A Generalized Nonlinear extension of Quantum Mechanics
Alan Chodos, Fred Cooper · 2025
Read A Generalized Nonlinear extension of Quantum Mechanics by Alan Chodos, Fred Cooper (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04320.txt.
Introduction
Alan Chodos and one co-author, Fred Cooper, build the broadest version yet of their nonlinear twist on quantum mechanics in a 2025 physics paper. Standard quantum theory is linear, but the authors have long explored a controlled nonlinear extension keeping three basic properties. The new general form gives up complete solvability, a trait of the simpler model, while gaining an underlying Hamiltonian structure, the energy-based frame physicists expect.
One particular solution receives detailed analysis. Particle paths are then computed through an extended Born rule, a natural widening of the standard link between quantum states and probabilities. Closed particle orbits, paths that loop back on themselves, turn out to be possible. Such loops would mark a sharp break from ordinary quantum behavior.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alan Chodos, Fred Cooper |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 33 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04320
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Generalized Nonlinear extension of Quantum Mechanics Alan Chodos, Fred Cooper Abstract We construct the most general form of our previously proposed nonlinear extension of quantum mechanics that possesses three basic properties. Unlike the simpler model, the new version is not completely integrable, but it has an underlying Hamiltonian structure. We analyze a particular solution in detail, and we use a natural extension of the Born rule to compute particle trajectories. We find that closed particle orbits are possible. pacs 3.65Ud, 3.65Ta, 05.45.-a, 11.10.Lm I Introduction of the model In a previous paper cf23 , we proposed a non-linear extension of quantum mechanics and studied some of its consequences. Our motivations were various: partly, in the spirit of Weinberg Weinberg89 and Kaplan and Rajendran Kaplan , we simply wanted to see what a particular non-linear extension of quantum mechanics might look like, and to deduce some of its consequences. But we also had in mind the question of whether, as others have speculated Penrose Carlip , the union of gravity with quantum mechanics is best achieved not by producing a fully quantum version of general relativity, as is contemplated for example in string theory or loop quantum gravity, but by some other means, such as the coupling of quantum mechanics to a classical version of gravity, as in the work of Oppenheim and collaborators Oppenheim , or indeed by the modification of quantum mechanics itself. In the model we introduced in cf23 ; cf24 , a given system is described by 2 state vectors, |\psi> and |\phi> , in Hilbert space, in contrast to the single state vector to which ordinary quantum mechanics limits itself. In cf23 an exploration of the extra information provided by the pair of state vectors was not attempted. The model had the advantage of simplicity and was completely integrable, in the sense that the equations of motion determined the time dependence of the inner products <\psi|\psi> , <\phi|\psi> , and <\phi|\phi> explicitly in terms of a small number of integration constants, and one could then go on to determine the modification of the time dependence of the state vectors themselves due to the non-linearities. The non-linearity in that model is proportional to the inner product \gamma=<\phi|\psi> . One finds that \gamma\rightarrow 0 for large times, so that the effect of the non-linearity vanishes in the far future and the far past. In this work we seek a generalization that will allow for a broader range of dynamical possibilities. If we define |\Psi>=\begin{pmatrix}|\psi>\\ |\phi>\\ \end{pmatrix} (1) and ~~\mathcal{H=}\begin{pmatrix}H&0\\ 0&H\\ \end{pmatrix} (2) where H is the Hamiltonian of the underlying system, then the equations of motion of the model in reference cf23 are ~~i\frac{\partial|\Psi>}{\partial t}\mathcal{=H|}\Psi\mathcal{>+M|}\Psi> (3) where \mathcal{M} is the Hermitian matrix ~~\mathcal{M=}\begin{pmatrix}0&g<\phi|\psi>\\ g^{*}<\psi|\phi>&0\\ \end{pmatrix} (4) The coupling constant g=a+ib is in general complex ( b\neq 0) . We want to replace this \mathcal{M\ } with a more general one, subject to the following conditions, all of which are obeyed by our original model: (I) Each element of \mathcal{M} should depend linearly on the inner products <\psi|\psi> , < \phi|\psi> , <\psi|\phi> , and <\phi|\phi> , and should depend on time only through them; (II) The equations of motion should imply that <\psi|\psi>+<\phi|\phi>=N=const.; (III) The equations of motion should be invariant under the separate constant phase transformations \left|\psi>\rightarrow e^{i\theta_{1}}\right|\psi> and \left|\phi>\rightarrow e^{i\theta_{2}}\right|\phi> . To implement condition (II), it is sufficient for \mathcal{M} to be Hermitian, but it is not necessary. \mathcal{M} can have an anti-Hermitian part of the form ~~\mathcal{M}^{{}^{\prime}}=\begin{pmatrix}i\mu<\phi|\phi>&\lambda<\phi|\psi>\\ -\lambda<\psi|\phi>&-i\mu<\psi|\psi>\\ \end{pmatrix}, (5) where \mu and \lambda are real constants. Then the most general \mathcal{M} satisfying (I), (II), and (III) is ~~\mathcal{M=}\mathcal{M}_{0}\mathcal{+M^{\prime}} (6) where ~~\mathcal{M}_{0}=\mathcal{M}_{0}^{\dagger}=\begin{pmatrix}\alpha_{1}<\psi|\psi>+\alpha_{2}<\phi|\phi>&g<\phi|\psi>\\ g^{*}<\psi|\phi>&\beta_{1}<\psi|\psi>+\beta_{2}<\phi|\phi>\\ \end{pmatrix} (7) Here the \alpha_{i} and \beta_{i} are real constants, and g=a+ib was defined above. In total, there are 8 real parameters, as compared to two in the original model. I.1 The \tau - \delta problem If \mathcal{M}=0 , all the inner products would be constant. Hence, the inner products obey evolution equations that are independent of H. In these equations, we find that most of the above parameters play no role. With \gamma=<\phi|\psi>,\ we define \delta=|\gamma|^{2} , and let \tau=<\psi|\psi>-<\phi|\phi>. (8) We then have that \tau and \delta obey the following differential equations: \displaystyle\frac{d\tau}{dt} \displaystyle=\mu\left(N^{2}-\tau^{2}\right)+4b\delta, \displaystyle\frac{d\delta}{dt} \displaystyle=-2(b+\mu)\tau\delta. (9) The analogous equations for the original model are recovered for \mu=0 . To gain some preliminary insight, we note that we can easily integrate eqs.( I.1 ) in 3 special cases: (1) \mu=0 ; (2) b+\mu=0;\ (3) b=0 . Case (1) is just the original model, for which we have that \tau(t) and \delta(t) are given by: \tau(t)=2\omega_{0}\tanh{2\omega_{0}bt},~~\delta(t)=\frac{\omega_{0}^{2}}{\cosh^{2}2\omega_{0}bt}, (10) where \omega_{0} is a constant of integration. In general, we expect the solution of these 2 equations to depend on one constant of integration in addition to the freedom to redefine the origin of time, t\rightarrow t-t_{0}, which we do not explicitly indicate. Case (2): we find \tau=-2\omega_{0}\tanh{2\omega_{0}bt} and \delta=\frac{N^{2}}{4}-\omega_{0}^{2} . Case (3): we find \tau=N\tanh{\mu Nt} and \delta=\frac{\delta_{0}}{\cosh^{2}\mu Nt} . In this case, the constant of integration does not appear in the argument of the tanh function, but only in the normalization of \delta . Noting that in all three special cases \tau is a hyperbolic tangent, we can make the ansatz ~~\tau=\alpha^{\prime}\tanh{\beta't}, (11) where \alpha^{\prime} and \beta^{\prime}\ are constants to be determined, and plug this into the full equations for \tau and \delta . We indeed find a solution, namely ~~\tau=N\tanh{(b + \mu)Nt} (12) and ~~\delta=\frac{N^{2}}{4}\left[\cosh{(b + \mu)Nt}\right]^{-2}. (13) But this is definitely not the general solution, because \alpha^{\prime} and \beta^{\prime} are fixed by the equations, so there is no free constant of integration. Indeed, if we go through the special cases that we solved above, we find that our solution to the general equations corresponds to a specific choice for the constant of integration: Case (1), \omega_{0}=\frac{N}{2} ; Case (2), \omega_{0}=0 ; Case (3), \delta_{0}=\frac{N^{2}}{4}. II Hamiltonian formulation of the \tau - \delta system of equations In this section, we want to show that the differential equations for \tau and \kappa=\ln\delta can be cast into a Hamiltonian framework, so that a conserved energy can be identified. In terms of the variables \kappa=\ln{\delta,\ } and \Omega=\tau^{2} , we have ~~\frac{d\kappa}{dt}=-2(b+\mu)\tau (14) and therefore ~~\frac{d\tau}{dt}=\frac{d\tau}{d\kappa}\frac{d\kappa}{dt}=-(b+\mu)\frac{d\Omega}{d\kappa}=\mu\left(N^{2}-\Omega\right)+4be^{\kappa}. (15) This is a first-order linear differential equation for \Omega as a function of \kappa , and can be integrated exactly: ~~\Omega=\tau^{2}=N^{2}-4e^{\kappa}-ce^{\frac{\mu\kappa}{b+\mu}}=N^{2}-4\delta-c\delta^{\frac{\mu}{b+\mu}}. (16) Here c is a constant of integration. In the original model, \mu=0, and c=N^{2}-4\omega_{0}^{2} . The relation above is the generalization of \omega_{0}^{2}=\frac{\tau^{2}}{4}+\delta (eq. (2.15) of cf23 ) in the original model. Since ~~N^{2}-\tau^{2}-4\delta=4\mathcal{S}, (17) where ~~\mathcal{S}=<\psi|\psi><\phi|\phi>-<\psi|\phi><\phi|\psi> (18) is the Schwarz parameter, the relation can also be expressed as 4\mathcal{S}=c\delta^{\frac{\mu}{b+\mu}}. In the original model, \mathcal{S} is a constant, but in this more general case it apparently will not be. To solve these equations completely, we would need to substitute the relation between \tau and \delta back into the equations for \frac{d\tau}{dt} and \frac{d\delta}{dt} and perform one more integration. To simplify the subsequent discussion, we adopt a slightly different notation. As evolution parameter, we choose s=-(b+\mu)t , and define p=\frac{\mu}{(b+\mu)} .[Note: this requires b+\mu\neq 0,\ so Case 2 above is not covered by this analysis.] The equations of motion for \tau and \kappa are then