Note on searching for critical lattice models as entropy critical points from strange correlator

Anran Jin, Ling-Yan Hung · 2025

Read Note on searching for critical lattice models as entropy critical points from strange correlator by Anran Jin, Ling-Yan Hung (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04947.txt.

Introduction

Critical points in lattice models can be hard to find when systems are small. Anran Jin and one co-author apply an entropy-based strategy to that search in a 2025 note on strange correlators. The strategy uses an entropy function designed to detect criticality even at small system size, combined with transfer matrices built from a topological holographic principle.

The authors find the combination cost-effective for identifying critical boundary conditions. It also estimates central charges and maps entire phase diagrams in a multi-dimensional parameter space. Their note presents the method as an efficient route to critical lattice models.

Catalog record

CREATORAnran Jin, Ling-Yan Hung
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE120 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04947

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Note on searching for critical lattice models as entropy critical points from strange correlator Anran Jin, Ling-Yan Hung Abstract An entropy function is proposed in Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 as a way to detect criticality even when the system size is small. In this note we apply this strategy in the search for criticality of lattice transfer matrices constructed based on the topological holographic principle. We find that the combination of strategy is indeed a cost-effective and efficient way of identifying critical boundary conditions, estimating central charges and moreover, plotting entire phase diagrams in a multi-dimensional phase space. I Introduction It is well known that statistical models undergoing second-order phase transitions exhibit scaling behavior with diverging correlation length. Historically, these statistical models particularly in 2 dimension had led to the discoveries of families of 2D conformal field theories Baxter 2016 . Recently, such interest is revived, making use of the topological holographic principle Ji and Wen 2020 ; Gaiotto and Kulp 2021 ; Apruzzi et al. 2023 ; Freed et al. 2024 and its explicit discrete realization, called the strange correlator Aasen et al. 2020 ; Aasen et al. 2016 ; Vanhove et al. 2018 . The idea is to construct appropriate boundary conditions to a 3D discrete TQFT such that the boundary is critical. The aggregate partition function thus produces 2D critical models with a given set of symmetries imposed by the 3D TQFT. The crucial problem is thus translated to one of searching for appropriate boundary conditions. It is thus of great utility if there are efficient ways to determine if a statistical model reaches criticality. To that end, it is proposed in Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 that an identity satisfied by the modular Hamiltonian and entanglement entropy of the ground state of 2D CFT can be a sensitive testing stone. It is observed that even for lattice wave-functions with very few spins (as few as four), it remains a sharp diagnosis. In comparison, usually to test criticality one could compute the entanglement entropy, and look for logarithmic dependence of the interval size i.e. S_{EE}(l)\sim c/3\ln l+\cdots , where l is the number of spins in the interval. To obtain such a logarithmic dependence requires a relatively long spin chain, making computation expensive. In this paper, we would like to test the entanglement identity proposed in Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 in the context of searching for critical boundary conditions for strange correlators. In particular, based on the ansatz we constructed in Ref. Chen et al. 2024 ; Hung et al. 2025 , we can test the utility of this identity in fixing the critical point while restricting the lattice to very small size. For a given strange correlator, one could obtain a transfer matrix over a cylinder. We solve for its ground state which is now a non-linear function of the boundary conditions of the 3D model, and we can scan through the couplings until the identity in Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 is satisfied. We find that this entanglement identity is indeed an efficient method as a first screen for criticality. Not only does it correctly recover to reasonable accuracy the correct critical points in the A-series lattice models, it also produces the same phase diagram of the Ashkin-Teller like model related to the A_{5} TQFT Kohmoto et al. 1981 , confirming the results in Ref. Hung et al. 2025 ; Shen 2025 with a very small lattice. Our paper is organized as follows. We first review the entanglement identity in Section II and also the strange correlator construction of critical lattice models in Section III . Then we present explicit illustration that one can recover accurate critical couplings in small lattices based on numerical simulation in Section IV . II CFT as critical points of entropy function We briefly review the entropic criterion of CFT ground states proposed in Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 . On an interval [x_{1},x_{2}] within an infinite line, the 1+1D CFT ground state has entanglement entropy S_{[x_{1},x_{2}]} Calabrese and Cardy 2009 and entanglement Hamiltonian K_{[x_{1},x_{2}]} Cardy and Tonni 2016 \begin{split}&S_{[x_{1},x_{2}]}=\frac{c}{3}\log\frac{x_{2}-x_{1}}{\epsilon}\\ &K_{[x_{1},x_{2}]}=2\pi\int_{x_{1}}^{x_{2}}dx\frac{(x-x_{1})(x_{2}-x)}{x_{2}-x_{1}}T_{00}(x)+\text{ const.,}\end{split} (1) where c is the central charge, \epsilon is the uniform UV cutoff, T the stress-energy tensor, and const. is a number that depends only on the UV cutoff \epsilon . Define the entropic function S_{\Delta} and operator K_{\Delta} of a state \ket{\psi} on an infinite system shown in Fig. 1 (a) as S_{\Delta}(\ket{\psi}):=(S_{AB}+S_{BC})-\eta(S_{A}+S_{C})-(1-\eta)(S_{B}+S_{ABC}), (2) \quad K_{\Delta}(\ket{\psi}):=(K_{AB}+K_{BC})-\eta(K_{A}+K_{C})-(1-\eta)(K_{B}+K_{ABC}), (3) where \eta=\frac{(x_{2}-x_{1})(x_{4}-x_{3})}{(x_{3}-x_{1})(x_{4}-x_{2})} is the cross ratio of the interval. S_{X} and K_{X} are the entanglement entropy and entanglement Hamiltonian of the reduced density matrix \rho_{X}:=\text{Tr}_{\bar{X}}(\ket{\psi}\bra{\psi}) . Note that \bra{\psi}K_{X}\ket{\psi}=S_{X} . It can then be shown by direct calculation Lin and McGreevy 2023 that for the 1+1D CFT ground state \ket{\psi_{\text{CFT}}} with central charge c the following entropic identities hold S_{\Delta}(\ket{\psi_{\text{CFT}}})=\frac{c}{3}h(\eta)\quad K_{\Delta}(\ket{\psi_{\text{CFT}}})=\frac{c}{3}h(\eta)I, (4) where I is the identity operator. The same result can be derived for CFT on a closed circle shown in Fig. 1 (b) with the cross-ratio \eta=\frac{\sin[\pi(x_{2}-x_{1})/L]\sin[\pi(x_{4}-x_{3})/L]}{\sin[\pi(x_{3}-x_{1})/L]\sin[\pi(x_{4}-x_{2})/L]} , where L is the circumference of the circle. Figure 1 : The entropy function Eq. ( 2 ) can be defined on (a) an infinite line and (b) a closed circle. \eta is the corresponding cross-ratio. In Ref. Lin and McGreevy 2023 , the authors verified numerically that Eq. ( 4 ) is satisfied approximately by a wide range of critical lattice models with a smallest system size of four spins. The error in the approximation decreases as a power law as the system size increases. Since the evaluation of the entropy functions is entirely local, this entropic criterion of CFT ground state is indeed efficient. Further to Eq. ( 4 ), if we take derivative of the entropy function S_{\Delta} , it can be shown that for a CFT ground state Lin and McGreevy 2023 , the derivative dS_{\Delta}(\ket{\psi_{\text{CFT}}})=0. (5) Hence, the CFT ground states lie at the critical points of the entropy function S_{\Delta} . This is shown to be equivalent to Eq. ( 4 ). Since in this work, we will be flowing the boundary conditions with respect to some parameters, Eq. ( 5 ) will be used primarily. III Strange correlator formalism III.1 Topological ground state The strange correlator formalism is an observation that classes of (1+1)D critical lattice model partition functions can be constructed as the inner product between the ground state wave-functions \ket{\Psi} of (2+1)D topological orders and some product state \bra{\Omega} Vanhove et al. 2018 ; Aasen et al. 2020 ; Aasen et al. 2016 . The topological ground state is represented as the string-net tensor network on 2D trivalent lattices Levin and Wen 2005 or equivalently the Turaev-Viro state-sum Turaev and Viro 1992 on the dual triangulation. We intentionally choose the discretization to be the square-octagon lattice shown in Fig. 2 (a) to manifest the symmetries of CFT. As shown in Fig. 2 (b), at each tensor location, the local tensor is six-legged with three physical degrees of freedom i,j,k and three auxiliary degrees of freedom \alpha,\beta,\gamma . These degrees of freedom take value in the simple objects of the input unitary fusion category (UFC), and the value of the local tensor is proportional to the quantum 6 j -symbol

Read the complete text