantity G=T^{7/2} gives: {\bf B}\cdot\nabla\left(\frac{1}{B^{2}}{\bf B}\cdot\nabla G\right)=-\frac{7H_{0}L^{2}}{2\kappa_{0}}f(B)=-H^{*}f(B)\;, (2) where H^{*}=7H_{0}L^{2}/2\kappa_{0} is the heating in units of G . The magnetic field around a two-dimensional magnetic null is defined in cartesian coordinates, {\bf r}=(x,y,z) , as: {{\bf B}=\frac{B_{0}}{L}(0,y,-z)}\;, (3) where y and z lie between -1 and 1 and B_{0}/L is a constant whose value is arbitrary since it appears in both the numerator and denominator in ( 1 ). For simplicity we set it to unity. This field can also be defined by the x-component of the vector potential: A_{x}=yz 1 1 1 The symbol A is retained for the cross-sectional area of a flux element . The field lines and field strength are shown in the left panel of Figure 1 . For convenience in this paper, we consider only the upper right quadrant in this figure with y and z positive. A field line is defined as starting on the upper boundary at a point y=y_{0},z=1,A_{x}=y_{0} , where 0<y_{0}<1 , and reaches the right hand side boundary at the point y=1,z=y_{0},A_{x}=y_{0} . The mid-point of the field line is at y=z=\sqrt{y_{0}} , and the temperature profile is symmetric about this point. Hereafter, we refer to this as the symmetry point of any field line. Thus, one need only solve for the temperature between the upper boundary and the symmetry point. [There is a direct analogy with the temperature distribution along magnetic field lines in closed coronal loop models where the temperature is fixed at the photospheric

Read the complete text