Nonlinear Stability in the Two-Fluid Model, v1
Alexander López-de-Bertodano, Alejandro Clausse · 2025
Read Nonlinear Stability in the Two-Fluid Model, v1 by Alexander López-de-Bertodano, Alejandro Clausse (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04679.txt.
Introduction
Simulating flows with two fluids is cheap in a one-dimensional two-fluid model, but runaway instability has long spoiled it. Alexander López-de-Bertodano and one co-author present a physics-based fix in a 2025 paper on nonlinear stability. Earlier approaches relied on unphysical fixes to control Kelvin-Helmholtz instability.
Their method adds a simple turbulent viscosity model. It gives nonlinear stabilisation and stays compatible with inertial coupling. They build analytic and numeric tools to study the dynamics that result. Those tools cover turbulent cascades, chaos, and the formation of churn or slug flow patterns.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexander López-de-Bertodano, Alejandro Clausse |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 105 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04679
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Nonlinear Stability in the Two-Fluid Model, v1 Alexander López-de-Bertodano, Alejandro Clausse Abstract I Abstract The 1-D Two-Fluid Model (TFM) promises a powerful and computationally cheap platform for simulating multi-fluid flow phenomena. However, runaway Kelvin-Helmholtz instabilities plagued previous approaches, necessitating aphysical regularizations. We demonstrate a novel physics-based approach, using a simple turbulent viscosity model to provide nonlinear stabilization, compatible with inertial coupling. We develop a set of analytical and numerical tools to investigate the resulting dynamics, including turbulent cascades, chaos, and formation of churn or slug flow. Our approach opens up a wide range of new capabilities for the TFM by capturing the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability physically. II Introduction The Two-Fluid Model (TFM) is a continuum approach to fluid dynamics, originally conceived for mixture flows in up to 3 dimensions Landau 1941 . It subsequently found wide use in 1-D interfacial flows Ishii and Hibiki 2011 , with applications in the design of nuclear reactors, geothermal plants, condensers, heat exchangers, rocket engines, and so on. In problems that may be reduced to one dimension (pipe flows), the TFM has one main advantage, computability. However, dimensional reduction constitutes a substantial approximation and introduces two key weaknesses: 1. Higher-Dimensional Structure. 3-D flow and interfacial structure may be baked into a 1-D TFM on an empirical basis, but cannot be derived from it. The sacrifice of this capability is the fundamental trade-off of simplification to 1-D. Modalities that seek to retain full predictive power by moving to higher dimension (e.g. Volume of Fluid or Level Set) incur a corresponding computational cost. 2. Badly Behaved Local Instabilities. Historically, the TFM has been subject to unruly local wave behavior resulting from the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. Short wavelength components grow too quickly, meaning solutions become dominated by noise or cease to exist altogether. The model is, in such a case, ill-posed . These two issues are not really separate. The real culprit of ill-posedness is a failure to appropriately account for higher-dimensional structure throughout the development of the Kelvin-Helmholtz, not the instability itself. It is important that we state precisely what we mean by ill-posedness. In prior work on the TFM Gidaspow 1994 , three ideas have often been regarded as equivalent and interchangeable: (1) the presence of complex linear eigenvalues, (2) ellipticity, and (3) “ill-posedness”. The original work on well-posedness by Hadamard Hadamard 1902 analyzed the wave and Laplace equations. For these simplest cases, the three ideas do perfectly intersect. An initial value (Cauchy) problem is well-posed on the hyperbolic wave equation with its constant, real eigenvalues. It is ill-posed on the elliptic Laplace equation with its constant, imaginary eigenvalues. In more complex systems, however, these equivalences break down. Dispersive systems Whitham 1999 need not be cleanly elliptic or hyperbolic. In some TFMs, eigenvalues even shift between complex and real based on wavelength. Signs also matter. Positive imaginary eigenvalues, corresponding to wave growth, are workable if confined to a finite range of wavelengths. Negative imaginary eigenvalues are no issue whatsoever. Throwing out a system of PDEs because it has complex eigenvalues is like throwing out a system of ODEs because it has any kind of fixed point other than oscillatory centers. Many famous dynamical models (predator-prey, Lorenz, Van der Pol) would need to be classed as “ill-posed”. For the purposes of the present analysis, we therefore adopt the following definition: a well-posed system has unique solutions (“possible et determiné”), and an ill-posed system lacks them. We are now free to analyze the linear dynamics on their own terms, as well as the nonlinear effects that may cause a TFM to be well- or ill-posed more generally. The problem of ill-posedness has reared its head repeatedly in the development of the TFM, and to combat it a slough of fixes have emerged Dinh et al. 2003 . These regularizations are universally unsatisfactory, either proving too weak or involving aphysical forces. The most convenient and widespread approach in simulation has been to employ “coarse” (large node) meshes, sidestepping low-wavelength Kelvin-Helmholtz behavior through a combination of numerical viscosity and the exclusion of sub-mesh length scales. Premier codes like RELAP Pokharna et al. 1997 rely on coarse meshes. This methodology makes the correspondence between numerical solutions and experimental or analytical results dependent on the level of mesh refinement used. We maintain that, to be of predictive value, numerical solutions of a TFM must converge up to arbitrarily fine mesh resolution, via the application of physical forces only. In pursuit of such a TFM, M. López-de-Bertodano et al. pioneered the use of surface tension López-de Bertodano et al. 2017 . Surface tension introduces a short-wavelength cutoff to linear perturbation growth, but further work Fullmer et al. 2014 Vaidheeswaran et al. 2019 showed that this cutoff is not sustained in numerical solutions when transitioning to a nonlinear regime. Surface tension is a beginning but not the end; we explore its role thoroughly in Sections IV and V . It has been previously held (see e.g. Pokharna et al. 1997 ) that numerical approaches to the TFM could not practically handle mesh scales where higher-order terms become strong enough to constrain wave growth. This limitation no longer stands. Inertial coupling (IC), which may be used to model conservative aspects of higher-dimensional structure, is a fully effective stabilizer for runaway short waves Clausse and López-de Bertodano 2021 Clausse and López-de Bertodano 2024 . In some regimes, however, it is more appropriate to leave the IC at least partially unstable in order to capture Kelvin-Helmholtz wave growth. In such cases, it is necessary to introduce nonlinear dissipation to bound the amplitude of the fluctuations. Our novel approach to the ill-posedness problem is inspired by the thesis of W. Fullmer Fullmer 2014 , who originated the idea of using a simple eddy model to represent turbulent dissipation around a fluid-fluid interface. The power of this approach lies in allowing viscosity to scale with the relative velocity across the interface. We present a methodology for the construction, analysis, and numerical solution of well-posed, Kelvin-Helmholtz unstable TFMs. We well-pose these cases through a combination of linearly and nonlinearly stabilizing higher-order forces. We hope that this work will open the door to an even broader class of well-posed, physically predictive models for a variety of applications. III Model Variables and Equations For simplicity, we assume two-fluid incompressible flow in a square channel of height H . The constant fluid densities are labeled \rho_{1} and \rho_{2} , with \rho_{1}\geq\rho_{2} by convention. The volume fractions of each fluid in a given perpendicular cross section are \alpha_{1} and \alpha_{2} , with the identity \alpha_{1}+\alpha_{2}=1 ; we will mostly denote \alpha_{2} as just \alpha (the void fraction) and \alpha_{1} as 1-\alpha . The average fluid velocities per cross section are likewise labeled u_{1} and u_{2} . We then define: \displaystyle\rho_{m}\equiv(1-\alpha)\rho_{1}+\alpha\rho_{2} \displaystyle:\text{``Mixture" density} (1) \displaystyle\Delta\rho\equiv\rho_{1}-\rho_{2} \displaystyle:\text{Density difference} \displaystyle j\equiv(1-\alpha)u_{1}+\alpha u_{2} \displaystyle:\text{Volumetric flux} \displaystyle u_{r}\equiv u_{2}-u_{1} \displaystyle:\text{Relative velocity} \displaystyle J\equiv\alpha(1-\alpha)u_{r} \displaystyle:\text{Drift flux} We introduce a function \Gamma(\alpha) Pauchon and Smereka 1992 to describe the inertia of relative motion, including inertial coupling (IC). The mixture kinetic energy (per area) can be written: T=\tfrac{1}{2}\Gamma\!J^{2}-\Delta\rho Jj+\tfrac{1}{2}\rho_{m}j^{2} (2) In the case of no IC, the inertial function is: \Gamma=\Gamma_{0}\equiv\frac{\rho_{1}}{1-\alpha}+\frac{\rho_{2}}{\alpha} (3) and the kinetic energy reduces to: T=\tfrac{1}{2}\left[\rho_{1}(1-\alpha)u_{1}^{2}+\rho_{2}\alpha u_{2}^{2}\right] (4) which is