Internal Stresses as Origin of the Anomalous Low-Temperature Specific Heat in Glasses
Walter Schirmacher, Giancarlo Ruocco · 2025
Read Internal Stresses as Origin of the Anomalous Low-Temperature Specific Heat in Glasses by Walter Schirmacher, Giancarlo Ruocco (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04986.txt.
Introduction
Glasses absorb more heat at very low temperatures than simple sound-wave theory predicts. Walter Schirmacher and one co-author explain that anomaly using frozen-in internal stresses in a 2025 theoretical physics paper. Their approach applies a recent theory of nonphononic vibrational states, the extra vibrations in glasses beyond ordinary sound waves.
Within a fully harmonic description, local excitations hybridise with waves to create an excess density of states. That excess produces a specific heat whose apparent temperature exponent falls between one and two, matching experiments. The authors discuss using the findings to characterise glassy materials, and contrast their harmonic account with theories needing tunnelling.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Walter Schirmacher, Giancarlo Ruocco |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 32 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04986
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Internal Stresses as Origin of the Anomalous Low-Temperature Specific Heat in Glasses Walter Schirmacher, Giancarlo Ruocco Abstract We apply a recently developed theory of the nonphononic vibrational density of states (DOS) in glasses to investigate the impact of local frozen-in stresses on the low-temperature specific heat. Using a completely harmonic description we show that the hybridization of the local nonphononic vibrational excitations with the waves leads to a low-frequency DOS, in excess to the Debye one, which varies linearly with frequency up to a certain crossover frequency, and then becomes constant. The actual value of the crossover depends of the ratio between the local stresses and the shear modulus. This excess DOS leads to a low-temperature specific heat with an apparent temperature exponent, which is between one and two, as observed experimentally. We discuss, how these findings may be utilized for the characterisation of glassy materials. We further compare our findings, which only rely on harmonic interactions, with the predictions of other theories, which invoke anharmonic interactions and tunneling for explaining the low-temperature behavior of the specific heat. The low-frequency spectral properties of glasses and the related low-temperature properties are very different from those of their crystalline counterparts. Zeller and Pohl 1971 ; Phillips 1981 ; Ramos 2022 . For example, the specific heat of glasses does not show the Debye temperature ( T ) law C(T)\sim T^{3} , observed in crystals, but, instead, varies approximately as C(T)\sim T^{\alpha} with an exponent \alpha between 1 and 2 Zeller and Pohl 1971 ; Lasjaunias et al. 1974 ; Lasjaunias et al. 1975 ; Stephens 1976 ; Pohl 1981 ; Liu and von Löhneysen 1993 ; Phillips 1981 ; Ramos 2022 . A first interpretation of the very-low temperature thermal anomalies of glasses was given by Anderson, Halperin, Varma and Phillipps in 1972 Anderson et al. 1972 ; Phillips 1972 : It was conjectured that in a glass bistable structural configurations would exist, characterized by a double-well potential as a function of some configurational coordinate. Further, tunneling between adjacent potential wells was assumed to be possible, which establishes quantum-mechanical two-level systems (TLS). It was then assumed that such TLS defect centers exist with a certain concentration and with a broad (constant) distribution, P(\Delta E) , of energy splittings, \Delta E . This TLS model leads to a specific heat varying linearly with temperature ( \alpha=1 ). Although the tunneling model is nowadays widely accepted as explanation of the low-temperature anomalies Würger 1997 , and is even called “standard tunneling model” Klinger 2010 , severe criticism has been expressed Yu and Leggett 1988 . Indeed, in the temperature range of 1 K the thermal de-Broglie wavelength of matter waves \lambda=h[mk_{B}T]^{-1/2} (where h and k_{B} are the Planck and Boltzmann constants, and m is the mass of a molecular unit) is only a few percent of an angstrom for atomic masses larger than 10, which makes the existence of quantum tunneling in this temperature regime rather improbable. It has, however, been pointed out that bistable structural rearrangements might involve rather small single-atom displacements, which would then allow for quantum tunneling Vegge et al. 2001 ; Lubchenko and Wolynes 2001 . Alternative suggestions for explaining the low-temperature thermal anomalies of glasses are based on interacting defects Yu and Leggett 1988 , on elastic dipoles Grannan et al. 1990 , or on the soft-potential model, which relies on the assumption of anharmonic defect states Karpov et al. 1983 ; Buchenau et al. 1991 ; Gurevich et al. 2003 . Most of the presently existing specific heat data have been evaluated using the TLS and soft-potential models Ramos 2020 ; Ramos 2022 . As mentioned, the existing explanations of the anomalous low-T behavior of the specific heat rely mainly on the presence of anharmonic interactions, often in the form of double-well shaped interatomic potentials. Here, we propose another possibility of explaining the low-temperature anomalies of the specific heat, which invokes neither quantum mechanics, nor anharmonicity. We present arguments that the spectral density of harmonic vibrations (density of states, DOS) g(\omega) contains a low-frequency contribution, in addition to the Debye g(\omega)\sim\omega^{2} law which leads to a specific heat with a scaling exponent \alpha which turns from 1 to 2 on lowering the temperature. These contributions arise from vortex-shaped pattern of vibrations around local frozen-in stresses. The presence of frozen-in stresses in glasses is well known to glass blowers and is widely used for industrial applications, e.g. tailoring the surface properties of utility materials Fotheringham 2021 . Evidence for the (unavoidable) existence of local, randomly distributed stresses in glasses has been presented in the literature from computer simulations Egami et al. 1980 ; Vitek and Egami 1987 ; Chen et al. 1988 and from considering the microscopic derivation of continuum elasticity Lutsko 1988 ; Lutsko 1989 ; Alexander 1998 ; Schirmacher et al. 2024 . Experimentally internal stresses may be measured by indentation Wang et al. 2011 or by x-ray diffraction Wu et al. 2015 . In a recent study, based on an entirely harmonic analysis, the continuum limit of the Hessian (dynamical) matrix of a glass was studied Schirmacher et al. 2024 . It was found, that the low-frequency nonphononic (not wavelike) vibrational excitations of small computer-simulated glasses are mainly governed by the local stresses. The nonphononic character of the excitations was guaranteed by considering small enough systems, which do not allow for low-frequency waves. By combining theory with molecular-dynamics simulations, these excitations (called “type-II modes”) were identified as nonirrotational, vortexlike states Schirmacher et al. 2024 . The spectrum of these states were shown to be related to the distribution of small stresses. Small stresses imply small forces, which occur at molecular separations, where the interpaticle-interaction potential has small values of its first derivative. In numerical simulations this artificially makes the low-frequency DOS very sensitive to the smoothed cutoff (tapering). A tapering, which guarantees continuity of the first two derivatives of the potential ( m=2 ) was shown to result in a DOS scaling as g(\omega)\sim\omega^{4} , whereas a tapering with m=\infty leads to g(\omega)\sim\omega^{3} . In real systems, for potentials with a minimum (like a Lennard-Jones potential) a scaling according to g(\omega)\sim\omega^{5} emerges. These results were obtained by considering the modification of the frequency-dependent shear modulus by the nonphononic excitations in the absence of waves in the interesting small frequency region. Schirmacher et al. 2024 . In the following we turn our attention to real, macroscopic, glasses and consider the influence of such vortexlike vibrational states on the DOS, coexisting with wavelike excitations in the same frequency range. We shall show that, in addition to the modification of the shear elasticity, there exists also a direct contribution to the low-frequency DOS, which just reflects the statistics of the local stresses. As already mentioned, such small stresses arise from the minimum of the intermolecular potentials, and exhibit a flat distribution, resulting in a DOS, which depends only weakly on frequency. In Refs. Alexander 1984 ; Alexander 1998 ; Schirmacher et al. 2024 it is shown that the continuum limit of the harmonic energy of a system, interacting via a pair potential \phi(r_{ij}) does not only involve the usual strain degrees of freedom, as considered in elasticity theory Born