Three models for charged hadron nuclear modification from light to heavy ions
Wilke van der Schee, Isobel Kolbé, Govert Nijs, Kumail Ruhani, Ishtiaq Ahmed, Shahin Iqbal · 2025
Read Three models for charged hadron nuclear modification from light to heavy ions by Wilke van der Schee, Isobel Kolbé, Govert Nijs, Kumail Ruhani, Ishtiaq Ahmed, Shahin Iqbal (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2509-04299.txt.
Introduction
Wilke van der Schee and five co-authors publish three predictions for energy loss in collisions of light atomic nuclei in a 2025 physics letter. In July 2025 the Large Hadron Collider smashed oxygen and neon nuclei to explore small droplets of quark-gluon plasma, the melted state of nuclear matter. Fast particles crossing that droplet should lose energy, called partonic energy loss. Whether such loss appears in tiny systems is a key open question for the run.
Three modeling ingredients are combined: a BDMPS-Z based energy-loss model, a path-weighted prescription, and the JEWEL simulation tool. Realistic shapes for both nucleus types complete the setup. Ion size changes the predicted loss in model-specific ways, giving experiments clear patterns to check.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Wilke van der Schee, Isobel Kolbé, Govert Nijs, Kumail Ruhani, Ishtiaq Ahmed, Shahin Iqbal |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2509-04299
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Three models for charged hadron nuclear modification from light to heavy ions Preprint: CERN-TH-2025-182 Wilke van der Schee, Isobel Kolbé, Govert Nijs, Kumail Ruhani, Ishtiaq Ahmed, Shahin Iqbal Abstract In July 2025 the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) collided 16 O 16 O and 20 Ne 20 Ne isotopes in a quest to understand the physics of ultrarelativistic light ion collisions. One of the key motivations for this run is to discover partonic energy loss in systems with a small quark-gluon plasma (QGP). In this letter we combine a BDMPS-Z based model, a path-length based energy loss prescription, and JEWEL together with two realistic geometries of the 16 O and 20 Ne isotopes. The different sizes of the ions affect the energy loss in characteristically different ways depending on the model. I Introduction Ultrarelativistic light-ion collisions at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) are bringing the collider into a new experimental phase that will not only enhance the discovery potential of the heavy-ion programme, but broadens the impact of particle and collider physics as a whole. In this context there has been an effort recently from the nuclear structure community to understand the shapes of the isotopes 16 O and 20 Ne precisely, which is both interesting and necessary to understand the upcoming collisions Giacalone et al. 2025a ; Giacalone et al. 2025b ; Summerfield et al. 2021 ; Wang et al. 2024 . The collisions will have an impact on cosmic-ray physics as well as synergy with the same collisions performed at RHIC at a lower collision energy Brewer et al. 2021 ; Huang 2023 . From a purely heavy-ion perspective, the light-ion run will enhance our understanding of relativistic hydrodynamcis at its limits, as well as jet-medium interactions in small droplets of quark-gluon plasma (QGP) Grosse-Oetringhaus and Wiedemann 2024 . A particular hope for the light-ion run at the LHC is that it will shed light on the question: “What is the smallest droplet of deconfined quark matter (quark-gluon plasma, QGP)?” The question lingers, since in (high multiplicity) proton-proton and proton-lead collisions several telltale signs such as collectivity, strangeness enhancement and J/\psi -melting have been seen Grosse-Oetringhaus and Wiedemann 2024 , but it has not been possible to observe in-medium parton energy loss Huss et al. 2021a . Part of the difficulty with observing the modification of hard partons due to the presence of the medium, often called jet-quenching, is that any quenching must necessarily be small, since the quenching is expected to depend on the distance travelled by a hard parton through the medium. The measurement of such a small signal is hampered by the need to select events with large event-activity, which correlates with the production of such partons and hence results in large systematic uncertainties. Excitingly, many of these experimental difficulties can be avoided entirely in minimum-bias light-ion collisions. A further theoretical and experimental reduction of the uncertainties is possible when taking ratios of observables in different but similar colliding systems, such as will now be possible with 16 O 16 O and 20 Ne 20 Ne. Freed from the experimental burden of attempting to select relevant events in which a medium with small initial spatial extent is created, the theoretical modelling of jet-quenching in small systems is more easily aligned with experimental measurements. In this letter we present three models that compute the charged hadron nuclear modification factor for 16 O and 20 Ne collisions at the LHC. The first is the Simple model based on BDMPS-Z in the multiple soft limit with the harmonic oscillator approximation. Second, we use a phenomenological model extrapolating experimental results for PbPb (central) collisions to other heavy and light ion collisions. Finally, we use the interface of the Trajectum hydrodynamic medium with the Monte Carlo jet evolution code JEWEL . We show all three of these predictions using nuclear structure input as computed from the framework of Nuclear Lattice Effective Field Theory (NLEFT, Lee 2009 ; Lähde and Meißner 2019 ; Lee 2020 ) simulations as well as the the ab initio Projected Generator Coordinate Method (PGCM, Frosini et al. 2021 ; Yao et al. 2018 ; Yao et al. 2020 ; Frosini et al. 2022a ; Frosini et al. 2022b ; Frosini et al. 2022c ). The path-length and JEWEL implementations additionally make use of the hydrodynamic framework Trajectum Nijs et al. 2021a ; Nijs et al. 2021b . Trajectum is a state-of-the-art heavy-ion simulation framework that combines models of the initial conditions, pre-equilibrium evolution, viscous hydrodynamics, and hadronic transport. Its parameters are constrained through Bayesian analyses of a wide set of experimental observables in lead-lead collisions, ensuring a quantitatively reliable description of the medium produced in heavy-ion collisions. We will first detail the three models, and then end with a discussion of the results. II The Simple model Huss et al. 2021b Despite its name, the Simple model is not all that simple. In practice it uses the so-called Simple formula due to Peter Arnold Arnold 2009 , which solves the full BDMPS-Z Baier et al. 1997 ; Zakharov 1996 emission equations in the harmonic oscillator approximation for a dynamic medium. It moreover includes realistic quark and gluon spectra, realistic fragmentation functions and, in this work, EPPS16 nuclear PDFs Eskola et al. 2017 . The geometry is relatively simple and boost invariant, but matches Trento Moreland et al. 2015 calculations in anisotropy and in size both for the plasma as well as for the locations of the binary collisions. Crucially, the model contains only one free parameter ( \hat{q} ) that is fitted to minimum bias charged hadron R_{AA} at 54 GeV in PbPb collisions at \sqrt{s_{NN}}=5.02 TeV (black datapoint in top panel of fig. 1 ). Both the transverse momentum ( p_{T} ) and the centrality dependence are then a prediction of the model. One major omission in Huss et al. 2021b is the absence of 20 Ne as a light ion system. Therefore we took this opportunity to redo the calculation, but now for updated Trento profiles for both 16 O and 20 Ne, both from PGCM and NLEFT. The results of this exercise can be seen in fig. 1 . Perhaps unsurprisingly the difference between both 16 O and 20 Ne, as well as the two structure calculations, is within the uncertainty (which, as in Huss et al. 2021b , is taken to be only the uncertainty propagated to \hat{q} from the CMS datapoint). Nevertheless, in the ratio this uncertainty cancels almost completely, and we see both a higher energy loss in 20 Ne as well as a clear difference between PGCM and NLEFT. We will come back to this difference in the Discussion. Figure 1: (top) Minimum bias charged hadron nuclear modification factor as a function of p_{T} for all ion species collided at the LHC as predicted by the Simple model Huss et al. 2021b , compared to data from CMS Khachatryan et al. 2017 . (bottom) Ratio of charged hadron nuclear modification factor for 20 Ne over that for 16 O, for both PGCM and NLEFT nuclear structure profiles. III A path-length based approach van der Schee et al. 2024 In this section we estimate the nuclear modification factor assuming a power-law