Effective LQG dynamics of a thin shell and the fate of a collapsing star
Francesco Fazzini · 2025
Read Effective LQG dynamics of a thin shell and the fate of a collapsing star by Francesco Fazzini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04945.txt.
Introduction
A collapsing star might bounce instead of ending in a singularity, under loop quantum gravity inspired models. Francesco Fazzini examines the fate of that bounce in a solo 2025 physics paper. In the model studied, the bounce is generally followed by shell-crossing singularities, which threaten the physical sense of the evolution.
Fazzini derives the dynamics of a thin dust shell inside the effective Hamiltonian framework. The shell's motion stays timelike throughout. After the quantum-gravitational bounce it expands again. In time it emerges from the white-hole vacuum region. The build thus extends spacetime past the shell-crossing singularity in a physically meaningful way.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Francesco Fazzini |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 38 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04945
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Effective LQG dynamics of a thin shell and the fate of a collapsing star Francesco Fazzini Abstract Effective models inspired by loop quantum gravity typically resolve the central singularity by replacing it with a bounce of the matter density in the Planckian regime. In the specific model analyzed here, this bounce is generally followed by the formation of shell-crossing singularities. The purpose of this work is to provide a physically meaningful extension of spacetime beyond the shell-crossing singularity. To this end, we derive the dynamics of a dust thin shell within the effective Hamiltonian framework. The motion of the shell remains timelike throughout: after undergoing a quantum-gravitational bounce, it expands and eventually emerges from the white-hole vacuum region. I Introduction The fate of a black hole is a topic of central importance in astrophysics and quantum gravity. Einstein’s theory of gravity predicts that a black hole forms when a star collapses under its own weight, ultimately ending in a physical singularity. This result, first obtained for particular spherically symmetric initial configurations Oppenheimer:1939ue , was later generalized by Penrose Penrose:1964wq . Although the inclusion of pressure or the consideration of sufficiently small stellar masses can prevent black hole formation (see, e.g., chandrasekhar1931 ; oppenheimer1939 ), once a black hole forms, its singular fate is unavoidable within the classical theory. This picture is generally believed to be incomplete, and its completion is expected to require a quantum theory of gravity Penrose1980 . Indeed, during classical collapse, the stellar energy density eventually reaches the Planck regime, where quantum gravity effects are expected to play a dominant role. Among the candidate theories of quantum gravity, loop quantum gravity (LQG) Rovelli:2004tv ; Thiemann:2007pyv is a leading contender. Its symmetry-reduced sectors are nowadays capable, at least at the effective level, of addressing problems of major physical interest, such as stellar collapse (see, e.g., Kelly:2020lec ; Giesel:2023hys ; Modesto:2006qh ; Ziprick:2009nd ; Tavakoli:2013rna ; Rovelli:2014cta ; Barrau:2014hda ; Haggard:2014rza ; Barcelo:2014npa ; Barcelo:2014cla ; Barrau:2014yka ; Barrau:2015uca ; Christodoulou:2016vny ; Malafarina:2017csn ; Olmedo:2017lvt ; Bianchi:2018mml ; BenAchour:2020bdt ) and cosmological evolution (for reviews see Bojowald2005 ; Ashtekar2009 ). While the spherical symmetry reduction complicates the quantum analysis compared with the homogeneous sector (see, e.g., Husain:2022gwp ), where models are under control both at the effective and the quantum level, the effective approach remains extremely useful for studying how quantum gravity may affect gravitational collapse. It should be stressed that these effective models modify the classical setup in ways inspired by LQG, but at this stage they cannot yet be regarded as direct spherically symmetric loop quantizations. Among the different approaches, a particularly relevant one was first introduced in Kelly:2020uwj ; Kelly:2020lec . The strength of this approach lies in the fact that it reproduces the effective dynamics of loop quantum cosmology (LQC) in the homogeneous sector while retaining the correct classical limit. Quantum gravitational effects are indeed suppressed when scalar quantities remain far from the Planck regime, which is achieved by adopting the improved dynamics scheme of LQC Ashtekar:2006wn . Briefly, the canonical formulation is expressed in the usual Ashtekar–Barbero variables, and the modifications inspired by LQG are implemented only in the gravitational part of the Hamiltonian constraint. In contrast, the gravitational part of the diffeomorphism constraint, as well as the matter contributions to both the Hamiltonian and diffeomorphism constraints, are kept classical. The modification in the gravitational Hamiltonian affects the curvature term, which is “holonomized” by expressing it in terms of holonomies of the extrinsic curvature, with a physical length proportional to the Planck length. This framework is often referred to as the \bar{\mu}+K loop quantization scheme. Research in this direction has in recent years focused on dust collapse, both for the Oppenheimer–Snyder model (see, e.g., Kelly:2020lec ; Giesel:2023hys ; Han:2023wxg ; Cafaro:2024 ; Bobula:2023kbo ; Lewandowski:2022zce ; Fazzini:2023scu ) and for more general profiles beyond Oppenheimer–Snyder Husain:2022gwp ; Fazzini:2023ova ; Bobula:2024chr , in both the marginally and non-marginally bound cases Cipriani:2024nhx , as well as in the presence of pressure Cafaro:2024lre . A common feature of the dynamics studied in these works is the bouncing behavior of the stellar core when the energy density reaches the Planck regime (similarly to what occurs in LQC), due to quantum gravitational repulsion. The bounce is then followed by the formation of shell-crossing singularities (SCS). Shell-crossing singularities occur when two matter layers composing the star intersect during evolution, leading to a divergence in the energy density. This phenomenon already appears in the classical evolution of specific initial data, but it can be avoided at the classical level through an appropriate choice of the initial density profile Hellaby:1985 . Consequently, SCS are generally considered less pathological than the central singularity: geodesic deviations remain finite near them Szekeres:1995gy , and they do not represent a serious violation of the cosmic censorship conjecture Penrose:1999vj . However, while SCS can be avoided classically, within LQC-inspired effective collapse they turn out to be unavoidable. This has been shown to hold generally for dust collapse Fazzini:2023ova , and also for perfect and non-perfect fluids with pressure Cafaro:2024lre . As a result, SCS must be regarded as central features of effective stellar collapse, much as the central singularity is in classical collapse. Another reason why such singularities are often considered non-problematic is that, in principle, the spacetime can be extended beyond them. In the classical case, this has been achieved by considering weak solutions of the integral formulation of the evolution equations Nolan:2003wp ; Lasky:2006hq , since these equations take the form of hyperbolic conservation laws in Painlevé–Gullstrand coordinates, and shell-crossing singularities correspond to characteristic crossings of such conservation laws. After the crossing, the matter is concentrated into a non-isolated thin shell, and soon afterward the entire stellar content collapses as an isolated thin shell. However, the integral approach has significant drawbacks: it does not allow one to impose timelike motion of the thin shell, because it implicitly assumes that the Painlevé–Gullstrand time remains continuous across the shell. This assumption has been shown to be inconsistent with requiring subluminal motion for ordinary matter, and therefore unphysical Fazzini:2025zrq . Similar problems arise when the integral approach is applied to the effective case: the thin shell generated by the crossing of physical layers generally moves in a spacelike manner, with the precise dynamics depending on the specific formulation adopted Husain:2022gwp ; Fazzini:2025hsf ; Liu:2025fil . It is also worth noting that alternative approaches not based on weak solutions suffer from the same physical inconsistencies Sahlmann:2025fde . A possible way to overcome this superluminal issue is to study the effective thin shell dynamics within the Israel framework (see, e.g., Israel1966 ; Poisson2004 ; Berezin1990 ; Ansoldi2000 ; Crisostomo:2003bb ; HajicekKijowski1997 ), which guarantees timelike behavior. The aim of the present work is precisely to extend the Israel approach to the effective case and to investigate how a thin shell of matter evolves in the effective spacetime. The main result is the derivation of an effective dynamics for the dust thin shell that is always timelike, that admits the correct classical Israel limit, and that provides an approximation of the spacetime evolution after the formation of SCS. II The first Israel junction condition To describe the spacetime generated by the