On the equivariant cohomological rigidity of semi-free Hamiltonian circle actions

Liat Kessler, Nikolas Wardenski · 2025

Read On the equivariant cohomological rigidity of semi-free Hamiltonian circle actions by Liat Kessler, Nikolas Wardenski (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04890.txt.

Introduction

When do fixed point data and equivariant cohomology determine a space with a circle symmetry? Liat Kessler and one co-author address that rigidity question in a 2025 paper. They study six-dimensional semi-free Hamiltonian circle actions, a setting where earlier published conditions proved wrong as stated.

The authors had previously proved a corrected version that relied on a restrictive distribution of fixed points. Here they swap that assumption for a global condition on equivariant cohomology, one that any isomorphism requires. They also extend the result beyond the symplectic setting to the equivariant topological setting, aiming for a final statement.

Catalog record

CREATORLiat Kessler, Nikolas Wardenski
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE89 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04890

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On the equivariant cohomological rigidity of semi-free Hamiltonian circle actions Liat Kessler, Nikolas Wardenski Abstract . We consider semi-free Hamiltonian S 1 S^{1} -manifolds of dimension six and establish when the equivariant cohomology and data on the fixed point set determine the isomorphism type. Gonzales listed conditions under which the isomorphism type of such spaces is determined by fixed point data. We pointed out in an earlier paper that this result as stated is erroneous, and proved a corrected version. However, that version relied on a certain distribution of fixed points that is not at all necessary. In this paper, we replace the latter assumption with a global assumption on equivariant cohomology that is necessary for an isomorphism. We also extend our result to the equivariant (non-symplectic) topological category. The variation in the earlier paper was tailored to suit the requirements of Cho’s application of Gonzales’ statement to classify semi-free monotone, Hamiltonian S 1 S^{1} -manifolds of dimension six. In the current paper, we aim to give the definitive statement relating fixed point data and equivariant cohomology to the isomorphism type of a semi-free Hamiltonian S 1 S^{1} -manifold. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification 53D35 (55N91, 53D20, 58D19) 1. Introduction An effective action of a torus T=(S^{1})^{d} on a symplectic manifold (M,\omega) is Hamiltonian if it admits a momentum map : \mu\colon M\to\mathbb{R}^{d}\cong(\Lie(S^{1})^{d})^{*} with d\mu(\cdot)(\xi)=-\omega(\bar{\xi},\cdot) for every \xi\in\Lie(S^{1})^{d} , where \bar{\xi} is the fundamental vector field of the action corresponding to \xi . An isomorphism between Hamiltonian T -manifolds is an equivariant symplectomorphism that intertwines the momentum maps. It follows from the definition that the set of critical points of \mu coincides with the fixed point set M^{T} . A driving question in Hamiltonian geometry is how much information on the action is encoded by data on the fixed points. Assume that the manifolds are compact and connected. Delzant [ De88 ] and Karshon [ Ka99 ] showed that when either the symmetry is maximal, i.e., the complexity {\dim M}/{2}-\dim T is zero (Delzant), or the manifold is of dimension four and the Hamiltonian action is of S^{1} (Karshon), the isomorphism type is determined by a combinatorial invariant that is determined by data on the fixed point set. In complexity zero, this is the image of the momentum map, which is the convex hull of the images of the fixed points; when \dim M=4 and T=S^{1} , this is the decorated graph associated with the action. Another natural question is: To what extent does the equivariant cohomology (which is an algebraic invariant) determine the equivariant diffeotype? For example, compact toric manifolds (smooth toric varieties) are equivariantly cohomologically rigid : two compact toric manifolds whose equivariant cohomology rings are isomorphic as algebras are equivariantly diffeomorphic [ Ma08 , Theorem 4.1] and [ HKM22 , Remark 2.5(1)] . This holds, in particular, for compact Hamiltonian T -manifolds of complexity zero. By [ HKT25 ] , equivariant cohomological rigidity holds for compact four-dimensional Hamiltonian S^{1} -manifolds as well. In this paper, we address both questions for semi-free Hamiltonian S^{1} -manifolds of dimension six. Recall that an S^{1} -action is semi-free if the stabilizers of the action are connected. This is the first case to consider when we relax the assumption on the complexity of the torus action or on the dimension of the manifold. In the semi-free Hamiltonian setting, the orbit space \mu^{-1}(t)/S^{1} at a regular value t of the momentum map is a manifold. By [ MW74 ] , the restriction of \omega to \mu^{-1}(t) descends to a symplectic form \omega_{t} in M_{t}:=\mu^{-1}(t)/S^{1} , making (M_{t},\omega_{t}) a symplectic manifold, natural in the sense that any isomorphism f\colon M\to M naturally induces a symplectomorphism f_{t}\colon M_{t}\to M_{t} . Gonzales [ Go11 ] claimed in [ Go11 , Theorems 1.5 and 1.6] that any two compact, connected semi-free Hamiltonian S^{1} -manifolds M^{1} and M^{2} are isomorphic, that is, equivariantly symplectomorphic, provided that they have the same (small) fixed point data (as defined in [ Go11 , Definitions 1.2 and 1.3] ) and that a certain rigidity assumption on the reduced spaces holds. Gonzales’ theorem was key in Cho’s proof of [ Ch21.2 , Theorem 1.1] (which was also carried out in [ Ch19 ] , [ Ch21.1 ] ), stating that any semi-free, monotone Hamiltonian S^{1} -manifold is equivariantly symplectomorphic to a Fano variety with a holomorphic S^{1} -action. However, as we pointed out in [ KW25 , Lemma 2.3, Lemma 2.4] , more assumptions are needed to conclude that M^{1} and M^{2} are isomorphic. In [ KW25 , Theorem 1.10] we proved a variation of [ Go11 , Theorem 1.6] , in which we further assume that the reduced spaces of dimension four of M^{1} and M^{2} are symplectic rational surfaces, and require that non-extremal fixed surfaces, if exist, only occur at one level of the momentum maps. We showed in [ KW25 , Theorem 1.14] that this variation is enough to for the application of Cho. The counterexample to [ Go11 , Theorems 1.5 and 1.6] that we gave in [ KW25 , Example 2.1] shows that it is, in general, not possible to extend an isomorphism f between Hamiltonian S^{1} -manifolds that is defined below a non-extremal critical level \lambda to above \lambda . In that example, the only fixed point components at \lambda were fixed surfaces F_{1}\subset M^{1},F_{2}\subset M^{2} . An extension of f over \lambda necessarily sends the fundamental class [F_{1}]\in H_{2}(M^{1}_{\lambda}) to the fundamental class [F_{2}]\in H_{2}(M^{2}_{\lambda}) , and this turned out to be incompatible with the action of f on the homology of a reduced space below level \lambda . In this article, we establish when the existence of an isomorphism between the equivariant cohomologies of the manifolds that is consistent with an isomorphism between the fixed point sets is sufficient for an isomorphism, both when isomorphism means equivariant symplectomorphism and when it means equivariant homeomorphism. In both results, we will drop the assumption on the distribution of the non-extremal fixed surfaces that we had in [ KW25 , Theorem 1.10] . To deduce that an isomorphism below a critical level that is well-behaved cohomology-wise extends over the critical level, we need some assumptions on the manifolds. In the main theorem’s version in which ’isomorphism’ means ’equivariant symplectomorphism intertwining the momentum maps’, the manifolds will be in the following setting. Setting 1.1 . Let M be a compact, connected semi-free Hamiltonian S^{1} -space of dimension 6 , and \mu a momentum map of M . Assume the following: • Every fixed sphere of M at a non-extremal critical value \lambda is exceptional in M_{\lambda} , i.e., it is an embedded symplectic sphere of self intersection -1 . • Every connected component of {M}^{S^{1}} is simply-connected. • Every reduced space of M that is of dimension 4 is a symplectic rational surface, i.e., a symplectic S^{2}\times S^{2} or \mathbb{C}P^{2}\#k\overline{\mathbb{C}P^{2}} with a symplectic blowup form. • For all consecutive critical levels \lambda<\lambda^{\prime} and all \lambda<t_{0}<t_{1}<\lambda^{\prime} , the pair (M_{t_{0}},(\omega_{t})_{t\in[t_{0},t_{1}]}) is rigid. The assumption on the fixed spheres being exceptional is important because for those, being in the same homology class implies that they are ambiently symplectically isotopic, which does not hold for symplectic spheres in general. The second bullet means

Read the complete text